This thread is very instructive. For a start, anyone expecting definitive answers or black and white examples in any aspect of the law is deluded and betrays a complete lack of understanding of the law. Every case is different and this is reason why we have judges and advoctes, CPS and police and the whole legal apparatus - to try to find a reasonable solution to unique and messy cases.
The law itself is quite clear. The guidance for courts and poice is quite clear. The legal framework is quite clear, and it is also clear that it is the sending of an offending tweet communication which makes the offence - it does not have to be received. What constitues an offensive message is ultimately for the courts to decide. And indeed they have decided on a few cases.
Alice - are you really arguing that because nobody has been banged up as a result of the dossier nobody will be in the future - you are giving far too much credit to the speed of the poiice courts, CPS and courts.
An excellent summation JP. The fact that it is the act of 'sending' an offensive tweet which is the crime - and that it makes no difference whether it is 'received' or not by the victim needed to be clarified.
IMO people confining themselves to hurling abuse at oneanother on the internet would not qualify as criminal activity IMO. It is when it is taken into 'real life' and/or there is a sustained attack against one person or one group of people that it takes on a different complexion IMO.
As you say - every case is different. IMO this in itself would mean it is a very time consuming operation for the police who - in the case of the dossier for example, would have to firstly examine every tweet by every person named - to decide whether they have broken the law or not.
Whether the police have the will or the resources to tackle this problem properly is questionable IMO.