Then why did she identify George as the man she saw ?
Tim Craig-Harvey: She was then presented with a photograph of this guy George in the market at which point she broke down and said “That is the guy that I saw carrying the child”. This was a pretty strong indication that the guy who had been seen in Portugal, had an integral role in the disappearance of Madeleine. It was extraordinary to be in the room next door on my own, listening to the conversation, and to be part of her reaction.
Transcript: The McCanns and the Conman Channel 5 - 04 June 2014Narrator: But Jane Tanner’s secret recording did reveal something unexpected. It seeded doubts about Kevin Halligen’s credentials to lead the investigation.
Richard Parton: I actually caught Kevin's voice on tape and also happened to catch him in action. I learned remarkable things about him. And not only did he have no skillsets, he was out of his depth, and honestly, for this person, that should not have been the case.
Narrator: Kevin Halligen’s team was halfway through the publicly funded investigation into Madeleine's disappearance. Questions about Halligens suitability to lead the investigation were emerging and divisions were opening up between him and the team.
https://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/conman_04_06_2014.htmThe pertinent part of the outcome of Jane's interview was the revelation of Halligan's ineptitude as an interviewer which led to questions being raised about his professionalism.
Is it any wonder if his interviewing technique was so bad as to arouse suspicion that the resultant interview was less than textbook satisfactory.
Put simply the man did not know the basics.
Who knows if left to their own devices the Exton team might have been able to deliver the goods?