Amaral and the dogs

[Benice]

good one B
nice to have a bit of humour sometimes in this depressing board

Ty mercury.      I'm sorry you find the board depressing - I think it's a fantastic forum - as it's the only one I know of where (thanks to the mods)  both 'sides' can debate their very different opinions with one-another.       

[mercury]

Ty mercury.      I'm sorry you find the board depressing - I think it's a fantastic forum - as it's the only one I know of where (thanks to the mods)  both 'sides' can debate their very different opinions with one-another.     

depressing as in the subject matter

[Mr Gray]

Lorraine Kelly , Kate Garraway and Fiona Phillips from GMTV has said "we've all done it" then qualified it with " I wouldn't personally" do it
Most people remember this,not  my problem if you don't or wish to accuse me of "making it up"

PS If I have time I will try and fish videos out from youtube IF they still exist

so you cannot supply an exact quote

[Mr Gray]

No, the point is you can't have proof if proof isn't possible, with remnant scent on it's own,doesn't mean the cadaver dog alert "means nothng"

I said that that the existence of remnant scent cannot be proven

[mercury]

so you cannot supply an exact quote

Not at the mo so was "obviously making it up"... just for fun

[mercury]

I said that that the existence of remnant scent cannot be proven

No it was me who said that, your mantra is the dog alerts mean nothing

[Benice]

depressing as in the subject matter

Oh right.  OK.

[stephen25000]

so you cannot supply an exact quote

So dave, how many people have done what the mccanns did ?

I give credit to Eleanor for admitting to doing it.

One of my students parents left their young son in a hotel room which was unlocked in Tenarife about 15 years ago. He got out (he was 3 years old at the time). The rest of the family were out to dinner, but fortunately for them, other people recognized their son and brought him back after he was wondering down a local road. They were lucky.

[stephen25000]

your usual ad hominem attack

Can you back up all the claims you have made ?

[Lace]

So dave, how many people have done what the mccanns did ?

I give credit to Eleanor for admitting to doing it.

One of my students parents left their young son in a hotel room which was unlocked in Tenarife about 15 years ago. He got out (he was 3 years old at the time). The rest of the family were out to dinner, but fortunately for them, other people recognized their son and brought him back after he was wondering down a local road. They were lucky.

What's that got to do with 'Amaral and the dogs'?    Another opportunity for you to repeat the 'left the children' AGAIN Stephen.

[Lace]

In my opinion,   Eddie smelt an aroma  that could have been from anything left on the floor after one of the people who stayed there after the McCann's.     Eddie was called back so many times in my opinion he barked at the smell because he wanted to end the exercise.

[mercury]

In my opinion,   Eddie smelt an aroma  that could have been from anything left on the floor after one of the people who stayed there after the McCann's.     Eddie was called back so many times in my opinion he barked at the smell because he wanted to end the exercise.

So you think the dog got fed up, and just wanted his tennis ball or biscuit quick, and alerted to "anythng" on the floor, maybe it was a sweaty flip flop? from a later holiday maker, but no chance the possibility of the Mccanns child, interesting sort of blanket denial

 

@ Benice no problems, I did say before, but got deleted

[carlymichelle]

What's that got to do with 'Amaral and the dogs'?    Another opportunity for you to repeat the 'left the children' AGAIN Stephen.

well they did didnt they??

[stephen25000]

In my opinion,   Eddie smelt an aroma  that could have been from anything left on the floor after one of the people who stayed there after the McCann's.     Eddie was called back so many times in my opinion he barked at the smell because he wanted to end the exercise.

Have you researched that ?

[ferryman]

The whole question of dog-alerts is just too fraught with unanswered questions:

Why could Eddie detect no scent on clothing in the villa he (apparently!) could (exactly the same clothing!) in the gym?

Was cuddle-cat an error of commission?

Or an error of omission?

Why were the 'inspections' of all other holiday apartments whistle-stop; yet the inspection of apartment 5a long-drawn out and protracted?

Why did Mark Harrison, in his report, expressly disavow UK involvement in those inspections he had nothing to do with (the places Madeleine never lived in or went near).

And so on ....