Wandering Off Topic

[slartibartfast]

Of course they can.

How insulting.

[barrier]

How insulting.

I suspect it would be to one who truly suffers.Mrs Leyland for one.

[faithlilly]

To you, yes, just as you seem to think this recent revelation is rather convenient.  But if you have proof that you are being treated for depression, is a judge going to decide you’re lying about it - based on it looking convenient?

If the answer to ‘how long have you been treated for depression’ is ‘a few months’......yes.

[Vertigo Swirl]

How insulting.

Who has been insulted?

[Vertigo Swirl]

If the answer to ‘how long have you been treated for depression’ is ‘a few months’......yes.

You can be depressed for years before seeking treatment you know.  You can also be depressed and never seek treatment.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I suspect it would be to one who truly suffers.Mrs Leyland for one.

So if I say it’s possible to fake an illness then it’s an insult to all those who have suffered from that illness?  What crazy nonsense is this? 

[faithlilly]

You can be depressed for years before seeking treatment you know.  You can also be depressed and never seek treatment.

Of course you can but it would look a tad convenient if help was sought just before the court case, don’t you think ?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Of course you can but it would look a tad convenient if help was sought just before the court case, don’t you think ?

That’s the second time you’ve asked me that question this morning.  My answer remains the same - see above.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I suspect it would be to one who truly suffers.Mrs Leyland for one.

What IS insulting is deciding to doubt that Gerry McCann has actually suffered from depression just because you don’t like the man.

[xtina]

As I said earlier, faking depression to get medical evidence  (especially for a medical professional and super especially for a medical professional whose daughter has disappeared and with a sympathetic GP or psychiatrist ) would be a piece of cake IMO.  Do you (who seem to who believe that the McCanns are ostensibly good people who did a bad thing) think that Kate and Gerry are unlikely to really have suffered from depression in the last 11 years?

Also, I can think of no advantage to claiming depression now, can you?

You can't go by whether the mccs are depressed...it proves nothing

They would be equally depressed if they had been involved in maddie's disappearance in my opinion.

[Vertigo Swirl]

You can't go by whether the mccs are depressed...it proves nothing

They would be equally depressed if they had been involved in maddie's disappearance in my opinion.

Why is it so hard for people to follow a discussion and comment on what has been said not on what hasn’t been said?

[xtina]

Why is it so hard for people to follow a discussion and comment on what has been said not on what hasn’t been said?

I wondered if I had missed the point...

My point all the same was...they are going to be depressed etc etc etc...whether involved or not...

[barrier]

What IS insulting is deciding to doubt that Gerry McCann has actually suffered from depression just because you don’t like the man.

He's not singled out,I'm totally ambivalent.

[barrier]

Good to see the Sun is the go to paper for accuracy, not.



"Sir Elton John and David Furnish have accepted “significant” libel damages over a newspaper claim that their dog inflicted “Freddy Krueger-like injuries” on a child at a play date.
The couple, who were not at London’s High Court on Friday, brought proceedings against News Group Newspapers (NGN) over a front page story in The Sun on Sunday in February."

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/john-and-david-furnish-accept-libel-damages-over-‘dog-attack’-slur/ar-AAAqeks?ocid=spartandhp

[Miss Taken Identity]

Because male depression is a hot topic right now?  Perhaps has approached by Radio 4 rather than the other way around?   Or do you think he decided one day to call up R4 and demand they make a programme about his depression?

"Because male depression is a hot topic right now?"  Yes, The McCanns love a bandwagon to jump on- them who want a private family life.

"Or do you think he decided one day to call up R4 and demand they make a programme about his depression?" No!  but maybe his PR guru did...

Why would they do that? welllllllllllllllllllllll now you ask. He may be depressed due to his wee shop closing down, having to pay court fees and losing his companies 'profits' AND having to fork out for ECHR costs. BUTmst of all they need  the victimhood to get SY to keep investigating  loonie toons theories.

One would have to diagose which type of depression he was suffering from. Also, erm who is he on the celeb table,  that people give a toss about him. Well apart from 'Sun' picture lookers.


Gunit, Kate did mention in her book that their sex life suffered- Gerry was.. well ...

This was plastered all over the Sun headlines.. from a couple who just wanted a quiet private family life.