UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: G-Unit on August 26, 2019, 11:03:34 AM
-
The UK police lost the opportunity to add important evidence to this case by not interviewing everyone who was identified to them as being in PdL between 28th April and 3rd May 2007 in my opinion.
[Reference material: http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Strategic-debrief-operation-task-2009.pdf
https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2019/06/05/home-office-update-on-funding-for-operation-grange/ ]
-
The UK police lost the opportunity to add important evidence to this case by not interviewing everyone who was identified to them as being in PdL between 28th April and 3rd May 2007 in my opinion.
How do you know they didn't?
-
How do you know they didn't?
I would have thought it quite difficult to do, considering that OG have no jurisdiction to question people over a 'crime' that took place in Portugal and that many of the people involved are likely not British subjects, or residing in Britain.
-
I would have thought it quite difficult to do, considering that OG have no jurisdiction to question people over a 'crime' that took place in Portugal and that many of the people involved are likely not British subjects, or residing in Britain.
Would the PJ be allowed to ask the UK police to question those that returned to England? For some reason Jez Wilkins and Bridget get interviewed twice while they were back in England.
Why if it can happen to them, can it not happen to the others?
-
How do you know they didn't?
According to their debrief they didn't. 559 people completed questionnaires, but in my opinion they should have been interviewed.
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Strategic-debrief-operation-task-2009.pdf
-
Would the PJ be allowed to ask the UK police to question those that returned to England? For some reason Jez Wilkins and Bridget get interviewed twice while they were back in England.
Why if it can happen to them, can it not happen to the others?
It was Portugal's 'crime' so they have the right to request assistance from UK police (among others).
OG don't have that right as it was not a British 'crime' so cannot insist on questioning anyone.
IMO
-
I would have thought it quite difficult to do, considering that OG have no jurisdiction to question people over a 'crime' that took place in Portugal and that many of the people involved are likely not British subjects, or residing in Britain.
559 UK citizens were contacted, but not interviewed. Had those people been interviewed then it could have provided a more complete picture of what occured. I think most would have agreed, because they filled in the questionnaires.
-
Remind me, was this a Portuguese initiated questionnaire or a UK one ?
-
Remind me, was this a Portuguese initiated questionnaire or a UK one ?
There's no record of a Portuguese request.
-
There's no record of a Portuguese request.
Ok, so did PJ receive copies of the completed questionnaires ? (Sorry for my ignorance about this)
-
Ok, so did PJ receive copies of the completed questionnaires ? (Sorry for my ignorance about this)
I don't think they did, no.
-
A dna and fingerprint profile was built up of these 559 witnesses according to the report. That’s quite impressive.
-
A dna and fingerprint profile was built up of these 559 witnesses according to the report. That’s quite impressive.
I wonder how that worked?
-
I wonder how that worked?
Was the questionnaire presented face to face so DNA and fingerprints could be taken at the same time?
-
Was the questionnaire presented face to face so DNA and fingerprints could be taken at the same time?
I find it difficult to believe that all 559 people willingly gave fingerprint & DNA samples.
Perhaps fingerprints & DNA were retrieved from the questionnaire paper
-
It would have been interesting to see statements from everyone who dined at the Tapas on 3rd May, particularly the Irwins and the Sperreys. I find it most peculiar that they weren't interviewed.
-
I wonder how that worked?
It was found from the review stages carried out independent of each other by Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria that there was ample justification to re-investigate Madeleine McCann's disappearance.
I wonder how that worked when they made the case for that to their respective political masters if they were unable to show that due diligence had been exercised in gathering and collating the necessary evidence ... which appears to be the contention of the thread title.
One wonders what evidence has subsequently kept SY and the PJ active in the field since 2013 and enabled them to justify the time, personnel and expenditure on Madeleine's case were there no substantial basis for doing so.
-
It was found from the review stages carried out independent of each other by Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria that there was ample justification to re-investigate Madeleine McCann's disappearance.
I wonder how that worked when they made the case for that to their respective political masters if they were unable to show that due diligence had been exercised in gathering and collating the necessary evidence ... which appears to be the contention of the thread title.
One wonders what evidence has subsequently kept SY and the PJ active in the field since 2013 and enabled them to justify the time, personnel and expenditure on Madeleine's case were there no substantial basis for doing so.
According to the Home Office SY don't have to justify anything;
When considering special grants applications, the Home Office does not take a view on whether an investigation should continue, which would be an operational matter for the police.
https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2019/06/05/home-office-update-on-funding-for-operation-grange/
-
It would have been interesting to see statements from everyone who dined at the Tapas on 3rd May, particularly the Irwins and the Sperreys. I find it most peculiar that they weren't interviewed.
Quite frankly you have absolutely no knowledge of who was interviewed by Scotland Yard at any stage of the proceedings ... prove me wrong on that by showing you knew of Dr Totman's alleged role or even if he is the person DCI Redwood referred to.
You have no idea what has taken place at any stage of the currently running investigation into Madeleine's case apart from the fact it is still active. Something which in my opinion prompts much of the negativity of the speculation posted by you.
-
According to the Home Office SY don't have to justify anything;
When considering special grants applications, the Home Office does not take a view on whether an investigation should continue, which would be an operational matter for the police.
https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2019/06/05/home-office-update-on-funding-for-operation-grange/
My supposition is that once the police reach the end of the trail as far as evidence is concerned that is it as far as personnel and money is concerned.
Cases do not continue without the justification for them to do so. Madeleine's case is still an active one, take from that what you will.
-
Quite frankly you have absolutely no knowledge of who was interviewed by Scotland Yard at any stage of the proceedings ... prove me wrong on that by showing you knew of Dr Totman's alleged role or even if he is the person DCI Redwood referred to.
You have no idea what has taken place at any stage of the currently running investigation into Madeleine's case apart from the fact it is still active. Something which in my opinion prompts much of the negativity of the speculation posted by you.
I wasn't referring to Scotland Yard, but to Leicestershire Constabulary who contributed nothing very much to the first investigation. Had those 559 people remained in Portugal the PJ would have interviewed them and something vital may have been recorded. That opportunity was lost.
-
I assume that the information from the questionnaires was collated and analysed by someone.
However, unless the results were passed on the the Portuguese, the exercise would have been of little value.
-
I assume that the information from the questionnaires was collated and analysed by someone.
However, unless the results were passed on the the Portuguese, the exercise would have been of little value.
It seems information collected in the UK was put into HOLMES. The PJ had access to it if they asked, but it must have been reported that they didn't ask. That makes me wonder why that wasn't discussed and a solution found. LC were supposed to be helping the PJ, but it wasn't very helpful if the information in HOLMES wasn't being passed on.
-
The problem with HOLMES would be that it was in English and Portuguese officers may not have been offered adequate training and might well have had language difficulties, so were unable to make full use of it.
Of course, when UK officers withdrew, they would take that HOLMES access with them.
-
I wasn't referring to Scotland Yard, but to Leicestershire Constabulary who contributed nothing very much to the first investigation. Had those 559 people remained in Portugal the PJ would have interviewed them and something vital may have been recorded. That opportunity was lost.
In my opinion your interpretation of the investigative role and powers as enjoyed and exercised by the Leicestershire Police in what was essentially a Portuguese investigation which they closed down barely a year after Madeleine's disappearance is addressed in the opening post and not really expanded further by you or anyone else.
Why do you think the responsibility for reviewing and reopening a case closed by the Portuguese authorities lay with the Leicestershire Police when only the dogged and persistent efforts of Madeleine's parents ... for which they have suffered so much opprobrium ... allowed her case to be reviewed and opened as a result?
What makes you think Leicestershire Police were empowered to do that at the time of which you speak?
-
The problem with HOLMES would be that it was in English and Portuguese officers may not have been offered adequate training and might well have had language difficulties, so were unable to make full us of it.
Of course, when UK officers withdrew, they would take that HOLMES access with them.
According to Amaral, they left when the McCanns left.
-
So often I find that it is what one doesn't say that matters.
-
In my opinion your interpretation of the investigative role and powers as enjoyed and exercised by the Leicestershire Police in what was essentially a Portuguese investigation which they closed down barely a year after Madeleine's disappearance is addressed in the opening post and not really expanded further by you or anyone else.
Why do you think the responsibility for reviewing and reopening a case closed by the Portuguese authorities lay with the Leicestershire Police when only the dogged and persistent efforts of Madeleine's parents ... for which they have suffered so much opprobrium ... allowed her case to be reviewed and opened as a result?
What makes you think Leicestershire Police were empowered to do that at the time of which you speak?
The role of Leicestershire Police was to assist the Policia Judiciaria. Not that the PJ asked for assistance; they were bulldozed into accepting it.
Normally the police gather as much information as possible before people forget. Whereas the PJ did this, LC chose not to. So we know where every employee of the Ocean Club was, but we have no idea where the holidaymakers were.
I don't recall suggesting that LC should have reviewed or reopened anything?
-
I was surprised to learn that there were 559 British holidaymakers (+ the negligent nine) in PDL that week
-
I was surprised to learn that there were 559 British holidaymakers (+ the negligent nine) in PDL that week
That would include a large number resident permanently or semi-permanently in PdL IMO.
-
That would include a large number resident permanently or semi-permanently in PdL IMO.
All UK citizens who were resident in the resort around the time that Madeleine went missing.
-
I was surprised to learn that there were 559 British holidaymakers (+ the negligent nine) in PDL that week
Would they be including the babies as well. The Tapas 9 had 8 kids with them to start with. Total 17.
-
Would they be including the babies as well. The Tapas 9 had 8 kids with them to start with. Total 17.
I doubt babies would be expected to complete questionnaires
-
I doubt babies would be expected to complete questionnaires
You were surprised at "559 British holidaymakers" . Were there 559 questionnaires as well?
I keep getting the feeling there is a lot we aren't being told.
-
The role of Leicestershire Police was to assist the Policia Judiciaria. Not that the PJ asked for assistance; they were bulldozed into accepting it.
Normally the police gather as much information as possible before people forget. Whereas the PJ did this, LC chose not to. So we know where every employee of the Ocean Club was, but we have no idea where the holidaymakers were.
I don't recall suggesting that LC should have reviewed or reopened anything?
Do we really know where every employee of Ocean Club was? How did you ascertain that? How did you determine the manner in which the PJ were able to confirm every employee's whereabouts were as they stated?
Why do you think the PJ neglected to trace and interview the British holidaymaker returning to Block 4 carrying his child on the night Madeleine disappeared?
In my opinion you are in effect accusing Leicestershire police of negligence in the opening post and the thread title you have chosen to use ... if not indeed highlighting a dereliction of duty.
Which entitles me to enquire from you why you think the "UK police" had the wherewithal to continue the investigation into Madeleine's disappearance when it had been archived by the Portuguese authorities?
Answering that could be mistaken for debate ... Heaven forfend though, that any such should interfere with whatever might be your defence of the narrow agenda of your posts .
-
The role of Leicestershire Police was to assist the Policia Judiciaria. Not that the PJ asked for assistance; they were bulldozed into accepting it.
Normally the police gather as much information as possible before people forget. Whereas the PJ did this, LC chose not to. So we know where every employee of the Ocean Club was, but we have no idea where the holidaymakers were.
I don't recall suggesting that LC should have reviewed or reopened anything?
Are you saying the UK police were not asked to assist the PJ. There was the document that outlined to procedure to follow to get involved with overseas investigations. Are you saying these were not followed?
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Strategic-debrief-operation-task-2009.pdf
-
Do we really know where every employee of Ocean Club was? How did you ascertain that? How did you determine the manner in which the PJ were able to confirm every employee's whereabouts were as they stated?
Why do you think the PJ neglected to trace and interview the British holidaymaker returning to Block 4 carrying his child on the night Madeleine disappeared?
In my opinion you are in effect accusing Leicestershire police of negligence in the opening post and the thread title you have chosen to use ... if not indeed highlighting a dereliction of duty.
Which entitles me to enquire from you why you think the "UK police" had the wherewithal to continue the investigation into Madeleine's disappearance when it had been archived by the Portuguese authorities?
Answering that could be mistaken for debate ... Heaven forfend though, that any such should interfere with whatever might be your defence of the narrow agenda of your posts .
Do you mean the person heading away from block 4 on the night Madeleine disappeared? The one who, according to Jane Tanner, was not associated with the OC night creche?
-
Do we really know where every employee of Ocean Club was? How did you ascertain that? How did you determine the manner in which the PJ were able to confirm every employee's whereabouts were as they stated?
Why do you think the PJ neglected to trace and interview the British holidaymaker returning to Block 4 carrying his child on the night Madeleine disappeared?
In my opinion you are in effect accusing Leicestershire police of negligence in the opening post and the thread title you have chosen to use ... if not indeed highlighting a dereliction of duty.
Which entitles me to enquire from you why you think the "UK police" had the wherewithal to continue the investigation into Madeleine's disappearance when it had been archived by the Portuguese authorities?
Answering that could be mistaken for debate ... Heaven forfend though, that any such should interfere with whatever might be your defence of the narrow agenda of your posts .
I have no reason to believe the UK police could or should have continued to investigate Madeleine's disappearance after it was archived. The period I'm discussing is May 2007 to August 2008.
-
Are you saying the UK police were not asked to assist the PJ. There was the document that outlined to procedure to follow to get involved with overseas investigations. Are you saying these were not followed?
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Strategic-debrief-operation-task-2009.pdf
No request was received from Portugal. The FCO contacted the Portuguese authorities and offered the sevices of FLO's and an incident room in Leicestershire. On 4th May an email from the PJ asked for support for the family. That, I assume, meant the FLO's could be provided. Note there was no mention of the incident room being wanted.
On page 17 it clearly states that the pressure for assistance did not come from Portugal, it was from the UK.
-
You were surprised at "559 British holidaymakers" . Were there 559 questionnaires as well?
I keep getting the feeling there is a lot we aren't being told.
Read the report.
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Strategic-debrief-operation-task-2009.pdf
Page 6 , ( or 8/42) Right hand side 2nd paragraph down
-
Read the report.
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Strategic-debrief-operation-task-2009.pdf
Page 6 , ( or 8/42) Right hand side 2nd paragraph down
Very helpful when you're busy like me. Thanks.
-
I have no reason to believe the UK police could or should have continued to investigate Madeleine's disappearance after it was archived. The period I'm discussing is May 2007 to August 2008.
Madeleine's case was under Portuguese jurisdiction throughout that time all coordinated by Goncalo Amaral who wasn't sacked until the October of 2007.
Why are you trying to blame Leicestershire Constabulary for the many shortcomings of the investigation during his time in office? Don't you think it is time for you to move on?
-
Madeleine's case was under Portuguese jurisdiction throughout that time all coordinated by Goncalo Amaral who wasn't sacked until the October of 2007.
Why are you trying to blame Leicestershire Constabulary for the many shortcomings of the investigation during his time in office? Don't you think it is time for you to move on?
As Amaral was not sacked, and you are picky about your choice of words, isn't it about time you stopped spreading blatant disinformation? Time for you to move on?
-
As Amaral was not sacked, and you are picky about your choice of words, isn't it about time you stopped spreading blatant disinformation? Time for you to move on?
The word in Portuguese is DEMITIDO ... that translates to SACKED in English.
Amaral was sacked which was probably quite fortuitous as far as timing goes ... particularly as the Portuguese Court was about to exchange his status from arguido to fully fledged criminal.
Don't bother to apologise for your error defaming the absolute truth of my post ... I think your post perfectly illustrates the huge gaps of your knowledge concerning Madeleine's case + Amaral's mismanagement + plus the role of the English police which allows you to make such mistakes..
Gonçalo Amaral fired
02.10.2007 at 16:36
The Portimão PJ coordinator leaves the investigation of Madeleine McCann's disappearance. At issue are the statements to DN where criticizes the English police.
The National Directorate of the PJ today dismissed the coordinator of the Portimão PJ, Gonçalo Amaral, who also fails to lead investigations into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.
According to Expresso learned, the order of cessation of the service commission was signed this Tuesday and is due to statements by Gonçalo Amaral to DN, where he was strongly criticizing the English police.
Gonçalo Amaral will return to PJ Faro.
https://expresso.pt/dossies/dossiest_actualidade/dos_madeleine_mccan/goncalo-amaral-demitido=f131397
-
The word in Portuguese is DEMITIDO ... that translates to SACKED in English.
Amaral was sacked which was probably quite fortuitous as far as timing goes ... particularly as the Portuguese Court was about to exchange his status from arguido to fully fledged criminal.
Don't bother to apologise for your error defaming the absolute truth of my post ... I think your post perfectly illustrates the huge gaps of your knowledge concerning Madeleine's case + Amaral's mismanagement + plus the role of the English police which allows you to make such mistakes..
Gonçalo Amaral fired
02.10.2007 at 16:36
The Portimão PJ coordinator leaves the investigation of Madeleine McCann's disappearance. At issue are the statements to DN where criticizes the English police.
he National Directorate of the PJ today dismissed the coordinator of the Portimão PJ, Gonçalo Amaral, who also fails to lead investigations into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.
According to Expresso learned, the order of cessation of the service commission was signed this Tuesday and is due to statements by Gonçalo Amaral to DN, where he was strongly criticizing the English police.
Gonçalo Amaral will return to PJ Faro.
https://expresso.pt/dossies/dossiest_actualidade/dos_madeleine_mccan/goncalo-amaral-demitido=f131397
Perhaps it is your ignorance of Portuguese which allows you to spread such disinformation, but I think not.
Demitir - to displace, to remove, to bounce, to discharge, to boot, to drive away, cashier, to demit, to dispose of, to fall.
Please don't post your understanding of Portuguese in future. It is risible.
You know for a fact that Verdade de Mentira was not published until shortly after Amaral had RESIGNED from the PJ.
Your own link shows he went to work in Faro PJ after being moved from the MBM case.
-
Perhaps it is your ignorance of Portuguese which allows you to spread such disinformation, but I think not.
Demitir - to displace, to remove, to bounce, to discharge, to boot, to drive away, cashier, to demit, to dispose of, to fall.
Please don't post your understanding of Portuguese in future. It is risible.
You know for a fact that Verdade de Mentira was not published until shortly after Amaral had RESIGNED from the PJ.
Your own link shows he went to work in Faro PJ after being moved from the MBM case.
Perhaps your criticism of my understanding of the Portuguese language would be better directed towards the headline writer of Expresso who wrote "Gonçalo Amaral demitido"
However ... away from pettiness and back to topic ...
Amaral's sacking is of some significance to the thread title and opening post which might be considered critical of Leicestershire police.
Newspaper reports of Amaral's tirade indicate there was a certain tension towards the 'interference' of his English counterparts which had been simmering in him for five months, not to mention his vilification of Kate and Gerry McCann.
Hardly professional in my opinion or conducive to benefiting the search for Madeleine McCann. Precisely the criticism which was aimed at the Brits by the institution of this thread actually appears to be owned instead by the Policia Judiciaria under the leadership of Amaral whose lack of experience in a missing child case let Madeleine down badly.
Madeleine McCann chief detective sacked
By Aislinn Simpson in Praia da Luz5:56PM BST 02 Oct 2007
The Portuguese detective leading the Madeleine McCann investigation has been sacked from the inquiry after launching an astonishing public attack on his British counterparts.
Chief Inspector Goncalo Amaral, 47, was dismissed from the position by the national director of the Judicial Police.
He had accused British detectives of only chasing leads Gerry and Kate McCann want followed up.
The move came after Portugal's Justice Minister Alberto Costa stepped into the row by insisting there is "fruitful cooperation" between the two countries' police forces over the inquiry.
Mr Costa said Portuguese police intend "to increase the collaboration" with their British counterparts and that the important thing is "to concentrate on the job and not on the comments" made by Mr Amaral.
Mr Amaral, who was jointly in charge of the inquiry, was also dismissed from his post as the head of the Judicial Police in the Algarve town of Portimao.
The 47-year-old detective not only laid into police but also attacked the McCanns, accusing them of "creating and working on" lines of inquiry which they then pass onto Leicestershire Police to investigate.
Mr Amaral, who headed the Policia Judiciaria in the nearby town of Portimao and is himself under investigation for allegedly concealing evidence about an alleged assault on the mother of another missing child, was speaking to the daily newspaper Diario de Noticias.
The paper said the detective, who has come under fire in the British press for his "boozy" three-hour lunches and allegedly failing to investigate some of the tip-offs his 30-strong team of officers have received, was in an "explosive and indignant" mood during the brief interview.
Sources said his departure follows five months of gripes about the British police involved in the case.
A family friend said it was "just plain wrong" that Kate and Gerry, both 39-year-old doctors from Rothley in Leicestershire, were seeking to exert any influence on the investigation, adding that British police were only involved to act as a liaison between the family and Portuguese detectives.
And one of the McCanns' two Portuguese lawyers, Carlos Pinto Abreu, told Lisbon radio station TSF that Mr Amaral's comments were "in very poor taste" and "unhelpful to the investigation".
"The British police have only been working on that which the McCann couple want them to and which is most convenient for them," he said.
"They have only investigated tips and information developed and worked on for the McCanns, forgetting that the couple are formal suspects in the death of their daughter Madeleine."
Officially, Portuguese detectives say they appreciate British help and expertise - particularly forensic - but unofficially claim they feel patronised and bullied.
Leicestershire Police were reluctant to wade into the developing row, only saying they would "continue to support the Portuguese investigation".
The McCanns' spokesman Clarence Mitchell was equally cautious, saying: "Kate and Gerry consistently said that they wish to cooperate with the Portuguese authorities in the hunt for Madeleine and that remains the case."
Mr Amaral has reportedly investigated only two child murders in his 26-year police career and he is facing a criminal hearing for allegedly concealing evidence, after a woman jailed for the murder of her daughter claimed police officers tortured her into making a confession.
Leonor Cipriano, 36, claims she was forced to kneel on glass ashtrays with a bag over her head as police repeatedly hit her during almost 48 hours of questioning.
She is serving 16 years for the murder of her eight-year-old daughter Joana, even though the body has never been found and she has since retracted her statement.
Mr Amaral, a father-of-three, strenuously denies covering up the alleged abuse said to have been carried out by three of his colleagues.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1564913/Madeleine-McCann-chief-detective-sacked.html
-
Perhaps your criticism of my understanding of the Portuguese language would be better directed towards the headline writer of Expresso who wrote "Gonçalo Amaral demitido"
However ... away from pettiness and back to topic ...
Amaral's sacking is of some significance to the thread title and opening post which might be considered critical of Leicestershire police.
Newspaper reports of Amaral's tirade indicate there was a certain tension towards the 'interference' of his English counterparts which had been simmering in him for five months, not to mention his vilification of Kate and Gerry McCann.
Hardly professional in my opinion or conducive to benefiting the search for Madeleine McCann. Precisely the criticism which was aimed at the Brits by the institution of this thread actually appears to be owned instead by the Policia Judiciaria under the leadership of Amaral whose lack of experience in a missing child case let Madeleine down badly.
Madeleine McCann chief detective sacked
By Aislinn Simpson in Praia da Luz5:56PM BST 02 Oct 2007
The Portuguese detective leading the Madeleine McCann investigation has been sacked from the inquiry after launching an astonishing public attack on his British counterparts.
Chief Inspector Goncalo Amaral, 47, was dismissed from the position by the national director of the Judicial Police.
He had accused British detectives of only chasing leads Gerry and Kate McCann want followed up.
The move came after Portugal's Justice Minister Alberto Costa stepped into the row by insisting there is "fruitful cooperation" between the two countries' police forces over the inquiry.
Mr Costa said Portuguese police intend "to increase the collaboration" with their British counterparts and that the important thing is "to concentrate on the job and not on the comments" made by Mr Amaral.
Mr Amaral, who was jointly in charge of the inquiry, was also dismissed from his post as the head of the Judicial Police in the Algarve town of Portimao.
The 47-year-old detective not only laid into police but also attacked the McCanns, accusing them of "creating and working on" lines of inquiry which they then pass onto Leicestershire Police to investigate.
Mr Amaral, who headed the Policia Judiciaria in the nearby town of Portimao and is himself under investigation for allegedly concealing evidence about an alleged assault on the mother of another missing child, was speaking to the daily newspaper Diario de Noticias.
The paper said the detective, who has come under fire in the British press for his "boozy" three-hour lunches and allegedly failing to investigate some of the tip-offs his 30-strong team of officers have received, was in an "explosive and indignant" mood during the brief interview.
Sources said his departure follows five months of gripes about the British police involved in the case.
A family friend said it was "just plain wrong" that Kate and Gerry, both 39-year-old doctors from Rothley in Leicestershire, were seeking to exert any influence on the investigation, adding that British police were only involved to act as a liaison between the family and Portuguese detectives.
And one of the McCanns' two Portuguese lawyers, Carlos Pinto Abreu, told Lisbon radio station TSF that Mr Amaral's comments were "in very poor taste" and "unhelpful to the investigation".
"The British police have only been working on that which the McCann couple want them to and which is most convenient for them," he said.
"They have only investigated tips and information developed and worked on for the McCanns, forgetting that the couple are formal suspects in the death of their daughter Madeleine."
Officially, Portuguese detectives say they appreciate British help and expertise - particularly forensic - but unofficially claim they feel patronised and bullied.
Leicestershire Police were reluctant to wade into the developing row, only saying they would "continue to support the Portuguese investigation".
The McCanns' spokesman Clarence Mitchell was equally cautious, saying: "Kate and Gerry consistently said that they wish to cooperate with the Portuguese authorities in the hunt for Madeleine and that remains the case."
Mr Amaral has reportedly investigated only two child murders in his 26-year police career and he is facing a criminal hearing for allegedly concealing evidence, after a woman jailed for the murder of her daughter claimed police officers tortured her into making a confession.
Leonor Cipriano, 36, claims she was forced to kneel on glass ashtrays with a bag over her head as police repeatedly hit her during almost 48 hours of questioning.
She is serving 16 years for the murder of her eight-year-old daughter Joana, even though the body has never been found and she has since retracted her statement.
Mr Amaral, a father-of-three, strenuously denies covering up the alleged abuse said to have been carried out by three of his colleagues.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1564913/Madeleine-McCann-chief-detective-sacked.html
So was he thrown out of the PJ on 2 Oct 2007 or not? Simple question. The answer is yes or no.
-
Madeleine's case was under Portuguese jurisdiction throughout that time all coordinated by Goncalo Amaral who wasn't sacked until the October of 2007.
Why are you trying to blame Leicestershire Constabulary for the many shortcomings of the investigation during his time in office? Don't you think it is time for you to move on?
It was indeed, and still is, may I remind you. The British pushed their way in with their offers of 'help'. They sent FLO's which the McCanns didn't want (page 20). They set up an incident room which the PJ didn't need or use (page 21). CEOP sent a Detective Superintendent and a Forensic Behavioural Analyst (page 17) which no-one wanted and they kicked their heels for a week before they got to speak to anyone (page 32). What they didn't seem to do was interview the British citizens who returned from PdL and who might have added information to the investigation.
Apparently LC still had officers working on the case at the time of the debrief (2009)
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Strategic-debrief-operation-task-2009.pdf
Page 7
-
It was indeed, and still is, may I remind you. The British pushed their way in with their offers of 'help'. They sent FLO's which the McCanns didn't want (page 20). They set up an incident room which the PJ didn't need or use (page 21). CEOP sent a Detective Superintendent and a Forensic Behavioural Analyst (page 17) which no-one wanted and they kicked their heels for a week before they got to speak to anyone (page 32). What they didn't seem to do was interview the British citizens who returned from PdL and who might have added information to the investigation.
Apparently LC still had officers working on the case at the time of the debrief (2009)
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Strategic-debrief-operation-task-2009.pdf
Page 7
Other references can be found on pages 16,
There can be no dispute that the, Portuguese gave up on the investigation into Maddie's, disappearance and if it wasn't fir the efforts of the McCanns and the UK police it would have remained closed
-
There can be no dispute that the, Portuguese gave up on the investigation into Maddie's, disappearance and if it wasn't fir the efforts of the McCanns and the UK police it would have remained closed
The Portuguese had the sense to realise that there wasn't the evidence needed to identify the crime, let alone solve it.
The McCanns claimed to have identified the crime straight away, and SY have taken the same path for reasons unknown. They are no nearer to solving it imo than the Portuguese were in 2008.
-
The Portuguese had the sense to realise that there wasn't the evidence needed to identify the crime, let alone solve it.
The McCanns claimed to have identified the crime straight away, and SY have taken the same path for reasons unknown. They are no nearer to solving it imo than the Portuguese were in 2008.
I would agree with that, although they may have managed to exclude a large number of people who had a very low probability of being involved to start with.
IMO
-
The Portuguese had the sense to realise that there wasn't the evidence needed to identify the crime, let alone solve it.
The McCanns claimed to have identified the crime straight away, and SY have taken the same path for reasons unknown. They are no nearer to solving it imo than the Portuguese were in 2008.
all your opinion again.......are you under the impression that your opinion is fact
The fact is we dont know what evidence SY has found or what its working on
According to amaral the pj thought they could prove Maddie died in the apartment.... That doesn't seem like they had any sense at all
-
i see the ignore button is working again 8(0(*
-
all your opinion again.......are you under the impression that your opinion is fact
The fact is we dont know what evidence SY has found or what its working on
I did say imo.
-
I did say imo.
You need to make it clear what is opinion... Making four statements with one imo at the end of one isn't clear
-
i see the ignore button is working again 8(0(*
I sometimes wonder why you bother.
-
The Portuguese had the sense to realise that there wasn't the evidence needed to identify the crime, let alone solve it.
The McCanns claimed to have identified the crime straight away, and SY have taken the same path for reasons unknown. They are no nearer to solving it imo than the Portuguese were in 2008.
I don't know about how straight away they identified the 'crime' We have to factor in they all went back to 'look' for madeleine searching the flat? why would an abductor stay in the flat hiding MBM when Kate left to go and tell the others?
The PJ were of the impression a child was missing suspected of wandering off no mention then of abduction. The t9 had some time to think about the impact on them!
I agree the UK police could have made use of the UK witnesses before going on to 'search' Portugual.
-
So was he thrown out of the PJ on 2 Oct 2007 or not? Simple question. The answer is yes or no.
Try reading the known facts of the case with more of an unbiased mindset. I posted that Amaral was sacked ... which is the fact of the matter.
The great pity is that it was not done on the 4th May when he was made an arguido in the grave misconduct of the events which he was in charge of in the only other missing child case with which he was involved.
The salient on topic part of my post which you choose to ignore is the manner in which the attitude this very flawed team leader affected Madeleine's case with the unsubtle move of laying the blame on the Brits.
In conjunction with the author of the thread title adopting the insular Portuguese resentment of the time when she posts of the Brits who "pushed their way in with their offers of 'help' http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10990.msg554249#msg554249
In my opinion incredible to proceed to equate the incompetence displayed by Amaral et al in the failed leadership of their investigation on biased opinion by farming out accusations on another force.
It might be pertinent at this stage to recall the thread asking what he and the PJ got right in Madeleine's case ... posts to which were conspicuous by their absence.
-
Try reading the known facts of the case with more of an unbiased mindset. I posted that Amaral was sacked ... which is the fact of the matter.
The great pity is that it was not done on the 4th May when he was made an arguido in the grave misconduct of the events which he was in charge of in the only other missing child case with which he was involved.
The salient on topic part of my post which you choose to ignore is the manner in which the attitude this very flawed team leader affected Madeleine's case with the unsubtle move of laying the blame on the Brits.
In conjunction with the author of the thread title adopting the insular Portuguese resentment of the time when she posts of the Brits who "pushed their way in with their offers of 'help' http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10990.msg554249#msg554249
In my opinion incredible to proceed to equate the incompetence displayed by Amaral et al in the failed leadership of their investigation on biased opinion by farming out accusations on another force.
It might be pertinent at this stage to recall the thread asking what he and the PJ got right in Madeleine's case ... posts to which were conspicuous by their absence.
We could also mention at this point the incompetency of the Parents and friends of Madeleine who left babies alone every night- couldn't string a sentence together when 'assisting' the police. or getting a timeline which actually reflected what may have happened.
-
We could also mention at this point the incompetency of the Parents and friends of Madeleine who left babies alone every night- couldn't string a sentence together when 'assisting' the police. or getting a timeline which actually reflected what may have happened.
Ah, that old chestnut.
-
As relevant as anything else on here - IMO
-
I don't know about how straight away they identified the 'crime' We have to factor in they all went back to 'look' for madeleine searching the flat? why would an abductor stay in the flat hiding MBM when Kate left to go and tell the others?
The PJ were of the impression a child was missing suspected of wandering off no mention then of abduction. The t9 had some time to think about the impact on them!
I agree the UK police could have made use of the UK witnesses before going on to 'search' Portugual.
Kate McCann knew straight away that Madeleine had been taken. According to Silvia Batista;
since the very beginning either Gerry or the others insisted on stating that Madeleine had been snatched, all using the word "abducted" instead of missing, and all showing much interest in informing the press of the situation.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/SILVIA_BATISTA.htm
-
We could also mention at this point the incompetency of the Parents and friends of Madeleine who left babies alone every night- couldn't string a sentence together when 'assisting' the police. or getting a timeline which actually reflected what may have happened.
One wonders why you appear to have only one string to your bow whatever the topic of the thread might be ... I wonder if it would be worthwhile experimenting with putting you on 'ignore' since I will be missing nothing having heard it all so many many times previously.
When did "... the Parents and friends of Madeleine who left babies alone every night ..." join the British police who are the current target for opprobrium?
-
Kate McCann knew straight away that Madeleine had been taken. According to Silvia Batista;
since the very beginning either Gerry or the others insisted on stating that Madeleine had been snatched, all using the word "abducted" instead of missing, and all showing much interest in informing the press of the situation.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/SILVIA_BATISTA.htm
Yes, this has been relayed by Kate on many interviews, however, it just doesn't tie in with them all going back to the flat to search. They also told Mrs Fen a child was missing - not abducted . The pollice were not looking for an abducted child initially.
-
Starter for ten,how can there be any missing evidence of an abduction when its not even known if an abduction occurred.
When asked if he accepted the girl was abducted,Pedro do Carmo replied we don't know what happened and have to be prepared for different scenario's.
-
Starter for ten,how can there be any missing evidence of an abduction when its not even known if an abduction occurred.
When asked if he accepted the girl was abducted,Pedro do Carmo replied we don't know what happened and have to be prepared for different scenario's.
I don’t think G-Unit started this thread to criticise the UK police for their failure to collect evidence of an abduction.
-
I don’t think G-Unit started this thread to criticise the UK police for their failure to collect evidence of an abduction.
So the title is only bound by the opening post?
-
I would agree with that, although they may have managed to exclude a large number of people who had a very low probability of being involved to start with.
IMO
Whats the saying,When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth.
-
So the title is only bound by the opening post?
If you want to be on topic, yes I guess so. Missing evidence of what exactly? Is this thread about missing evidence of an abduction? I tend to think not.
-
I know the weekend beckons but could we all please stay on topic. TY
-
I know the weekend beckons but could we all please stay on topic. TY
John as my post above yours attracted a 10% warning but has not been changed in any way (unlike the post I was replying to which has been severely edited) could you please tell me if you believe it is fair that I should have received this warning?
-
John as my post above yours attracted a 10% warning but has not been changed in any way (unlike the post I was replying to which has been severely edited) could you please tell me if you believe it is fair that I should have received this warning?
Can't you see your post was an ad hom? OK other posts maybe just as bad, but that is where I started off from today, your post, and it was unacceptable IMO.
-
If you want to be on topic, yes I guess so. Missing evidence of what exactly? Is this thread about missing evidence of an abduction? I tend to think not.
Just for clarification because it's late and I'm never sure what is or is not ad hom is this the post you had warning points given?
-
Just for clarification because it's late and I'm never sure what is or is not ad hom is this the post you had warning points given?
No.
-
Can't you see your post was an ad hom? OK other posts maybe just as bad, but that is where I started off from today, your post, and it was unacceptable IMO.
Your warning was completely unwarranted and broke no rules. I started a series of sentences with a question asking “Is it stupid to...” Can you explain how asking someone if it’s stupid to believe that human memory is fallible can in any way constitute an ad hom? I await your reply with interest.
-
Your warning was completely unwarranted and broke no rules. I started a series of sentences with a question asking “Is it stupid to...” Can you explain how asking someone if it’s stupid to believe that human memory is fallible can in any way constitute an ad hom? I await your reply with interest.
Look it was subtle and quite clever the way you worded your post. It could be a classic in the right place. But it is gone now and I can't remember it in full so I can't explain it now, but the post in its entirety was considered by me to be ad hom. You should take up writing a novel or something like that.
-
Look it was subtle and quite clever the way you worded your post. It could be a classic in the right place. But it is gone now and I can't remember it in full so I can't explain it now, but the post in its entirety was considered by me to be ad hom. You should take up writing a novel or something like that.
Rob, the fact is you misread it, misunderstood it, and acted in haste. Perhaps you have a quota to fill, I don’t know. I do have a novel in me, but so does everyone, apparently.
-
Rob, the fact is you misread it, misunderstood it, and acted in haste. Perhaps you have a quota to fill, I don’t know. I do have a novel in me, but so does everyone, apparently.
In my opinion the post was off topic, which made it liable to removal anyway. Do you have anything to say about missing evidence?
-
In my opinion the post was off topic, which made it liable to removal anyway. Do you have anything to say about missing evidence?
My post was in response to a long ad hom rant by Miss Taken, perhaps I should have introduced a discussion about what I had for dinner last night or reminiscing about the good old days instead.
What would you like to discuss about missing evidence? What do you think 559 Brits (whose DNA and fingerprints and questionnaires have been taken by the police) got to tell us about the McCanns involvement in Madeleine’s disappearance?
-
My post was in response to a long ad hom rant by Miss Taken, perhaps I should have introduced a discussion about what I had for dinner last night or reminiscing about the good old days instead.
What would you like to discuss about missing evidence? What do you think 559 Brits (whose DNA and fingerprints and questionnaires have been taken by the police) got to tell us about the McCanns involvement in Madeleine’s disappearance?
There is very little information about the whereabouts of the British holidaymakers, which LC could have collected and forwarded to the PJ. I am of the opinion that the information would have been useful.
-
There is very little information about the whereabouts of the British holidaymakers, which LC could have collected and forwarded to the PJ. I am of the opinion that the information would have been useful.
Why didn't the Policia Judiciaria?
-
Why didn't the Policia Judiciaria?
Why didn't they what?
-
Rob, the fact is you misread it, misunderstood it, and acted in haste. Perhaps you have a quota to fill, I don’t know. I do have a novel in me, but so does everyone, apparently.
There is no quota to fill.
-
IMO, the Investigation was a botch up from day one. It failed miserably, but it didn't half investigate The McCanns.
-
Rob, the fact is you misread it, misunderstood it, and acted in haste. Perhaps you have a quota to fill, I don’t know. I do have a novel in me, but so does everyone, apparently.
I don't have an agenda.
-
IMO, the Investigation was a botch up from day one. It failed miserably, but it didn't half investigate The McCanns.
There has never been an innocent couple who have suffered the vituperation the McCanns have as a direct result of that botched investigation and the book and documentary produced to justify Amaral's failed thesis which could not be supported when investigated appropriately by his peers.
-
There has never been an innocent couple who have suffered the vituperation the McCanns have as a direct result of that botched investigation and the book and documentary produced to justify Amaral's failed thesis which could not be supported when investigated appropriately by his peers.
Neither could the McCann's thesis, despite their book and documentary.
-
We are in esteemed company some posters obviously know what happened,how else can it be said the first investigation was botched,what was missed?
-
We are in esteemed company some posters obviously know what happened,how else can it be said the first investigation was botched,what was missed?
You think that you know. Can you tell me how you know?
-
You think that you know. Can you tell me how you know?
How I know what.
-
How I know what.
If you don't know, you don't know.
-
There has never been an innocent couple who have suffered the vituperation the McCanns have as a direct result of that botched investigation and the book and documentary produced to justify Amaral's failed thesis which could not be supported when investigated appropriately by his peers.
Can you provide a cite of what they are innocent of please?
The couple you mention went on holiday but came home minus a daughter. Her mysterious disappearance has never been solve and they have never been charged with any crime. They managed to gain 'celebrity' status, travelled the world with their 'story' despite there being NO evidence of their claims. In fact closer scrutiny shows them to be 'confused' about what happened that night. They got new jobs, moved on.
In this country there would have had a very different outcome imo. You and I and millions of Britons know this!
So there really is no point in repeating 'poor McCanns.
-
We are in esteemed company some posters obviously know what happened,how else can it be said the first investigation was botched,what was missed?
Hindsight is a wonderful thing I agree. When Madeleine was discovered to be missing, everyone dispersed around the complex looking for her. When the first GNR officers arrived, they too instigated a local search for her. This search was expanded over the next few days to included air and sea searches. They weren't looking for an abductor, they were looking for a young child who had wandered off. The question arises therefore as to what else could have realistically been done in the circumstances?
-
Hindsight is a wonderful thing I agree. When Madeleine was discovered to be missing, everyone dispersed around the complex looking for her. When the first GNR officers arrived, they too instigated a local search for her. This search was expanded over the next few days to included air and sea searches. They weren't looking for an abductor, they were looking for a young child who had wandered off. The question arises therefore as to what else could have realistically been done in the circumstances?
And to this end , it is hardly the fault of the Portuguese investigators working on what they were told. It is also wrong, IMO, to blame Sr AMARAL for what had nothing to do with him. He just became the whipping boy IMO.
Not taking part in a rconstrution and refusing to answer questions certainly couldn't have helped the investigation either.
-
Posters are reminded of the forum rules and should not engage in any conduct which breaches those rules. Sniping, goading, use of inappropriate language, posting insulting comments and unnecessary criticism of other members should be avoided. Moderators are also reminded of the need to lead by example and should avoid inappropriate comment or unnecessary moderation.
Members can message me at any time if necessary.
-
And to this end , it is hardly the fault of the Portuguese investigators working on what they were told. It is also wrong, IMO, to blame Sr AMARAL for what had nothing to do with him. He just became the whipping boy IMO.
Not taking part in a rconstrution and refusing to answer questions certainly couldn't have helped the investigation either.
I think it is wrong to completely disregard Amaral's theory as to what happened to Madeleine until such time as the disappearance is solved. Investigators still don't know what happened to the youngster so on that basis, every theory must be judged on its merits.
-
I think it is wrong to completely disregard Amaral's theory as to what happened to Madeleine until such time as the disappearance is solved. Investigators still don't know what happened to the youngster so on that basis, every theory must be judged on its merits.
I think it's fair to point out that the evidence he bases his theory on doesn't stand up to scrutiny... And therefore his claim he can prove Maddie died in the apartment and her death was covered up by a claim of abduction is false
-
I think it's fair to point out that the evidence he bases his theory on doesn't stand up to scrutiny... And therefore his claim he can prove Maddie died in the apartment and her death was covered up by a claim of abduction is false
50% right then,there is a claim of an abduction not least by the parents.
OG by their remit are supposed to be looking into one.
Amaral suggest's one was staged.
Almost on the same page,who knows where the evidence will lead,if there is any.
-
As the same can be said for the McCans claim of an abduction from her bed. Under scrutiny which was shown and discussed by respected experts, in a documentry. Even by inexperienced onliners can establish this just by reading ther version of accounts and their interviews.
IMO they have not been properly grilled to thrash out the truth.
-
50% right then,there is a claim of an abduction not least by the parents.
OG by their remit are supposed to be looking into one.
Amaral suggest's one was staged.
Almost on the same page,who knows where the evidence will lead,if there is any.
Amaral claims the evidence proves it... That's where he is wrong
-
I think it's fair to point out that the evidence he bases his theory on doesn't stand up to scrutiny... And therefore his claim he can prove Maddie died in the apartment and her death was covered up by a claim of abduction is false
It would be more diplomatic to state that his claim on balance is unlikely. I should add also that the abduction from the bedroom claim falls into that same category since there is no evidence to back it up.
-
Amaral claims the evidence proves it... That's where he is wrong
Amaral claims the abduction was staged,others claim its for real,so if Amaral is wrong then where is the evidence it was for real.Bearing in mind not one investigating officer has said they have evidence of such.
-
It would be more diplomatic to state that his claim on balance is unlikely.
I'm not saying his theory isn't possible... I'm saying he hasn't proved it as he has claimed. If the evidence he presented did prove it then it could be taken to a court
-
Amaral claims the abduction was staged,others claim its for real,so if Amaral is wrong then where is the evidence it was for real.Bearing in mind not one investigating officer has said they have evidence of such.
Amaral claims he can prove it... That's where I say he is wrong
-
It would be more diplomatic to state that his claim on balance is unlikely. I should add also that the abduction from the bedroom claim falls into that same category since there is no evidence to back it up.
The only theory that stands up to scrutiny imo is the woke and wandered and was taken from the street outside one.
-
Amaral claims the evidence proves it... That's where he is wrong
We do not know what evidence he has/had at that time to make that claim. please no dogs talk!
-
The UK police lost the opportunity to add important evidence to this case by not interviewing everyone who was identified to them as being in PdL between 28th April and 3rd May 2007 in my opinion.
[Reference material: http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Strategic-debrief-operation-task-2009.pdf
https://homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2019/06/05/home-office-update-on-funding-for-operation-grange/ ]
Can anyone offer a suggestion as to why SY haven't been allowed a free hand in their investigation?
-
Can anyone offer a suggestion as to why SY haven't been allowed a free hand in their investigation?
I would say the only restriction on SY is that imposed by the PJ... And that may well be what Sutton was warned about
-
I would say the only restriction on SY is that imposed by the PJ... And that may well be what Sutton was warned about
They had a free hand in their search of the shrub land and the questioning of the three amigo's.imo.
-
The only theory that stands up to scrutiny imo is the woke and wandered and was taken from the street outside one.
Thereafter is the problem imo.
-
They had a free hand in their search of the shrub land and the questioning of the three amigo's.imo.
I wonder how long it took to arrange that... As I understand they wanted dna of the three but were not given a free hand
-
Can anyone offer a suggestion as to why SY haven't been allowed a free hand in their investigation?
6 million dollar question Angelo!
It appears that their initial input at the beginning was assisting the PJ. Then something seemed to happened to change that. Some one, I suspect high up, removed those who did suspect the paretns of not telling the truth. and were not pulling towards the abduction from bed scenario.
They seem to be chasing a lot of 'public assistance' theories. that seems to be keeping them busy. anyone can phone up and claim MR A and MRS B OR a gang are responsible here is their address.. somewhere is; Genramy Holland, ameraca, New Zealand, the hymalayas...
-
I wonder how long it took to arrange that... As I understand they wanted dna of the three but were not given a free hand
I think its been discussed before regarding DNA,if not on a data base what reason would they have to take it? not forgetting its a PJ case.
-
I think its been discussed before regarding DNA,if not on a data base what reason would they have to take it? not forgetting its a PJ case.
They wanted it... But were not allowed... So didn't have a free hand
-
They wanted it... But were not allowed... So didn't have a free hand
Look at it another way,why was the need for SY to want it whilst investigating a crime outwith their jurisdiction.
Was there any unidentified dna from the alleged crime scene.Initially yes but don't forget the PJ had reopened the case.
-
Look at it another way,why was the need fro SY to want it whilst investigating a crime outwith their jurisdiction.
The point wad did they have a free hand... The answer seems to be no
-
The point wad did they have a free hand... The answer seems to be no
I suspect they knew what the constraints were.
Where did the tale of the DNA merge from,the lead investigators, the press?
Ah!
The request appears in a letter rogatory dated of July last year, but was challenged by the PJ, since it is an illegality.
https://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2014/07/english-ask-for-dna-of-arguidos-at-all.html
https://www.jn.pt/nacional/dossiers/o-caso-maddie-mccann/interior/ingleses-pedem-adn-de-arguidos-a-todo-o-custo-no-caso-maddie-4003235.html?id=4003235
-
50% right then,there is a claim of an abduction not least by the parents.
OG by their remit are supposed to be looking into one.
Amaral suggest's one was staged.
Almost on the same page,who knows where the evidence will lead,if there is any.
The evidence has kept the Judicial Police and Scotland Yard investigating Madeleine's case for the past seven years making it certain that something was overlooked in 2007.
There is no rumour of or sign of them closing it down yet.
-
The only theory that stands up to scrutiny imo is the woke and wandered and was taken from the street outside one.
If that is so ... she was clearly abducted.
-
If that is so ... she was clearly abducted.
Maybe, but in that case, not from the apartment as claimed by the McCanns, which makes the open windows story bollocks - IMO
-
They had a free hand in their search of the shrub land and the questioning of the three amigo's.imo.
I do not think they had. I believe the Portuguese authorities refused them certain permissions.
-
I do not think they had. I believe the Portuguese authorities refused them certain permissions.
On the basis of law. there were somethings the PJ/authorities could not allow. NOt bourne from stubborness or indefference.
-
Can anyone offer a suggestion as to why SY haven't been allowed a free hand in their investigation?
SY were probably told to investigate all others possible scenarios except the tapas 9. SY have produced nothing to make Portugal change their mind and their Supreme Court confirmed who are still main suspects.
-
SY were probably told to investigate all others possible scenarios except the tapas 9. SY have produced nothing to make Portugal change their mind and their Supreme Court confirmed who are still main suspects.
The SC didn't refer to anyone as suspects