IMO Fiona's attention was focussed on Kate at the time - and not on the state of the room. Breezes gust at varying levels and can change in intensity from second to second. This was not a gale blowing continuously at a consistent level.
One person noticed the open window - another one didn't. Both were in the room for different reasons. To assume that one must be lying is unrealistic IMO.
fiona was so close she touched the webbing but didn't raise the shutters. So she is saying they were closed.
when I went into the room that Madeleine was sleeping in, the room was dark, Madeleine, erm, Madeleine's bed was sort of folded back, the sheets, quite kind of neatly really, erm, Sean and Amelie were fast asleep in their cots, they didn't stir, you know, I was opening the cupboards in the room and moving around the room, they didn't stir at all, which that was, that was odd. Erm, we were trying to ascertain whether Madeleine could have got out, and I've already said earlier the shutters were very heavy, and I was almost trying to convince Kate that she could have opened the shutter and climbed out, although knowing that wasn't a likely thing, but at that point we were just trying to pacify Kate in that Madeleine was going to be alright. Erm, and I, I think I touched the webbing in that room, but because Sean and Amelie were asleep,
I didn't actually open the shutter in that room,
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm