Documentaries & Articles for Discussion

[Brietta]

Yet in this case, no evidence of a break in.

Even Mitchell acknowledged that.

What evidence was there of the break-ins in block 5?

It was alleged the tourists had left their door unlocked?

The resident, Mrs Fenn, recorded it in a statement some time after the event.

That the window was open and the shutter raised was recorded in Dr McCann's statement.  If you choose not to believe that ... it is entirely your choice.
However it would have been a pretty lame 'faked abduction plot' if you set the scene up with raised shutter only to check out if it was possible to raise the shutter from outside by lowering it, don't you think.

[Brietta]

CRIME UNKNOWN dave.

What part of that don't you get ?

Now let's have the carte blanche evidence of abduction 

Okey dokey ... lets all pretend no serious crime happened eight years ago in Luz?  Where is Madeleine, then?

[Mr Gray]

CRIME UNKNOWN dave.

What part of that don't you get ?

Now let's have the carte blanche evidence of abduction 

can we rule out abduction by aliens....according to you ...no

[stephen25000]

can we rule out abduction by aliens....according to you ...no

Are you having a bad morning again with your ludicrous assertions ?

[stephen25000]

Okey dokey ... lets all pretend no serious crime happened eight years ago in Luz?  Where is Madeleine, then?

I'm not the one saying she is alive.

So, again to a mccann supporter, if you think she is alive, where will that be ?

[G-Unit]

Okey dokey ... lets all pretend no serious crime happened eight years ago in Luz?  Where is Madeleine, then?

Clearly something happened because a child disappeared. Various hypotheses have been explored. None of them have been proved, none of them haves been disproved.

[G-Unit]

redwood states that based on the evidence he believes Maddie was abducted

Not quite. He said Madeleine's disappearance does, on one reading of the evidence, have the hallmarks of a pre-planned abduction (thanks SIL).

Consequently other readings of the evidence could suggest other scenarios.

[Mr Gray]

Not quite. He said Madeleine's disappearance does, on one reading of the evidence, have the hallmarks of a pre-planned abduction (thanks SIL).

Consequently other readings of the evidence could suggest other scenarios.

do you have a cite...he doesn't say that on the live video I watched

[stephen25000]

do you have a cite...he doesn't say that on the live video I watched

In case you haven't noticed, Redwood is irrelevant and off the scene.

and his investigative team found ZIP.

[Mr Gray]

Not quite. He said Madeleine's disappearance does, on one reading of the evidence, have the hallmarks of a pre-planned abduction (thanks SIL).

Consequently other readings of the evidence could suggest other scenarios.

Redwood states live...so no misreporting...
it is our belief...based on the evidence...that it was a criminal act by a stranger

listen at 3 minutes

[Lace]

I'm not the one saying she is alive.

So, again to a mccann supporter, if you think she is alive, where will that be ?

There are a number of scenarios,   Madeleine could have been abducted to be sold for illegal adoption,  abducted for a paedophile ring,   abducted as a means for raising money.

[Brietta]

I'm not the one saying she is alive.

So, again to a mccann supporter, if you think she is alive, where will that be ?

Maybe if it is possible to get results from the foreign DNA still held in storage ~ we may be a step closer to answering that perennial question of yours.
But even for that we will have to wait for the professionals to give us the information to your shallow query.

[Mr Gray]

Not quite. He said Madeleine's disappearance does, on one reading of the evidence, have the hallmarks of a pre-planned abduction (thanks SIL).

Consequently other readings of the evidence could suggest other scenarios.

looks like you have been reduced to making things up

[stephen25000]

looks like you have been reduced to making things up

You mean the abduction ?

[Mr Gray]

You mean the abduction ?

I'm making nothing up but perhaps you do not have the intelligence to see that... I am reporting what Redwood actually said live on camera