UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: faithlilly on October 29, 2013, 07:05:48 PM

Title: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: faithlilly on October 29, 2013, 07:05:48 PM
McCanns could face court over report

by Gerard Couzens

THE parents of Madeleine McCann faced further pressure yesterday after ex-police chief Goncalo Amaral hinted he may fight them in court over a key report they allegedly held back.

Gerry and Kate McCann were accused at the weekend of sidelining the 2008 report by former MI5 investigators they hired after it pinpointed ‘anomalies’ in statements they and their friends made.

The result was that e-fits of the prime suspect in Madeleine McCann’s abduction – hidden for five years in the unpublished report – were only made public this month during a new Met Police appeal.

The report said Irish holidaymaker Martin Smith’s sighting of a man carrying a girl in pyjamas near the McCann’s Algarve holiday apartment was ‘credible evidence’ which had been ‘neglected for too long.’

Mr Amaral’s lawyer said last night he was considering raising the issue in the couple’s ongoing libel trial against the former police.

The McCanns are seeking one million pounds in damages over the ex-detective’s claims in his July 2008 book The Truth of the Lie that they faked their daughter’s abduction to cover up her death in their holiday flat.

Vitor Santos de Oliveira, who is representing Mr Amaral, said: ‘We are aware of the revelations concerning this report by the McCanns’ former investigators and believe they are very important.

‘It is possible I may try to submit it as evidence to defend my client but I haven’t decided yet.

‘Nothing’s been ruled out. We are analysing the relevance of the report and considering our position. We have no intention of introducing irrelevant material into this case because we respect the McCanns as people and have no intention of harming them for sake of it,’ he said.

‘But I can tell you that if we feel something is relevant in disproving the McCanns’ claims about my client then we will have no hesitation in using it.

‘I think the revelations about the suppression of this report are very important with regards to the ongoing criminal case.

‘It’s a report written by McCann-hired investigators who make strong criticisms of the couple.

‘As far as the civil libel case is going we are very calm,’ Mr de Oliveira continued.

‘My client’s arguments in his book have been backed up in court by his former police colleagues who say it was the police position in 2008 when the book was published.’

The ongoing libel case launched by the McCanns against Mr Amaral is due to restart next Tuesday.

in Irish Daily Mail, 29 out 2013, paper edition



IF Oakley's report is admitted as evidence in the libel trial by Amaral's lawyer and IF the McCanns give evidence as they have requested it will be interesting to see them questioned with regard to the suppression of the report.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Redblossom on October 29, 2013, 07:57:33 PM
Love to be fly on the wall there! Rock and a hard place methinks......for the  plaintiffs!!
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: imustpointout on October 29, 2013, 07:59:22 PM
It will be fascinating.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: VIXTE on October 29, 2013, 07:59:49 PM
Rubbish! There was no active police investigation at the time.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: carlymichelle on October 29, 2013, 08:00:16 PM
Love to be fly on the wall there! Rock and a hard place methinks......for the  plaintiffs!!

oh dear tears before bedtime for the mcanns?? 8@??)(
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Rachel Granada on October 29, 2013, 08:01:33 PM
I think the Sunday Telegraph could be paying out plenty over this matter.

It's a shame that they didn't heed SY's plea for press restraint.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Rachel Granada on October 29, 2013, 08:03:07 PM
oh dear tears before bedtime for the mcanns?? 8@??)(

Why do you hate two strangers so much, charly?
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Jazzy on October 29, 2013, 08:06:11 PM
Love to be fly on the wall there! Rock and a hard place methinks......for the  plaintiffs!!

Wait and see, don't let spite cloud your judgement.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: carlymichelle on October 29, 2013, 08:08:39 PM
couldnt  GA lawyer say that his book had no effect on the search for maddie because the mcanns hid the E fits therefore they prevented anyone looking for her not him???
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: stephen25000 on October 29, 2013, 08:09:00 PM
Why do you hate two strangers so much, charly?

Bearing in mind the hatred, and I mean hatred shown to Amaral by the mccann supporters, isn't your comment just a tad hypocritical ?
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Kazcutt on October 29, 2013, 08:09:56 PM
What a shame
This forum is obviously one sided at far to many cooks in the kitchen .
Its like being in junior school you cant do this cant do that .
Lots of warnings lots of moaning

Could be so much more
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: imustpointout on October 29, 2013, 08:10:05 PM
couldnt  GA lawyer say that his book had no effect on the search for maddie because the cmanns hid the E fits therefore they prevented anyone looking for her not him???

And the Mccanns could say that the PJ interviewed the Smiths in May 2007 and didn't follow it up.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Redblossom on October 29, 2013, 08:10:30 PM
Wait and see, don't let spite cloud your judgement.

can you ever  do a single solitary post without your emotive emotional blackmailing claptrap?

Spite has nothing to do with the facts here, perhaps you should ponder them more for a change
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: carlymichelle on October 29, 2013, 08:12:11 PM
can you ever  do a single solitary post without your emotive emotional blackmailing claptrap?

Spite has nothing to do with the facts here, perhaps you should ponder them more for a change

imo   GA  would  win    his case with this because the mcanns hindered the search for maddie not him he and his lawyer are right
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: imustpointout on October 29, 2013, 08:14:37 PM
Maybe the papers can't believe that "evidence" that has come light 5 years after the event would have any bearing on the effects of the book. Especially as it was apparently secret and not known to the general public, or indeed to many people at all.

Think about it
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Redblossom on October 29, 2013, 08:16:23 PM
imo   GA  would  win    his case with this because the mcanns hindered the search for maddie not him he and his lawyer are right

Its a very strong addition.....
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: DCI on October 29, 2013, 08:16:30 PM
Quote
‘It is possible I may try to submit it as evidence to defend my client but I haven’t decided yet.

Don't think he can submit new anything, if not in the original court papers. Can he?
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: carlymichelle on October 29, 2013, 08:17:31 PM
Maybe the papers can't believe that "evidence" that has come light 5 years after the event would have any bearing on the effects of the book. Especially as it was apparently secret and not known to the general public, or indeed to many people at all.

Think about it

thats what im saying clearly  GA  book had no affect on the search for maddie becaus ethe mcanns supressed the e fit images   so it was that  that affected  people looking for maddie and the so called abductor NOT GA
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Mr Gray on October 29, 2013, 08:18:02 PM
Don't think he can submit new anything, if not in the original court papers. Can he?

with respect hes talking out of his arse again
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Redblossom on October 29, 2013, 08:18:52 PM
with respect hes talking out of his arse again

Takes one etc
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Montclair on October 29, 2013, 08:19:28 PM
Don't think he can submit new anything, if not in the original court papers. Can he?

Don't worry, lawyers always find a way.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: carlymichelle on October 29, 2013, 08:19:59 PM
Takes one etc

it shows GA  truly wants to  give justice for maddie he has not given up despite what it has cost him
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: carlymichelle on October 29, 2013, 08:20:37 PM
Don't worry, lawyers always find a way.

lots of technicalities  in cases like this   things can change!!!
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 29, 2013, 08:20:58 PM
Don't think he can submit new anything, if not in the original court papers. Can he?
I don't see how he can, if the McCanns don't take the stand. The matter has to be relevant in one of the pre-established areas to be taken in consideration in this trial.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Mr Gray on October 29, 2013, 08:21:13 PM
he can call Halligan to give evidence... I think hes out of jail now
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Redblossom on October 29, 2013, 08:24:34 PM
it shows GA  truly wants to  give justice for maddie he has not given up despite what it has cost him

Sensible people see this.....justice for him and his family too and the PT police all of whom were demonised by the british press
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Mr Gray on October 29, 2013, 08:25:36 PM
Sensible people see this.....justice for him and his family too and the PT police all of whom were demonised by the british press

and for good reason
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Eleanor on October 29, 2013, 08:26:45 PM
he can call Halligan to give evidence... I think hes out of jail now

And Exton is only a Shop Lifter.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Mr Gray on October 29, 2013, 08:29:29 PM
And Exton is only a Shop Lifter.

I think that's a bit cruel Eleanor, hadn't he had a mental breakdown at this time..probably didn't even know what day of the week it was
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Eleanor on October 29, 2013, 08:31:52 PM
I think that's a bit cruel Eleanor, hadn't he had a mental breakdown at this time..probably didn't even know what day of the week it was

Really? He'll be a big help then.  Not.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: DCI on October 29, 2013, 08:32:29 PM
Don't worry, lawyers always find a way.

He can try, good job there are decent judges in this case though. This one ain't daft, or got at, is she?
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Mr Gray on October 29, 2013, 08:32:58 PM
Really? He'll be a big help then.  Not.

he was probably just a bit confused at the time
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: DCI on October 29, 2013, 08:33:21 PM
with respect hes talking out of his arse again

I know that, Davel, but you have to  @)(++(*
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: DCI on October 29, 2013, 08:34:22 PM
he was probably just a bit confused at the time

Dot.com
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Rachel Granada on October 29, 2013, 09:46:52 PM
Bearing in mind the hatred, and I mean hatred shown to Amaral by the mccann supporters, isn't your comment just a tad hypocritical ?

Not at all, Stephen.  After all, we have only commented on the facts of his perjury conviction, and the fact that he defrauded his brother.  And of course the lies in his book about the "frozen remains" etc.

It should be noted that the presence or otherwise of a frozen
cadaver has not been proven one way or another.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Kazcutt on October 29, 2013, 09:52:47 PM
Not at all, Stephen.  After all, we have only commented on the facts of his perjury conviction, and the fact that he defrauded his brother.  And of course the lies in his book about the "frozen remains" etc.

It should be noted that the presence or otherwise of a frozen
cadaver has not been proven one way or another.


Dont forget sacked lol
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 29, 2013, 09:59:15 PM
Not at all, Stephen.  After all, we have only commented on the facts of his perjury conviction, and the fact that he defrauded his brother.  And of course the lies in his book about the "frozen remains" etc.

It should be noted that the presence or otherwise of a frozen
cadaver has not been proven one way or another.

Where the author differs from the Prosecutors who have written the dispatch, is in the logical, police-work-related and investigative interpretation that he does of those facts.

Finally, concerning the damage to the right to usufruct ['Usufruct' is the legal right to use and derive profit or benefit from property that belongs to another person] from the penal process' guarantees, namely the right to a fair investigation and the right to freedom and safety, we still cannot understand how it is possible for said rights to be offended by the contents of a book that describes facts from the investigation, although it parts from the interpretation that the Public Ministry's Magistrates made of those facts, yet offering based, solidly built and logical interpretations.

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id344.html
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Rachel Granada on October 29, 2013, 10:09:59 PM
Where the author differs from the Prosecutors who have written the dispatch, is in the logical, police-work-related and investigative interpretation that he does of those facts.

Finally, concerning the damage to the right to usufruct ['Usufruct' is the legal right to use and derive profit or benefit from property that belongs to another person] from the penal process' guarantees, namely the right to a fair investigation and the right to freedom and safety, we still cannot understand how it is possible for said rights to be offended by the contents of a book that describes facts from the investigation, although it parts from the interpretation that the Public Ministry's Magistrates made of those facts, yet offering based, solidly built and logical interpretations.

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id344.html

I see.  What about the allegations of a frozen corpse being driven in the Scenic?  Is that a solidly built and logical interpretation?
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Redblossom on October 29, 2013, 10:11:52 PM
not allegations, theories and musings of a seasoned officer dear rachel....no rule against them, get over it, its getting sooooo boring, pick something else for a change, zzzz.....ok had enough rubbish on here today, see ya





Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: blonk on October 29, 2013, 10:12:21 PM
McCanns could face court over report

by Gerard Couzens

THE parents of Madeleine McCann faced further pressure yesterday after ex-police chief Goncalo Amaral hinted he may fight them in court over a key report they allegedly held back.

Gerry and Kate McCann were accused at the weekend of sidelining the 2008 report by former MI5 investigators they hired after it pinpointed ‘anomalies’ in statements they and their friends made.

The result was that e-fits of the prime suspect in Madeleine McCann’s abduction – hidden for five years in the unpublished report – were only made public this month during a new Met Police appeal.

The report said Irish holidaymaker Martin Smith’s sighting of a man carrying a girl in pyjamas near the McCann’s Algarve holiday apartment was ‘credible evidence’ which had been ‘neglected for too long.’
 
Actually, is Martin Smith's evidence credible?

According to the best informamtion we have, he contacted Portuguese police with news of his sighting on 16 May 2007, after he had been back in Ireland for days.

That was 3 days after Tanner had (wrongly) been adamant that Murat was the man she said she'd seen on 3 May - and 1-2 days after Rachael Oldfield, Fiona Payne and Dr Matthew Oldfield claimed they'd sen Murat on the night of 3 May - a claim they unanimously jettisoned nine months later. And, of course, 2 days after Murat was made n arguido (14 May).

Why the heck did he wait for 13 days?

And why did he, when he described the person he said he saw, repeat almost exactly Jane Tanner's description?

'Not a tourist'

'Dark jacket'

'Light trousers'

'5' 10" tall'...

...and so on.

And why was he so sure that his 'sighting' was not of his very good acquaintance ("I had been to Praia da Luz many times and met Murat several times") Robert Murat? 

At the time of this claimed sighting, it was dark. None of the Smiths can remember a thing about his face.

Yet, four months later, Smith said he was '60% to 80%' sure - by the way he walked and held his child - that he had seen Gerry McCann! - even though Gerry McCann was clearly at the Ocean Club at this time.

His daughter even professed to be (60%)  'sure' that the child carried by this man was Madeleine McCann. On what basis?

Now it seems he has changed his mind again and accepts it was NOT Gerry McCann.

And, courtesy of Crimewatch, DCI Redwood says the Smiths have drawn up TWO different efits - looking like completey different blokes.

The whole tale of Martin Smith's sighting is a load of hogwash.

The question now is: why is Redwood and why are the McCanns making such a big deal of this? - especially after apparently hiding these efits for 5 years?     
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 29, 2013, 10:18:00 PM
I see.  What about the allegations of a frozen corpse being driven in the Scenic?  Is that a solidly built and logical interpretation?

These 3 didn't have a problem with it,
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id344.html
Lisbon and Appeals Court, 14.10.2010
The Appellate Court Judges,
Francisco Bruto da Costa
Catarina Arelo Manso
António Valente

and the supreme court didn't overturn their decision.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Lyall on October 29, 2013, 10:22:25 PM
 
Actually, is Martin Smith's evidence credible?

According to the best informamtion we have, he contacted Portuguese police with news of his sighting on 16 May 2007, after he had been back in Ireland for days.

That was 3 days after Tanner had (wrongly) been adamant that Murat was the man she said she'd seen on 3 May - and 1-2 days after Rachael Oldfield, Fiona Payne and Dr Matthew Oldfield claimed they'd sen Murat on the night of 3 May - a claim they unanimously jettisoned nine months later. And, of course, 2 days after Murat was made n arguido (14 May).

Why the heck did he wait for 13 days?

And why did he, when he described the person he said he saw, repeat almost exactly Jane Tanner's description?

'Not a tourist'

'Dark jacket'

'Light trousers'

'5' 10" tall'...

...and so on.

And why was he so sure that his 'sighting' was not of his very good acquaintance ("I had been to Praia da Luz many times and met Murat several times") Robert Murat? 

At the time of this claimed sighting, it was dark. None of the Smiths can remember a thing about his face.

Yet, four months later, Smith said he was '60% to 80%' sure - by the way he walked and held his child - that he had seen Gerry McCann! - even though Gerry McCann was clearly at the Ocean Club at this time.

His daughter even professed to be (60%)  'sure' that the child carried by this man was Madeleine McCann. On what basis?

Now it seems he has changed his mind again and accepts it was NOT Gerry McCann.

And, courtesy of Crimewatch, DCI Redwood says the Smiths have drawn up TWO different efits - looking like completey different blokes.

The whole tale of Martin Smith's sighting is a load of hogwash.

The question now is: why is Redwood and why are the McCanns making such a big deal of this? - especially after apparently hiding these efits for 5 years?   

Because they had nothing else to show on Crimewatch?

Pressure.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Sherlock Holmes on October 30, 2013, 02:26:34 AM
 
Actually, is Martin Smith's evidence credible?

According to the best informamtion we have, he contacted Portuguese police with news of his sighting on 16 May 2007, after he had been back in Ireland for days.

That was 3 days after Tanner had (wrongly) been adamant that Murat was the man she said she'd seen on 3 May - and 1-2 days after Rachael Oldfield, Fiona Payne and Dr Matthew Oldfield claimed they'd sen Murat on the night of 3 May - a claim they unanimously jettisoned nine months later. And, of course, 2 days after Murat was made n arguido (14 May).

Why the heck did he wait for 13 days?

And why did he, when he described the person he said he saw, repeat almost exactly Jane Tanner's description?

'Not a tourist'

'Dark jacket'

'Light trousers'

'5' 10" tall'...

...and so on.

And why was he so sure that his 'sighting' was not of his very good acquaintance ("I had been to Praia da Luz many times and met Murat several times") Robert Murat? 

At the time of this claimed sighting, it was dark. None of the Smiths can remember a thing about his face.

Yet, four months later, Smith said he was '60% to 80%' sure - by the way he walked and held his child - that he had seen Gerry McCann! - even though Gerry McCann was clearly at the Ocean Club at this time.

His daughter even professed to be (60%)  'sure' that the child carried by this man was Madeleine McCann. On what basis?

Now it seems he has changed his mind again and accepts it was NOT Gerry McCann.

And, courtesy of Crimewatch, DCI Redwood says the Smiths have drawn up TWO different efits - looking like completey different blokes.

The whole tale of Martin Smith's sighting is a load of hogwash.

The question now is: why is Redwood and why are the McCanns making such a big deal of this? - especially after apparently hiding these efits for 5 years?   

Pretty weak stuff.

By the same token, can we really blame the failure of the investigation on the McCanns withholding the e-fits, given the pictures' vagueness and the fact that they are products of such a contradictory account?
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Sherlock Holmes on October 30, 2013, 02:30:46 AM
McCanns could face court over report

by Gerard Couzens

THE parents of Madeleine McCann faced further pressure yesterday after ex-police chief Goncalo Amaral hinted he may fight them in court over a key report they allegedly held back.

Gerry and Kate McCann were accused at the weekend of sidelining the 2008 report by former MI5 investigators they hired after it pinpointed ‘anomalies’ in statements they and their friends made.

The result was that e-fits of the prime suspect in Madeleine McCann’s abduction – hidden for five years in the unpublished report – were only made public this month during a new Met Police appeal.

The report said Irish holidaymaker Martin Smith’s sighting of a man carrying a girl in pyjamas near the McCann’s Algarve holiday apartment was ‘credible evidence’ which had been ‘neglected for too long.’

Mr Amaral’s lawyer said last night he was considering raising the issue in the couple’s ongoing libel trial against the former police.

The McCanns are seeking one million pounds in damages over the ex-detective’s claims in his July 2008 book The Truth of the Lie that they faked their daughter’s abduction to cover up her death in their holiday flat.

Vitor Santos de Oliveira, who is representing Mr Amaral, said: ‘We are aware of the revelations concerning this report by the McCanns’ former investigators and believe they are very important.

‘It is possible I may try to submit it as evidence to defend my client but I haven’t decided yet.

‘Nothing’s been ruled out. We are analysing the relevance of the report and considering our position. We have no intention of introducing irrelevant material into this case because we respect the McCanns as people and have no intention of harming them for sake of it,’ he said.

‘But I can tell you that if we feel something is relevant in disproving the McCanns’ claims about my client then we will have no hesitation in using it.

‘I think the revelations about the suppression of this report are very important with regards to the ongoing criminal case.

‘It’s a report written by McCann-hired investigators who make strong criticisms of the couple.

‘As far as the civil libel case is going we are very calm,’ Mr de Oliveira continued.

‘My client’s arguments in his book have been backed up in court by his former police colleagues who say it was the police position in 2008 when the book was published.’

The ongoing libel case launched by the McCanns against Mr Amaral is due to restart next Tuesday.

in Irish Daily Mail, 29 out 2013, paper edition



IF Oakley's report is admitted as evidence in the libel trial by Amaral's lawyer and IF the McCanns give evidence as they have requested it will be interesting to see them questioned with regard to the suppression of the report.

Surprised that Amaral's lawyer is talking directly to the press about what evidence he may or may not decide to submit in court in a live case.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Kazcutt on October 30, 2013, 07:33:03 AM
‘Nothing’s been ruled out. We are analysing the relevance of the report and considering our position. We have no intention of introducing irrelevant material into this case because we respect the McCanns as people and have no intention of harming them for sake of it,’ he said.



You lickle liar
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Luz on October 30, 2013, 12:51:07 PM
Not at all, Stephen.  After all, we have only commented on the facts of his perjury conviction, and the fact that he defrauded his brother.  And of course the lies in his book about the "frozen remains" etc.

The low level of your argumentation and the high level of your libelous comments shows clearly the poor defense you can offer to those you so fiercely want to clear.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Luz on October 30, 2013, 01:00:51 PM
According to the recent changes in the Civil Law Procedure, the one that allows the introduction of new witnesses until the end of the trial, it is perfectly possible to introduce the Ockley Report, which would have more relevance if Exton accepted to testify in Court. But I doubt Amaral's defense will use that strategy, first because they don't need to, and second, because unlike the appellants, the respondents seem to have much more respect for the counterpart than they deserve.

So far the litigators were unable to show any evidence of what was their main arguments:

-the investigation has not been hampered;
-none of the McCann were hurt by the publication of the book. In fact the prospective damage to the twins, argumented by someone that only is not a psychologist or psychiatrist and only saw them once, was highly damaging. In psychology or psychiatry it's impossible to make prognosis, and even if that was possible, much more damaging is the environment the parents have created to those children - which I believe could be diagnosed now.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: j.rob on October 30, 2013, 01:18:20 PM
Well I think it is about time they had a taste of their own medicine. They have been mighty active sueing everyone who disagrees with their abduction theory. Despite the fact that there is no evidence for it. And there isn't - the shutters were not found to be broken. They give differing accounts of their actions on the evening Madeleine disappeared. They allowed everyone to contaminate what they knew was a scene of crime (now, how did they KNOW that, I wonder, surely it was simply a place that a child had disappeared from.....).

In any case of a missing child, the last people who saw the child always have to be ruled out completely as suspects. That is completely normal - the McCanns know this. As doctors they would have more knowledge of child protection issues than the average person, I would think.

God only knows how their other children will ever get their heads around the whole fiasco.

The McCanns have played the victim role for a very long time. What is that expression - chutzpah. I happen to believe it is quite apt.

And yes, my opinion on this case has done a 360 degree turn. I had enormous sympathy for them at the time and felt that they took a lot of flak about their babysitting arrangement which were not that different to the type of baby listening service that hotels and resort sometimes offer. So I genuinely felt for them.

Then I read a bit more about the case. I watched them in interviews. I read the police reports. I read some of the things that they had said. I watched their behaviour in interviews. I looked at the people they had employed - extradition lawyers, lawyers who are experts in libel (the most feared apparently). Detectives who are not necessarily experts in missing children cases but know about money laundering. Spin doctors/reputation managers and media experts.

And all paid for by the general public who have given generously to a Fund that purports to help find their daughter. Not to mention the millions of tax payers money that must have gone into the case. And it has sold a lot of newspapers and filled a lot of news programmes.

And still - the whereabouts of Madeleine is apparently just as much a mystery as the day she disappeared. Well, SOMEONE knows, obviously. But who can those people be?
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: stephen25000 on October 30, 2013, 01:22:33 PM
Well I think it is about time they had a taste of their own medicine. They have been mighty active sueing everyone who disagrees with their abduction theory. Despite the fact that there is no evidence for it. And there isn't - the shutters were not found to be broken. They give differing accounts of their actions on the evening Madeleine disappeared. They allowed everyone to contaminate what they knew was a scene of crime (now, how did they KNOW that, I wonder, surely it was simply a place that a child had disappeared from.....).

In any case of a missing child, the last people who saw the child always have to be ruled out completely as suspects. That is completely normal - the McCanns know this. As doctors they would have more knowledge of child protection issues than the average person, I would think.

God only knows how their other children will ever get their heads around the whole fiasco.

The McCanns have played the victim role for a very long time. What is that expression - chutzpah. I happen to believe it is quite apt.

And yes, my opinion on this case has done a 360 degree turn. I had enormous sympathy for them at the time and felt that they took a lot of flak about their babysitting arrangement which were not that different to the type of baby listening service that hotels and resort sometimes offer. So I genuinely felt for them.

Then I read a bit more about the case. I watched them in interviews. I read the police reports. I read some of the things that they had said. I watched their behaviour in interviews. I looked at the people they had employed - extradition lawyers, lawyers who are experts in libel (the most feared apparently). Detectives who are not necessarily experts in missing children cases but know about money laundering. Spin doctors/reputation managers and media experts.

And all paid for by the general public who have given generously to a Fund that purports to help find their daughter. Not to mention the millions of tax payers money that must have gone into the case. And it has sold a lot of newspapers and filled a lot of news programmes.

And still - the whereabouts of Madeleine is apparently just as much a mystery as the day she disappeared. Well, SOMEONE knows, obviously. But who can those people be?

Excellent post.

 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 30, 2013, 01:28:15 PM
Well I think it is about time they had a taste of their own medicine. They have been mighty active sueing everyone who disagrees with their abduction theory. Despite the fact that there is no evidence for it. And there isn't - the shutters were not found to be broken. They give differing accounts of their actions on the evening Madeleine disappeared. They allowed everyone to contaminate what they knew was a scene of crime (now, how did they KNOW that, I wonder, surely it was simply a place that a child had disappeared from.....).  8@??)(

In any case of a missing child, the last people who saw the child always have to be ruled out completely as suspects. That is completely normal - the McCanns know this. As doctors they would have more knowledge of child protection issues than the average person, I would think.  8@??)(

God only knows how their other children will ever get their heads around the whole fiasco. 8@??)(

The McCanns have played the victim role for a very long time. What is that expression - chutzpah. I happen to believe it is quite apt.

And yes, my opinion on this case has done a 360 degree turn. I had enormous sympathy for them at the time and felt that they took a lot of flak about their babysitting arrangement which were not that different to the type of baby listening service that hotels and resort sometimes offer. So I genuinely felt for them.

Then I read a bit more about the case. I watched them in interviews. I read the police reports. I read some of the things that they had said. I watched their behaviour in interviews. I looked at the people they had employed - extradition lawyers, lawyers who are experts in libel (the most feared apparently). Detectives who are not necessarily experts in missing children cases but know about money laundering. Spin doctors/reputation managers and media experts. 8@??)(

And all paid for by the general public who have given generously to a Fund that purports to help find their daughter. Not to mention the millions of tax payers money that must have gone into the case. And it has sold a lot of newspapers and filled a lot of news programmes. 8@??)(

And still - the whereabouts of Madeleine is apparently just as much a mystery as the day she disappeared. Well, SOMEONE knows, obviously. But who can those people be?

 8@??)(


Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Redblossom on October 30, 2013, 01:39:25 PM
usual mud slinging rubbish

How disingenuous a reply to someone who is explaining their views and reasons.......you should be thanking them instead for their honesty.......even if you disagree with their points of view
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Jazzy on October 30, 2013, 03:06:56 PM
Well I think it is about time they had a taste of their own medicine. They have been mighty active sueing everyone who disagrees with their abduction theory. Despite the fact that there is no evidence for it. And there isn't - the shutters were not found to be broken. They give differing accounts of their actions on the evening Madeleine disappeared. They allowed everyone to contaminate what they knew was a scene of crime (now, how did they KNOW that, I wonder, surely it was simply a place that a child had disappeared from.....).

In any case of a missing child, the last people who saw the child always have to be ruled out completely as suspects. That is completely normal - the McCanns know this. As doctors they would have more knowledge of child protection issues than the average person, I would think.

God only knows how their other children will ever get their heads around the whole fiasco.

The McCanns have played the victim role for a very long time. What is that expression - chutzpah. I happen to believe it is quite apt.

And yes, my opinion on this case has done a 360 degree turn. I had enormous sympathy for them at the time and felt that they took a lot of flak about their babysitting arrangement which were not that different to the type of baby listening service that hotels and resort sometimes offer. So I genuinely felt for them.

Then I read a bit more about the case. I watched them in interviews. I read the police reports. I read some of the things that they had said. I watched their behaviour in interviews. I looked at the people they had employed - extradition lawyers, lawyers who are experts in libel (the most feared apparently). Detectives who are not necessarily experts in missing children cases but know about money laundering. Spin doctors/reputation managers and media experts.

And all paid for by the general public who have given generously to a Fund that purports to help find their daughter. Not to mention the millions of tax payers money that must have gone into the case. And it has sold a lot of newspapers and filled a lot of news programmes.

And still - the whereabouts of Madeleine is apparently just as much a mystery as the day she disappeared. Well, SOMEONE knows, o]viously. But who can those people be?

Whoever took her is the short answer.

A taste of their own medicine? Protecting themselves from libel?

The Mccanns, their missing child included are the victims.

They haven't behaved as you would like? You think the people they have employed, transparently, in the full gaze of the media and the public were employed to help them cover up? They have hidden their "crime" in full view, aided by an army of money launderers?

All paid for by a fund designed to help them and their daughter. They also pay taxes, as do I and I am glad my taxes are being used to help find a missing child.

The whereabouts of their missing daughter is unknown, that's true, for the moment, hopefully the new investigations will unearth some answers.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 30, 2013, 03:09:34 PM
Whoever took her is the short answer.

A taste of their own medicine? Protecting themselves from libel?

The Mccanns, their missing child included are the victims.

They haven't behaved as you would like? You think the people they have employed, transparently, in the full gaze of the media and the public were employed to help them cover up? They have hidden their "crime" in full view, aided by an army of money launderers?

All paid for by a fund designed to help them and their daughter. They also pay taxes, as do I and I am glad my taxes are being used to help find a missing child.

The whereabouts of their missing daughter is unknown, that's true, for the moment, hopefully the new investigations will unearth some answers.

 'unearth'   

Quite.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Jazzy on October 30, 2013, 03:16:19 PM
'unearth'   

Quite.

For the sake of a missing child, I hope not.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: ferryman on October 30, 2013, 05:17:10 PM
... because we respect the McCanns as people and have no intention of harming them for sake of it,’ he said.

(Oliveria Santos)

Let us hope that is a statement of conviction.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: imustpointout on October 30, 2013, 05:47:41 PM
Whoever took her is the short answer.

A taste of their own medicine? Protecting themselves from libel?

The Mccanns, their missing child included are the victims.

They haven't behaved as you would like? You think the people they have employed, transparently, in the full gaze of the media and the public were employed to help them cover up? They have hidden their "crime" in full view, aided by an army of money launderers?

All paid for by a fund designed to help them and their daughter. They also pay taxes, as do I and I am glad my taxes are being used to help find a missing child.

The whereabouts of their missing daughter is unknown, that's true, for the moment, hopefully the new investigations will unearth some answers.

"hopefully the new investigations will unearth some answers."

quite

(did you notice what i did then - I used the words in context)
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Rachel Granada on October 31, 2013, 09:15:15 AM
The low level of your argumentation and the high level of your libelous comments shows clearly the poor defense you can offer to those you so fiercely want to clear.

Can you point out where I have made libellous comments, Luz?  I can only see the truth.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 31, 2013, 10:17:31 AM
But who can those people be?
Just ordinary people like you and me. The trial is exemplary on that topic, actually the accusation is... ordinary. Dra Duarte is absolutely convinced of the legitimacy of the complaint. The amount of damages is unprecedented though..and it's not claimed to be for the Fund but for the family, i.e selfless.
I've pmed you a link.
Title: Re: Irish Daily Mail suggests McCanns could face court over suppressed Report!
Post by: Eleanor on October 31, 2013, 10:34:21 AM

Personally, I hope The McCanns do keep whatever they win.  But I don't suppose that they will.