UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Mr Gray on October 11, 2018, 01:17:51 PM
-
IMO, there was no real evidence against the mccanns when they were made arguidos and according to Pedro Da Carmo there is no evidence against them now...whether they have evidence against others I don't know
-
IMO, there was no real evidence against the mccanns when they were made arguidos and according to Pedro Da Carmo there is no evidence against them now...whether they have evidence against others I don't know
How long ago was it that PDeC said that , Davel , although I do remember him saying it in an interview.
He also replied to a question posed to him regarding what he thought in his heart had happened to Madeleine .
He replied that if it was up to what he thought in his heart the case would have been solved already .
Now what do you think he meant by that ?
-
How long ago was it that PDeC said that , Davel , although I do remember him saying it in an interview.
He also replied to a question posed to him regarding what he thought in his heart had happened to Madeleine .
He replied that if it was up to what he thought in his heart the case would have been solved already .
Now what do you think he meant by that ?
You didn't provide the cite.. I would need to see his exact words...
-
You didn't provide the cite.. I would need to see his exact words...
From the same interview you said he said that the parents were not suspects .
-
From the same interview you said he said that the parents were not suspects .
In the video... If so I wil need to watch it again..
I don't see it... Do you have a link
-
In the video... If so I wil Ned to watch it again
I suspect that question and answer was cut from the video recording.
I distinctly recall him adding unfortunately cases can’t be solved by feelings from the heart.
-
I suspect that question and answer was cut from the video recording.
I distinctly recall him adding unfortunately cases can’t be solved by feelings from the heart.
So no cite... So we don't know what words he used... That's not what you originally said
-
So no cite... So we don't know what words he used... That's not what you originally said
Word for word I could not possibly reproduce his reply to the posed question but I recall being a bit shocked that he’d been asked it and that he gave one .
Do you think I would make something like that up ?
The video currently available https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b08pmtb1 (https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b08pmtb1)
-
Word for word I could not possibly reproduce his reply to the posed question but I recall being a bit shocked that he’d been asked it and that he gave one .
Do you think I would make something like that up ?
You have given two different versions.... Without a cite we don't know what he said and if you have remembered it properly
-
You have given two different versions.... Without a cite we don't know what he said and if you have remembered it properly
The video is currently unavailablehttps://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b08pmtb1 (https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b08pmtb1)
Do you really think I could make something like that up ? I thought he shouldn’t have given an answer to the question .Someine could have played with that.
-
The video is currently unavailablehttps://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b08pmtb1 (https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b08pmtb1)
Do you really think I could make something like that up ? I thought he shouldn’t have given an answer to the question .Someine could have played with that.
Without a cite we only have your version of what he said.... You may have misremebered
-
Without a cite we only have your version of what he said.... You may have misremebered
Yes you do
However I would hardly misremember something like that because as I said I was surprised that he gave an answer although as I said I cannot quote word for word .
-
Yes you do
However I would hardly misremember something like that because as I said I was surprised that he gave an answer although as I said I cannot quote word for word .
It's important to know what he actualy said.... And we don't know that
-
It's important to know what he actualy said.... And we don't know that
Can you just forget I brought it up in response to your post re what he said about the parents not being suspects ? In the great scheme of things it’s not important is it ? imo .
I can’t prove what he said. I’ve shown you in a link that the video is no longer there ?
-
It's important to know what he actualy said.... And we don't know that
Found it in here , it. As I said I couldn’t repeat word for word .
http://portugalresident.com/amaral-breaks-his-silence
As PJ deputy head Pedro do Carmo told the BBC this week: “We have never had any case like this, either before or since”.
His response to the question, “do you think in your heart it will ever be solved” was telling nonetheless. He said: “If it depended on my heart, the case would already be solved. But it doesn’t depend on my heart. It depends, very much, on our minds”
-
You didn't provide the cite.. I would need to see his exact words...
0:00:52 0:00:59
In your heart, do you think it will be solved?
0:00:59 0:01:01
It doesn't depend on my heart - it depends very much on our minds.
-
Found it in here , it. As I said I couldn’t repeat word for word .
http://portugalresident.com/amaral-breaks-his-silence
As PJ deputy head Pedro do Carmo told the BBC this week: “We have never had any case like this, either before or since”.
His response to the question, “do you think in your heart it will ever be solved” was telling nonetheless. He said: “If it depended on my heart, the case would already be solved. But it doesn’t depend on my heart. It depends, very much, on our minds”
You quote the Portuguese resident... Faith quotes the actual video... The Resident misquoted it... What he actually said was quite different
What you have shown is we cannot trust newspapers... Even when they claim actual quotes
-
0:00:52 0:00:59
In your heart, do you think it will be solved?
0:00:59 0:01:01
It doesn't depend on my heart - it depends very much on our minds.
bump....
I think it was the Portugal Resident that completely misquoted and changed the meeting...so it joins the list of papers that cannot be trusted
-
bump....
I think it was the Portugal Resident that completely misquoted and changed the meeting...so it joins the list of papers that cannot be trusted
So Fake News because it contradicts your beliefs?
-
So Fake News because it contradicts your beliefs?
No because it's fake
-
No because it's fake
Well you would say that.
-
Well you would say that.
I've provided proof it's fake
-
I've provided proof it's fake
You have provided proof that the paper’s quote didn’t come from the “video”.
-
You have provided proof that the paper’s quote didn’t come from the “video”.
Where did it come from then? Are you suggesting the Portugal Resident had an exclusive interview with De Carmo when he used a similar set of words but altered the meaning slightly?
-
You have provided proof that the paper’s quote didn’t come from the “video”.
Did he give another interview that was only picked up by the Resident...scraping the barrel
The resident say their quote came from an interview with the BBC that week...
So are you suggesting their were two interviews that week with the BBC where he was asked the same question twice and gave different answers....absolute rubbish....it's clear he was totally misquoted by the Resident
-
You have provided proof that the paper’s quote didn’t come from the “video”.
Documentaries, I'm sure, get cut. Was this documentary shown in Portugal? If so, perhaps it wasn't cut for that showing.
-
Did he give another interview that was only picked up by the Resident...scraping the barrel
The resident say their quote came from an interview with the BBC that week...
So are you suggesting their were two interviews that week with the BBC where he was asked the same question twice and gave different answers....absolute rubbish....it's clear he was totally misquoted by the Resident
I have already told you in either this thread or another that in the Panorama interview I saw in the UK he was asked that question. As I said I don' t think he should have answered it . As he did and as the PR said it was "telling".
-
I have already told you in either this thread or another that in the Panorama interview I saw in the UK he was asked that question. As I said I don' t think he should have answered it . As he did and as the PR said it was "telling".
The PR mistranslated it and is totally biased against the mccanns...faith had provided the correct translation and the actual video
-
Documentaries, I'm sure, get cut. Was this documentary shown in Portugal? If so, perhaps it wasn't cut for that showing.
The question and the answer were shown on the video...
-
I have already told you in either this thread or another that in the Panorama interview I saw in the UK he was asked that question. As I said I don' t think he should have answered it . As he did and as the PR said it was "telling".
And you were right and Davel was wrong Snowgirl
https://subsaga.com/bbc/news/panorama/madeleine-mccann-10-years-on.html
At around 59 minutes. I have put the link on the other thread too.
-
Your link gives this..
0:00:52 0:00:59
In your heart, do you think it will be solved?
0:00:59 0:01:01
It doesn't depend on my heart - it depends very much on our minds.
Which is NOT what the Portugal Resident said...this is the correct translation..and confirms I am correct
Davel READ it AGAIN! I said around 59 minutes not 0.59 minutes. Then apologise to me as it confirms that despite protestation you are in fact incorrect.
-
Davel READ it AGAIN! I said around 59 minutes not 0.59 minutes. Then apologise to me as it confirms that despite protestation you are in fact incorrect.
Just a tad confusing to be arguing the toss on the same issue but between two threads ... can we make an executive decision to choose an appropriate one and confine posts there?
-
Just a tad confusing to be arguing the toss on the same issue but between two threads ... can we make an executive decision to choose an appropriate one and confine posts there?
Whichever you want Brietta unless you can create a new thread regarding what he said.
-
Davel READ it AGAIN! I said around 59 minutes not 0.59 minutes. Then apologise to me as it confirms that despite protestation you are in fact incorrect.
why should i apologise to you...lol
-
0:00:52 0:00:59
In your heart, do you think it will be solved?
0:00:59 0:01:01
It doesn't depend on my heart - it depends very much on our minds.
there you are...quote by faith
-
there you are...quote by faith
Have you confirmed the times quoted are correct?
-
Have you confirmed the times quoted are correct?
Rob they are correct. Davel has it wrong not that he will admit it. I was leaving this thread so as to keep the Pedro Do Carmo discussion on one thread only at Brietta's request.