Wandering Off Topic

[Wonderfulspam]

It would be wrong to rule out any theory that lies within the realms of possibility, Vertigo!

SY were able to prove Gerry couldn't possibly be Smithman when they forensically examined the timeline & ran it all through the magic computer. Hey presto, McCanns not suspects.

[misty]

Oh dear. You're relying on 'Wolters said so'. That's a little embaressing.

Right back at you. "Smiths said so".
I am aware of what the evidence apparently is, from another source. Whether it can be admitted in a future trial  will rest on the outcome of current BKA appeal against the acquittals.

[Wonderfulspam]

Right back at you. "Smiths said so".
I am aware of what the evidence apparently is, from another source. Whether it can be admitted in a future trial  will rest on the outcome of current BKA appeal against the acquittals.

Yes, just trust me bro is what you're saying & I'm not buying it.

[Wonderfulspam]

Wolters doesn't appear to have shared the secret evidence with Madeleine's parents, only with misty for some reason?

[misty]

Wolters doesn't appear to have shared the secret evidence with Madeleine's parents, only with misty for some reason?

HCW hasn't shared anything with me.

[Wonderfulspam]

HCW hasn't shared anything with me.

No sorry it was your secret source that told you about the secret evidence which for some unknown reason is connected somehow to the outcome of some unrelated cases. Ok.

[Uncle Jr]

I think Spams scenario goes something like this, Vertigo, Maddie has to be gone from the apartment when the Tapas 7 rush there after the alarm is raised, so Gerry moves the body a short distance to waste land on his first check once it is pitch black. To move the body to its final resting place at that time would have taken way too long and caused suspicion.
But, after the alarm is raised, no one would be at all suspicious if Gerry disappeared for several minutes or even an hour or more searching for his daughter!

You make a valid point about the light, or lack of it.
Sunset was 20.25pm that night, give or take.

[Uncle Jr]

The Smith family didn't come forward until Murat's face was all over the news. That was a red flag in itself, given the fear factor for the children in their care and the small resort was crawling with police and journalists for the remainder of their holiday. If only there had been CCTV showing the exact time Smiths returned to the complex that night...what time did you say it was?
The evidence against CB is unrelated to the Smith sighting.

I've seen you present this theory before - the Smiths only got involved when Robert Murat was in the frame.
I'm afraid that's just about as far fetched as we've seen thus far. Perverting justice en masse and happily trotting into infamy to ensure Robert doesn't get heat? No, it's not a theory I can get behind. At all.

[Uncle Jr]

Right back at you. "Smiths said so".
I am aware of what the evidence apparently is, from another source. Whether it can be admitted in a future trial  will rest on the outcome of current BKA appeal against the acquittals.

What is it?

[Uncle Jr]

There is evidence placing him at the scene. It's just not been made public yet.

If there was evidence placing him at the scene they would have used it when he was still in prison I would have thought. I hope you're right, but I think your source is playing you.

[Wonderfulspam]

What is it?

It's a secret but just trust me bro!

[Uncle Jr]

It's a secret but just trust me bro!

If it's this evidence placing him at the scene, it doesn't scan.
Imagine sitting on potentially pivotal information, letting CB out and he abducts another child. It's beyond improbable, it would be criminal.

[misty]

I've seen you present this theory before - the Smiths only got involved when Robert Murat was in the frame.
I'm afraid that's just about as far fetched as we've seen thus far. Perverting justice en masse and happily trotting into infamy to ensure Robert doesn't get heat? No, it's not a theory I can get behind. At all.

Do you think the Smiths would have come forward if RM hadn't been in the frame? Why didn't the 2 adult males help with efits while PJ investigation was still open - how were they helping police find Madeleine?

[Joe Blogs]

You make a valid point about the light, or lack of it.
Sunset was 20.25pm that night, give or take.

Yes, so its also a possibility that Gerry actually moved Maddie to the scrubland before they left for dinner then, Uncle? If guilty of course!

[Uncle Jr]

Do you think the Smiths would have come forward if RM hadn't been in the frame? Why didn't the 2 adult males help with efits while PJ investigation was still open - how were they helping police find Madeleine?

You didn't read my post did you?
Explain why they would pervert the course of justice to assist their estate agent during the biggest manhunt in world.