two peas in a pod......neither amarals or sadies theory have been proven wrong...that was the point i was making
Erm …….
Two peas in a pod ? I think not.
I think Amarals theory has been shown to be wrong in a number of places, and he doesn't adjust his thinking when that is shown, except when he thinks that he has been uncovered. If one makes a mistake, then one should adjust ones theory and go back to where everything was definitely correct. In Engineering that place was called The Datum
I feel sure that I will have made some mistakes in the books of facts and co-incidences that I have given to SY, but at least I have shown the integrity to rectify these … and pointed out to them that I cannot be sure, when I am not sure.
As far as I can see, Amaral has set his mind right from the start and never allowed anything that discredits his theory to get in the way. He has ignored stuff that he should have looked at and also stuff that made a nonsense of parts of his theory … he has just gone along, set in his mind, in the same vein as he decided on at the very beginning. Bad Practice.
These are just my observations and I believe correct. No, I am not going to get bogged down in finding cites. I am too old for that. By all means challenge my statement here; that is often the way that I realise new facts.
SY have a multitude of mini proofs of what I am saying and many more things that I haven't divulged here. Facts that not one of you knows about. And that is the way it has to stay.