No, amateur detective are just walts who think themselves smarter than professional police
Many amateur detectives are probably as smart as police officers. In some cases smarter. All that's required are certain skills which are transferable: analytical, problem-solving, research, critical thinking, communication etc.
The downside is that amateur detectives do not have any investigatory powers. But on the plus side they have not been police trained so can think outside the box more easily which can help with solving more unusual types of crime.
All the research shows diversity produces the best outcomes but what you find in the police service is a lack of diversity probably more than any other walk of life. Your typical British police officer tends to have joined at a young age 17/18 so by definition has limited life experiences. He, and it is mostly he, is then trained in a very specific way. Senior officers make it to these positions by progressing up the ranks. So what you get is a very homogeneous group of people who have all been trained to think alike. The structure and mode of management being hierarchical and autocratic.