Amaral and the dogs

[misty]

Perhaps you should watch dogs in the field.

This is what they do.

And you will be well aware of dogs sense of smell if far more effective than our own and the consequences of that.

Yes, I am well aware of just how good trained dogs are in general. However, it has not escaped my attention that they normally move towards the source of a scent rather than away from it, in the same manner that Eddie did in on the beach demonstration video. Please explain what caused the scent to diffuse so far when the car was enclosed underground & not in a field.

[Mr Gray]

That is not evidence dave.

Can you cite examples  please.

I just have....You have repeatedly claimed posters had not seen scent dogs working... I have and many on here will have seen dogs being led once along a queue at an airport...showing your claims to be BS..

[stephen25000]

I just have....You have repeatedly claimed posters had not seen scent dogs working... I have and many on here will have seen dogs being led once along a queue at an airport...showing your claims to be BS..

That is not proof.

That is on your say so.

There is a plethora of programs showing dogs in action and they go to and from sites when they are being employed.

[Mr Gray]

That is not proof.

That is on your say so.

There is a plethora of programs showing dogs in action and they go to and from sites when they are being employed.

Do you see why I criticise your poor ability to properly read a post....you suddenly replace the word evidence with proof as though they are interchangeable  ...they are not..

could you guide us to one example of the dogs behaving in teh way you have claimed

[slartibartfast]

Do you see why I criticise your poor ability to properly read a post....you suddenly replace the word evidence with proof as though they are interchangeable  ...they are not..

could you guide us to one example of the dogs behaving in teh way you have claimed

You are happy with the dog alerts as evidence rather than proof then?

[Mr Gray]

That is not proof.

That is on your say so.

There is a plethora of programs showing dogs in action and they go to and from sites when they are being employed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CO09LXMd-ps

what good would these dogs be if they did not react at once to a scent

[Mr Gray]

You are happy with the dog alerts as evidence rather than proof then?

haven't you read any of my posts...my opinion is unimportant...Grime's is...the alerts are not evidence

[ferryman]

haven't you read any of my posts...my opinion is unimportant...Grime's is...the alerts are not evidence

Indeed.

Evidence is allowed in court.

Uncorroborated dog alerts are not ...

[Lace]

Meanwhile dave, we're still waiting for scientific proof that

pH  -  pOH  means anything at all.

It seems your sole aim is to disrupt every thread on this forum Stephen.

Who the hell cares what you know and what you don't.   There is no doubt things you don't know about other subjects,   other posters are not bragging about their knowledge on this forum are they?

The thread is called 'Amaral and the dogs'.

[stephen25000]

I just have....You have repeatedly claimed posters had not seen scent dogs working... I have and many on here will have seen dogs being led once along a queue at an airport...showing your claims to be BS..

I'm afraid dave, you need more than that.

Now tell me dave. what range of materials do dogs look for at airports ?

[Mr Gray]

so it seem that scent dogs alert immediately to the scent they are trained for and do not require constantly being brought back for another go

[ferryman]

You are happy with the dog alerts as evidence rather than proof then?

The dog alerts are intelligence!

[Mr Gray]

The dog alerts are intelligence!

so once again...what do the alerts tell us... I would say b....r all

[ferryman]

so once again...what do the alerts tell us... I would say b....r all

In a nut-shell!

[faithlilly]

In a nut-shell!

Then let's hope SY agree with you.