Amaral and the dogs

[mercury]

Not at all , you are mistaken
There are several scenarios
Eddie could be wrong
Grime could be wrong
The alerts may have been due to contamination
There may have been a cadaver in the apartment previously

last point is dud as police confirmed no one had ever died there before, so you are mistaken there
you also have to furnish us with evidence or reason  of how Mr Grime could be wrong,tia

[Mr Gray]

last point is dud as police confirmed no one had ever died there before, so you are mistaken there
you also have to furnish us with evidence or reason  of how Mr Grime could be wrong,tia

I'm referring to a cadaver with Maddie as a possibility ...no dud

[Matthew Wyse]

Not at all , you are mistaken
There are several scenarios
Eddie could be wrong
Grime could be wrong
The alerts may have been due to contamination
There may have been a cadaver in the apartment previously

but then again Eddie and Grime might have been right and you are wrong.

[mercury]

There has to be a reason why the alerts are not admissible......
The only one I can think of is they are not reliable

keep saying that to yourself, one day you might actually believe it
hopefully not though as its patently untrue
Or alternatively join the Gerry Mccann club of cadaver dogs are incredibly unreliable claptrap

[G-Unit]

Not at all , you are mistaken
There are several scenarios
Eddie could be wrong
Grime could be wrong
The alerts may have been due to contamination
There may have been a cadaver in the apartment previously

In which case PJ officers wiping cadavers and planting the scent in the apartment were wasting their time, weren't they? You can't have your cake and eat it. One minute the dog was wrong, next minute it was right but it was a plant gov. 

[mercury]

I'm referring to a cadaver with Maddie as a possibility ...no dud

err no you posted no cadaver in the apartment previously

so yes dud

[Mr Gray]

but then again Eddie and Grime might have been right and you are wrong.

Grime doesn't mention Maddie
Grime says there are several options including contamination

[mercury]

In which case PJ officers wiping cadavers and planting the scent in the apartment were wasting their time, weren't they? You can't have your cake and eat it. One minute the dog was wrong, next minute it was right but it was a plant gov. 

PMSL, how true

 

[Mr Gray]

In which case PJ officers wiping cadavers and planting the scent in the apartment were wasting their time, weren't they? You can't have your cake and eat it. One minute the dog was wrong, next minute it was right but it was a plant gov. 

The lasting of evidence would be to enable an arrest or force a confession of guilty

[Mr Gray]

PMSL, how true

 

I will resist the obvious joke

[Mr Gray]

Off out npe

[mercury]

who is npe?
yes, bye now, dont bang your head and falloff the sofa on your way out lol

[pegasus]

There is something wrong with the exact theory proposed by Amaral to explain the dog alerts.
If someone finds something in the lounge and takes it to the outdoors - all that happening within a tiny slot of a two or three minutes  - why on earth would anyone waste time taking it into a wardrobe in a different room on the way - it would be pointless wouldn't it? - and Amaral fails to state a believable reason why someone would do that complicated diversion.

[mercury]

There is something wrong with the sequence of events proposed by Amaral to explain the dog alerts.
If someone finds something in the lounge and takes it to the outdoors - all that happening within a tiny slot of a two or three minutes  - why on earth would anyone waste time taking it into a wardrobe in a different room on the way - it would be pointless wouldn't it? - and Amaral fails to state a believable reason why someone would do that complicated diversion.

Its possible Madleine died in 5a and its possible she was in the parents bedroom before or after, (MO went looking for her in her parents room rather  than her own room for some reason and also Kate Mccann is on tv record saying you would never think someone would take your child out of "your bed") the alerts outside have always been a bit mysterious
Mr Amaral never claimed to be God or a cadaver and blood dog expert...he spoke as he found as he understood at the time and after advice and info from UK experts, and lets face it, most child disappearances are NOT by strangers, why blame him

What is ridiculous to me is that some people say the cadaver dog could have alerted to sweat in 5A! etc etc Smacks of total denial

[G-Unit]

who is npe?
yes, bye now, dont bang your head and falloff the sofa on your way out lol

More likely on the way in perhaps if drinking is happening?