Taken from Goncalo Amaral interview with Miguel Sousa Tavares.
... I cannot speak about the book, but you doctor can
(Miguel: yes I can, I was not forbidden, when you talk about evidences, you speaks about the hypothesis of her being killed by her parents, to hide her body)
GA: no, no I never said that,
Miguel says: but it is what is in the book,
GA: what I say in the book, let me explain
(Miguel: but you had fun yourself).
GA: I don´t say,
(Miguel: the final conclusion),
GA: no, no, then you had not read the book, that book is the English truth and there is nothing there.
Miguel: I have not read it? Oh yes I have read it, the book ends with 4 conclusions marked in black.
GA says: conclusions which are not talking about murder by the parents.
(Miguel: I didn´t said murder by her parents, could been killed accidentally).
GA repeats: no, no,accidentally is not killed by someone, an accident is an accident, it´s not any murder.
Miguel says: it is involuntary murder, you always told that they hid their daughter´s body, is that not in your book? Miguel repeats this question, Is this not in your book?)
GA says: this is where you Miguel is wrong, what´s in the book is six month of investigation, during which I was in charge and where it concludes with reports which are there, the suspicions at that time and has you Miguel knows, criminal investigation has it´s time, a beginning, a middle and an end, and so on, and in that moment there was suspicion, which doesn´t mean later, but, but
(Miguel says: but the suspicions were mostly yours, you know GA, another thing that is impressive is, let´s get back, shall we)
GA: you are putting words in my mouth, you are forbidden
(Miguel continues: no no, the words are mine, my conclusions and taken from your book and taken from the process)
GA says: no the suspicions, you are putting words in my mouth or what, no, you are talking about the injunction, it is an interpretation of the book
(Miguel: it is an interpretation of the book, you receive the news, gives the order to PJ picket, go to your home,
(GA: yes, like in any other case).
Miguel continues: you go to your home, wake up in the morning, this is in your book, and the first thing that comes to your brain is to ask the British who are the McCanns?
And you start immediately to suspect and ask questions, the questions you ask are:
- if they hurt children,
- if the have a serious problem with law,
- if they have psychological problems,
- if they are in fact doctors in full time,
and then, much ahead you say is common sense in these cases to suspect of the parents, so,
- you have not yet seen the McCanns,
- you have not yet been at the crime scene
and you´re already suspect them? Is it, or is it not. You´re a master).
GA says: yes, then says, listen, I or any other, yes, yes, it´s normal, to suspect, you´re wrong, it´s common sense, listen doctor, you are making fantasies, something,
Miguel says: no, I´m not making fantasies, I read your book).
GA repeats: the issue is this: the national and international laws in any of these cases and we were criticised by the FBI about this, is the issue of suspect or not of parents, or the closest in these types of cases and I can tell you, (Miguel says: you believe, but I don´t say suspect, at a certain time now, the first suspicions is that it?).
GA says: it´s not the first suspicion, we have to know first who those people are.
Miguel says: Was it not most urgent to know if the borders were all closed? Are all the marinas under surveillance? All the cars who left there under control?).
GA says: But we knew. We took care of that. No, it cannot know all cars who left there. And look, we reached the conclusion that for example the Via of Infant has some TV cameras which didn´t work, we talked with Spanish colleagues to control the border of Cádiz, in terms of access to Morocco, all those, Tenerife, and so on
(Miguel says: the marinas were not immediately controlled, because I know who left for example of Lagos marina one day after, quietly).
GA: but we have all that information.
We know that.
From a place where some occurrence happens, we analyze it, if there are CCTV, if there are no CCTV, if there are any CCTV, what can be seen, what cannot be seen, all of that, at the same time, look, saying that we aimed immediately to, it´s not like that, that question is relativity to the parents, excuse me, that first question, that, was answered, it is the first, was never answered, it is the first, it is important to understand...
(Miguel: since the first day, anyone who read your book concludes immediately that in the first meeting, at the end of the first day, is the strongest hypothesis you have, and I believe that has been created at a certain time of the investigation, but now, is the first hypothesis of work, it is the first hypothesis of work you pick and seems to be the only.
GA says: it´s not
(Miguel insists: it looks to be the only one).
GA repeats: not it´s not.
Miguel insists again: it is, it is.
GA says: doctor read the book.
Miguel says: I read the book.
GA says: notice, there are at the book , there are the investigations for the abduction, there we have the abduction, what has been done.
Miguel says: in terms of abduction, yes).
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2957.msg105234#msg105234
It seems your opinion was wrong "The only thing wrong with the police investigation is that they didn't IMMEDIATELY suspect the parents,IMO"
Apparently Mr Amaral had worked out his thesis of what may have happened to Madeleine well in advance of carrying out any investigative diligences ... and found nothing at all during the period he was in charge to encourage him deviating from that central theory.
The most elementary error it is possible for an investigator to make is to formulate a theory then look for the evidence to fit. The evidence has primacy ... not the uninformed notion of the police.
That this inept investigation has in some people's minds been turned into the textbook operation it demonstrably was not and its co-ordinator considered a Sherlock Holmes surely must represent the propaganda coup of the last couple of centuries.
I hadn't seen this stuff before so it was very interesting, and many thanks to you.
"Apparently Mr Amaral had worked out his thesis of what may have happened to Madeleine well in advance of carrying out any investigative diligences ... and found nothing at all during the period he was in charge to encourage him deviating from that central theory."
Just before he was removed from the enquiry, he was trying to chase up an analysis on human blood found outside Quinta dos Figos, blood discovered shortly after Madeleine disappeared. This has, AFAIK, nothing to do with the McCanns, or Madeleine. However, we are not going to know for certain, as Amaral got hoiked, and this diligence was not followed through in the time of the PJ files.