UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Holly Goodhead on July 04, 2019, 01:21:57 PM
-
As usual apologies if this has been covered at length elsewhere but sometimes its useful to review.
-
As usual apologies if this has been covered at length elsewhere but sometimes its useful to review.
Because it was closer to the PARTEEH baby, WOO!
So as not to wake the children
In my opinion, of course.
-
Why Did The McCanns Check Via The Back And Keep Patio Door Unlocked Unlike T9?
They had the easiest access to the patio door through a side gate onto the street.
Paynes had no other access than their front door.
tHE OTHER TWO APARTMENTS YOU'D NEED TO GO ALONG THE LANE. I'm nOT SURE OF THE LIGHTING along there.
-
Because it was closer to the PARTEEH baby, WOO!
So as not to wake the children
In my opinion, of course.
Yes that's what I thought.
KM tell us in her book that upon arrival the cots were in the back bedroom which had the balcony and patio doors. She then moved the cots to the front bedroom with window and shutter and assigned the back bedroom for herself and GM on the basis the children would only be sleeping in their bedroom. (What was she planning to do in hers?!)
This effectively put the children closer to the front door. Had the children slept in the back bedroom would the checks have still been carried out via the patio door or front door?
-
The cleaner saw a cot in the parent's bedroom on Wednesday.
-
Why Did The McCanns Check Via The Back And Keep Patio Door Unlocked Unlike T9?
They had the easiest access to the patio door through a side gate onto the street.
Paynes had no other access than their front door.
tHE OTHER TWO APARTMENTS YOU'D NEED TO GO ALONG THE LANE. I'm nOT SURE OF THE LIGHTING along there.
Well the Paynes had the hitec baby monitor.
But was it easier to carry out the checks via the patio door? In order to do so they had to enter/exit the gate linked to road, ascend/descend the flight of steps, enter/exit the child safety gate, slide patio doors open/close, wrestle with curtain or find the gap after quaffing wine? Sounds a whole lot easier to me to simply take a few extra steps around the corner and open and close the front door plus at least know the children were locked in.
The lighting was poor round the front but likewise for the McCanns as evidenced by the following doc @ 16 mins in
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=khP0dEsZaug
See how dark it is up the steps a complete contrast to the front.
-
Well the Paynes had the hitec baby monitor.
But was it easier to carry out the checks via the patio door? In order to do so they had to enter/exit the gate linked to road, ascend/descend the flight of steps, enter/exit the child safety gate, slide patio doors open/close, wrestle with curtain or find the gap after quaffing wine? Sounds a whole lot easier to me to simply take a few extra steps around the corner and open and close the front door plus at least know the children were locked in.
The lighting was poor round the front but likewise for the McCanns as evidenced by the following doc @ 16 mins in
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=khP0dEsZaug
See how dark it is up the steps a complete contrast to the front.
The problem with comparing lighting via video, or photograph, is
1) that the lighting of the image can be adjusted (?)electronically to lilluminate more, or to darken the screne .... and the viewer would not know..
False messages can be given out.
2) You should also be aware that in 2007 the parking area at the front and access to the apartment was much darker than it is now. There were trees with fairly dense foliage surrounding the front of 5A and the streetlamp heads were mainly within the head of the trees. Limited light penetrated, but a few years ago, just before Pat Browns visit, all the trees werer cut down ... and voila, there was light!
3) We are told that the street lighting has been upgraded since 2007 and there is now more light.
Because of these facts, I am always a bit sceptical of the lighting in comparison photos
-
The problem with comparing lighting via video, or photograph, is
1) that the lighting of the image can be adjusted (?)electronically to lilluminate more, or to darken the screne .... and the viewer would not know..
False messages can be given out.
2) You should also be aware that in 2007 the parking area at the front and access to the apartment was much darker than it is now. There were trees with fairly dense foliage surrounding the front of 5A and the streetlamp heads were mainly within the head of the trees. Limited light penetrated, but a few years ago, just before Pat Browns visit, all the trees werer cut down ... and voila, there was light!
3) We are told that the street lighting has been upgraded since 2007 and there is now more light.
Because of these facts, I am always a bit sceptical of the lighting in comparison photos
But the experts were physically there. The experts included all relevant personnel of long experience to input on a case like this. They would undoubtedly take into account all the factors you have stated above.
-
Experts - pah, what do they know compared with an amateur detective ?
-
Experts - pah, what do they know compared with an amateur detective ?
Yeah Michael Gove "People have had enough of experts".
Based on the cases that I've looked at in the main the experts have been spot on imo. I'm not inclined to refer to Martin Grime as an expert for the reasons stated in the review of the Shannon Matthews case:
Furthermore, there is no national standard for accrediting dogs and handlers, or record keeping of the success rate they achieve. This makes it difficult for SIO's to interpret the indication from a dog with no way knowing how reliable that indication was in the first place. ACPO is currently examining this issue due to a number of recent cases where the use of victim recovery dogs has had the potential to cause complications in an enquiry.
-
Not an expert?
FROM MARTIN GRIME’S REPORT TO THE PORTUGUESE POLICE
Personal Profile [August 2007]
I am a 'retired' police officer, formally a senior instructor at the South Yorkshire Police dog training establishment. I have 35 years experience in the training of dogs both within the police service and in the public sector. I specialise in the development and training of specialist search dogs, to include narcotics, explosives, currency, human remains, blood and semen.
I am the Special Advisor to The U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation, in relation to their Canine Forensic Program. I am a U.K.A.C.P.O. (Association of Chief Police Officers, England and Wales) accredited police dog training instructor. I am a Subject Matter Expert in forensic canine search and on the N.P.I.A. (National Policing Improvement Agency) Expert Advisers database. I advise Domestic and International Law enforcement agencies on the operational deployment of police dogs in the role of homicide investigation. I develop methods of detecting forensically recoverable evidence by the use of dogs and I facilitate training. I am regularly deployed to homicide cases within my portfolio and form a 'Specialist Canine Homicide Search Team' including the S.A.M dog teams from Dyfed Powys and USA. I have trained and handle two operational specialist search dogs: 'Eddie' is a 7-year-old English Springer spaniel dog who is trained as an Enhanced Victim Recovery Dog (EVRD). 'Keela' is a three-year old English Springer spaniel bitch who is trained as a human blood search dog (C.S.I. dog).
Q. Is there any chance, however remote, of any confusion?
A. The dogs do not get confused. They transmit a behavioural response inspired by the recognition of the odour for which they were trained.
Q. How long does a cadaver have to be in contact with a surface or an object for the odour to be detected?
A. Cross-contamination is immediate.
Q. Can the dog mix up traces of human odours with others that are non-human?
A. I cannot comment on what the dogs think. However, from a forensic point of view and from confirmations of scientific testimonies, the dogs appear to be extremely exact. But, forensic confirmation is required in all cases so as to be included as proof. The CSI dog is trained using only human blood - and using a wide spectrum of donors to ensure that the dog does not individualize them. EVRD used to be trained using swine (pigs) as their odour is the closest to that of humans. But most of the time, however, the dog was trained using the odour of a human cadaver. Operationally, the dog has ignored large amounts of animal remains/bones when locating human decomposition.
Q. Based upon your experience with the dogs, can you specify whether the positive signals given by them have always matched the scientific results?
A. I cannot. In this case, for example, not all the alert signals have been investigated by the appropriate agencies in order to provide forensic comparisons, in spite of indications to the contrary. It also should be taken into account that the procedures for forensic testing are still less discriminating than the system of dogs’ smell. During training, the dogs are barely rewarded for positive alert signals regarding targets of known substances.
-
Yeah Michael Gove "People have had enough of experts".
Based on the cases that I've looked at in the main the experts have been spot on imo. I'm not inclined to refer to Martin Grime as an expert for the reasons stated in the review of the Shannon Matthews case:
Furthermore, there is no national standard for accrediting dogs and handlers, or record keeping of the success rate they achieve. This makes it difficult for SIO's to interpret the indication from a dog with no way knowing how reliable that indication was in the first place. ACPO is currently examining this issue due to a number of recent cases where the use of victim recovery dogs has had the potential to cause complications in an enquiry.
The documentation quoted may be out of date as ACPO hasn't existed since 2015
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_of_Chief_Police_Officers
-
The documentation quoted may be out of date as ACPO hasn't existed since 2015
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_of_Chief_Police_Officers
But the document was produced in 2009 as a result of the investigation into the disappearance of Shannon Matthews:
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Operation-Paris.pdf
Page 25 of doc relates to the dogs.
-
But the document was produced in 2009 as a result of the investigation into the disappearance of Shannon Matthews:
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Operation-Paris.pdf
Page 25 of doc relates to the dogs.
2009 - so don't you think they might have reported on their findings and published appropriate guideline by now ?
-
Not an expert?
FROM MARTIN GRIME’S REPORT TO THE PORTUGUESE POLICE
Personal Profile [August 2007]
I am a 'retired' police officer, formally a senior instructor at the South Yorkshire Police dog training establishment. I have 35 years experience in the training of dogs both within the police service and in the public sector. I specialise in the development and training of specialist search dogs, to include narcotics, explosives, currency, human remains, blood and semen.
I am the Special Advisor to The U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation, in relation to their Canine Forensic Program. I am a U.K.A.C.P.O. (Association of Chief Police Officers, England and Wales) accredited police dog training instructor. I am a Subject Matter Expert in forensic canine search and on the N.P.I.A. (National Policing Improvement Agency) Expert Advisers database. I advise Domestic and International Law enforcement agencies on the operational deployment of police dogs in the role of homicide investigation. I develop methods of detecting forensically recoverable evidence by the use of dogs and I facilitate training. I am regularly deployed to homicide cases within my portfolio and form a 'Specialist Canine Homicide Search Team' including the S.A.M dog teams from Dyfed Powys and USA. I have trained and handle two operational specialist search dogs: 'Eddie' is a 7-year-old English Springer spaniel dog who is trained as an Enhanced Victim Recovery Dog (EVRD). 'Keela' is a three-year old English Springer spaniel bitch who is trained as a human blood search dog (C.S.I. dog).
Q. Is there any chance, however remote, of any confusion?
A. The dogs do not get confused. They transmit a behavioural response inspired by the recognition of the odour for which they were trained.
Q. How long does a cadaver have to be in contact with a surface or an object for the odour to be detected?
A. Cross-contamination is immediate.
Q. Can the dog mix up traces of human odours with others that are non-human?
A. I cannot comment on what the dogs think. However, from a forensic point of view and from confirmations of scientific testimonies, the dogs appear to be extremely exact. But, forensic confirmation is required in all cases so as to be included as proof. The CSI dog is trained using only human blood - and using a wide spectrum of donors to ensure that the dog does not individualize them. EVRD used to be trained using swine (pigs) as their odour is the closest to that of humans. But most of the time, however, the dog was trained using the odour of a human cadaver. Operationally, the dog has ignored large amounts of animal remains/bones when locating human decomposition.
Q. Based upon your experience with the dogs, can you specify whether the positive signals given by them have always matched the scientific results?
A. I cannot. In this case, for example, not all the alert signals have been investigated by the appropriate agencies in order to provide forensic comparisons, in spite of indications to the contrary. It also should be taken into account that the procedures for forensic testing are still less discriminating than the system of dogs’ smell. During training, the dogs are barely rewarded for positive alert signals regarding targets of known substances.
So it begs the question why in 2009 The National Policing Improvement Agency stated the following in a report produced to review the disappearance of Shannon Matthews in 2008 which was obviously post MM.
Furthermore, there is no national standard for accrediting dogs and handlers, or record keeping of the success rate they achieve. This makes it difficult for SIO's to interpret the indication from a dog with no way knowing how reliable that indication was in the first place. ACPO is currently examining this issue due to a number of recent cases where the use of victim recovery dogs has had the potential to cause complications in an enquiry.
Page 25 of doc:
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Operation-Paris.pdf
I appreciate this may will be contentious but has anyone actually checked out MG's claims about his credentials?
https://uk.linkedin.com/in/martin-grime-9724a78
-
2009 - so don't you think they might have reported on their findings and published appropriate guideline by now ?
Quite possibly yes but I thought we were looking at the standards in place at the time Grime and the dogs entered 5A in 2007?
-
Quite possibly yes but I thought we were looking at the standards in place at the time Grime and the dogs entered 5A in 2007?
Ok. but it would be useful to see if they had changed since then, which would, to my mind, indicate a need for improvement.
No change would suggest that the 2007 arrangements were adequate.
-
Experts - pah, what do they know compared with an amateur detective ?
You obviously don’t consider the Met to be experts then!
-
You obviously don’t consider the Met to be experts then!
*%87
-
*%87
Well do you or not?
-
Well do you or not?
I don't understand your question which quoted my previous post, which was comparing experts with amateur detectives
-
I don't understand your question which quoted my previous post, which was comparing experts with amateur detectives
Amateur detectives on the net have decided the McCanns are guilty as sin, the Met have ruled out the McCanns as supects, whose opinion do you trust more?
-
Amateur detectives on the net have decided the McCanns are guilty as sin, the Met have ruled out the McCanns as supects, whose opinion do you trust more?
If you read the context of the post - 6 onward you would see it was not discussing the guilt or otherwise of the McCanns.
-
If you read the context of the post - 6 onward you would see it was not discussing the guilt or otherwise of the McCanns.
I was discussing the principle of experts versus armchair detectives. You seem to think the latter to be less credible than the former, but only when it suits you, perhaps...
-
I was discussing the principle of experts versus armchair detectives. You seem to think the latter to be less credible than the former, but only when it suits you, perhaps...
No, amateur detective are just walts who think themselves smarter than professional police
-
No, amateur detective are just walts who think themselves smarter than professional police
Just what?
-
Just what?
Walts - walter Mitty character
-
Walts - walter Mitty character
Wow. A few walts on here then that you’ve just insulted. @)(++(*
-
Wow. A few walts on here then that you’ve just insulted. @)(++(*
I do hope so ?{)(**
I'm all for question the information in the files and media. Claiming to know what did & didn't happen is just plain nonsense- IMO
-
I do hope so ?{)(**
I'm all for question the information in the files and media. Claiming to know what did & didn't happen is just plain nonsense- IMO
Pathfinder and Spam know dontcha know. 8(0(*
-
I do hope so ?{)(**
I'm all for question the information in the files and media. Claiming to know what did & didn't happen is just plain nonsense- IMO
Ditto!
-
Experts - pah, what do they know compared with an amateur detective ?
Exactly - sweety FA!
-
I do hope so ?{)(**
I'm all for question the information in the files and media. Claiming to know what did & didn't happen is just plain nonsense- IMO
Well, nonsensical I must be. But then, when have I ever made sense.
-
No, amateur detective are just walts who think themselves smarter than professional police
Is that libellous? Slagging of amateur detectives? How serious is it to be called a "Walt"?
-
Is that libellous? Slagging of amateur detectives? How serious is it to be called a "Walt"?
Who knows?
If those who identify with this description are offended, so what ?
-
Who knows?
If those who identify with this description are offended, so what ?
I thought you were being disrespectful to the brand to American tools called "De Walt".
-
So I've heard it from the horse's mouth now...GM states at about 13.40 in that the reason the checks were carried out via the patio door was to minimise noise thus they avoided the front door for this reason:
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9058.msg442846#msg442846
-
No, amateur detective are just walts who think themselves smarter than professional police
Many amateur detectives are probably as smart as police officers. In some cases smarter. All that's required are certain skills which are transferable: analytical, problem-solving, research, critical thinking, communication etc.
The downside is that amateur detectives do not have any investigatory powers. But on the plus side they have not been police trained so can think outside the box more easily which can help with solving more unusual types of crime.
All the research shows diversity produces the best outcomes but what you find in the police service is a lack of diversity probably more than any other walk of life. Your typical British police officer tends to have joined at a young age 17/18 so by definition has limited life experiences. He, and it is mostly he, is then trained in a very specific way. Senior officers make it to these positions by progressing up the ranks. So what you get is a very homogeneous group of people who have all been trained to think alike. The structure and mode of management being hierarchical and autocratic.
-
Many amateur detectives are probably as smart as police officers. In some cases smarter. All that's required are certain skills which are transferable: analytical, problem-solving, research, critical thinking, communication etc.
The downside is that amateur detectives do not have any investigatory powers. But on the plus side they have not been police trained so can think outside the box more easily which can help with solving more unusual types of crime.
All the research shows diversity produces the best outcomes but what you find in the police service is a lack of diversity probably more than any other walk of life. Your typical British police officer tends to have joined at a young age 17/18 so by definition has limited life experiences. He, and it is mostly he, is then trained in a very specific way. Senior officers make it to these positions by progressing up the ranks. So what you get is a very homogeneous group of people who have all been trained to think alike. The structure and mode of management being hierarchical and autocratic.
I think your post is quite misleading. Mark Rowley went to the same school as I did and then went on to cambridge university...how many armchair detectives are as smart as that,.
We then have the fact that they have all the information and evidence that we dont have...
-
Many amateur detectives are probably as smart as police officers. In some cases smarter. All that's required are certain skills which are transferable: analytical, problem-solving, research, critical thinking, communication etc.
The downside is that amateur detectives do not have any investigatory powers. But on the plus side they have not been police trained so can think outside the box more easily which can help with solving more unusual types of crime.
All the research shows diversity produces the best outcomes but what you find in the police service is a lack of diversity probably more than any other walk of life. Your typical British police officer tends to have joined at a young age 17/18 so by definition has limited life experiences. He, and it is mostly he, is then trained in a very specific way. Senior officers make it to these positions by progressing up the ranks. So what you get is a very homogeneous group of people who have all been trained to think alike. The structure and mode of management being hierarchical and autocratic.
Armchair detectives are not in full possession of the facts, FACT.
-
Many amateur detectives are probably as smart as police officers. In some cases smarter. All that's required are certain skills which are transferable: analytical, problem-solving, research, critical thinking, communication etc.
The downside is that amateur detectives do not have any investigatory powers. But on the plus side they have not been police trained so can think outside the box more easily which can help with solving more unusual types of crime.
All the research shows diversity produces the best outcomes but what you find in the police service is a lack of diversity probably more than any other walk of life. Your typical British police officer tends to have joined at a young age 17/18 so by definition has limited life experiences. He, and it is mostly he, is then trained in a very specific way. Senior officers make it to these positions by progressing up the ranks. So what you get is a very homogeneous group of people who have all been trained to think alike. The structure and mode of management being hierarchical and autocratic.
A good comment. In the late 80s they all looked like clones, even down to their awful Grey Polyester Suits.
I don't know if they might have improved since then because I left England shortly after that.
-
It’s a wonder any crimes get solved in this country with its dunderhead police forces, all trained to think alike.
-
It’s a wonder any crimes get solved in this country with its dunderhead police forces, all trained to think alike.
I think it's a somewhat disingenuous analogy. The training in the police, just like most professions, makes up maybe 15-20% of development. They become rounded (in more ways than one) policemen and women with experience and having to think on their feet, and even improvise, on a daily basis. There are numerous incidents / occurrences that police deal with that there is no training for - it need humans, not automatons.
In addition, they are constantly evolving with technology and new techniques and generally embrace innovation and are willing to learn from international counterparts.
So they're far from this Borg Collective that Holly describes, but I responded to the wrong person but can't be bothered cutting and pasting this and going back and fixing it.
-
I think it's a somewhat disingenuous analogy. The training in the police, just like most professions, makes up maybe 15-20% of development. They become rounded (in more ways than one) policemen and women with experience and having to think on their feet, and even improvise, on a daily basis. There are numerous incidents / occurrences that police deal with that there is no training for - it need humans, not automatons.
In addition, they are constantly evolving with technology and new techniques and generally embrace innovation and are willing to learn from international counterparts.
So they're far from this Borg Collective that Holly describes, but I responded to the wrong person but can't be bothered cutting and pasting this and going back and fixing it.
Oh well at least we’re agreeing on something, which always gladdens my heart a little.
-
I think your post is quite misleading. Mark Rowley went to the same school as I did and then went on to cambridge university...how many armchair detectives are as smart as that,.
We then have the fact that they have all the information and evidence that we dont have...
I had to Google Mark Rowley. The same would apply to Cressida Dick. I said in my post "typical British police officer". I do not believe the aforementioned are typical.
How has having "all the information and evidence" assisted in solving the murder of Jill Dando and the disappearance of MM to name but 2 high profile unsolved crimes?
http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20140501-meet-the-bedroom-detectives
-
Armchair detectives are not in full possession of the facts, FACT.
And you think the police are? If so why do a lot of the more complex crimes remain unsolved? Why do we have miscarriages of justice which are often in part based on police ineptitude.
-
I had to Google Mark Rowley. The same would apply to Cressida Dick. I said in my post "typical British police officer". I do not believe the aforementioned are typical.
How has having "all the information and evidence" assisted in solving the murder of Jill Dando and the disappearance of MM to name but 2 high profile unsolved crimes?
http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20140501-meet-the-bedroom-detectives
All the information and evidence solved 90% of the rest though. These cases only catch the interest of armchair detectives because they are high profile and unsolved. You won't see many interested in trying to catch the baghead who stole the charity box from the counter of Gregg's in Wakefield.
Besides, Dando was assassinated by Serb Special Ops, everyone knows that.
-
I think it's a somewhat disingenuous analogy. The training in the police, just like most professions, makes up maybe 15-20% of development. They become rounded (in more ways than one) policemen and women with experience and having to think on their feet, and even improvise, on a daily basis. There are numerous incidents / occurrences that police deal with that there is no training for - it need humans, not automatons.
In addition, they are constantly evolving with technology and new techniques and generally embrace innovation and are willing to learn from international counterparts.
So they're far from this Borg Collective that Holly describes, but I responded to the wrong person but can't be bothered cutting and pasting this and going back and fixing it.
But a lot of what you describe above applies to many individuals in other occupations.
-
But a lot of what you describe above applies to many individuals in other occupations.
I said that.
-
I had to Google Mark Rowley. The same would apply to Cressida Dick. I said in my post "typical British police officer". I do not believe the aforementioned are typical.
How has having "all the information and evidence" assisted in solving the murder of Jill Dando and the disappearance of MM to name but 2 high profile unsolved crimes?
http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20140501-meet-the-bedroom-detectives
These are the officers charged with leading the investigation so they are the ones who are relevant. I think your claim Re the two cases you mention is ridiculous... Even the best surgeons can't save everyone... But they are still highly skilled.
I don't see any particular smartness from armchair detectives here... In general... IMO... Many simply do not understand the evidence
-
And you think the police are? If so why do a lot of the more complex crimes remain unsolved? Why do we have miscarriages of justice which are often in part based on police ineptitude.
No one is saying the police force is perfect... But to suggest a bunch of untrained armchair detectives with unknown education... Training... Might do better... Is just plain daft.. Imo
-
All the information and evidence solved 90% of the rest though. These cases only catch the interest of armchair detectives because they are high profile and unsolved. You won't see many interested in trying to catch the baghead who stole the charity box from the counter of Gregg's in Wakefield.
Besides, Dando was assassinated by Serb Special Ops, everyone knows that.
I agree the police are good at solving run of the mill crime through intelligence gathering but I'm talking about the more complex crimes.
I don't believe JD was assassinated by SSO. There's a dedicated thread here:
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=106.0
I woz there and now I'm here 8)--))
-
I said that.
Did you? Sorry I must have missed it.
So what do you believe police officers have over armchair detectives in solving complex crimes?
-
Did you? Sorry I must have missed it.
So what do you believe police officers have over armchair detectives in solving complex crimes?
A huge crime database.
Experience.
Yes, the training, particularly in new techniques.
Analysis resources.
Admin - many of these crimes involve 100's of quasi-civilian admin staff to plough through the volume of information.
Sheer weight of numbers.
Right of entry.
Informants.
Donuts.
-
I agree the police are good at solving run of the mill crime through intelligence gathering but I'm talking about the more complex crimes.
I don't believe JD was assassinated by SSO. There's a dedicated thread here:
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=106.0
I woz there and now I'm here 8)--))
I know, I baited the line with Dando.........
-
These are the officers charged with leading the investigation so they are the ones who are relevant. I think your claim Re the two cases you mention is ridiculous... Even the best surgeons can't save everyone... But they are still highly skilled.
I don't see any particular smartness from armchair detectives here... In general... IMO... Many simply do not understand the evidence
You mean they have oversight of MM's case? But they will not be hands on?
There are numerous high profile cases the police have been unable to solve. We also have many miscarriages of justice that involve in part police ineptitude. Plus corruption in the police is probably worse than most other walks of life.
-
A huge crime database.
Experience.
Yes, the training, particularly in new techniques.
Analysis resources.
Admin - many of these crimes involve 100's of quasi-civilian admin staff to plough through the volume of information.
Sheer weight of numbers.
Right of entry.
Informants.
Donuts.
Especially the donuts ?{)(**
-
A huge crime database.
Experience.
Yes, the training, particularly in new techniques.
Analysis resources.
Admin - many of these crimes involve 100's of quasi-civilian admin staff to plough through the volume of information.
Sheer weight of numbers.
Right of entry.
Informants.
Donuts.
But why haven't they been able to put away the person responsible for murdering Jill Dando? Why haven't they found Suzy Lamplugh, Claudia Lawrence, Corrie McKeague, MM? Why do we have so many miscarriages of justice?
-
You mean they have oversight of MM's case? But they will not be hands on?
There are numerous high profile cases the police have been unable to solve. We also have many miscarriages of justice that involve in part police ineptitude. Plus corruption in the police is probably worse than most other walks of life.
Yes, but as I've been stressing, nothing is perfect, nobody is infallible, particularly organisations.
If you replaced it with a utopian model it would evolve into something just as flawed.
-
But why haven't they been able to put away the person responsible for murdering Jill Dando? Why haven't they found Suzy Lamplugh, Claudia Lawrence, Corrie McKeague, MM? Why do we have so many miscarriages of justice?
The same reason as to why people still die in hospitals... Perhaps some of the armchair detectives could turn their hand to medicine
-
Yes, but as I've been stressing, nothing is perfect, nobody is infallible, particularly organisations.
If you replaced it with a utopian model it would evolve into something just as flawed.
I agree nothing is perfect. But I don't see the police service as it stands as a lean mean crime fighting machine fit for 21st century.
Ooops way off topic. Do any of the mods have the capability of splitting a thread? Maybe something like the 'Role Of Armchair Detectives?
-
But why haven't they been able to put away the person responsible for murdering Jill Dando? Why haven't they found Suzy Lamplugh, Claudia Lawrence, Corrie McKeague, MM? Why do we have so many miscarriages of justice?
As Brandon Flowers said, 'Are we human, or are we policemen?' (I used 'policemen' as a gender label, as 'police' was one syllable too few).
Sometimes the perp is too clever, skips the country and job done. Sometimes they get lucky. Sometimes it's ineptitude on the part of the police. Sometimes the police are unlucky (I think they interviewed Sutcliffe a few times). Sometimes they're fed duff info. Sometimes they're corrupt. Many times it's a lack of resources and having to juggle plates and maybe focus on the wrong facet.
-
The same reason as to why people still die in hospitals... Perhaps some of the armchair detectives could turn their hand to medicine
No because potentially they could cause harm. Armchair detectives are harmless.
-
I agree nothing is perfect. But I don't see the police service as it stands as a lean mean crime fighting machine fit for 21st century.
Ooops way off topic. Do any of the mods have the capability of splitting a thread? Maybe something like the 'Role Of Armchair Detectives?
It's been cut the bone, I think most of us agree on that.
-
And you think the police are? If so why do a lot of the more complex crimes remain unsolved? Why do we have miscarriages of justice which are often in part based on police ineptitude.
Look, this is an undeniable fact: in any police investigation the police will know more facts about the case than the general public, do you or don’t you accept this?
-
No because potentially they could cause harm. Armchair detectives are harmless.
Potentially they could cause harm... Are you serious
I don't think they are... Not with the power of social media
-
But why haven't they been able to put away the person responsible for murdering Jill Dando? Why haven't they found Suzy Lamplugh, Claudia Lawrence, Corrie McKeague, MM? Why do we have so many miscarriages of justice?
Do you think that’s down to police ineptitude, or is it possible that until more evidence comes to light (often by chance, years after the event) that some crimes by their nature remain unsolvable?
-
Potentially they could cause harm... Are you serious
I don't think they are... Not with the power of social media
True. Not even the most staunch sceptic can tell me that Tony Bennett has been a force for good.
-
Look, this is an undeniable fact: in any police investigation the police will know more facts about the case than the general public, do you or don’t you accept this?
No I do not accept this based on the cases I have looked at in any sort of depth:
Bamber/White House Farm - 1985
Essex Boys/Rettendon murders -1995
Jill Dando - 1999
-
No I do not accept this based on the cases I have looked at in any sort of depth:
Bamber/White House Farm - 1985
Essex Boys/Rettendon murders -1995
Jill Dando - 1999
Do you accept grange has information we, are not privy to
-
Looks like the feeling on the forum is that UK police are not perfect and make mistakes.... Apart from Martin Grime... He's just perfect
-
Looks like the feeling on the forum is that UK police are not perfect and make mistakes.... Apart from Martin Grime... He's just perfect
Are you on a mission?
-
Are you on a mission?
I've already said I think Grime is
-
I've already said I think Grime is
What is this mission?
-
What is this mission?
If you read his white paper it's to increase the perceived value of cadaver dog trainers and the alerts
-
485
'What about the rest of the party, Kate and Gerry, did they ever discuss with you whether they locked their doors or their windows when they were in and out''
Reply
'Erm, I mean, I was aware of them swapping their arrangement at some point, because I know they had been coming, using the front door, erm, which is the door with the key, to go in and check the children.
1485
'Yeah. Did Kate ever discus that with you, you know, when she discussed about Madeleine, did she ever discuss, you know, the''
Reply
'No, as I say, it came up at that, that conversation, which I think was on the, on the, on the Thursday night, about, erm, you know, whether I would feel happy leaving, leaving a door unlocked, but that was the only time I'd heard Kate sort of almost saying, question whether they should do it or not'.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
How extraordinary! This important info comes out on the night Madeleine disappears!
-
As Brandon Flowers said, 'Are we human, or are we policemen?' (I used 'policemen' as a gender label, as 'police' was one syllable too few).
Sometimes the perp is too clever, skips the country and job done. Sometimes they get lucky. Sometimes it's ineptitude on the part of the police. Sometimes the police are unlucky (I think they interviewed Sutcliffe a few times). Sometimes they're fed duff info. Sometimes they're corrupt. Many times it's a lack of resources and having to juggle plates and maybe focus on the wrong facet.
I’m more ‘Are We Not Men? We Are Devo!’
-
No I do not accept this based on the cases I have looked at in any sort of depth:
Bamber/White House Farm - 1985
Essex Boys/Rettendon murders -1995
Jill Dando - 1999
How do the general public come to have more information about a criminal investigation than the police?
-
How do the general public come to have more information about a criminal investigation than the police?
Because all of the police working on the cases are retired. Or dead. Or both.
-
Potentially they could cause harm... Are you serious
I don't think they are... Not with the power of social media
I said untrained medi staff could potentially cause harm. How exactly could armchair detectives cause harm?
-
Look, this is an undeniable fact: in any police investigation the police will know more facts about the case than the general public, do you or don’t you accept this?
No I don't accept it based on the cases I've looked at.
-
I'm responding here to a post on the thread about the moderation:
I want to share this, please. I do understand that it is a contentious issue: Our closest overseas break is Mauritius, Madagascar and Reunion. We have been to Mauritius a couple of times. The setup is the same as at the OC. Room overlooking the pool and dining area, kids going off to kids’ club during the day, kids having an early dinner at the restaurant, putting them to bed and we having our evening meal. We too went to check on them to make sure they are fine. Never, ever did it cross our minds that someone will enter our room, taking one of our children.
Imo the lax security of 5A ie the unsecured patio door is key to solving the case. I think the McCanns and their advisers/supporters haven't helped the case by downplaying this aspect. I disagree that it was the same as eating at home in the garden whilst the children were asleep upstairs. Most private properties have defined boundaries meaning intruders have to bypass fences, walls etc. Whereas with 5A all anyone needed to do was open the side gate situated on a public road and they were within the confines. There's no way T9 could observe from tapas anyone sneaking around the gate, steps and patio doors. When KM found MM missing, as per her testimony, she did not shout from the balcony but left 5A to inform the others. Why? I would suggest the reason for this is that she knew her voice would not carry over the distance involved.
I also disagree that the MW listening service can be likened to what the McCanns were doing. It can't because the MW listening service involves listening through locked doors. If those doing the listening hear any disturbance they alert the parents who return to settle their children.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1907317/Kate-McCanns-mother-wanted-to-shake-her-for-leaving-Madeleine.html
I accept the McCanns may have been counselled psychologically to minimise this for their own sanity but it doesn't help the case for finding MM by downplaying it imo.
Btw Anthro have you thought further about putting your theory in the private area?
-
How do the general public come to have more information about a criminal investigation than the police?
secrets within communities is and families is well known. Many go unpunished for henious crimes. They are protected in some instances. look at the Kray twins- the IRA and fundamentalist muslim terrorists to name a few...
The police often meet with a wall of silence. The most recent highlighted is the high death rates among gay men from chem sex. Most are afraid to speak out. Which is heading towards a catastrophy for their families and loved ones.
-
Hi Holly, I am prepared to do that but strongly feel that Admin should look at the hypothesis in advance to guide me as to the legality of mentioning persons by name. If Admin is willing to do that, I will post my line of thinking.
-
Hi Holly, I am prepared to do that but strongly feel that Admin should look at the hypothesis in advance to guide me as to the legality of mentioning persons by name. If Admin is willing to do that, I will post my line of thinking.
I am looking forward to reading it Anthro.
-
secrets within communities is and families is well known. Many go unpunished for henious crimes. They are protected in some instances. look at the Kray twins- the IRA and fundamentalist muslim terrorists to name a few...
The police often meet with a wall of silence. The most recent highlighted is the high death rates among gay men from chem sex. Most are afraid to speak out. Which is heading towards a catastrophy for their families and loved ones.
All very interesting but I asked how do the general public come to know more about a criminal investigation than the police, not those actually closely involved in those directly affected by the criminal acts.
-
All very interesting but I asked how do the general public come to know more about a criminal investigation than the police, not those actually closely involved in those directly affected by the criminal acts.
The general public get to hear about things word of mouth!