Amaral and the dogs

[ferryman]

Do you know offhand if any of the people who like to ask questions have gone to the bother to ascertain why Mr Amaral did not invite the dogs in when they were offered at a time when they might actually have made a positive contribution to finding Madeleine McCann?

The thought occurs that, in the early days, the English might have offered a sam dog, which would have been the dog-type with the best chance of finding Madeleine in the early days.

Although I don't know how soon after a disappearance you have to deploy such dogs.

[G-Unit]

But we can dismiss this as hogwash as it was in the Sun, correct?

How can a story without a named source be verified? It's just gossip.

[Mr Gray]

How much do you know about D.N.A. analysis in forensic science ?

Would it be more or less than Amaral ? &%+((£

from what amaral has said I would say I know more than amaral

[pathfinder73]

When did this happen?  Before or during dinner?

You will find out.

"When a body is frozen and thawed, Notman said, blood cells rupture and leak intracellular fluid."

http://articles.latimes.com/1994-07-18/news/mn-17063_1_frozen-depths

[Alfred R Jones]

You will find out.

"When a body is frozen and thawed, Notman said, blood cells rupture and leak intracellular fluid."

http://articles.latimes.com/1994-07-18/news/mn-17063_1_frozen-depths

When and where was Madeleine frozen?

[Alice Purjorick]

When and where was Madeleine frozen?

Are you suggesting that because no one can say where or when (good song title) it could not have happened?
There is at least one unsolved case where it did happen but no one knows where and only approximately when.

[Alfred R Jones]

Are you suggesting that because no one can say where or when (good song title) it could not have happened?
There is at least one unsolved case where it did happen but no one knows where and only approximately when.

No, I'm asking Pathfinder where and when Madeleine was frozen, is that OK with you?

[Alfred R Jones]

Are you suggesting that because no one can say where or when (good song title) it could not have happened?
There is at least one unsolved case where it did happen but no one knows where and only approximately when.

PS: I take it from your post that we should consider all and any scenario as eminently possible re: Madeleine's fate: fed to pigs, abducted by hot air ballon, sewn into the body of a dog, thrown down a volcano, etc.

[Alice Purjorick]

No, I'm asking Pathfinder where and when Madeleine was frozen, is that OK with you?

Fine by me. I was just pointing out the question and answer will not prove much as it has been done before and the case remains unsolved.

[Alice Purjorick]

PS: I take it from your post that we should consider all and any scenario as eminently possible re: Madeleine's fate: fed to pigs, abducted by hot air ballon, sewn into the body of a dog, thrown down a volcano, etc.

I was saying don't give your customary sneer to something which has happened before.
You are always big on asking that it be shown something has happened before and if it hasn't it is unlikely it can happen.

[Alfred R Jones]

Fine by me. I was just pointing out the question and answer will not prove much as it has been done before and the case remains unsolved.

When I want your opinion and advice I'll be sure to ask you directly, but thanks anyway.

[pegasus]

You've got a short memory Pfinder
Eddie picked Ccat up and threw it up in the air.  He didn't alert to it
Even when it was placed at the bottom of the cupboard, Eddie sniffed really close, inches from it, twice, but did not alert either time.
Later, after Martin G had insisted Eddie checked the counter above,  he alerted to a pile of folders, papers on the top of the cupboard counter.  These were feet away from CCat.
Martin mistakenly took that as an alert to CCat.
Eddie was alerting to the papers.
Eddie DID NOT alert to CCat.

"Eddie DID NOT alert to CCat" I agree with you Sadie.

"Eddie was alerting to the papers". I agree the first of his two alerts in the villa was to that pile on the sideboard.
The pile he sniffs just before alerting.
However in that pile are folded clothes.

Everything in the box labelled "sala comum" came from IMO on the dining table or on that sideboard.
Check the other items to confirm (its easy to find the pillows, pillowcases, towels) 

[Alfred R Jones]

I was saying don't give your customary sneer to something which has happened before.
You are always big on asking that it be shown something has happened before and if it hasn't it is unlikely it can happen.

You really have picked up the wrong end of the stick Alice, now kindly butt out - I am quizzing Pathfinder on her/his beliefs, I am well aware that bodies have been frozen before, thanks.

[pathfinder73]

You really have picked up the wrong end of the stick Alice, now kindly butt out - I am quizzing Pathfinder on her/his beliefs, I am well aware that bodies have been frozen before, thanks.

You start with a KEY. They were given keys to the church so getting access to another property is certainly a possibility. You investigate sightings at unknown properties and the person who got them the keys and stored the car isn't mentioned once in their truth book. He was not questioned by the PJ. It's like he didn't exist! Will the yard finally investigate this KEY man.

[sadie]

You start with a KEY. They were given keys to the church so getting access to another property is certainly a possibility. You investigate sightings at unknown properties and the person who got them the keys and stored the car isn't mentioned once in their truth book. He was not questioned by the PJ. It's like he didn't exist! Will the yard finally investigate this KEY man.

Aw Gawd, Pfinder, what new myth are you developing?


So you think the Church keys would fit other properties?