Author Topic: Was it all Amaral's fault?  (Read 45387 times)

0 Members and 6 Guests are viewing this topic.

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #240 on: September 15, 2016, 08:22:38 AM »
Well you've given me a hint, thank you.

The open window and shutters aren't evidence of stranger abduction.

The accounts of people present that evening are so confused they confirm little except that a group of people were dining at the Tapas. Jeremy Wilkins saw Gerry McCann between 8.45 and 9.15pm, for example. Very imprecise and not at all helpful. The UK police, who could easily have checked the difference in the levels of dusk/darkness at the relevant times and discussed that with him didn't. Jane Tanner gives the impression it was dark, but was it? Russell wasn't exactly sure how dark it was at 9.30pm.

Scotland Yard have said it could have been a pre-planned abduction..or not. Madeleine may have been alive when she left the apartment..or she may not. She may still be alive..or she may not.

Scotland Yard have investigated unsavoury characters...but they haven't been arrested or charged so they may have done something wrong...or they may not. There was a possibility that Madeleine's disappearance was connected to other crimes against children in the Algarve...but then again maybe not.

Lots of evidence? Maybe; time will tell. Lots of hypotheses? Yes. Any proof? None which has led to charges being made, it would seem.

If your 'evidence' can be verified or confirmed beyond reasonable doubt I'd be very surprised.
Can the dog evidence be verified or confirmed?  No, but you accept it as evidence whilst rejecting everything I have put forward.

Let's simplify this.

Do you accept the possibility that Madeleine was abducted by a stranger, yes or no?  Once you have answered that will lead me to the next question.

Offline G-Unit

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #241 on: September 15, 2016, 08:56:07 AM »
Can the dog evidence be verified or confirmed?  No, but you accept it as evidence whilst rejecting everything I have put forward.

Let's simplify this.

Do you accept the possibility that Madeleine was abducted by a stranger, yes or no?  Once you have answered that will lead me to the next question.


I agree with the Legal Summary. There isn't enough evidence to decide why and how Madeleine disappeared. I agree that she is unlikely to have survived.

You see evidence suggesting stranger abduction. Your evidence doesn't convince me. I suggest we agree to disagree and move on because neither of us will ever convince the other to change their mind.

While it is an unavoidable fact that Madeleine disappeared from Apartment 5A of the 'Ocean Club', the manner and circumstances under which this happened are not - despite the numerous diligences made in that sense -, therefore the range of crimes that were indicated and referred to during the inquiry remains untouched.

Concerning the other indicated crimes, they are no more than that and despite our perception that, due to its high degree of probability, the occurrence of a homicide cannot be discarded, such cannot be more than a mere supposition, due to the lack of sustaining elements in the files.

Despite all of this, it was not possible to obtain any piece of evidence that would allow for a medium man, under the light of the criteria of logics, of normality and of the general rules of experience, to formulate any lucid, sensate, serious and honest conclusion about the circumstances under which the child was removed from the apartment (whether dead or alive, whether killed in a neglectful homicide or an intended homicide, whether the victim of a targeted abduction or an opportunistic abduction), nor even to produce a consistent prognosis about her destiny and inclusively - the most dramatic - to establish whether she is still alive or if she is dead, as seems more likely.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm

Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #242 on: September 15, 2016, 09:02:02 AM »
Can the dog evidence be verified or confirmed?  No, but you accept it as evidence whilst rejecting everything I have put forward.

Let's simplify this.

Do you accept the possibility that Madeleine was abducted by a stranger, yes or no?  Once you have answered that will lead me to the next question.

It's simple really, a number of possibilities.

a) The McCanns were responsible for the disappearance. In which case their statements are an invention.
b) The narrative as put forward by the McCanns is totally accurate. In which case their statements are evidence of what happened.
c) The McCanns were not actively responsible for the disappearance but the narrative was tweaked to paint the McCanns in the best possible light. The validity of the statements is unknown.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #243 on: September 15, 2016, 09:23:20 AM »

I agree with the Legal Summary. There isn't enough evidence to decide why and how Madeleine disappeared. I agree that she is unlikely to have survived.

You see evidence suggesting stranger abduction. Your evidence doesn't convince me. I suggest we agree to disagree and move on because neither of us will ever convince the other to change their mind.

While it is an unavoidable fact that Madeleine disappeared from Apartment 5A of the 'Ocean Club', the manner and circumstances under which this happened are not - despite the numerous diligences made in that sense -, therefore the range of crimes that were indicated and referred to during the inquiry remains untouched.

Concerning the other indicated crimes, they are no more than that and despite our perception that, due to its high degree of probability, the occurrence of a homicide cannot be discarded, such cannot be more than a mere supposition, due to the lack of sustaining elements in the files.

Despite all of this, it was not possible to obtain any piece of evidence that would allow for a medium man, under the light of the criteria of logics, of normality and of the general rules of experience, to formulate any lucid, sensate, serious and honest conclusion about the circumstances under which the child was removed from the apartment (whether dead or alive, whether killed in a neglectful homicide or an intended homicide, whether the victim of a targeted abduction or an opportunistic abduction), nor even to produce a consistent prognosis about her destiny and inclusively - the most dramatic - to establish whether she is still alive or if she is dead, as seems more likely.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm
I'm not letting you off the hook that easily.  I will answer for you as you have swerved yet again giving me a direct and honest answer with no ifs or buts.

"Yes" is what you meant to say.  "Yes, it is possible that Madeleine was abducted by a stranger". 

Here now is your chance to tell me you don't think that abduction is a possibility.

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #244 on: September 15, 2016, 09:27:55 AM »
It's simple really, a number of possibilities.

a) The McCanns were responsible for the disappearance. In which case their statements are an invention.
b) The narrative as put forward by the McCanns is totally accurate. In which case their statements are evidence of what happened.
c) The McCanns were not actively responsible for the disappearance but the narrative was tweaked to paint the McCanns in the best possible light. The validity of the statements is unknown.
Well yes, but evidence is evidence.  It can be accurate, inaccurate, made up or mistaken.  It is still evidence.  If Gerry and Kate and their friends were called in court to give evidence then much of what is in their statements would be repeated in court as evidence, evidence to support their contention that an abductor took Madeleine.  It would be for a jury to decide whether the evidence was compelling enough to come to a verdict but it is still evidence.  To say that evidence given by these people, in particular about the way the room was left on their return to the apartment, is not evidence of abduction, but that a few barks by a dog is evidence of something other than abduction is simply nonsense. 

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #245 on: September 15, 2016, 09:32:30 AM »
Well yes, but evidence is evidence.  It can be accurate, inaccurate, made up or mistaken.  It is still evidence.  If Gerry and Kate and their friends were called in court to give evidence then much of what is in their statements would be repeated in court as evidence, evidence to support their contention that an abductor took Madeleine.  It would be for a jury to decide whether the evidence was compelling enough to come to a verdict but it is still evidence.  To say that evidence given by these people, in particular about the way the room was left on their return to the apartment, is not evidence of abduction, but that a few barks by a dog is evidence of something other than abduction is simply nonsense.

A missing child does not necessarily correlate to abduction.

Dogs of course have no axe to grind, they merely do what they are trained to do, as did Eddie and Keela.

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #246 on: September 15, 2016, 09:44:14 AM »
Well yes, but evidence is evidence.  It can be accurate, inaccurate, made up or mistaken.  It is still evidence.  If Gerry and Kate and their friends were called in court to give evidence then much of what is in their statements would be repeated in court as evidence, evidence to support their contention that an abductor took Madeleine.  It would be for a jury to decide whether the evidence was compelling enough to come to a verdict but it is still evidence.  To say that evidence given by these people, in particular about the way the room was left on their return to the apartment, is not evidence of abduction, but that a few barks by a dog is evidence of something other than abduction is simply nonsense.
But Alfie you still have to admit that all the things Kate noted about the bedroom can all be done from within the kids bedroom.  (Open the window raise the shutters, free-up the curtains.)  So it is possible it was set up to look like an abduction had occurred via the window.)  No true child abductor would bother doing this.  A true abductor would have opened the window to use it, but there was no evidence it was used. So that bit points away from an abduction, and if Madeleine had died prior to cause the cadaver odour in the main bedroom no true abductor would bother abducting a dead child.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline sadie

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #247 on: September 15, 2016, 09:45:06 AM »
Well you've given me a hint, thank you.

The open window and shutters aren't evidence of stranger abduction.

The accounts of people present that evening are so confused they confirm little except that a group of people were dining at the Tapas. Jeremy Wilkins saw Gerry McCann between 8.45 and 9.15pm, for example. Very imprecise and not at all helpful. The UK police, who could easily have checked the difference in the levels of dusk/darkness at the relevant times and discussed that with him didn't. Jane Tanner gives the impression it was dark, but was it? Russell wasn't exactly sure how dark it was at 9.30pm.

Scotland Yard have said it could have been a pre-planned abduction..or not. Madeleine may have been alive when she left the apartment..or she may not. She may still be alive..or she may not.

Scotland Yard have investigated unsavoury characters...but they haven't been arrested or charged so they may have done something wrong...or they may not. There was a possibility that Madeleine's disappearance was connected to other crimes against children in the Algarve...but then again maybe not.

Lots of evidence? Maybe; time will tell. Lots of hypotheses? Yes. Any proof? None which has led to charges being made, it would seem.

If your 'evidence' can be verified or confirmed beyond reasonable doubt I'd be very surprised.
Thankfully there aren't many abductions from 'home', but I think you would find in most cases like this that the open shutters and window would be considered a clue.

For some reason Amaral decided immediately.... immediately .... that the Mccanns were responsible. 

The unthinking man said that it would have been impossible to get into the apartment via the bedroom window ... or the front door cos it was locked ... or the patio door cos it was overlooked

Heriberto has disproved the window scenario, although it would be mighty difficult to get in that way ... and marks would inevitably have been left IMO

The burglaries in other apartments via the front door have disproved his front door theory ...and the keys went missing.  So easy to cast a spare. 

The front door was almost certainly the way in.  Before all the felling of the beautiful trees and the new lamp, the front door was in complete darkness .... and no-one passed by. 

It was also within easy signalling view of the balcony opposite as mentioned below.  For a young athletic person there was an easy escape route over the wall


I agree with Amaral about the patio door.,  The patio area was bathed in light (a pale light) from the street lamp opposite and an abductor would have been very concerned about being seen by the tapas group who were just over 50 metres away.. 

Also houses in the little side street opposite the Tapas reception and the little parking area would, I think, have had a good view of anyone trying to get in.  It is difficult to be certain if they would have had a good view, or not, because of a highish wall and the ground slope of the area.  The main windows of these houses are upstairs ... and obviously I could not physically go up someones outside steps to check.

Also this patio area was well overlooked by anyone coming up the street on the eastern pavement and by several windows and balconies in block 6 opposite.   


In fact I think it likely that the whole abduction was orchestrated by someone watching the comings and goings from the balcony on the western side of block 6.  Probably the one on the first floor which also looked straight across into the patio area and into the Mccann apartment living room.  Fag ends were found there, so someone had loitered there.


The front door was almost certainly the way in and out.  The window was opened as an escape route and for several other reasons, which I have covered before.



Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #248 on: September 15, 2016, 09:46:35 AM »
But Alfie you still have to admit that all the things Kate noted about the bedroom can all be done from within the kids bedroom.  (Open the window raise the shutters, free-up the curtains.)  So it is possible it was set up to look like an abduction had occurred via the window.)  No true child abductor would bother doing this.  A true abductor would have opened the window to use it, but there was no evidence it was used. So that bit points away from an abduction, and if Madeleine had died prior to cause the cadaver odour in the main bedroom no true abductor would bother abducting a dead child.
Whether you accept it as evidence of an abduction is of no interest to me - it's evidence, like it or not.  Do you not think this information would ever be used as evidence in court, either for the prosecution or defence?  If not, why not?

Offline sadie

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #249 on: September 15, 2016, 09:51:22 AM »

I agree with the Legal Summary. There isn't enough evidence to decide why and how Madeleine disappeared. I agree that she is unlikely to have survived.

You see evidence suggesting stranger abduction. Your evidence doesn't convince me. I suggest we agree to disagree and move on because neither of us will ever convince the other to change their mind.

While it is an unavoidable fact that Madeleine disappeared from Apartment 5A of the 'Ocean Club', the manner and circumstances under which this happened are not - despite the numerous diligences made in that sense -, therefore the range of crimes that were indicated and referred to during the inquiry remains untouched.

Concerning the other indicated crimes, they are no more than that and despite our perception that, due to its high degree of probability, the occurrence of a homicide cannot be discarded, such cannot be more than a mere supposition, due to the lack of sustaining elements in the files.

Despite all of this, it was not possible to obtain any piece of evidence that would allow for a medium man, under the light of the criteria of logics, of normality and of the general rules of experience, to formulate any lucid, sensate, serious and honest conclusion about the circumstances under which the child was removed from the apartment (whether dead or alive, whether killed in a neglectful homicide or an intended homicide, whether the victim of a targeted abduction or an opportunistic abduction), nor even to produce a consistent prognosis about her destiny and inclusively - the most dramatic - to establish whether she is still alive or if she is dead, as seems more likely.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm
There is a very good reason why she may have been abducted, but if I mention it here it will be scoffed at, so I will desist.

Almost certainly Madeleine is still alive and basically well ... but unhappily she is not the lovely bubbly fun loving Madeleine that she was.  She is altered.

Offline G-Unit

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #250 on: September 15, 2016, 09:54:33 AM »
I'm not letting you off the hook that easily.  I will answer for you as you have swerved yet again giving me a direct and honest answer with no ifs or buts.

"Yes" is what you meant to say.  "Yes, it is possible that Madeleine was abducted by a stranger". 

Here now is your chance to tell me you don't think that abduction is a possibility.

Your persistence is beginning to feel somewhat like bullying, which I'm sure is not your intention. I'm not on any hook, my answers have been as open and honest as I can make them. You can, as is your habit, answer for me but the answer will, of course, be yours and not mine.

My views on evidence supporting stranger abduction can be seen on other threads, particularly the thread set up for the purpose of evaluating it. I have no intention of posting anything because you demand I do so.

I feel like you're harassing me so could you please modify your tone, stop making demands and allow us to return to the thread topic.

Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #251 on: September 15, 2016, 09:58:45 AM »
Whether you accept it as evidence of an abduction is of no interest to me - it's evidence, like it or not.  Do you not think this information would ever be used as evidence in court, either for the prosecution or defence?  If not, why not?
They would both try to use it as evidence, but the evidence that it wasn't used as a way out, would win the argument.
I think on analysis it is evidence that Madeleine missing (the initial stages getting her out of the apartment) was not a child abduction, but I argue she was abducted from a position outside her apartment.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #252 on: September 15, 2016, 10:05:14 AM »
Well yes, but evidence is evidence.  It can be accurate, inaccurate, made up or mistaken.  It is still evidence.  If Gerry and Kate and their friends were called in court to give evidence then much of what is in their statements would be repeated in court as evidence, evidence to support their contention that an abductor took Madeleine.  It would be for a jury to decide whether the evidence was compelling enough to come to a verdict but it is still evidence.  To say that evidence given by these people, in particular about the way the room was left on their return to the apartment, is not evidence of abduction, but that a few barks by a dog is evidence of something other than abduction is simply nonsense.

Until such as a solution is found we don't know if their evidence is good or bad. If you believe them because of their narrative and believe their narrative because you believe them, it is circular reasoning.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #253 on: September 15, 2016, 10:54:08 AM »
Your persistence is beginning to feel somewhat like bullying, which I'm sure is not your intention. I'm not on any hook, my answers have been as open and honest as I can make them. You can, as is your habit, answer for me but the answer will, of course, be yours and not mine.

My views on evidence supporting stranger abduction can be seen on other threads, particularly the thread set up for the purpose of evaluating it. I have no intention of posting anything because you demand I do so.

I feel like you're harassing me so could you please modify your tone, stop making demands and allow us to return to the thread topic.
Bless you.  I realise you feel backed into a corner, and so I will stop "bullying" you.  I've made my point.  There IS evidence to support abduction, contrary to your claim there is not, of that there can be no further dispute.   Thanks for giving me the opportunity to demonstrate this. 


Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #254 on: September 15, 2016, 10:56:02 AM »
Until such as a solution is found we don't know if their evidence is good or bad. If you believe them because of their narrative and believe their narrative because you believe them, it is circular reasoning.
The question wasn't to quantify or judge the quality of the evidence, the question was is there evidence of abduction - the answer is yes.  It is at least equal to the evidence of a couple of dogs, which also is completely unverifiable at this time.