Author Topic: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?  (Read 115594 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline sadie

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #105 on: March 24, 2014, 12:18:50 AM »
Talking about the evening of 3rd May, witness SC says;
"I vaguely remember that Gerry and Kate and other people from the group would leave the table in intervals".
The 7th word indicates that SC and family were still at tapas when KM left the table

I understand what you are saying now, Pegasus.

But they quite regularly ate in the tapas restaurant, didn't they ?  Both parties.

How can you be sure that Stephen was not generalizing, remembering what happened other nights? 

How can you be sure that Kate wasn't going to adjust her make up, or popping to the loo?


I think that you might be taking that statement too literally, but I do understand what you are saying tho.

Offline pegasus

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #106 on: March 24, 2014, 12:58:46 AM »
I understand what you are saying now, Pegasus.

But they quite regularly ate in the tapas restaurant, didn't they ?  Both parties.

How can you be sure that Stephen was not generalizing, remembering what happened other nights? 

How can you be sure that Kate wasn't going to adjust her make up, or popping to the loo?


I think that you might be taking that statement too literally, but I do understand what you are saying tho.
The main proof is the recollection by SC's wife, that during the the walk home she heard a searcher shouting the childs name.

Offline pathfinder73

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #107 on: March 24, 2014, 12:58:59 AM »
Certainly not.

Thanks. We will have to go through the rog interviews for where they were searching.

Russell O'Brien

1578    “’We searched the cul-de-sac area’?”
Reply    “Erm, which is actually the passageway, I think, erm, when I said ‘cul-de-sac’, erm, I was referring to the fact that, although we’d never been along it in that direction, you can’t get out at the other side of the complex from the passageway that separates the pool from patio sides of the apartments.  But we searched down there and we done the adjacent gardens”.
1578    “So we need to describe ‘the cul-de-sac area’ as?”
Reply    “As the ‘passage’, well there, there was, erm, ‘the passageway’.  Erm, and then the last bit says ‘Shopping Centre and tennis courts’ there, that was actually on the, the sort of second wave of searching that I did.  Erm, so after we searched immediately around the, the complex, erm, and we hadn’t found her, I then went, I think around the back, or the front really, where the car park and the apartments are, to the main road, dropping down into the, into the town centre, erm, I forget the name of it, and went down round the back of the tennis courts, looking in there, round the back of the Baptista Supermarket where there’s a car park area and a bit of derelict ground, erm, and then into the Shopping Centre, which is the bottom two or three floors of a of a relatively large building just down the hill.  Erm, so that is a separate, erm, sort of search, after coming back to the foot of the apartment and clarifying that, that Madeleine hadn’t been found in the immediate vicinity”.
1578    “So after coming back to the foot of the apartment?”
Reply    “Yeah, we then went on separate searches further from the apartment and mine involved the front, and by that, I mean the car park side of the apartment and then down the hill towards the town centre, erm, and along there looking through fences, into the complex and the tennis courts, the back of the Supermarket and the derelict ground adjacent to that and the shopping, the lower echelons of this building which is a small, a small precinct”.
1578    “Sorry, back of the tennis courts?”
Reply    “Uh hu”.
1578    “Back of?”
Reply    “The back of the Supermarket and then into the, the small, slightly old, erm, Shopping Centre, which goes over one or two floors”.
1578    “Yeah”.
Reply    “Erm, it’s actually the day I met, ‘On the way back from the Shopping Centre’, in the next paragraph, I met Dave and he was running down the hill with a, with, you know, sort of panic in his eyes, saying ‘This is really bad, this is bad, they haven’t found her’.  There was obviously, a number of minutes had passed by this point, while we were looking individually”.
1578    “So ‘I met Dave on the return’?”
Reply    “On the return”.
1578    “’On my return’?”
Reply    “Heading back towards the, the, erm, the Super, well near the Baptista Supermarket, just down from there, erm, met Dave and it was him that said to me ‘This is bad.  This is really bad.  They haven’t found her.  She’s missing’”.
1578    “And he said?”
Reply    “Yeah, ‘This is really’, you know, He said ‘This is really bad, they haven’t found her’’”.
1578    “’This is bad, this is really bad, they’ve not found her’?”
Reply    “Yeah, or, you know, sort of words very similar to that.  The, erm, the next bit is, erm, sort of correct but relatively brief compared to what we discussed yesterday.  Erm, it said, erm, there was then Dave, Matt and myself shortly after this point swept down the hill towards the beach”.
1578    “So ‘we’ needs to be changed with ‘Dave, Matt and?”
Reply    “’Dave, Matt and myself’, yeah”.
1578    “’Searched down towards the beach area towards the Ocean Club’?”
Reply    “Erm, well it’s, yeah, I mean, that’s, that’s sort of later, no, it’s a bit misleading really.  Erm, we actually dropped down, almost directly, as the roads would take you to the beach”.
1578    “So ‘We searched down towards the beach area’?”
Reply    “Yeah, you can remove ‘towards the Ocean Club’”.
1578    “And we can remove ‘towards the Ocean Club’?”
Reply    “And the addition there was what we described, that Matt searched the, the beach immediately in front of where we came down at, which would be the sort of west, yeah, the western end of the beach, as far as, erm, Matt and Dave came into, erm, the area in between, and I went over towards the eastern part of the beach, erm, predominantly walking down the, the beachfront away from”.
1578    “Sorry, just repeat that again for me please.  Matt searched?”
Reply    “Matt searched, yeah, well, what would be the sort of west, he, where, where we came out we were sort of the west end of the, the beach anyway and he stayed and searched the rocks and the, the surrounding immediately there”.
1578    “’Matt searched west end of beach’?”
Reply    “Yeah, Dave took a sort of central portion of it and I went right over towards the sort of the, the main sandy area of the beach, erm”.
1578    “’And I went over to’?”
Reply    “Sort of on the west, well the eastern part of the beach”.
1578    “’Main sandy part of beach’?”
Reply    “Yeah, and dropped down to the waterline because it was quite easy to see back towards the town, because it was, there was street lighting, erm, but you couldn’t, certainly from further in, you couldn’t see if, you couldn’t see the beachfront terribly well.  And there was quite a lot of beach in that direction, so I went a certain amount, I didn’t, I didn’t go all the way over to, erm, I think it’s called Black Rock, but I got to a certain point and thought, you know, it’s actually, you know, well away from the beach (inaudible), turned back and, erm, on the return journey, this was when I bumped into, erm, somebody who, who, who was already aware that someone was missing.  I think, I don’t, I don’t remember her necessarily being, erm, definitely somebody I recognised form MARK WARNER, but she was an English woman in her, in her early or mid-twenties, fair or blonde’ish sort of hair, erm, I’d asked her if she’d seen, erm, you know, a little girl wandering around and, you know, I can’t remember what she said, but she was already aware that somebody was missing, so clearly she’d either bumped into Dave or somebody else searching around higher up in the town.  Erm, and then, before we kind of rejoin here, I sort, I sort of zigzagged back up through some of the roads, such that you, I would have covered a sort of triangle, from the apartment down to the beach, along the beach a little bit, and then, and then sort of heading back up to the starting point, over, over a number of minutes, I mean, it was certainly not every road or every garden, but, you know, just, as I headed back I tried to take in a number of, a number of roads and entrances just to see if there was anything there.  And during the course of this I’d spoken to a few people, there weren’t, there weren’t masses of people around actually and, erm, you know, a couple of holidaymakers and I can, I can remember speaking to some relatively elderly, erm, Portuguese people who were just walking along near the front at one point, but, erm, and the only other person I spoke to was, I presume, a Bar owner in that, in the Shopping Centre, and there was just one other, erm, elderly Portuguese man in there having a drink, erm, and they just sort of shrugged and, so.  Those are the kind of people that we discussed the other day who I met during that search.  Erm, and then, then it picks up back here really, where it says ‘We went back to five ‘A’, it was clear that panic was setting in on Gerry’ and certainly, certainly this was my first, erm, experience of, of, erm, of the anguish that Gerry was in, you know”.
1578    “Yes”.
Reply    “So, I don’t know whether this, at this point here was where Gerry was on the phone.

"I did an immediate search err we then doubled back, we split up again, I searched the, round the back of the tennis courts, down that road, supermarket, shopping centre, met up with Dave at some point near that, found out that we’d still not, still not been met. I think probably at that point is when I went back to see Jane and, and, and found out what she, what she, what she said, and then me, Dave and Matt went down to the water front, split up on the beach, met a few, you know asked a few people as we were going round what’s going on, swept back up from the beach, err back to the, back to the apartment then spent a fair amount of time on there both just talking to people err we got photographs there, there was some attempts to, to get, you know contact with consulate and so on and so forth."

"Err then, it’s hard to get it all back in, then we at some stage there I will have gone into the flat, seen Gerry err briefly and I just lingered around inside the flat feeling fairly useless and at some point I made the decision, I’m going to go and do another search you know I can’t be just standing around now, nothing seems to be happening, went off, searched that sort of northern part over towards Millennium and the accompanying roads and flats just below it, came back and I think at this point the, the PJ had either arrived or shortly after arrived err and then as we discussed made a brief timeline, sat in on the, the early part of the discussion where Dave was asking the PJ to release the information, you know he was saying something get it on the radio, shouldn’t there be more people here, blah, blah and then I think when Jane came in I think perhaps we saw the others housekeeper I’m not sure but then somebody offered to help with translation err then I left, went back to the flat err and then the rest of the night itself was, was largely in and around the flats err at some point Rachael making the call to her friend."
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Offline pegasus

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #108 on: March 24, 2014, 01:12:24 AM »
Thanks. We will have to go through the rog interviews for where they were searching.
...
I already posted, from the files, a British CIU analyst on Mr Amarals team stating clearly it was GM whom the witnesses heard and saw searching and shouting the childs name.
It is highly likely the witnesses are correct in their identification, because they not only heard and saw him, but also went down from the balcony and spoke with him.
« Last Edit: March 24, 2014, 01:14:12 AM by pegasus »

Offline sadie

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #109 on: March 24, 2014, 08:14:38 AM »
I already posted, from the files, a British CIU analyst on Mr Amarals team stating clearly it was GM whom the witnesses heard and saw searching and shouting the childs name.It is highly likely the witnesses are correct in their identification, because they not only heard and saw him, but also went down from the balcony and spoke with him.

Thankyou for trying to always post the facts.  Refreshing.

So Amarals team has confirmed that witnesses heard and saw Gerry shouting.  They went and talked to him


So we KNOW of three witnesses who saw Gerry searching.  The myths that he did not search can be put to bed.  

The time when Jeronimo is somewhat muddled.  He is good on observation but not on time.  However it can be fixed as roughly between 10pm and 10.05 ish from Diane Websters statement. 

 Therefore, she can only say with precision that, at 22.00 Kate McCann returned to the restaurant, seemingly in panic, communicating to others the fact that of Madeleine's disappearance. Asked about the reaction of other members of the group when they heard the above from KATE, the witness says that everyone, except the witness, left the restaurant and went to the apartment of the couple McCANN in order to find out what was going on.
In turn, as relates to her, the witness says she stayed at the restaurant for about five minutes,[/b] then, noting that the remaining members of the group had not returned, she followed in the direction of the apartment McCANN.

Do we know the time the other guys saw Gerry, please pegasus?

Offline pathfinder73

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #110 on: March 24, 2014, 11:24:05 AM »
I already posted, from the files, a British CIU analyst on Mr Amarals team stating clearly it was GM whom the witnesses heard and saw searching and shouting the childs name.
It is highly likely the witnesses are correct in their identification, because they not only heard and saw him, but also went down from the balcony and spoke with him.

We don't have a confirmed time re Berry/Balu. Did Gerry say he went to G6 car park to check after the alarm was first raised? Nope only one tapas staff employee said they saw him searching in the tapas/pool area but one of the waiters at the Millennium said the McCann's had been having breakfast there every morning LOL.

And this confirms how early Kate left the table before the McCann's claim 10pm or 10.03 in Gerry's case. There were people getting confused between Russell and Gerry.

"The second to leave (about 40/45 years of age, having the physical characteristics of the first, but having less bulky hair) did so for about 30 minutes, and that shortly after he returned, all left the table, except for an elderly person, who told him that a child had disappeared, the daughter of a member of the group, due to which he thought that the second person to leave could have been the father of the child." (JOAQUIM JOSE MOREIRA BATISTA - Waiter)

Russell returned at 9.45 so Kate seems to have gone at 9.50 (not 10pm) as Russell and Matt both said.
« Last Edit: March 24, 2014, 12:50:27 PM by pathfinder73 »
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Offline pegasus

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #111 on: March 24, 2014, 09:18:44 PM »
So Amarals team has confirmed that witnesses heard and saw Gerry shouting.
Yes a Brit expert (like Harrison and Grime) states in files it was GM whom the  balcony witnesses saw and heard searching - - - Absolutely genuinely searching IMO.

Offline pegasus

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #112 on: March 24, 2014, 09:34:45 PM »
.... Kate seems to have gone at 9.50 ...
I agree it is possible the alarm was earlier than 10pm.
However my point is that if we forget clocks and just take themoment the 7 rushing adults arrived back at the street gate, IMO within maximum 3 minutes of that street gate arrival, inevitably one those adults would search beneath 606 balcony.
Why? Because it is so close to 5A. The buildings 5 and 6 are next-door to each other. Unless you are suggesting a selective search  conspiracy like "look everyone, lets search everywhere except around that bullding next door, lets all agree to delay searching around that next-door building until after 20 minutes" ?
 >@@(*&)
« Last Edit: March 24, 2014, 09:36:34 PM by pegasus »

Offline pegasus

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #113 on: March 24, 2014, 09:51:45 PM »
To illustrate how close this balcony is:
The tapas reception entrance is visible.
The minority east-side-of-road version of chat location is visible.

Offline pathfinder73

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #114 on: March 24, 2014, 10:06:16 PM »
[So we KNOW of three witnesses who saw Gerry searching.  The myths that he did not search can be put to bed.    ]

Sadie, the whole point of this thread is where Gerry was between 10 to 10.10pm? It still hasn't been answered. One waiter claims to have seen him searching the tapas area but others don't mention seeing Gerry only David and Matt. One waiter at the Millennium said the McCann's had breakfast there every morning which is not true! Anyway Dianne left the table at around 10pm and they had finished searching that area by that time. The only ones confirmed are Neil Berry and Raj Balu but their first statements are missing from the files and somehow Birch got a time of 10.15 when they first spot Gerry (unconfirmed!). I don't think you'll find anyone who seen him in that time period  8(0(*
« Last Edit: March 24, 2014, 10:23:36 PM by pathfinder73 »
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Silkywhiskers

  • Guest
Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #115 on: March 24, 2014, 10:14:39 PM »
[So we KNOW of three witnesses who saw Gerry searching.  The myths that he did not search can be put to bed.    ]

Sadie, the whole point of this thread is where Gerry was between 10 to 10.10pm? It still hasn't been answered. One waiter claims to have seen him searching the tapas area but others don't mention Gerry only David and Matt. One waiter at the Millennium said the McCann's had breakfast there every morning which is not true! Anyway Dianne left the table at around 10pm and they had finished searching that area by that time. I don't think you'll find anyone who seen him in this time period  8(0(*

Kate sat on tv and said they did not physically search.

Also, I used to be a waitress and on a busy night where you have a big drinking table (such as the Tapas Crew) you are literally running and in NO position to swear where your customers are at any particular time unless you are physically standing over them with one eye on the clock.

Ridiculous.

Offline pathfinder73

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #116 on: March 24, 2014, 10:27:21 PM »
Kate sat on tv and said they did not physically search.

Also, I used to be a waitress and on a busy night where you have a big drinking table (such as the Tapas Crew) you are literally running and in NO position to swear where your customers are at any particular time unless you are physically standing over them with one eye on the clock.

Ridiculous.

Gerry was out and about and so quick that nobody noticed him gone.

"Gerry was Scotland's under-19 1500 metres and Scottish universities 800 metres champion. He was also a skilled footballer and could have turned professional but opted to go to university instead."

"Kate and Gerry McCann were planning to try for another baby before Madeleine went missing, Kate's dad said yesterday."

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/kate-and-gerry-were-talking-about-a-new-506057



« Last Edit: March 24, 2014, 10:37:56 PM by pathfinder73 »
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Offline sadie

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #117 on: March 24, 2014, 11:11:24 PM »
[So we KNOW of three witnesses who saw Gerry searching.  The myths that he did not search can be put to bed.    ]

Sadie, the whole point of this thread is where Gerry was between 10 to 10.10pm? It still hasn't been answered. One waiter claims to have seen him searching the tapas area but others don't mention seeing Gerry only David and Matt. One waiter at the Millennium said the McCann's had breakfast there every morning which is not true! Anyway Dianne left the table at around 10pm and they had finished searching that area by that time. The only ones confirmed are Neil Berry and Raj Balu but their first statements are missing from the files and somehow Birch got a time of 10.15 when they first spot Gerry (unconfirmed!). I don't think you'll find anyone who seen him in that time period  8(0(*


No that is wrong.  Diane left the table at about 10.05 or a little later.  She had spoken to Gerry as he searched.  I am doing this from memory but am confident that you will find I am right.

Jeronomos times are all over the place but he saw Gerry searching whilst Daine was still there on her own.  So it must have been between about 10pm and say 10.07pm.

Others went into the tapas area and searched too.  From memory, I think that it was Matt and Russell, but am happy to be corrected.  That must have been between 10.05 and 10.10, cos IIRC Matt left straight after that to run to the main Reception. 
My bet is that every single one of them searched the Tapas garden area and the pools, but it just isn't mentioned in any of the statements.

My bet is that they all searched EVERYWHERE close by, possibly several times ... but it just aint mentioned.

Well I prefer words from the mouth of witnesses, rather than from a third party.  So Neil Berry and Raj Balus statements are missing are they?  Strange cos Carolyn Carpenters statement is missing too.  Hmmm?    >@@(*&)

Offline sadie

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #118 on: March 24, 2014, 11:49:25 PM »
Quote from: Silkywhskers
[.... moderated abuse ...]

Kate is on record having admitted they did not search.

The first interview with Jane Hill from the BBC - 25 May 2007, Kate admits never actually 'physically searching' for Madeleine
 
Jane Hill: "I met people who didn't go to work for more than a week because everyday they were down on the beach, searching the streets. Did you, as a mother Kate, just sometimes think 'I've got to go and be out there with them. I want to go and just physically look as well."

Kate: (Pause) I mean, I did. Errm... (Long Pause) Errm, we'd been working really hard really. Apart... I mean, the first 48 hours, as Gerry said, are incredibly difficult and we were almost non-functioning, I'd say, errm, but after that you get strength from somewhere. We've certainly had loads of support and that's given us strength and its been able to make us focus really so we have actually, in our own way, it might not be physically searching but we've been working really hard and doing absolutely everything we can really to get Madeleine back."

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id123.html


She did NOT say she never searched.  Do NOT twist her words.  It is underhand to do so

It was in one of the statements, Fionas Rog, I think, that Fiona went to be with Kate and Kate took the opportunity to go out and search.  She did the Baptista Supermarket stretch, which probably included the little side roads radiating off.  I seem to remember thta she also ahd a look around the car park at the front.  According to Fiona, Kate was hardly functioning

She also went out with Gerry before first light on the morning afterwards... 5 -6 am  That is also included in either Fionas or Rachels statement

Spinning isn't the way forward.

Offline pathfinder73

Re: Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?
« Reply #119 on: March 25, 2014, 12:11:55 AM »

No that is wrong.  Diane left the table at about 10.05 or a little later.  She had spoken to Gerry as he searched.  I am doing this from memory but am confident that you will find I am right.

Jeronomos times are all over the place but he saw Gerry searching whilst Daine was still there on her own.  So it must have been between about 10pm and say 10.07pm.

Others went into the tapas area and searched too.  From memory, I think that it was Matt and Russell, but am happy to be corrected.  That must have been between 10.05 and 10.10, cos IIRC Matt left straight after that to run to the main Reception. 
My bet is that every single one of them searched the Tapas garden area and the pools, but it just isn't mentioned in any of the statements.

My bet is that they all searched EVERYWHERE close by, possibly several times ... but it just aint mentioned.

Well I prefer words from the mouth of witnesses, rather than from a third party.  So Neil Berry and Raj Balus statements are missing are they?  Strange cos Carolyn Carpenters statement is missing too.  Hmmm?    >@@(*&)

Dianne got the time wrong. She didn't know the time she guessed.

Dianne Webster Rog Interview

"4078    “After Evie had been poorly, do you know any, have you any idea what time that was? Presumably it’s, you say that you assume Russell got back to the table (inaudible).”

 Reply    “Well I mean Russell, by the time Russell had got back to the table err he’d err they’d err they’d cooked another steak for him, it didn’t take very long and he literally I suppose just had about two bites of it when err Kate came running, so that must have been about, I don’t know, getting on for ten o’ clock I would imagine because, well just working out the time that we had our starters and our main course and we were all finished our main course, it was only Russell err that had his to eat. We would have been waiting normally for him to finish that and order desert.

Russell got back to the table at 9.45. He waited 5 minutes for his reheated steak. Kate came running back not long after. This is 9.55 at the very latest. Dianne waits at the table for 5 minutes then goes to 5A at 10pm. You're working from an incorrect timeline.
« Last Edit: March 25, 2014, 12:14:14 AM by pathfinder73 »
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.