Did the PJ conduct a proper search for evidence at OC?

[VIXTE]

Air scent only lasts a short while, minutes.  If Maddie was abducted she was carried out, her feet never touched the ground.  Simples!!

What the GNR dogs found was her trail part way to the junior club and to the supermercado.

That is your opinion. But the fact is that this 'spot' was never investigated. In the UK the spot would be surrounded by tents and checked fine comb..

[Angelo222]

That is your opinion. But the fact is that this 'spot' was never investigated. In the UK the spot would be surrounded by tents and checked fine comb..

No abductor is going to walk down the very road where Jez, Gerry and Jane were moments earlier. Common sense my dear Watkins!!

[VIXTE]

No abductor is going to walk down the very road where Jez, Gerry and Jane were moments earlier. Common sense my dear Watkins!!

We don't know what happened and when.. this is why things like this.. the search dog lead hours after disappearance should have been checked out.. they could have found something.. a paper from his pocket, a cigarette, Madeleine's hair, hair band, anything really and that would be a real lead..

[Redblossom]

We don't know what happened and when.. this is why things like this.. the search dog lead hours after disappearance should have been checked out.. they could have found something.. a paper from his pocket, a cigarette, Madeleine's hair, hair band, anything really and that would be a real lead..

You have seen the map havent you showing the identical dog trail on two separate days?


http://www.mccannfiles.com/imagelib/sitebuilder/misc/show_image.html?linkedwidth=actual&linkpath=http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/maddietrail.jpg&target=tlx_picqfob

It ran from the apartment westward and down the alleys, back out to the main street.....so you think an abductor took this route? To the car park? Opposite the Tapas restaraunt? Why? As Angelo mentioned, this was exactly the route Gerry Mccann described his kids running around a day or so earlier, and going theuh the car patk was a shortcut to Madeleines nursery.

Theres an old thread on it somewhere.

[Lyall]

You have seen the map havent you showing the identical dog trail on two separate days?


http://www.mccannfiles.com/imagelib/sitebuilder/misc/show_image.html?linkedwidth=actual&linkpath=http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/maddietrail.jpg&target=tlx_picqfob

It ran from the apartment westward and down the alleys, back out to the main street.....so you think an abductor took this route? To the car park? Opposite the Tapas restaraunt? Why? As Angelo mentioned, this was exactly the route Gerry Mccann described his kids running around a day or so earlier, and going theuh the car patk was a shortcut to Madeleines nursery.

Theres an old thread on it somewhere.

I've always found it odd that people keep going on about theories that the McCanns don't even believe in themselves. They are continually going way beyond what's written in their book, and even disputing some of it.

All very curious >@@(*&)

[Eleanor]

You have seen the map havent you showing the identical dog trail on two separate days?


http://www.mccannfiles.com/imagelib/sitebuilder/misc/show_image.html?linkedwidth=actual&linkpath=http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/maddietrail.jpg&target=tlx_picqfob

It ran from the apartment westward and down the alleys, back out to the main street.....so you think an abductor took this route? To the car park? Opposite the Tapas restaraunt? Why? As Angelo mentioned, this was exactly the route Gerry Mccann described his kids running around a day or so earlier, and going theuh the car patk was a shortcut to Madeleines nursery.

Theres an old thread on it somewhere.

I could have sworn that Angelo said that the scent would disappear in minutes.  But now we have two days.

[Redblossom]

I've always found it odd that people keep going on about theories that the McCanns don't even believe in themselves. They are continually going way beyond what's written in their book, and even disputing some of it.

All very curious >@@(*&)

Lyall, unless every millimetre was examined in any place where something was supposed to be, or could have been, some will always just criticise the whole investigation, and as giu say, even contradict what the parents themselves have said to create myths.

[VIXTE]

You have seen the map havent you showing the identical dog trail on two separate days?


http://www.mccannfiles.com/imagelib/sitebuilder/misc/show_image.html?linkedwidth=actual&linkpath=http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/maddietrail.jpg&target=tlx_picqfob

It ran from the apartment westward and down the alleys, back out to the main street.....so you think an abductor took this route? To the car park? Opposite the Tapas restaraunt? Why? As Angelo mentioned, this was exactly the route Gerry Mccann described his kids running around a day or so earlier, and going theuh the car patk was a shortcut to Madeleines nursery.

Theres an old thread on it somewhere.

So you never take Gerry for granted but this time you do?
If I was a policeman I wouldn't leave it like that.. The next day, hours after the disappearance I had dog)s) pointing me out at a route of the missing person, and it stopped at a certain place.. I would have it cordoned and comb checked and I am sure many of the inspectors in the UK would do the same..

[Redblossom]

So you never take Gerry for granted but this time you do?
If I was a policeman I wouldn't leave it like that.. The next day, hours after the disappearance I had dog)s) pointing me out at a route of the missing person, and it stopped at a certain place.. I would have it cordoned and comb checked and I am sure many of the inspectors in the UK would do the same..

Listen to what youre saying


Gerry described the exact same route his kids took as the dogs did,after Madeleines disappearance, because?...AND which would be a wierd route for any abductor to take....


 8-)(--)


Oh hang on....

And yes, we get the message, the PJ were rubbish and the British would have solved it, end of story

Think Im done with you

[Silkywhiskers]

Listen to what youre saying


Gerry described the exact same route his kids took as the dogs did,after Madeleines disappearance, because?...AND which would be a wierd route for any abductor to take....


 8-)(--)


Oh hang on....

And yes, we get the message, the PJ were rubbish and the British would have solved it, end of story

Think Im done with you

Team McCann are not concerned with accuracy.

[VIXTE]

Listen to what youre saying


Gerry described the exact same route his kids took as the dogs did,after Madeleines disappearance, because?...AND which would be a wierd route for any abductor to take....


 8-)(--)


Oh hang on....

And yes, we get the message, the PJ were rubbish and the British would have solved it, end of story

Think Im done with you

I thought this was a topic of whether the PJ have done a proper search of evidence..
And on my list this is one of the omissions...and it has always been.. since the day 2

[Silkywhiskers]

That is your opinion but the dogs the day after the disappearance stopped in-next to that car park..IMO this is a big clue..
You don't make a theory and then fit the clues into a theory. You first look at a clue and then form a theory.

And you can't totally dismiss the dogs in one post then use them when it suits you to prove a point.

Your position is that the dogs are unreliable except when you choose to believe them.

See the flaw in this?

[VIXTE]

And you can't totally dismiss the dogs in one post then use them when it suits you to prove a point.

Your position is that the dogs are unreliable except when you choose to believe them.

See the flaw in this?

I don't choose to to believe them, they cannot talk.. The dogs are only pointers to evidence.. their findings needs to be investigated..and in this case it wasn't.

[Silkywhiskers]

I don't choose to to believe them, they cannot talk.. The dogs are only pointers to evidence.. their findings needs to be investigated..and in this case it wasn't.

No, you have outright dismissed their "findings" and the results of the "investigation" into those findings which revealed Madeleine's DNA at the cadaver sites.

Make up your mind.  They're either a reliable investigative tool or they're not.

[VIXTE]

No, you have outright dismissed their "findings" and the results of the "investigation" into those findings which revealed Madeleine's DNA at the cadaver sites.

Make up your mind.  They're either a reliable investigative tool or they're not.

I have dismissed nothing. I am just trusting the police and my sane mind instead being lured off by the conspiracy theorists..