Amaral and the dogs

[Mr Gray]

Are you saying you left three children under five sleeping in an unlocked apartment in another country while you went out for dinner for two to three hours?

get back on topic

[Mr Gray]

You cant prove a remnant cadaver scent alert
The arguments about alledged blood alerts by cadaver dog  in this case have not been proven, oh hello, because its impossible

so the remnant scent cannot be proved...that's the whole point...we do not know if it is factual or not...yet amaral has said he can prove maddie died in the apartment based on remnant scent..he can't

[mercury]

never seen...not me personally...reckon you are making it up...prove me wrong with a quote

Your reckoning is often wrong, why on earth would I "make anything up"

You will have your quote, then that might shut you up.

[Mr Gray]

Your reckoning is often wrong, why on earth would I "make anything up"

You will have your quote, then that might shut you up.

I doubt there will be any quote..it doesn't exist...perhaps if you cannot supply the quote...you should shut up

[stephen25000]

As I said the other day, the dogs alerted to a body or they didn't.

Since the dogs clearly worried thew mccanns and the lack of evidence of anything else, well to use one of Sadie's words, they are POINTERS.

[Mr Gray]

As I said the other day, the dogs alerted to a body or they didn't.

Since the dogs clearly worried thew mccanns and the lack of evidence of anything else, well to use one of Sadie's words, they are POINTERS.

that's right... there may have been a body...or there might not...so the alerts tell us nothing

[Mr Gray]

no wonder the alerts are not admissible...can you imagine grime in court...

There might have been a body there...or there might not....

[Eleanor]

get back on topic

Sorry, sorry.

[mercury]

so the remnant scent cannot be proved...that's the whole point...we do not know if it is factual or not...yet amaral has said he can prove maddie died in the apartment based on remnant scent..he can't

No, the point is you can't have proof if proof isn't possible, with remnant scent on it's own,doesn't mean the cadaver dog alert "means nothng"

[mercury]

I doubt there will be any quote..it doesn't exist...perhaps if you cannot supply the quote...you should shut up

Lorraine Kelly , Kate Garraway and Fiona Phillips from GMTV has said "we've all done it" then qualified it with " I wouldn't personally" do it
Most people remember this,not  my problem if you don't or wish to accuse me of "making it up"

PS If I have time I will try and fish videos out from youtube IF they still exist

[Benice]

As I said the other day, the dogs alerted to a body or they didn't.

Since the dogs clearly worried thew mccanns and the lack of evidence of anything else, well to use one of Sadie's words, they are POINTERS.

No they weren't Pointers Stephen - they were Spaniels.

(sorry I'll get me coat) :-)

[stephen25000]

that's right... there may have been a body...or there might not...so the alerts tell us nothing

There is nothing else.

Likewise did the dogs alert anywhere else other than where the mccanns had been ?

[mercury]

No they weren't Pointers Stephen - they were Spaniels.

(sorry I'll get me coat) :-)

 

good one B
nice to have a bit of humour sometimes in this depressing board

[stephen25000]

No they weren't Pointers Stephen - they were Spaniels.

(sorry I'll get me coat) :-)

 

[G-Unit]

get back on topic

Thought not.