Well you've given me a hint, thank you.
The open window and shutters aren't evidence of stranger abduction.
The accounts of people present that evening are so confused they confirm little except that a group of people were dining at the Tapas. Jeremy Wilkins saw Gerry McCann between 8.45 and 9.15pm, for example. Very imprecise and not at all helpful. The UK police, who could easily have checked the difference in the levels of dusk/darkness at the relevant times and discussed that with him didn't. Jane Tanner gives the impression it was dark, but was it? Russell wasn't exactly sure how dark it was at 9.30pm.
Scotland Yard have said it could have been a pre-planned abduction..or not. Madeleine may have been alive when she left the apartment..or she may not. She may still be alive..or she may not.
Scotland Yard have investigated unsavoury characters...but they haven't been arrested or charged so they may have done something wrong...or they may not. There was a possibility that Madeleine's disappearance was connected to other crimes against children in the Algarve...but then again maybe not.
Lots of evidence? Maybe; time will tell. Lots of hypotheses? Yes. Any proof? None which has led to charges being made, it would seem.
If your 'evidence' can be verified or confirmed beyond reasonable doubt I'd be very surprised.
Thankfully there aren't many abductions from 'home', but I think you would find in most cases like this that the open shutters and window would be considered a clue.
For some reason Amaral decided immediately.... immediately .... that the Mccanns were responsible.
The unthinking man said that it would have been impossible to get into the apartment via the bedroom window ... or the front door cos it was locked ... or the patio door cos it was overlooked
Heriberto has disproved the window scenario, although it would be mighty difficult to get in that way ... and marks would inevitably have been left IMO
The burglaries in other apartments via the front door have disproved his front door theory ...and the keys went missing. So easy to cast a spare.
The front door was almost certainly the way in. Before all the felling of the beautiful trees and the new lamp, the front door was in complete darkness .... and no-one passed by.
It was also within easy signalling view of the balcony opposite as mentioned below. For a young athletic person there was an easy escape route over the wall
I agree with Amaral about the patio door., The patio area was bathed in light (a pale light) from the street lamp opposite and an abductor would have been very concerned about being seen by the tapas group who were just over 50 metres away..
Also houses in the little side street opposite the Tapas reception and the little parking area would, I think, have had a good view of anyone trying to get in. It is difficult to be certain if they would have had a good view, or not, because of a highish wall and the ground slope of the area. The main windows of these houses are upstairs ... and obviously I could not physically go up someones outside steps to check.
Also this patio area was well overlooked by anyone coming up the street on the eastern pavement and by several windows and balconies in block 6 opposite.
In fact I think it likely that the whole abduction was orchestrated by someone watching the comings and goings from the balcony on the western side of block 6. Probably the one on the first floor which also looked straight across into the patio area and into the Mccann apartment living room. Fag ends were found there, so someone had loitered there.
The front door was almost certainly the way in and out. The window was opened as an escape route and for several other reasons, which I have covered before.