Crecheman's identity finally revealed

[barrier]

Jane Tanner said that she saw a man carrying a child from the direction of Block 4, towards the house of Robert Murat.  This has been discussed at great length, so No Cite needed.

We do NOT now know this to be Dr. Totman.

Tanner is the only one to mention a direction,all others are asumptions.

[faithlilly]

A good try.  But Redwood never did say for certain.

Read my post. I said every possibility.

[barrier]

I remain convinced Jane Tanner's account of the events concerning her is yet to be overturned.  In my opinion it is accurate and therefore I believe that man is still to be traced.

How do you square the circle of Redwood stating that they identified a British holiday maker in the exact same area at the time of the Tanner sighting if hes not been traced.

[jassi]

How do you square the circle of Redwood stating that they identified a British holiday maker in the exact same area at the time of the Tanner sighting if hes not been traced.

Assuming that Trotman was there at the specified time, it is strange that he seems to have seen neither Tanner or Tannerman.

[Robittybob1]

Assuming that Trotman was there at the specified time, it is strange that he seems to have seen neither Tanner or Tannerman.

How did you work that out?

[barrier]

Assuming that Trotman was there at the specified time, it is strange that he seems to have seen neither Tanner or Tannerman.

Redwood was clear on the exact same time,so the holiday maker belived to be Totnam either looked at his watch or confirmed he saw some one to enable Redwood to be precise.No one else about,time line moved on.

[Robittybob1]

Redwood was clear on the exact same time,so the holiday maker belived to be Totnam either looked at his watch or confirmed he saw some one to enable Redwood to be precise.No one else about,time line moved on.

Is that fact or fiction?

[jassi]

Is that fact or fiction?

I guess you either believe Redwood or you don't.

[Brietta]

How do you square the circle of Redwood stating that they identified a British holiday maker in the exact same area at the time of the Tanner sighting if hes not been traced.

In my opinion there is no circle to be squared ~ nor do I share the sentiment of someone in Luz that ...

It is not in my opinion what DCI Redwood did say which is of interest to me ... it is what he did not say which in my opinion says it all.

[faithlilly]

Redwood was clear on the exact same time,so the holiday maker belived to be Totnam either looked at his watch or confirmed he saw some one to enable Redwood to be precise.No one else about,time line moved on.

Perhaps he saw Tanner but not Gerry/Wilkins and that is why Redwood said almost certain ?

[barrier]

Redwood was clear on the exact same time,so the holiday maker believed to be Totnam either looked at his watch or confirmed he saw some one to enable Redwood to be precise.No one else about,time line moved on.

Is that fact or fiction?

I have used the DCI's words "in the exact same area at the time of the sighting",I have used the words quoted to be from Mrs Totnam on the opening gambit of this thread,you decide.

[Eleanor]

From the opening gambit on this thread.

Redwood: We in the work we have done have been able to indentify a British holiday maker returning to their apartment in the exact same area at the time of the sighting Jane tanner saw.

This lead them to move the focus on,Redwood is clear moved on,Mrs Totman is clear it was her husband,no other sightings were reported in the exact same area,now ask yourself who or what did Mr Totnam see to be so precise about their timings,Redwood never made that up,some one gave him Mr Totmans times.

So we now have proof of this?  I don't think so.

[barrier]

It is not in my opinion what DCI Redwood did say which is of interest to me ... it is what he did not say which in my opinion says it all.

So when Redwood says the McCanns nor their friends are suspects,its of no interest.

[Miss Taken Identity]

Assuming that Trotman was there at the specified time, it is strange that he seems to have seen neither Tanner or Tannerman.

...and the two men chatting. IF JT saw the abductor and it wasn't Totman then someone else was in the area walking about at the same time. makes sense. there was three people in that area apparently.

[Eleanor]

Murats house was along that direction along with others,not towards his house,world of difference

Only in the direction of.  But it was still in that direction.  What was Dr Totman doing in going that way.  If indeed it was him?