Amaral and the dogs

[mercury]

The significance is plane to see: the only location in which the clothing could have acquired scent that evening was on that shelf.

You cannot say that as fact when a) clothes have not been identified in that fuzzy  pile and b) even if they were, what is to say the scent was acqured there and no where else?

Are you sayng the shelf was contaminated before May 3?

[pathfinder73]

But he doesn't alert at wardrobe floor level Pathfinder. He alerts to first shelf above floor level.

And it wasn't the clothes on that shelf that Eddie alerted to three months later.

[mercury]

And it wasn't the clothes on that shelf that Eddie alerted to three months later.

Mr Grime said the scent can transfer in a room from it's original source point, so any porous material nearby can have picked it up

[pegasus]

I can see the smilarity in shapes now. Where did you get that image no. 2?

There isn't any red top with a white design in the forensic clothing file?

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CLOTHES.htm

But where are you going with all this?

item 3 Mercury

[mercury]

item 3 Mercury

Yes,thanks for replying hours later after bypassing my post inititally. I did figure out you had cut and pasted and enlarged the one white aeroplane on that red top and enlarged it to match the thing in the wardrobe you thought it matched. Besides, the item in the wardrobe was not red, more orange.

You have not elaborated on your latest "theory" about the clothes and dog alerts.

[pegasus]

Yes,thanks for replying hours later after bypassing my post inititally. I did figure out you had cut and pasted and enlarged the one white aeroplane on that red top and enlarged it to match the thing in the wardrobe you thought it matched. Besides, the item in the wardrobe was not red, more orange.

You have not elaborated on your latest "theory" about the clothes and dog alerts.

The proposition is that item 3 was on that shelf the whole evening.
 

[mercury]

The proposition is that item 3 was on that shelf the whole evening.

So what if it was?

[pathfinder73]

The proposition is that item 3 was on that shelf the whole evening.

And Kate's pants? Maybe she wore them on 3 May as she likes wearing them as is proven in many pics.

[pegasus]

So what if it was?

That means it acquired scent while it was not being worn.

[mercury]

That means it acquired scent while it was not being worn.

Even if that was true, so?

[pegasus]

And Kate's pants? Maybe she wore them on 3 May as she likes wearing them as is proven in many pics.

IMO all three clothes listed as alerted were on that shelf for the whole evening/night of May 3rd.

[pegasus]

Even if that was true, so?

It is progress which dumps the rubbish assumption
"clothing 1 2 3 contacted source at location unknown while being worn by someone"
and replaces it with
"clothing 1 2 3 contacted source while at exact location a in room b and it was not being worn at the time".

[mercury]

It is progress which dumps the rubbish assumption
"clothing 1 2 3 contacted source at location unknown while being worn by someone"
and replaces it with
"clothing 1 2 3 contacted source while at exact location a in room b and it was not being worn at the time".

Didnt you digest and or factor in my previous post? The scent source can settle anywhere porous in the near vicinity

But yes you could argue scented clothes were not actually worn

[pegasus]

Didnt you digest and or factor in my previous post? The scent source can settle anywhere porous in the near vicinity

But yes you could argue scented clothes were not actually worn

In addition to alerting to the 3 listed clothes, he on earlier date alerted to the empty shelf where IMO the clothes had been the whole evening of the 3rd May. There was no alerts to the porous air-trapping beds mattresses.

[mercury]

In addition to alerting to the 3 listed clothes, he on earlier date alerted to the empty shelf where IMO the clothes had been the whole evening of the 3rd May. There was no alerts to the porous air-trapping beds mattresses.

But you have no proof all three items were in that shelf and also AS I said the scent could have come from anywhere in that room

Now I am interested to know what your underlying thesis is surrounding all this