Author Topic: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?  (Read 84626 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Carana

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #300 on: September 23, 2015, 12:24:32 PM »
He blithely contradicted his own witness live on camera, at a stroke decimating her credibility, so why not ?

He did? Perhaps we all come to different conclusions.

All I understood from that sequence was that they had different (fleeting) recollections of details and stood by them.
« Last Edit: September 23, 2015, 12:29:04 PM by Carana »

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #301 on: September 23, 2015, 12:25:46 PM »
He blithely contradicted his own witness live on camera, at a stroke decimating her credibility, so why not ?
Because it would have been a really stupid thing to do.  Consider:
On the night of Madeleine's disappearance the group sat down and sketched out the timeline of events - twice.  On both timelines, one event remains unchanged - the time Kate raises the alarm - 10pm, which just so happens to be round about the time you think her husband was engaged in some nefarious activity.  Now.  Fast forward a week, a week in which Gerry has all the time in the world to think about things.  Currently he has the perfect alibi - all the rest of his group agree on the time of the alert, and will vouch for him being with them at the time of the alert.  You then would have us believe that he decided to totally and deliberately obliterate that cast iron alibi by telling the police the alert happened 15 minutes later than the time everyone else in his group agreed it occurred.

Why would he do that Faithlilly?  Think!!

Offline faithlilly

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #302 on: September 23, 2015, 12:32:07 PM »
He did? Perhaps we all come to diferent conclusions.

All I understood from that sequence was that they had different (fleeting) recollections of details and stood by them.

It is there in black and white Carana. Gerry contradicted both Tanner ( on camera) and Jez by placing himself on the wrong side of the road during the talk.

Why didn't Gerry, when faced with the recollections of two different witnesses, one his friend, simply accept that he could have been wrong ? 

Why was it so important that he was on the right side of the road rather than the left ?
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #303 on: September 23, 2015, 12:43:20 PM »
It is there in black and white Carana. Gerry contradicted both Tanner ( on camera) and Jez by placing himself on the wrong side of the road during the talk.

Why didn't Gerry, when faced with the recollections of two different witnesses, one his friend, simply accept that he could have been wrong ? 

Why was it so important that he was on the right side of the road rather than the left ?
Perhaps (like you) he always has to be right?

Offline faithlilly

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #304 on: September 23, 2015, 02:11:04 PM »
Perhaps (like you) he always has to be right?

If two other eyewitnesses to an event stated one thing and I thought another I certainly bow to their combined recollection, Especially if it meant undermining the credibility of my own witness.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #305 on: September 23, 2015, 02:39:35 PM »
If two other eyewitnesses to an event stated one thing and I thought another I certainly bow to their combined recollection, Especially if it meant undermining the credibility of my own witness.

What did he say in his statements to the fuzz?
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Brietta

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #306 on: September 23, 2015, 02:51:57 PM »
Aoife wouldn't necessarily remember the date she went home (not memorable to a kid) but she would remember the night out at the restaurant and bar and seeing a young kid being carried at that late hour. Her testimony is the only one that connects to the Dolphin restaurant receipt time so she is a credible witness.

Regarding the 3rd of May, 2007, she went, with all her family, to eat at the Dolphin restaurant, which is close to Kelly's Bar. When they left the restaurant, around 21H30, they headed toward Kelly's Bar. They stayed there for about 30 minutes.
— Around 22H00, they left Kelly's Bar. The group headed, on foot, for their apartment.
— Questioned, she responds that she knows the time that they left because her father and her brother decided to leave early that night.

Aoife remembered the date perfectly well ... it was the day that defeated her.

The fact that the following morning none of the Smith family recalled the event of the man carrying a child in the dark in the near vicinity of the place from where a child had vanished is something else.

The fact recall didn't occur for a fortnight is also a bit of a puzzlement.

I didn't know that until relatively recently.  I thought the Smiths had reported their sighting to the PJ immediately; which actually might have helped the investigation in its early stages.

The place was heaving with GNR and their dogs, the PJ, search parties ... not to mention the media and their equipment ... plus terrified Smith grandchildren following the event on TV.
They received at least one phone call from Ireland where the event was big news.  Yet no-one remembered.

Isn't memory a mysterious thing though.

The fact that Aoife 'saw' long sleeves and 'remembered' the time which you have incorporated into your theory ... does not exactly make her the witness of the century when you take into consideration the things which didn't immediately spring to the front of her mind at any time from the 4th to the 9th May.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #307 on: September 23, 2015, 02:59:18 PM »
If two other eyewitnesses to an event stated one thing and I thought another I certainly bow to their combined recollection, Especially if it meant undermining the credibility of my own witness.
Well perhaps Gerry is even more pig-headed than you.  BTW, I'm rather disappointed you haven't seen fit to comment on my earlier post of 12.25pm today.  On reflection, and considering the illogicality of Gerry destroying his own perfectly good alibi, might you concede that certain elements of your theory may in fact be wrong - combined recall being (as you say) perhaps more reliable that the recall of one individual?
« Last Edit: September 23, 2015, 03:01:52 PM by Alfred R Jones »

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #308 on: September 23, 2015, 03:09:03 PM »
Because it would have been a really stupid thing to do.  Consider:
On the night of Madeleine's disappearance the group sat down and sketched out the timeline of events - twice.  On both timelines, one event remains unchanged - the time Kate raises the alarm - 10pm, which just so happens to be round about the time you think her husband was engaged in some nefarious activity.  Now.  Fast forward a week, a week in which Gerry has all the time in the world to think about things.  Currently he has the perfect alibi - all the rest of his group agree on the time of the alert, and will vouch for him being with them at the time of the alert.  You then would have us believe that he decided to totally and deliberately obliterate that cast iron alibi by telling the police the alert happened 15 minutes later than the time everyone else in his group agreed it occurred.

Why would he do that Faithlilly?  Think!!

It's also worth essaying the sequence of events by the Gospel according to Amaral.

Kate returns to the villa to find Madeleine (dead!)

Gerry is oblivious and unaware in the restaurant.

Kate (somehow) pulls it together, returns to the restaurant and communicates devastating news to Gerry (without anyone noticing).

Gerry leaves the restaurant (without anyone noticing), returns to the apartment, scoops up the remains of his daughter, whisks them past the noses of the Smiths and "hides" (Amaral's exact word!) them on the beach.

He returns back to the restaurant.

Kates leaves the restaurant, then returns a second time to simulate an 'abduction'.

Does that ring true and realistic?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #309 on: September 23, 2015, 03:29:41 PM »
It's also worth essaying the sequence of events by the Gospel according to Amaral.

Kate returns to the villa to find Madeleine (dead!)

Gerry is oblivious and unaware in the restaurant.

Kate (somehow) pulls it together, returns to the restaurant and communicates devastating news to Gerry (without anyone noticing).

Gerry leaves the restaurant (without anyone noticing), returns to the apartment, scoops up the remains of his daughter, whisks them past the noses of the Smiths and "hides" (Amaral's exact word!) them on the beach.

He returns back to the restaurant.

Kates leaves the restaurant, then returns a second time to simulate an 'abduction'.

Does that ring true and realistic?
No - not unless all those who gathered to put the timeline together shortly after Madeleine's disappearance are in on it.  Does that ring true and realistic?

Offline faithlilly

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #310 on: September 23, 2015, 03:32:21 PM »
What did he say in his statements to the fuzz?

Nothing in May 4th and arguido as far as I an see, apartment side in combined timeline and opposite side on 10th May.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #311 on: September 23, 2015, 03:38:19 PM »
Is it not fair to say that the only way that Gerry could possibly be Smithman is if all or at least the majority of the members of the Tapas group were covering for him? 

Offline Carana

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #312 on: September 23, 2015, 03:38:48 PM »
If two other eyewitnesses to an event stated one thing and I thought another I certainly bow to their combined recollection, Especially if it meant undermining the credibility of my own witness.

I might be tempted to, unless instructed to rely only on my own recollection.

My recollection of an event could have been that I'd seen someone in blue. Someone else thought that they'd seen someone in mauve or even dark green.

Should I change my recollection to coincide with theirs (perhaps they are right after all), or stick to my own recollection (even if it's not accurate, and others have different recollections)?



Offline faithlilly

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #313 on: September 23, 2015, 03:47:12 PM »
Because it would have been a really stupid thing to do.  Consider:
On the night of Madeleine's disappearance the group sat down and sketched out the timeline of events - twice.  On both timelines, one event remains unchanged - the time Kate raises the alarm - 10pm, which just so happens to be round about the time you think her husband was engaged in some nefarious activity.  Now.  Fast forward a week, a week in which Gerry has all the time in the world to think about things.  Currently he has the perfect alibi - all the rest of his group agree on the time of the alert, and will vouch for him being with them at the time of the alert.  You then would have us believe that he decided to totally and deliberately obliterate that cast iron alibi by telling the police the alert happened 15 minutes later than the time everyone else in his group agreed it occurred.

Why would he do that Faithlilly?  Think!!

All the rest of the group ? Really ? While most said the helpfully ambiguous 'around 10' Tanner states that she first heard Kate and Fiona between 10-10.15'. So no consensus there. and certainly no  bar against the actual time of the alert being 'around 10.13'.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline faithlilly

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #314 on: September 23, 2015, 03:51:43 PM »
I might be tempted to, unless instructed to rely only on my own recollection.

My recollection of an event could have been that I'd seen someone in blue. Someone else thought that they'd seen someone in mauve or even dark green.

Should I change my recollection to coincide with theirs (perhaps they are right after all), or stick to my own recollection (even if it's not accurate, and others have different recollections)?

If another eyewitness  had also said that they had seen the same person in mauve I'm sure you would have.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?