Author Topic: Would it have been better if the McCanns had given up on Madeleine years ago?  (Read 20429 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
There is constant carping on this forum about (amongst other things) the amount spent on Operation Grange, on all the poor children who have been mistaken for Madeleine over the years because of widely circulated age progression pics, the media celebrity status of the McCanns themselves, sueing the ex-cop who wrote a book on the basis that it harmed the search for her daughter and so on....

Would it have been better all round if the McCanns had drawn a line under Madeleine's disappearance years ago, not bothered writing a book themselves, not lobbied for a case review, withdrawn completely from the media and quietly applied for a Presumption of Death certificate seven years after her disappearance?

Would that have met with "sceptic" approval, seeing as how the McCanns have come in for severe criticism for doing the complete opposite and not giving up hope that their daughter may still be alive?

Offline G-Unit

Would it have been better if the McCanns had given up on Madeline years ago? Better all round? It's difficult to answer because who would have gained?

The taxpayer would have saved millions of pounds, but we don't know how it would have been spent if not on Operation Grange.

The media wouldn't have sold as many newspapers, but some of them would have saved the money they paid out for libel.

Portuguese and British courts and lawyers would have been the poorer, as would assorted private investigation companies.

The McCanns would have avoided a lot of criticism, but they weren't criticised because they didn't give up looking for their daughter, they were criticised because of the methods they used and because their story was suspected of being untrue.








Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Lace

I don't think it would have been better for the McCann's to have given up on Madeleine years ago,  for one she is their daughter whom they love and they could not have just not bother to try and find her.

I bet there isn't one person on this forum who wouldn't have done what the McCann's have done for Madeleine,  if there is please lets hear what you would have done instead.

Offline misty

Would it have been better if the McCanns had given up on Madeline years ago? Better all round? It's difficult to answer because who would have gained?

The taxpayer would have saved millions of pounds, but we don't know how it would have been spent if not on Operation Grange.

The media wouldn't have sold as many newspapers, but some of them would have saved the money they paid out for libel.

Portuguese and British courts and lawyers would have been the poorer, as would assorted private investigation companies.

The McCanns would have avoided a lot of criticism, but they weren't criticised because they didn't give up looking for their daughter, they were criticised because of the methods they used and because their story was suspected of being untrue.

The person/people who committed the crime of taking a little girl away from her family would have gained, had the McCanns given up years ago. As it is, they will be constantly on tenterhooks, awaiting the knock on the door.

If all you care about is money, then remember we have spent £12m helping a foreigner escape the long arm of US/Swedish law & kept him in pizzas & shoulder massages for 3 years. Is that value for money? Are human rights more important than justice?

To give up on Madeleine would have consigned her to the same destiny as all the other missing children before her - gone & forgotten by everyone bar her nearest & dearest.



 

Offline G-Unit

I don't think it would have been better for the McCann's to have given up on Madeleine years ago,  for one she is their daughter whom they love and they could not have just not bother to try and find her.

I bet there isn't one person on this forum who wouldn't have done what the McCann's have done for Madeleine,  if there is please lets hear what you would have done instead.

Your answer is only valid if the child was stolen and the parents are innocent. They failed to convince the Portuguese police at the time and they have failed to convince many others since.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline G-Unit

The person/people who committed the crime of taking a little girl away from her family would have gained, had the McCanns given up years ago. As it is, they will be constantly on tenterhooks, awaiting the knock on the door.

If all you care about is money, then remember we have spent £12m helping a foreigner escape the long arm of US/Swedish law & kept him in pizzas & shoulder massages for 3 years. Is that value for money? Are human rights more important than justice?

To give up on Madeleine would have consigned her to the same destiny as all the other missing children before her - gone & forgotten by everyone bar her nearest & dearest.
 

Once again, your argument is only valid if someone did take a little girl away from her family.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

stephen25000

  • Guest
The person/people who committed the crime of taking a little girl away from her family would have gained, had the McCanns given up years ago. As it is, they will be constantly on tenterhooks, awaiting the knock on the door.

If all you care about is money, then remember we have spent £12m helping a foreigner escape the long arm of US/Swedish law & kept him in pizzas & shoulder massages for 3 years. Is that value for money? Are human rights more important than justice?

To give up on Madeleine would have consigned her to the same destiny as all the other missing children before her - gone & forgotten by everyone bar her nearest & dearest.



 

We haven't. Spent 12 million pounds, Cameron has, on the clear behest of the Americans.

Surely, by your logic, all missing children should have the same amount of time and resources spent on them ?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
In an alternative reality, the McCanns fade away into obscurity starting in 2008, they do not write a book, they do not lobby for the case to be reviewed, they do not give media interviews, they do not draw attention to themselves in any way - do they look on the face of it more or less guilty in the eyes of the "sceptics"?

Would we ever have had a re-opening of the case in the above scenario?

Would we still be discussing this case in the absence of any new material to fan the flames?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Once again, your argument is only valid if someone did take a little girl away from her family.
If someone did take Madeleine away from her family, would it have been better all round (for you, for the country's coffers and general well-being, for the McCanns themselves) if they had just accepted that fact and got on with their lives quietly?

Offline Lace

Your answer is only valid if the child was stolen and the parents are innocent. They failed to convince the Portuguese police at the time and they have failed to convince many others since.

The fact that they did all that they did,  makes it more realistic that the parents are innocent and that Madeleine was abducted.

It would have been so easy for the McCann's to have thought 'phew,  we got away with it'  and to have just let it all fade away,  but they didn't,  they hired PI's they sued Amaral they petitioned for a review which got the case reopened,  they have tried to keep Madeleine in the spot light.

If they were guilty why the hell do that?

Offline misty

We haven't. Spent 12 million pounds, Cameron has, on the clear behest of the Americans.

Surely, by your logic, all missing children should have the same amount of time and resources spent on them ?

We have spent £12m because of our obligations under the rules of international political asylum, not because of the US.
My logic dictates that the amount of time & resources spent on a missing child are dependent on the circumstances. Madeleine's case is almost unique.
There are relatively few children under 10 in the UK missing with fate unknown. Their cases have not been consigned to the scrapheap.
 There are several who have been taken overseas by a parent to a country which has no extradition treaty with us & the other parent in this country has no legal rights to regain custody.
It is a question of where the moral & legal boundary should be drawn.

Offline G-Unit

If someone did take Madeleine away from her family, would it have been better all round (for you, for the country's coffers and general well-being, for the McCanns themselves) if they had just accepted that fact and got on with their lives quietly?

If someone didn't take Madeleine away from her family, would it have been better all round (for you, for the country's coffers and general well-being, for the McCanns themselves) if they had just accepted that fact and got on with their lives quietly?
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline G-Unit

The fact that they did all that they did,  makes it more realistic that the parents are innocent and that Madeleine was abducted.

It would have been so easy for the McCann's to have thought 'phew,  we got away with it'  and to have just let it all fade away,  but they didn't,  they hired PI's they sued Amaral they petitioned for a review which got the case reopened,  they have tried to keep Madeleine in the spot light.

If they were guilty why the hell do that?

You are assuming that the parents drove everything that followed. The parents made very strong statements in the beginning. Madeleine had been taken from her bed, they weren't neglectful, they were innocent.

They got hordes of people supporting them. Friends, family, football and rugby stars, legal firms, politicians and the media. The bandwagon was rolling along after that with or without their input. We don't know if they ever tried to get off it. Madeleine wasn't their exclusive property she had a wider family and now, thanks to the publicity, hordes of people interested in her and her parents. It's possible that events were driven by others just as much as by them. Maybe it just proved too difficult to stop the bandwagon rolling along even if they wanted to.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline ShiningInLuz

I don't think it would have been better for the McCann's to have given up on Madeleine years ago,  for one she is their daughter whom they love and they could not have just not bother to try and find her.

I bet there isn't one person on this forum who wouldn't have done what the McCann's have done for Madeleine,  if there is please lets hear what you would have done instead.
If the test is boiled down to continue searching v stop searching, then I would have continued searching.

Beyond that, the list of things I would have done differently is too long to itemise.  The de-emphasis of Smithman from when he emerged to the current time is shocking, to put it mildly.
What's up, old man?

Offline misty

You are assuming that the parents drove everything that followed. The parents made very strong statements in the beginning. Madeleine had been taken from her bed, they weren't neglectful, they were innocent.

They got hordes of people supporting them. Friends, family, football and rugby stars, legal firms, politicians and the media. The bandwagon was rolling along after that with or without their input. We don't know if they ever tried to get off it. Madeleine wasn't their exclusive property she had a wider family and now, thanks to the publicity, hordes of people interested in her and her parents. It's possible that events were driven by others just as much as by them. Maybe it just proved too difficult to stop the bandwagon rolling along even if they wanted to.

Do you view the bandwagon as a bad thing & do you think they are still riding high on it?