What advantage was achieved by lying about the Huelva trip?

[Alfie]

OK so they didn't lie about that, unbelievable isn't it.  Yet the search warrant states they are allowed to stay, well at least one of them was.  Shame Corner didn't stay and video them setting up the ruse I believe the PJ set up on Cuddle Cat.
But we know now he was clean as a whistle.

Maybe Jon Corner lied about it as well.  You do know that it's not just the McCanns who lie don't you?  It's all their family, friends and supporters too.  They just lie, lie, lie, almost continuously all day long, about everything.  It's weird. 

*Note to Mods ^^^joke, not libel. 

[Robittybob1]

Maybe Jon Corner lied about it as well.  You do know that it's not just the McCanns who lie don't you?  It's all their family, friends and supporters too.  They just lie, lie, lie, almost continuously all day long, about everything.  It's weird. 

*Note to Mods ^^^joke, not libel.

I was taking you quite seriously till I got to the end. 

[Brietta]

BILTON: He was right to sense a change. On the day filming was due to start the police arrive at the McCann villa. As they pictures show, they would return.

CORNER: They took most of their clothing, they were taking even the wet clothes out of the washing machine. I was aware that the cuddlecat was boxed up and we were asked to leave the villa.

BILTON: The crew?

CORNER: Everybody.

It appears they were never told that according to the search warrant, there was a right to have an observer present during the search.

A lie of omission on the part of the Policia Judicairia?

[misty]

It appears they were never told that according to the search warrant, there was a right to have an observer present during the search.

A lie of omission on the part of the Policia Judicairia?

Omission. Paiva was one of the officers who arrived at the villa at 6pm. He spoke English & would have known the McCanns rights, especially being their FLO.
Murat was able to stay in his mother's villa when the PJ searched with the dogs.

[Robittybob1]

Omission. Paiva was one of the officers who arrived at the villa at 6pm. He spoke English & would have known the McCanns rights, especially being their FLO.
Murat was able to stay in his mother's villa when the PJ searched with the dogs.

I'd say it was the video cameras and two camera men that were the issue.

[faithlilly]

Good example.  What happened when Gerry said "no comment" in that instance?  A whole new conspiracy was born!

So the McCanns were adjusting their behaviour so the sceptics had nothing to gossip about. Is that what you are saying?

[Alice Purjorick]

So I'm right.

The McCanns were not keen to advertise to the world that the place they last lived with their daughter before she vanished was about to be invaded by police.

I defy any, here, in identical circumstances, to say they would be.

And I will call into question their honesty.

I always lie.

[Alfie]

So the McCanns were adjusting their behaviour so the sceptics had nothing to gossip about. Is that what you are saying?

I'm saying that whatever the McCanns say or do you will harshly criticise and then tell us what they should have said or done instead.  It's tiresome, childish, and very predictable.

[Brietta]

Omission. Paiva was one of the officers who arrived at the villa at 6pm. He spoke English & would have known the McCanns rights, especially being their FLO.
Murat was able to stay in his mother's villa when the PJ searched with the dogs.

In other words a coach and horses was driven through the McCann's legal rights if the truth was not disclosed to them.

There was obviously no language barrier because Paiva was one of the attending officers.  Therefore it seems the failure was intentional and was done intentionally to deprive the McCanns of their legal rights.

It was a lie.  A very serious lie at that, as the comparison with the Murat search makes clear. 

[Alice Purjorick]

In other words a coach and horses was driven through the McCann's legal rights if the truth was not disclosed to them.

There was obviously no language barrier because Paiva was one of the attending officers.  Therefore it seems the failure was intentional and was done intentionally to deprive the McCanns of their legal rights.

It was a lie.  A very serious lie at that, as the comparison with the Murat search makes clear.

If it was done you have no evidence it was intentional.
Anyway look on the positive side, were it to finish up before a judge any halfway decent brief would be able to make capital out of it so not too much lost eh?

[faithlilly]

I'm saying that whatever the McCanns say or do you will harshly criticise and then tell us what they should have said or done instead.  It's tiresome, childish, and very predictable.

You really have to make your mind up Alfie. Either the McCanns have absolutely no interest in what sceptics say, bigger fish to fry bladdy, bladdy blah or they hide things in case sceptics question their actions. Which one is it ?

[ShiningInLuz]

In other words a coach and horses was driven through the McCann's legal rights if the truth was not disclosed to them.

There was obviously no language barrier because Paiva was one of the attending officers.  Therefore it seems the failure was intentional and was done intentionally to deprive the McCanns of their legal rights.

It was a lie.  A very serious lie at that, as the comparison with the Murat search makes clear.

The keyword is "if".

The rest is speculation.

[misty]

The keyword is "if".

The rest is speculation.

Portuguese justice system has an odd way of allowing an arguido to watch the PJ search his property but kicking the victim's parents out of their residence for the same purpose.

[sadie]

I always lie.

yep, we noticed.

[Alice Purjorick]

yep, we noticed.

I am sure if you ask Slarti nicely he will explain it to you as he seems to be the only one who has ever cottoned on when I have posted that; it is a sort of intelligence test......................................