McCanns could face court over report
by Gerard Couzens
THE parents of Madeleine McCann faced further pressure yesterday after ex-police chief Goncalo Amaral hinted he may fight them in court over a key report they allegedly held back.
Gerry and Kate McCann were accused at the weekend of sidelining the 2008 report by former MI5 investigators they hired after it pinpointed ‘anomalies’ in statements they and their friends made.
The result was that e-fits of the prime suspect in Madeleine McCann’s abduction – hidden for five years in the unpublished report – were only made public this month during a new Met Police appeal.
The report said Irish holidaymaker Martin Smith’s sighting of a man carrying a girl in pyjamas near the McCann’s Algarve holiday apartment was ‘credible evidence’ which had been ‘neglected for too long.’
Actually,
is Martin Smith's evidence credible?
According to the best informamtion we have, he contacted Portuguese police with news of his sighting on 16 May 2007, after he had been back in Ireland for days.
That was 3 days after Tanner had (wrongly) been adamant that Murat was the man she said she'd seen on 3 May - and 1-2 days after Rachael Oldfield, Fiona Payne and Dr Matthew Oldfield claimed they'd sen Murat on the night of 3 May - a claim they unanimously jettisoned nine months later. And, of course, 2 days after Murat was made n arguido (14 May).
Why the heck did he wait for 13 days?
And why did he, when he described the person he said he saw, repeat almost exactly Jane Tanner's description?
'Not a tourist'
'Dark jacket'
'Light trousers'
'5' 10" tall'...
...and so on.
And why was he so sure that his 'sighting' was not of his very good acquaintance ("I had been to Praia da Luz many times and met Murat several times") Robert Murat?
At the time of this claimed sighting, it was dark. None of the Smiths can remember a thing about his face.
Yet, four months later, Smith said he was '60% to 80%' sure - by the way he walked and held his child - that he had seen Gerry McCann! - even though Gerry McCann was clearly at the Ocean Club at this time.
His daughter even professed to be (60%) 'sure' that the child carried by this man was Madeleine McCann. On what basis?
Now it seems he has changed his mind again and accepts it was NOT Gerry McCann.
And, courtesy of Crimewatch, DCI Redwood says the Smiths have drawn up TWO different efits - looking like completey different blokes.
The whole tale of Martin Smith's sighting is a load of hogwash.
The question now is: why is Redwood and why are the McCanns making such a big deal of this? - especially after apparently hiding these efits for 5 years?