Wandering Off Topic

[Vertigo Swirl]

Nearly half of websleuths polled had the parents or family member involved

https://www.websleuths.com/forums/threads/what-happened-to-isabel-celis.173262/

[Brietta]

An interesting article from last year, before this development:

"Was Isabel abducted from her window in the night?  Was she taken while her unknowing family members slept in the next room?  Does Isabel’s father’s bizarrely calm demeanor on the 911 call indicate that he may be culpable?  Or, did authorities fixate on her parents and develop tunnel vision early on in the investigation?

How can a child vanish entirely with little to no evidence left behind?  And, most importantly, where is Isabel Celis?"

Yes, there was no evidence of the child having been taken from her bedroom via the window, and yes at least one parent was suspected because of his demeanour.

More criticism for the father here based on his apparently calm attitude and use of the word "abducted"
https://thestir.cafemom.com/politics_views/137622/911_calls_from_isabel_celis

Say no more.


https://truenoirstories.wordpress.com/2017/02/12/isabel-celis/

There isn't much from the McCann sceptic lexicon that is missing from that, is there?  Reading it makes me feel very sad indeed.

[Miss Taken Identity]

No relation to MBM so why her name gets a headline is disrespectful to Isabel. THE comments are interesting on that page...

No evidence of abduction of MBM.

[Robittybob1]

No relation to MBM so why her name gets a headline is disrespectful to Isabel. THE comments are interesting on that page...

No evidence of abduction of MBM.

if it has to be alleged abductor it also has to be "alleged abduction".

[slartibartfast]

if it has to be alleged abductor it also has to be "alleged abduction".

Rob, English is quite a flexible language. No evidence of abduction is expressing uncertainty over abduction the same as alleged or IMO.

[Vertigo Swirl]

No relation to MBM so why her name gets a headline is disrespectful to Isabel. THE comments are interesting on that page...

No evidence of abduction of MBM.

Until the suspect showed the police where Isabel’s body was hidden there was no evidence that Isabel had been abducted apart from a missing child, a forced window screen and her parents insistence that she was abducted.  Apart from that, no relevance to Madeleine’s case whatsoever.

[barrier]

One for davel and his faith in british justice,incidently I believe it was 40 yrs today Carl Bridgewater was murdered.


https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/1381563/Latest-victim-of-miscarriages-of-justice.html

[Mr Gray]

One for davel and his faith in british justice,incidently I believe it was 40 yrs today Carl Bridgewater was murdered.


https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/1381563/Latest-victim-of-miscarriages-of-justice.html

you think thats bad.....montclair posted there are no examples of misscarriages of justice in portugal....perhaps they  just dont admit to them....I have a lot of faith in British justice...nothing is perfect

[Miss Taken Identity]

This is a particularly heartless and tasteless post IMO.  Who has EVER suggested that it’s always sweetness and light following a child abduction?

You missed that whole she could have been abducted by a loving caring childless couple? Having the time of her life  and she came to no harm.

[Erngath]

You missed that whole she could have been abducted by a loving caring childless couple? Having the time of her life  and she came to no harm.

Possibly what the family of an abducted child wish would be so.
And try to keep that thought, rather than think of the worst.

[jassi]

Possibly what the family of an abducted child wish would be so.
And try to keep that thought, rather than think of the worst.

An unwillingness to face up to reality. Is this another aspect of Gerry's mental state.

[Miss Taken Identity]

Possibly what the family of an abducted child wish would be so.
And try to keep that thought, rather than think of the worst.

Or try to make out she is happy, and came to no harm- as once they were found out to be eating and drinking every night leaving their children alone to fend for themselves, the public  were not quite so 'supportive'

I mean one minute they are screaming she is abducted by a gang of paedophiles the next she came to no harm?  yeah O.K.

[Miss Taken Identity]

An unwillingness to face up to reality. Is this another aspect of Gerry's mental state.

They have moved on, years ago, they said as much in one of their interviews. Is there really any evidence of Gerrys depression? or are we just getting his own 'story'.

[jassi]

Between Gerry's depression and Kate sticking pins into an Amaral hate doll, it must be a bundle of fun at chez McCann.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Between Gerry's depression and Kate sticking pins into an Amaral hate doll, it must be a bundle of fun at chez McCann.

Why would you expect there to be a bundle of fun at the McCanns?

I knew it wouldn’t be long before Gerry’s depression became a source of mirth for the sceptics.