Has support for Amaral and the Mccanns reached devotion by their supporters ?

[jassi]

are you a devotee?

Sardines and wine ? - devoted to them

[carlymichelle]

Sardines and wine ? - devoted to them

i persona;lly find  devoting  so much  time defending people you  know on both sides odd  i  defend maddies rights  to be protected by her parents and she wasnt but you know what i mean  bottom line  what ever did happen the mcanns leaving those children  caused all this to happen

[jassi]

i persona;lly find  devoting  so much  time defending people you  know on both sides odd  i  defend maddies rights  to be protected by her parents and she wasnt but you know what i mean  bottom line  what ever did happen the mcanns leaving those children  caused all this to happen

You really can't argue with that, though I sure some will.

[Benita]

i persona;lly find  devoting  so much  time defending people you  know on both sides odd  i  defend maddies rights  to be protected by her parents and she wasnt but you know what i mean  bottom line  what ever did happen the mcanns leaving those children  caused all this to happen

so you keep parroting ...zzzzzzzzzz boring  8-)(--)

[sadie]

Sardines and wine ? - devoted to them

Ah, Stephen will not answer.

So let's ask you. 

Do you think Amaral is a decent , honest good policeman

[jassi]

Ah, Stephen will not answer.

So let's ask you. 

Do you think Amaral is a decent , honest good policeman

Other than pointing out that he is an ex-policeman, I shan't indulge you.

[Aiofe]

You really can't argue with that, though I sure some will.

It is possible to argue with it. The question is- what was the primary cause.

Certainly leaving the children alone was part of a causal chain (which also includes deciding to go on holiday, choosing PdL, choosing those dates, and other possible secondary causes.) but if as the Met and PJ seem to believe now that Madeleine was abducted, the primary cause becomes the abductor! If the McCanns were guilty of hiding a corpse, then equally, 'leaving the children alone' is not the primary cause.

Your argument leaves out the question of direct rather than indirect responsibility. Many things were potentially indirectly responsible for Madeleine's disappearance or death, but 'leaving them alone' can never be the prime cause!

[carlymichelle]

You really can't argue with that, though I sure some will.

yep thy will but that dosnt make it ok     they support child negect and dont care about maddie imo if they did they wouldnt defend  her parents in front  of maddies  neeeds  as a toddler  to feel safe and loved

[Mr Gray]

Other than pointing out that he is an ex-policeman, I shan't indulge you.

 Why are both you and Stephen frightened to express your opinion...when Stephen asked me about the Mcanns I had no problem replying

[jassi]

Why are both you and Stephen frightened to express your opinion...when Stephen asked me about the Mcanns I had no problem replying

That's because you are a devotee, solid in your belief.

I, on the other hand,  have no such certainty about anything, particularly not about people I do not know.

[Benita]

Other than pointing out that he is an ex-policeman, I shan't indulge you.

priceless 

[Lyall]

Ah, Stephen will not answer.

So let's ask you. 

Do you think Amaral is a decent , honest good policeman

Ex-policeman. Yes I think so. You only had to hear the British officer speaking to the select committee this week to understand some things about policeman who have had long careers.

[Mr Gray]

That's because you are a devotee, solid in your belief.

I, on the other hand,  have no such certainty about anything, particularly not about people I do not know.

 Who said I was certain and who says I don't know them

[jassi]

Who said I was certain and who says I don't know them

I was referring to myself, not you.

You certainly come come across as a true believer. Please accept mu apology if I have maligned you.

[carlymichelle]

I was referring to myself, not you.

You certainly come come across as a true believer. Please accept mu apology if I have maligned you.

maybe a  little bit obesssed with them even??