According to some, there is certainly circumstantial evidence of abduction.

[Vertigo Swirl]

You have undermined all your arguments if you say Madeleine "was missing for 12 hours or more", and then claim that "they maybe telling the truth".  I can't see how you can have both of those ideas in the same theory.

I think you need to outline your "theory" to stop us guessing as to what position you are arguing from.

???

[Mr Gray]

???

Rob thinks you mean Maddie, was missing for 12 hours before the alarm was, raised

[faithlilly]

Who knows whether she is guilty or not ?
It's never been tested in court and  as far as casual  observers are concerned, it's all down to individual belief

The PJ found no evidence of abduction and as no one is an arguido at the moment it would appear OG and the new PJ investigation haven’t either.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Rob thinks you mean Maddie, was missing for 12 hours before the alarm was, raised

No that's certainly not what I meant.

[Mr Gray]

The PJ found no evidence of abduction and as no one is an arguido at the moment it would appear OG and the new PJ investigation haven’t either.

The pj didn't find anything... Redwood  made it clear that based on the evidence they believed maddie had been abducted.. Rowley has reinforced  that...

[faithlilly]

The pj didn't find anything... Redwood  made it clear that based on the evidence they believed maddie had been abducted.. Rowley has reinforced  that...

At one point Amaral and Rebelo believed  that the McCanns had been involved in Madeleinw’s disappearance. That could not be substantiated. Redwood in 2013, you believe, said that Madeleine may have been abducted. Five years later and their appears to be no evidence to substantiate that claim either.

Tell me Davel if there was enough evidence in 2011-2013 to convince Redwood that Madeleine had been abducted why has the evidence lead nowhere ? Further why have we not heard from Walls, Redwood’s successor, in all those years ?

[Mr Gray]

At one point Amaral and Rebelo believed  that the McCanns had been involved in Madeleinw’s disappearance. That could not be substantiated. Redwood in 2013, you believe, said that Madeleine may have been abducted. Five years later and their appears to be no evidence to substantiate that claim either.

Tell me Davel if there was enough evidence in 2011-2013 to convince Redwood that Madeleine had been abducted why has the evidence lead nowhere ? Further why have we not heard from Walls, Redwood’s successor, in all those years ?

It's led nowhere because the trail has run cold... Byron posted an article from a, Portuguese, paper highlighting the sheer incompetence of the initial investigation... If only SY could have been involved earlier we may have got some, answers

[Alice Purjorick]

It's led nowhere because the trail has run cold... Byron posted an article from a, Portuguese, paper highlighting the sheer incompetence of the initial investigation... If only SY could have been involved earlier we may have got some, answers

UK police had an MIR in PdL early doors.

[faithlilly]

It's led nowhere because the trail has run cold... Byron posted an article from a, Portuguese, paper highlighting the sheer incompetence of the initial investigation... If only SY could have been involved earlier we may have got some, answers

Or they had a hypothesis but found nothing to substantiate it.

And my question re: Nicola Walls ? Could it be that she doesn’t want to go on the record and perhaps have to fudge the truth ? Perhaps she hasn’t as good a poker face as Redwood when asked if the parents are being investigated?

[slartibartfast]

It's led nowhere because the trail has run cold... Byron posted an article from a, Portuguese, paper highlighting the sheer incompetence of the initial investigation... If only SY could have been involved earlier we may have got some, answers

When you translate the Portuguese it doesn’t quite say that.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Or they had a hypothesis but found nothing to substantiate it.

And my question re: Nicola Walls ? Could it be that she doesn’t want to go on the record and perhaps have to fudge the truth ? Perhaps she hasn’t as good a poker face as Redwood when asked if the parents are being investigated?

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GUVT1NZtZPo

[Mr Gray]

When you translate the Portuguese it doesn’t quite say that.

So what do you think it says... I've read the whole article with the online translation... Point out where that translation is, wrong

[Alice Purjorick]

The pj didn't find anything... Redwood  made it clear that based on the evidence they believed maddie had been abducted.. Rowley has reinforced  that...

In 14 months they came up empty handed.
After 7 years the MPS have come up empty handed.

[Mr Gray]

In 14 months they came up empty handed.
After 7 years the MPS have come up empty handed.

No.. They have at least ruled, the, parents out

[Robittybob1]

Rob thinks you mean Maddie, was missing for 12 hours before the alarm was, raised

if VS is meaning 12 hours after there is no issue.  But it wasn't clear in the post.