UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Alleged Miscarriages of Justice => Jeremy Bamber and the callous murder of his father, mother, sister and twin nephews. Case effectively CLOSED by CCRC on basis of NO APPEAL REFERRAL. => Topic started by: Holly Goodhead on August 31, 2015, 08:57:29 PM

Title: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 31, 2015, 08:57:29 PM
Conventional serological analysis

"Analysis of the proteins, enzymes, and antigens present in the blood. These substances are more susceptible to degradation than DNA and this type of testing usually requires a "large" sample (quarter size) in good condition for optimal results. This type of testing is rarely statistically individualizing".

"Blood evidence must never be exposed to excessive heat or humidity. If possible, the bloodstained evidence should be refrigerated until it can be transported to the crime lab. The evidence should also be taken to the lab as soon as possible".

The blood in the silencer was analysed using conventional serological analysis producing the following results:

                             ABO                    PGM                  EAP                  AK                  Hp

Nevill Bamber         O                        PGM1+               EAP BA            AK1                 Hp2-1
June Bamber          A                         PGM1+               EAP BA            AK2-1              Hp2-1
Daniel Caffell          O                        PGM2+1+           EAP B              AK1                 Hp2
Nicholas Caffell       O                        PGM2+1+           EAP B              AK1                 Hp2
Sheila Caffell          A                         PGM1+               EAP BA            AK1                 Hp2-1

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Blood In Silencer      A                        Nil                     EAP BA              AK1                Hp2-1
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Robert Boutflour       A                        PGM1+               EAP BA              AK1               Hp2-1

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ABO = Blood Group System

PGM = Phosphoglucomutase (Enzyme) Breaks down quickly outside the body hence blood in silencer was unable to produce a reading

EAP = Erythrocyte Acid Phosphatase (Enzyme)

AK = Adenylate Kinase (Enzyme)

HP = Haptoglobin (Protein)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Many other exhibits were also analysed using conventional serological analysis:

- Carpet samples from main bedroom
- Wallpaper from wall near kitchen
- Rifle
- Blue socks
- NB's car seat
- JB's dressing gown
- JB's jacket

Blood on the above items was found to be either human in origin or only capable of limited results. The only exhibit capable of full serological analysis as per the table above was the silencer.  A possible explanation for this is that EP deliberately contaminated the silencer with SC's blood from her sample handed to EP by the pathologist and stored in EP's soc fridge at Chelmsford police station.  This would ensure good quality blood in prime condition as it was stored at the correct temperature and in sufficient quantity. 

If heat has the potential to destroy blood evidence how did the blood 'found' in the silencer produce full serological results as per the table above? 

I have previously posted up a youtube clip showing a silencer heating up to 390F after 30 rounds being fired through it but the bullets used were clearly more powerful than the bullets used at WHF based on the size of the magazine. 

The barrel of the rifle would also heat up but not as much as the silencer due to the hot gasses getting trapped in the silencer's expansion chamber and baffles. The CoA doc states after firing 25 rounds through the silencer it heated up to 24.5C/76.1F. The reason for this test was to establish how quickly the blood dried and whether it was possible for June's blood to dry and overlay NB's blood or vice-versa (irrelevant to this thread but just explaining the reason for the temp test).  The ITV documentary aired around March/April 2012 shows the rifle/silencer heated up after firing but no actual temperature was given.  It was shown to be insufficient to cause the burn marks to NB's back.  In CAL's book Dr V states that NB would have been mindful of not grabbing the rifle as it would be hot after firing and yet 24.5C would not be capable of causing any sort of skin burn?  Dr V also states in his interview with CAL that he is now of the opinion that the burn marks on NB's back were caused by the rifle.  Malcolm Fletcher states that he fired the rifle "loads of times" and grabbed the barrel and silencer but it would only warm up and wasn't hot enough to burn skin. 

John Hayward the biologist who carried out the blood analysis left FSS shortly after the murders at WHF and was in private practice at the time of trial.  His son David Hayward now runs the practice:

http://www.haywardforensics.co.uk/client-resources/professional-profiles/

I need to establish whether the blood 'found' in the silencer was capable of withstanding the heat from the silencer after firing AND ambient temperature over many days until it was analysed by FSS and still capable of producing the above results.

 &%+((£

...Hello David... 8**8:/:



Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Myster on August 31, 2015, 09:13:08 PM
Should that not be "Hello Sailor!"  8**8:/: ... and who's David, anyway!!!?  &%+((£
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 31, 2015, 09:31:55 PM
Should that not be "Hello Sailor!"  8**8:/: ... and who's David, anyway!!!?  &%+((£

David son of John Hayward who now runs Hayward associates:

http://www.haywardforensics.co.uk/client-resources/professional-profiles/
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Myster on August 31, 2015, 09:33:04 PM
You trying to wangle some free professional advice?
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 01, 2015, 08:31:53 AM
You trying to wangle some free professional advice?

I wish... but no if the commercial rate isn't applied the expert witness could be seen as bias and lack credibility in court. 
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 05, 2017, 09:07:55 PM
I've recently stumbled across the attached doc.  It contains info from a Dr Harris at the lab in Hunts who was tasked with carrying out tests in connection with JB's first appeal hearing in 1989.  The tests involve Dr Harris placing blood inside a silencer and firing the rifle 25 x's to check what effect, if any, this had on blood test results.  According to Dr Harris the tests showed the blood was not adversely affected (hope I've got my effects/affects the right way round  8)><() and was still able to consistently produce reliable test results. 

I understand the reason the rifle was fired 25 x's is that in 1988 JB's defence still considered the blood flake was heterogeneous representing an intimate mix of NB and June's blood from gsw's sustained at any stage.  I do not believe a heterogeneous blood flake is possible in this case.  Anyway that's by the by the whole point is that according to Dr Harris the blood withstood repeated firing from the rifle and was still capable of producing reliable blood test results.

Here a renowned US pathologist, Dr Di Maio, who specialises in gsw's wrote in a book he authored:

Blood may be detected in the barrel even after the weapon has been
discharged. In a study of 25 revolvers and 36 pistols, in 40% of revolvers and
in 42% of pistols, blood was detected after one test firing.  More remarkable
was the fact that blood was still detected in 16% of revolvers and 25% of
pistols after a second shot was fired.


Based on the above detecting blood in the barrel seems to diminish after every discharge and yet Dr Harris above said not only was he able to detect blood but the blood test results were not compromised after the rifle had been discharged 25 x's.  I appreciate the above is not like-for-like eg the above uses unsilenced handguns but surely it is the effect (or affect) of the discharge in terms of propellant and primer that would adversely effect (or affect) the blood? 

I think this is one for Scipio. 

[attachment deleted by admin]
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: scipio_usmc on March 06, 2017, 06:07:21 AM

If heat has the potential to destroy blood evidence how did the blood 'found' in the silencer produce full serological results as per the table above? 

Just because it has the potential to damage blood evidence doesn't mean it will. By definition potential means possible.

They obtained results in other moderators as well not just the one connected to this case.  Thus is it documented that blood can survive in a moderator. 

We had this same discussion several times in the past.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: scipio_usmc on March 06, 2017, 06:23:55 AM
I've recently stumbled across the attached doc.  It contains info from a Dr Harris at the lab in Hunts who was tasked with carrying out tests in connection with JB's first appeal hearing in 1989.  The tests involve Dr Harris placing blood inside a silencer and firing the rifle 25 x's to check what effect, if any, this had on blood test results.  According to Dr Harris the tests showed the blood was not adversely affected (hope I've got my effects/affects the right way round  8)><() and was still able to consistently produce reliable test results. 

I understand the reason the rifle was fired 25 x's is that in 1988 JB's defence still considered the blood flake was heterogeneous representing an intimate mix of NB and June's blood from gsw's sustained at any stage.  I do not believe a heterogeneous blood flake is possible in this case.  Anyway that's by the by the whole point is that according to Dr Harris the blood withstood repeated firing from the rifle and was still capable of producing reliable blood test results.

Here a renowned US pathologist, Dr Di Maio, who specialises in gsw's wrote in a book he authored:

Blood may be detected in the barrel even after the weapon has been
discharged. In a study of 25 revolvers and 36 pistols, in 40% of revolvers and
in 42% of pistols, blood was detected after one test firing.  More remarkable
was the fact that blood was still detected in 16% of revolvers and 25% of
pistols after a second shot was fired.


Based on the above detecting blood in the barrel seems to diminish after every discharge and yet Dr Harris above said not only was he able to detect blood but the blood test results were not compromised after the rifle had been discharged 25 x's.  I appreciate the above is not like-for-like eg the above uses unsilenced handguns but surely it is the effect (or affect) of the discharge in terms of propellant and primer that would adversely effect (or affect) the blood? 

I think this is one for Scipio.

You left out the part where there was still blood detected even after 4 plus shots fired.  In any event that refers to rifled barrels. A bullet touches the side of the rifled barrel and thus will take some of the blood that touches the bullet with it. In particular the blood gets in the rifling and the bullet is scored by that rifling thus deposiing some of the blood on the bullet.

We are talking about a moderator where the bullet doesn't touch the sides.  Moreover, the blood was on the front of the baffles so not anywhere near the path of the bullet and the GSR would hit the back not front of the plates if it did hit the plates.

In any event the contact shot to Sheila was the last shot fired, that's the shot that killed her. So even if we were talking about a gun barrel rather than moderator it makes no difference no shots were fired after that to clear it out. 

If it were a rifle barrel we are discussing then in that case the more shots fired after June was killed the less likely her blood still would have remained inside even if she had suffered a contact shot.  This would then tend to undermine the defense supposition the blood was June's.  But blood has still been found after more than 4 shots so you never know less likely doesn't mean impossible.

You want absolutes but there are few of those.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Myster on March 06, 2017, 06:25:37 AM
I think this is one for Scipio.

.... but surely it is the effect (n) of the discharge in terms of propellant and primer that would adversely affect (v) the blood? (or would have an adverse effect (n) on the blood)

... and Emily Brewster.
  https://www.merriam-webster.com/video/affect-vs-effect (https://www.merriam-webster.com/video/affect-vs-effect)

Merriam-Webster's other vids are informative too... https://www.merriam-webster.com/video/see-all (https://www.merriam-webster.com/video/see-all)
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: adam on March 06, 2017, 06:51:21 AM
Both guilters & supporters agree it was human blood in the silencer. There was no blood or paint at the end of the rifle which means the silencer was on the rifle. This rules out Sheila as she would not bother to put on the silencer if Nevill was already awake. Assuming she knew how to.

Sheila would also not bother putting the silencer away. In a box at the back of the  gun cupboard. One of Sheila's shots being a contact shot and the evidence stating it was her blood in the silencer makes it impossible for her to have done this anyway.

The evidence that it is Sheila's blood shows Bamber is guilty. Although there have been claims that two silencers were used to frame Bamber, that Stan Jones took Sheila's blood to frame Bamber & that RB found out he had a similar blood type to Sheila & shot himself with the silencer on.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: John on March 06, 2017, 03:39:49 PM
Both guilters & supporters agree it was human blood in the silencer. There was no blood or paint at the end of the rifle which means the silencer was on the rifle. This rules out Sheila as she would not bother to put on the silencer if Nevill was already awake. Assuming she knew how to.

Sheila would also not bother putting the silencer away. In a box at the back of the  gun cupboard. One of Sheila's shots being a contact shot and the evidence stating it was her blood in the silencer makes it impossible for her to have done this anyway.

The evidence that it is Sheila's blood shows Bamber is guilty. Although there have been claims that two silencers were used to frame Bamber, that Stan Jones took Sheila's blood to frame Bamber & that RB found out he had a similar blood type to Sheila & shot himself with the silencer on.

I think we can put Tesko's framed rubbish safety to bed.   He has a personal vendetta with the police over what happened to him in his youth so any view he has is tainted by that experience.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 08, 2017, 04:06:00 AM
Both guilters & supporters agree it was human blood in the silencer. There was no blood or paint at the end of the rifle which means the silencer was on the rifle. This rules out Sheila as she would not bother to put on the silencer if Nevill was already awake. Assuming she knew how to.

Sheila would also not bother putting the silencer away. In a box at the back of the  gun cupboard. One of Sheila's shots being a contact shot and the evidence stating it was her blood in the silencer makes it impossible for her to have done this anyway.

The evidence that it is Sheila's blood shows Bamber is guilty. Although there have been claims that two silencers were used to frame Bamber, that Stan Jones took Sheila's blood to frame Bamber & that RB found out he had a similar blood type to Sheila & shot himself with the silencer on.

I don't believe the silencer evidence but there's some crazy stuff that surrounds it:

AH in CTSB alludes to animal blood. 

Lol
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 08, 2017, 04:27:42 AM
.... but surely it is the effect (n) of the discharge in terms of propellant and primer that would adversely affect (v) the blood? (or would have an adverse effect (n) on the blood)

... and Emily Brewster.
  https://www.merriam-webster.com/video/affect-vs-effect (https://www.merriam-webster.com/video/affect-vs-effect)

Merriam-Webster's other vids are informative too... https://www.merriam-webster.com/video/see-all (https://www.merriam-webster.com/video/see-all)

Thanks.  I think I need to pm you for some private tuition. 
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 08, 2017, 05:02:48 AM
You left out the part where there was still blood detected even after 4 plus shots fired.  In any event that refers to rifled barrels. A bullet touches the side of the rifled barrel and thus will take some of the blood that touches the bullet with it. In particular the blood gets in the rifling and the bullet is scored by that rifling thus deposiing some of the blood on the bullet.

We are talking about a moderator where the bullet doesn't touch the sides.  Moreover, the blood was on the front of the baffles so not anywhere near the path of the bullet and the GSR would hit the back not front of the plates if it did hit the plates.

In any event the contact shot to Sheila was the last shot fired, that's the shot that killed her. So even if we were talking about a gun barrel rather than moderator it makes no difference no shots were fired after that to clear it out. 

If it were a rifle barrel we are discussing then in that case the more shots fired after June was killed the less likely her blood still would have remained inside even if she had suffered a contact shot.  This would then tend to undermine the defense supposition the blood was June's.  But blood has still been found after more than 4 shots so you never know less likely doesn't mean impossible.

You want absolutes but there are few of those.

After 4 plus shots?  I've arrived at 3 shots?  We are talking about the excerpt from Dr DiMaio above?

But surely it is the hot discharge gases that affect any blood drawn into a barrel/silencer rather than the exiting of subsequent bullets per se?  I'm thinking of the attached GIF.  David1819 thinks any blood drawn in remains protected as per attached image which doesn't seem to reconcile with GIF?

Yes I appreciate Dr Harris' test of 25 x discharges bears no resemblance to SC's contact shot but I'm questioning the validity of the test which MIGHT indicate something awry at lab.  When I consider the % reductions in Dr DiMaio's test after 3/4 shots it seems unlikely any blood would be detected after 25 shots.  Yet Dr Harris is saying not only did he detect blood after 25 shots but the integrity of the blood was uncompromised in terms of typing and I have a big question mark about this.

I have had communication with arguably the world's expert on blood serology:

Sorry I have not responded earlier, but things have been very busy here.  The amount of stain used seems about right to get a result. The stability of the genetic markers that were conducted on the1/4 inch flake of blood are all well within the expected results time frame.  ABO is good for about two years at ambient temperatures and is the longest for the series of five markers you listed.  Haptoglobin and PGM would be the next at about a year, and AK & EAP are about six months.  This is, of course, is for dried stains that have not been environmentally insulted by temperature or humidity.  XXXX would not have the capability of a fingerprint chamber or to test fire a weapon at our facility.

Email forwarded to Myster for verification. 

[attachment deleted by admin]
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Myster on March 08, 2017, 05:45:21 AM
Are you filling up my inbox again!!  Yes, of course the letter is genuine, we're not that sceptical, Holly!
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Myster on March 08, 2017, 05:53:05 AM
Thanks.  I think I need to pm you for some private tuition.
Bluestockings Emily and Kory whipped me into submission and taught me everything I know.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: adam on March 08, 2017, 08:13:49 AM
I think we can put Tesko's framed rubbish safety to bed.   He has a personal vendetta with the police over what happened to him in his youth so any view he has is tainted by that experience.

Everyone has different reasons for supporting Bamber.

Mike said he shared a prison cell with him for a few hours once & may also have a grudge against the police.

Lookout said she had a 'gut feeling' in 1986 & says 'hell would freeze over' before she accepted the mountain of incriminating forensic and circumstantial evidence.

Other posters watched the 'Crimes that shook Britain' video & either joined the (at the time) pro Bamber  Blue forum or started sending letters to him. Or both.

Nugs thinks outside the box and suggests amazing things no one else has ever thought of while other posters simply didn't like Julie's court outfit.

Alias says Bamber would not have shot Sheila twice, even if it meant Sheila lived while Grahame returned to the Blue forum for a short period saying the police framed Bamber.

Only David has changed stance to innocent after his 'forensic evidence breakthrough' which is apparently so strong it can't be revealed as it would give 'the crown more time to prepare'.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: scipio_usmc on March 08, 2017, 04:51:44 PM
After 4 plus shots?  I've arrived at 3 shots?  We are talking about the excerpt from Dr DiMaio above?

But surely it is the hot discharge gases that affect any blood drawn into a barrel/silencer rather than the exiting of subsequent bullets per se?  I'm thinking of the attached GIF.  David1819 thinks any blood drawn in remains protected as per attached image which doesn't seem to reconcile with GIF?

Yes I appreciate Dr Harris' test of 25 x discharges bears no resemblance to SC's contact shot but I'm questioning the validity of the test which MIGHT indicate something awry at lab.  When I consider the % reductions in Dr DiMaio's test after 3/4 shots it seems unlikely any blood would be detected after 25 shots.  Yet Dr Harris is saying not only did he detect blood after 25 shots but the integrity of the blood was uncompromised in terms of typing and I have a big question mark about this.

I have had communication with arguably the world's expert on blood serology:

Sorry I have not responded earlier, but things have been very busy here.  The amount of stain used seems about right to get a result. The stability of the genetic markers that were conducted on the1/4 inch flake of blood are all well within the expected results time frame.  ABO is good for about two years at ambient temperatures and is the longest for the series of five markers you listed.  Haptoglobin and PGM would be the next at about a year, and AK & EAP are about six months.  This is, of course, is for dried stains that have not been environmentally insulted by temperature or humidity.  XXXX would not have the capability of a fingerprint chamber or to test fire a weapon at our facility.

Email forwarded to Myster for verification.

Dr. Harris' test was in a moderator not a rifle barrel so is not the same test you are referring to.

The heat wasn't even sufficient to rapidly dry the blood inside the moderator so was not high enough to damage the blood to prevent a reading of same.



 

Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 08, 2017, 06:08:59 PM
Quote from: Myster link=topic=6585http://miscarriageofjustice.co/Smileys/custom/c032.gif.msg388004#msg388004 date=1488952385
Bluestockings Emily and Kory whipped me into submission and taught me everything I know.

Maybe time to broaden your horizons; move out of your comfort zone?  8)-)))
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 08, 2017, 06:36:41 PM
Dr. Harris' test was in a moderator not a rifle barrel so is not the same test you are referring to.

The heat wasn't even sufficient to rapidly dry the blood inside the moderator so was not high enough to damage the blood to prevent a reading of same.

Yes I said in post #5 the tests carried out by Dr's Harris and DiMaio are not on a like-for-like basis:

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6585.msg387638#msg387638 

The tests carried out by Dr Harris to determine the integrity of the blood flake after 25 x discharges, and the tests carried out by John Hayward to determine the affect of temperature and drying on the blood flake were both undertaken by the FSS. 

An insepection of the silencer by forensic scientist (biologist) appointed by the defence, Mark Webster, identified soot in the silencer:

A: Yes.  I mentioned soot because when I examined the sound moderator, I did find flakes of soot inside the moderator.  (@ point 345 - see attached).
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: John on March 08, 2017, 06:40:18 PM
I don't believe the silencer evidence but there's some crazy stuff that surrounds it:

AH in CTSB alludes to animal blood. 

Lol

This has been well covered previously.  There was an enzyme in the blood which is only attributable to humans.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 08, 2017, 06:54:53 PM
This has been well covered previously.  There was an enzyme in the blood which is only attributable to humans.

Yes.  No doubt whatsoever the blood identified within the silencer was human in origin.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: scipio_usmc on March 09, 2017, 06:33:08 PM
Yes I said in post #5 the tests carried out by Dr's Harris and DiMaio are not on a like-for-like basis:

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6585.msg387638#msg387638 

The tests carried out by Dr Harris to determine the integrity of the blood flake after 25 x discharges, and the tests carried out by John Hayward to determine the affect of temperature and drying on the blood flake were both undertaken by the FSS. 

An insepection of the silencer by forensic scientist (biologist) appointed by the defence, Mark Webster, identified soot in the silencer:

A: Yes.  I mentioned soot because when I examined the sound moderator, I did find flakes of soot inside the moderator.  (@ point 345 - see attached).

It's hardly a surprise that soot would be found inside. Not all the GSR is expelled from a moderator or gun barrel. That is why they must be cleaned periodically.

That doesn't speak to your question though of whether the heat would damage the blood to the point where it could not be successfully tested.  Both in tests and in examinations from real life incidents they have successfully tested blood.  That is why the defense did not try contesting such at trial.  They had no way to do so without experts willing to refute the possibility. 

On appeal they found a guy who tossed out the silly speculation that maybe the prosecution experts mistook a flake of soot for a flake of blood.  Speculation like that is meaningless to appeal courts so it went nowhere but the court even criticized him for suggesting it.

"Firstly, there is Mr Webster's suggestion that Mr Hayward might have mistaken a flake of soot which was blood stained for a flake of dried blood. Mr Hayward had given evidence at trial of a close visual examination of the flake. He was an experienced forensic scientist. If he had made the sort of mistake suggested by Mr Webster, it must have represented a significant failing in the performance of his duties in what was clearly a highly important case. There was no suggestion, then or now, that Mr Hayward was other than a competent and careful forensic scientist. Before such a suggestion was made by another forensic scientist, one would expect to see some evidential basis for that suggestion. There was absolutely none. That fact that soot was found on the baffles did not begin to suggest that Mr Hayward would have made the sort of error suggested."
 
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 09, 2017, 09:52:37 PM
It's hardly a surprise that soot would be found inside. Not all the GSR is expelled from a moderator or gun barrel. That is why they must be cleaned periodically.

That doesn't speak to your question though of whether the heat would damage the blood to the point where it could not be successfully tested.  Both in tests and in examinations from real life incidents they have successfully tested blood.  That is why the defense did not try contesting such at trial.  They had no way to do so without experts willing to refute the possibility. 

On appeal they found a guy who tossed out the silly speculation that maybe the prosecution experts mistook a flake of soot for a flake of blood.  Speculation like that is meaningless to appeal courts so it went nowhere but the court even criticized him for suggesting it.

"Firstly, there is Mr Webster's suggestion that Mr Hayward might have mistaken a flake of soot which was blood stained for a flake of dried blood. Mr Hayward had given evidence at trial of a close visual examination of the flake. He was an experienced forensic scientist. If he had made the sort of mistake suggested by Mr Webster, it must have represented a significant failing in the performance of his duties in what was clearly a highly important case. There was no suggestion, then or now, that Mr Hayward was other than a competent and careful forensic scientist. Before such a suggestion was made by another forensic scientist, one would expect to see some evidential basis for that suggestion. There was absolutely none. That fact that soot was found on the baffles did not begin to suggest that Mr Hayward would have made the sort of error suggested."
 

I agree it is hardly surprising soot was found inside the silencer, but soot is caused by the process of burning something and blood doesn't take kindly to a) the heat/temperature necessary for something to burn and b) being burned.

In JB's case tests have not been carried out to determine whether or not the blood flake underpinning JB's conviction was capable of withstanding the environments from SC's contact wound, which the prosecution claim resulted in draw-back, through to analysis of the blood flake in the lab on 12th Sept 1985.  It is necessary to consider the accumulative effect:

- draw-back
- time spent at ambient temp
- humidity in cyanoacrylate fuming chamber 

The fact the lab/Dr Harris claims to have placed blood in the rifle and fired it 25 x's and was still able to successfully remove the blood and type it is imo stretching credulity.  I appreciate this test is largely irrelevant based on SC's contact wound but imo it shows that something MIGHT have gone awry at the lab.   

The fact that JB's defence haven't explored the above or undertaken tests means squat other than potentially they were bunch of incompetent fools. 

I agree Mark Webster's claims that the flake of blood supposedly identified in the silencer was a flake of soot spattered with blood doesn't make any sense.

The only way to resolve is to arrange for tests which are due to commence shortly:

"Thank you for your email. I have always found this case very interesting. As I'm sure you have seen on my out of office reply, I am away from work on maternity leave at the moment. I am not back until mid-March so I would not be able to work on any specifics until then.

I have taken on projects of this type in the past but as I work part time now I would need to speak to some colleagues before agreeing to any work. We do have a cyanoacrylate fuming chamber and some kind of firearms licence but I'm not sure what It covers as it may only be for our flare gun.

Maybe we could speak in the new year to discuss your requirements further.

Best wishes"


Dr XXXX is a Lecturer in Forensic Science. She studied for her first degree in Biochemistry at the University of XXXX before completing an MSc in Biomolecular Archaeology jointly run by XXXX and the University of XXXX.  She then moved to the University of XXXX to complete her PhD under the supervision of Professor XXXX, where she stayed to work as a Post-Doctoral Research Associate, before taking up her position at XXXX.

XXXX is a member of the Forensic Science Society, the International Society of Forensic Genetics and the British Association for Human Identification.

Could it be that a young mother, 20/30 something, female scientist will finally resolve the WHF murders? 

Copy of email sent to Myster for verification. 
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: scipio_usmc on March 09, 2017, 10:34:36 PM
I agree it is hardly surprising soot was found inside the silencer, but soot is caused by the process of burning something and blood doesn't take kindly to a) the heat/temperature necessary for something to burn and b) being burned.

In JB's case tests have not been carried out to determine whether or not the blood flake underpinning JB's conviction was capable of withstanding the environments from SC's contact wound, which the prosecution claim resulted in draw-back, through to analysis of the blood flake in the lab on 12th Sept 1985.  It is necessary to consider the accumulative effect:

- draw-back
- time spent at ambient temp
- humidity in cyanoacrylate fuming chamber 

The fact the lab/Dr Harris claims to have placed blood in the rifle and fired it 25 x's and was still able to successfully remove the blood and type it is imo stretching credulity.  I appreciate this test is largely irrelevant based on SC's contact wound but imo it shows that something MIGHT have gone awry at the lab.   

The fact that JB's defence haven't explored the above or undertaken tests means squat other than potentially they were bunch of incompetent fools. 

I agree Mark Webster's claims that the flake of blood supposedly identified in the silencer was a flake of soot spattered with blood doesn't make any sense.

The only way to resolve is to arrange for tests which are due to commence shortly:

"Thank you for your email. I have always found this case very interesting. As I'm sure you have seen on my out of office reply, I am away from work on maternity leave at the moment. I am not back until mid-March so I would not be able to work on any specifics until then.

I have taken on projects of this type in the past but as I work part time now I would need to speak to some colleagues before agreeing to any work. We do have a cyanoacrylate fuming chamber and some kind of firearms licence but I'm not sure what It covers as it may only be for our flare gun.

Maybe we could speak in the new year to discuss your requirements further.

Best wishes"


Dr XXXX is a Lecturer in Forensic Science. She studied for her first degree in Biochemistry at the University of XXXX before completing an MSc in Biomolecular Archaeology jointly run by XXXX and the University of XXXX.  She then moved to the University of XXXX to complete her PhD under the supervision of Professor XXXX, where she stayed to work as a Post-Doctoral Research Associate, before taking up her position at XXXX.

XXXX is a member of the Forensic Science Society, the International Society of Forensic Genetics and the British Association for Human Identification.

Could it be that a young mother, 20/30 something, female scientist will finally resolve the WHF murders? 

Copy of email sent to Myster for verification.

The burning that takes place is powder inside of a cartridge case burns.  That causes the bullet to leave the case and launch.  Some of the unburned particulate is forced through the barrel. 

Long ago it was established that blood that enters via drawback is able to be typed even after subsequent shots are fired.

We are not talking about any subsequent shots being fired here though.  The final shot exited the weapon, entered sheila and caused blood to get inside. There were no subsequent shots.   

Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 09, 2017, 11:50:26 PM
The burning that takes place is powder inside of a cartridge case burns.  That causes the bullet to leave the case and launch.  Some of the unburned particulate is forced through the barrel. 

Long ago it was established that blood that enters via drawback is able to be typed even after subsequent shots are fired.

We are not talking about any subsequent shots being fired here though.  The final shot exited the weapon, entered sheila and caused blood to get inside. There were no subsequent shots.   

Yes I appreciate how a cartridge/bullet is fired (image below) but hot discharge gases follow the bullet down the barrel and silencer where they exit the muzzle into the atmosphere (as per gif).  As you know the purpose of a silencer is to reduce the sound of the hot gases exiting the muzzle into the atmosphere by allowing the gases to expand in an expansion chamber and release slowly through a series of baffle plates.

It isn't just a case of considering the affect of blood entering the silencer and the hot discharge gases simultaneously exiting and what exactly happens when these Newtonian and non-Newtonian fluids collide but also the time spent at ambient temperature and time spent in the cyanoacrylate fuming chamber.  The accumulative effect needs considering. 

I know we're not talking about any subsequent shots with SC's contact wound/draw-back but as you know at trial and JB's appeals: 1989 and 2002 lawyers went down the heterogeneous route ie the blood flake represented an intimate mix of NB and June's blood, not something I have ever subscribed to.  JB's lawyers at trial claimed the heterogeneous flake could have come about at any time during the shootings.  As a result for the 1989 appeal, lawyers arranged for Dr Harris at FSS Hunts to carry out tests by placing blood in the silencer and firing the rifle 25 x's followed by removing the blood and typing it which he claims produced consistent results which imo is stretching credulity.  This experiment doesn't relate to draw-back but imo it might show something was awry at the lab.   


[attachment deleted by admin]
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: scipio_usmc on March 10, 2017, 02:54:27 AM
Yes I appreciate how a cartridge/bullet is fired (image below) but hot discharge gases follow the bullet down the barrel and silencer where they exit the muzzle into the atmosphere (as per gif).  As you know the purpose of a silencer is to reduce the sound of the hot gases exiting the muzzle into the atmosphere by allowing the gases to expand in an expansion chamber and release slowly through a series of baffle plates.

It isn't just a case of considering the affect of blood entering the silencer and the hot discharge gases simultaneously exiting and what exactly happens when these Newtonian and non-Newtonian fluids collide but also the time spent at ambient temperature and time spent in the cyanoacrylate fuming chamber.  The accumulative effect needs considering. 

I know we're not talking about any subsequent shots with SC's contact wound/draw-back but as you know at trial and JB's appeals: 1989 and 2002 lawyers went down the heterogeneous route ie the blood flake represented an intimate mix of NB and June's blood, not something I have ever subscribed to.  JB's lawyers at trial claimed the heterogeneous flake could have come about at any time during the shootings.  As a result for the 1989 appeal, lawyers arranged for Dr Harris at FSS Hunts to carry out tests by placing blood in the silencer and firing the rifle 25 x's followed by removing the blood and typing it which he claims produced consistent results which imo is stretching credulity.  This experiment doesn't relate to draw-back but imo it might show something was awry at the lab.

The main exit of gasses would go with the bullet and then the blood would be drawn in.

In any event the most hot and sizable flow of gases would be down the middle, that which leaves afterwards will have time to cool and not be as forceful.

Those gases are not hot enough even to destroy blood in a barrel where the gas is actually going across the same exact spot where the blood is while in a moderator the blood was on the other sides of the baffles.

Not just the intensity of heat but the duration in combination is significant in destruction of blood. 

A split second(s) of the heat caused by a firing bullets isn't sufficient to destroy it.  On occasion the impact will be more pronounced than others but it is not enough to in general destroy it.

Given the success in the past of obtaining results under the same conditions or even worse conditions that rules out hoping to establish drawback blood will ALWAYS be damaged to the point of not being able to be successfully tested.  That is what would be necessary in order to establish the blood had to have been planted and can't have gotten there from drawback. That is why the defense has not tried that route. 

You keep saying you want to do testing. How do you propose to prove that the successful results in all past documented instances were faked and in fact it is impossible to obtain a result.  There is no testing capable of refuting all the past instances of success.

In the meantime they know if they do tests they will get successful results in at least some of them because of past results.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 10, 2017, 08:56:15 AM
The main exit of gasses would go with the bullet and then the blood would be drawn in.

In any event the most hot and sizable flow of gases would be down the middle, that which leaves afterwards will have time to cool and not be as forceful.

Those gases are not hot enough even to destroy blood in a barrel where the gas is actually going across the same exact spot where the blood is while in a moderator the blood was on the other sides of the baffles.

Not just the intensity of heat but the duration in combination is significant in destruction of blood. 

A split second(s) of the heat caused by a firing bullets isn't sufficient to destroy it.  On occasion the impact will be more pronounced than others but it is not enough to in general destroy it.

Given the success in the past of obtaining results under the same conditions or even worse conditions that rules out hoping to establish drawback blood will ALWAYS be damaged to the point of not being able to be successfully tested.  That is what would be necessary in order to establish the blood had to have been planted and can't have gotten there from drawback. That is why the defense has not tried that route. 

You keep saying you want to do testing. How do you propose to prove that the successful results in all past documented instances were faked and in fact it is impossible to obtain a result.  There is no testing capable of refuting all the past instances of success.

In the meantime they know if they do tests they will get successful results in at least some of them because of past results.

Do you have any documented cases you can refer us to?  Documented cases where blood has been found in barrels or silencers and subsequently typed using conventional serological analysis of blood?  Not DNA as this is less prone to degrade as a result of environmental insults. 
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 10, 2017, 11:33:01 AM
After 4 plus shots?  I've arrived at 3 shots?  We are talking about the excerpt from Dr DiMaio above?

But surely it is the hot discharge gases that affect any blood drawn into a barrel/silencer rather than the exiting of subsequent bullets per se?  I'm thinking of the attached GIF.  David1819 thinks any blood drawn in remains protected as per attached image which doesn't seem to reconcile with GIF?

Yes I appreciate Dr Harris' test of 25 x discharges bears no resemblance to SC's contact shot but I'm questioning the validity of the test which MIGHT indicate something awry at lab.  When I consider the % reductions in Dr DiMaio's test after 3/4 shots it seems unlikely any blood would be detected after 25 shots.  Yet Dr Harris is saying not only did he detect blood after 25 shots but the integrity of the blood was uncompromised in terms of typing and I have a big question mark about this.

I have had communication with arguably the world's expert on blood serology:

Sorry I have not responded earlier, but things have been very busy here.  The amount of stain used seems about right to get a result. The stability of the genetic markers that were conducted on the1/4 inch flake of blood are all well within the expected results time frame.  ABO is good for about two years at ambient temperatures and is the longest for the series of five markers you listed.  Haptoglobin and PGM would be the next at about a year, and AK & EAP are about six months.  This is, of course, is for dried stains that have not been environmentally insulted by temperature or humidity.  XXXX would not have the capability of a fingerprint chamber or to test fire a weapon at our facility.

Email forwarded to Myster for verification.

Scipio, the US forensic scientist referred to above is arguably the world's expert on blood serology.  He has testified in cases as follows:

COURT PRESENTATIONS

Expert testimony presentations in forensic serology
made in excess of four hundred (400) times in
Superior Courts of the following states:
 

Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Georgia,
Illinois, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, Missouri,
Nebraska, Nevada, New York, Ohio, Oklahoma,
Oregon, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Texas, Utah,
Wisconsin and Washington. 

Superior Courts in California: 

Alameda, Butte, Contra Costa, El Dorado, Fresno,
Humboldt, Kern, Los Angeles,  Orange,  Sacramento, 
San  Bernardino,  San  Diego,  San  Francisco, 
San  Joaquin,  Santa  Clara, Shasta, Solano, Sonoma,
Sutter, Tulare, and Ventura Counties.

He qualified during the 1970's and has been practising since.  When I put to him the environments the blood flake underwent prior to identification and analysis he said:

The amount of stain used seems about right to get a result. The stability of the genetic markers that were conducted on the1/4 inch flake of blood are all well within the expected results time frame.  ABO is good for about two years at ambient temperatures and is the longest for the series of five markers you listed.  Haptoglobin and PGM would be the next at about a year, and AK & EAP are about six months.  This is, of course, is for dried stains that have not been environmentally insulted by temperature or humidity


Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: scipio_usmc on March 10, 2017, 03:51:04 PM
Scipio, the US forensic scientist referred to above is arguably the world's expert on blood serology.  He has testified in cases as follows:

COURT PRESENTATIONS

Expert testimony presentations in forensic serology
made in excess of four hundred (400) times in
Superior Courts of the following states:
 

Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Georgia,
Illinois, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, Missouri,
Nebraska, Nevada, New York, Ohio, Oklahoma,
Oregon, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Texas, Utah,
Wisconsin and Washington. 

Superior Courts in California: 

Alameda, Butte, Contra Costa, El Dorado, Fresno,
Humboldt, Kern, Los Angeles,  Orange,  Sacramento, 
San  Bernardino,  San  Diego,  San  Francisco, 
San  Joaquin,  Santa  Clara, Shasta, Solano, Sonoma,
Sutter, Tulare, and Ventura Counties.

He qualified during the 1970's and has been practising since.  When I put to him the environments the blood flake underwent prior to identification and analysis he said:

The amount of stain used seems about right to get a result. The stability of the genetic markers that were conducted on the1/4 inch flake of blood are all well within the expected results time frame.  ABO is good for about two years at ambient temperatures and is the longest for the series of five markers you listed.  Haptoglobin and PGM would be the next at about a year, and AK & EAP are about six months.  This is, of course, is for dried stains that have not been environmentally insulted by temperature or humidity

Pay careful attention to what he said:

He said you can get results in the timeframe in which they did the testing.  There are 2 parts to that:

1) That the heat from the gases would not cause the blood to be unable to be tested successfully. If in fact the heat from the gases would have rendered it unable to be tested successfully then he would not have said the results were reasonable.

2) Blood breaks down over time. He addressed the general length of time it could sit in ambient temperature and yet still be successfully tested after a such period.  Of course if kept in cold storage rules change and some evidence has been stored in places without climate control which can cause evidence to spoil faster.

You want to make the leap that the gases from the shot that caused the drawback damages it and prevents a successful reading.  He didn't suggest any such thing but rather suggested the opposite by saying not only can a reading be obtained but it can be obtained a significant time later successfully.

Since it is well established that readings can be obtained from drawback the issue that experts care about is the length of time when the testing was done and storage conditions.  When done a sizable time later and the material was kept under miserable conditions then the odds of getting successful results will be much lower and sometimes near impossible.  That is when the expert is most useful to the defense.

ABO typing of blood found in barrels was done in plenty of US cases from murders to suicides.  Most of such cases involved blood in barrels of weapons.  Silencers are rarely used here and when used for murder it is rare to have a contact shot let alone one resulting in drawback. 

I will give you the simplest analogy I can consider a tomato.  Will a very short burst of heat immediately demolish a freshly picked tomato?  No but over time the tomato will rot. By storing it in a cool place you delay the process for a longer period of time than if you leave it at room temperature.  If you leave it near a heating vent that will speed up the process.  Quite obviously a tomato can't sit at room temperature for more than a couple of weeks without spoiling. If left consistently in hotter temps it is not going to ripen in an hour and be rotten but it is not going to last 2 weeks. That is what he is speaking to about the blood.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 10, 2017, 07:46:34 PM
Pay careful attention to what he said:

He said you can get results in the timeframe in which they did the testing.  There are 2 parts to that:

1) That the heat from the gases would not cause the blood to be unable to be tested successfully. If in fact the heat from the gases would have rendered it unable to be tested successfully then he would not have said the results were reasonable.

2) Blood breaks down over time. He addressed the general length of time it could sit in ambient temperature and yet still be successfully tested after a such period.  Of course if kept in cold storage rules change and some evidence has been stored in places without climate control which can cause evidence to spoil faster.

You want to make the leap that the gases from the shot that caused the drawback damages it and prevents a successful reading.  He didn't suggest any such thing but rather suggested the opposite by saying not only can a reading be obtained but it can be obtained a significant time later successfully.

Since it is well established that readings can be obtained from drawback the issue that experts care about is the length of time when the testing was done and storage conditions.  When done a sizable time later and the material was kept under miserable conditions then the odds of getting successful results will be much lower and sometimes near impossible.  That is when the expert is most useful to the defense.

ABO typing of blood found in barrels was done in plenty of US cases from murders to suicides.  Most of such cases involved blood in barrels of weapons.  Silencers are rarely used here and when used for murder it is rare to have a contact shot let alone one resulting in drawback. 

I will give you the simplest analogy I can consider a tomato.  Will a very short burst of heat immediately demolish a freshly picked tomato?  No but over time the tomato will rot. By storing it in a cool place you delay the process for a longer period of time than if you leave it at room temperature.  If you leave it near a heating vent that will speed up the process.  Quite obviously a tomato can't sit at room temperature for more than a couple of weeks without spoiling. If left consistently in hotter temps it is not going to ripen in an hour and be rotten but it is not going to last 2 weeks. That is what he is speaking to about the blood.

The reply was in direct response to my questions covering the size of sample and duration of the environments the flake was exposed to pre identification and testing.  The scientist has given timescales for analysing antigens, enzymes and proteins from dried bloodstains that haven't been environmentally insulted by temperature and humidity.   

I don't need or want to make any leaps.  I was first alerted to the possibility the blood evidence was fabricated when I considered the bloodstaining on the rifle, in the form of "splashes" and "smears", wasn't capable of being typed beyond confirming the splashes and smears were in fact blood and human in origin.  In fact none of the bloodstained exhibits were capable of yielding the sort of results the flake of blood in the silencer did.

A tomato isn't a good analogy.  A 1/4 inch flake of tomato juice would be a better analogy. 

Are you able to refer us to some documented cases?
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: scipio_usmc on March 10, 2017, 11:58:50 PM
The reply was in direct response to my questions covering the size of sample and duration of the environments the flake was exposed to pre identification and testing.  The scientist has given timescales for analysing antigens, enzymes and proteins from dried bloodstains that haven't been environmentally insulted by temperature and humidity.   

I don't need or want to make any leaps.  I was first alerted to the possibility the blood evidence was fabricated when I considered the bloodstaining on the rifle, in the form of "splashes" and "smears", wasn't capable of being typed beyond confirming the splashes and smears were in fact blood and human in origin.  In fact none of the bloodstained exhibits were capable of yielding the sort of results the flake of blood in the silencer did.

A tomato isn't a good analogy.  A 1/4 inch flake of tomato juice would be a better analogy. 

Are you able to refer us to some documented cases?

The outside splashes of blood on metal were smaller amounts of blood than the flake unless it is all combined together.  That it was not enough to get typing done on each stain compared to the flake is hardly surprising.  The blood on the stocks soaked into the wood so would not be that easy to get a good sample as big as the flake was. That outer blood was not only disturbed by the shooter while using the weapon after the blood was deposited, the killer blocked additional blood from getting on it by having hands where some additional blood would have gone so prevented the stains from being better.   

What surprises me is that you don't take note that if the killer used bare hands that the killers hands would have had blood on them and been apt to leave prints on the weapon or elsewhere in blood by touching the weapon that had blood all around it. Also that the killer would have bee hit with the spatter as well in areas like face and clothing. It would not all get on the rifle just.  That blood no doubt was Nevill's since he is the one who was beaten with he rifle.

I know you bring up the defense argument of her maybe cleaning herself before killing herself based on religious ritualistic killings but that is rare and doesn't square with this case.  I really wonder why you don't look at that more seriously. 





Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 11, 2017, 11:30:19 AM
The outside splashes of blood on metal were smaller amounts of blood than the flake unless it is all combined together.  That it was not enough to get typing done on each stain compared to the flake is hardly surprising.  The blood on the stocks soaked into the wood so would not be that easy to get a good sample as big as the flake was. That outer blood was not only disturbed by the shooter while using the weapon after the blood was deposited, the killer blocked additional blood from getting on it by having hands where some additional blood would have gone so prevented the stains from being better.   

What surprises me is that you don't take note that if the killer used bare hands that the killers hands would have had blood on them and been apt to leave prints on the weapon or elsewhere in blood by touching the weapon that had blood all around it. Also that the killer would have bee hit with the spatter as well in areas like face and clothing. It would not all get on the rifle just.  That blood no doubt was Nevill's since he is the one who was beaten with he rifle.

I know you bring up the defense argument of her maybe cleaning herself before killing herself based on religious ritualistic killings but that is rare and doesn't square with this case.  I really wonder why you don't look at that more seriously.

Some of the stains on the rifle were significantly larger than the 1/4" flake supposedly found in the silencer - see attached.  The blood on the rifle obviously wasn't subjected to the hot discharge gases from from firing or the cyanoacrylate fuming chamber.  It was tested on 13th Aug.  Conversely the blood flake had to survive the hot discharge gases from firing, cyanoacrylate fuming chamber and ambient temperature until 12th Sep.  It was potentially also exposed to other hazardous environments such as claims JB replaced the silencer in a plastic bag.  An absolute no, no in forensic science is placing wet blood in plastic as it provides the right environment for bacteria and mould which have the potential to destroy any forensic value.  It was also placed in AE's car boot which had been parked outside WHF for several hours during the height of the British summer whilst she 'tidied'.  I haven't banged on about the the latter two as they will prove difficult, if not impossible, to quantify.  Surely anyone looking at the case objectively will ask themselves how the flake of blood supposedly found in the silencer was able to yield the sort of results claimed when the rifle wasn't?

I think SC's found state is entirely consistent with her carrying out the murders and taking her own life.  I don't believe she engaged in any ritual cleaning or changed her clothes.  We cannot be sure she was forensically clean.  The police destroyed her nightdress which may have yielded vital clues using 21st century forensic science.  The autopsy report notes an unexplained graze to her abdomen covered by a dressing and two small holes were found in her nightdress with a  ? about burning.  Of course there may be entirely innocent explanations eg SC was a smoker so she may simply have caught herself with a cigarette.  Point is a bunch of amateur sleuths shouldn't be speculating about all of this 3 decades on.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 11, 2017, 01:24:47 PM
Scipio, David1819, or anyone else, are you able to refer us to any documented cases where the prosecution case has in part or full relied upon blood evidence found within the barrel of a firearm or silencer?  Preferably blood evidence by way of conventional serological analysis of blood but also interested in any cases involving blood evidence by way of DNA analysis.  Thanks.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Samson on March 12, 2017, 03:13:46 PM
I think we can more or less agree that if the silencer was not used in killing the family, any expert opinion establishing the mixed blood of June and Neville became fused in a 6 mil blood flake, or that Sheila's blood itself could constitute that flake, means we have expert witnesses in the Bamber case that should be prosecuted or hauled before a range of disciplinary committees.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: APRIL on March 12, 2017, 04:28:33 PM
I think we can more or less agree that if the silencer was not used in killing the family, any expert opinion establishing the mixed blood of June and Neville became fused in a 6 mil blood flake, or that Sheila's blood itself could constitute that flake, means we have expert witnesses in the Bamber case that should be prosecuted or hauled before a range of disciplinary committees.

I can just see it now. NO expert witnesses willing to testify for fear that SOMEONE will prosecute them for something and their reputations will be ruined simply because they gave their opinion. ALL experts have differing opinions. They sure as hell wouldn't be picked to testify if their theory went against what was trying to be proved.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Samson on March 12, 2017, 07:26:36 PM
I can just see it now. NO expert witnesses willing to testify for fear that SOMEONE will prosecute them for something and their reputations will be ruined simply because they gave their opinion. ALL experts have differing opinions. They sure as hell wouldn't be picked to testify if their theory went against what was trying to be proved.
No, there is always the option to refuse the attempt to make a declaration on obscure material. In the Lundy case every expert in the world on ImmunoHistoChemistry refused, but one man in Texas agreed to establish that necrotic rotten material was a woman's brain. He is in the process, 16 years on of being called to task. He put Lundy in jail and he stays there despite having a cast iron alibi. He was 100 miles from the crime scene when it occurred. There is no need to make things up. This is the case in this Bamber nonsense, the silencer was in a cupboard during the commission of this crime, and the man in jail was 4 miles away, yet blood that could not be recognised as human becomes victims' blood. Where was the obligation to voice an opinion that results in a finding precluded by the case facts?
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Caroline on March 13, 2017, 08:27:44 AM
No, there is always the option to refuse the attempt to make a declaration on obscure material. In the Lundy case every expert in the world on ImmunoHistoChemistry refused, but one man in Texas agreed to establish that necrotic rotten material was a woman's brain. He is in the process, 16 years on of being called to task. He put Lundy in jail and he stays there despite having a cast iron alibi. He was 100 miles from the crime scene when it occurred. There is no need to make things up. This is the case in this Bamber nonsense, the silencer was in a cupboard during the commission of this crime, and the man in jail was 4 miles away, yet blood that could not be recognised as human becomes victims' blood. Where was the obligation to voice an opinion that results in a finding precluded by the case facts?

This isn't the Lundy case.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 15, 2017, 02:21:18 PM
I think we can more or less agree that if the silencer was not used in killing the family, any expert opinion establishing the mixed blood of June and Neville became fused in a 6 mil blood flake, or that Sheila's blood itself could constitute that flake, means we have expert witnesses in the Bamber case that should be prosecuted or hauled before a range of disciplinary committees.

The rifle was found on SC's body sans silencer.  JB claims the first he knew there was problem at the farm was when he received NB's phone call.  As we know the silencer was found in the gun cupboard days later by relatives.  However instead of looking at ways to repudiate the silencer and blood flake, JB's QC, Geoffrey Rivlin, chose to include it by suggesting SC used the silencer to murder her parents and sons and then removed it before taking her own life.  He also suggested the blood flake represented an intimate mix of NB and June's blood  caused by close range shots and/or the beating NB sustained.  Now bearing in mind the relatives said they found the silencer in a bag (plastic?) behind a dart board at the back of the cupboard it makes the case for SC using the silencer highly implausible.  More likely if SC used it and found it easier to pull the trigger sans silencer she would simply detach it and leave it hanging about.  Why would she go to the trouble of replacing it in the cupboard?  Prof Knight at trial said those who murder and commit suicide often tidy up and carry out mundane chores but imo it's a lot to ask a jury to buy into.  Furthermore although much of the expert evidence at trial surrounding ballistics was rudimentary there was virtually nothing to support the case that blood from any gsw's or non gsw's sustained by NB and June had the potential to enter into the silencer.  With the advent of the internet and easy access to forensic textbooks etc we can see Geoffrey Rivlin's claims of the mixed blood flake are unsustainable. 

I reject the blood/silencer evidence as I don't believe a flake of blood measuring a 1/4" would survive the hot discharge gases, the cyanoacrylate fuming chamber and time spent at ambient temperature until it was identified on 12th Sep and tested by way of conventional serological analysis of blood.  The success of this type of analysis is dependent on the quality and quantity of the sample.  The quantity of blood on the outside of the rifle was significantly greater than the 1/4" blood flake and was analysed about a month earlier; wasn't subjected to the hot discharge gases and cyanoacrylate fuming chamber but was unable to produce any blood test results other than confirming it was blood and human in origin.

Samson take a peep at the blood results table in the following.  GR argued that a combination of NB and June's blood results could have resulted in SC's thus providing a false reading if you will:

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6585.msg268313#msg268313

For those who believe JB is innocent I blame JB's defence: law firm Kinglsey Napley and solicitor Paul Terzeon, the late Ed Lawson QC and Geoffrey Rivlin QC. 

Arrogant - Thought the jury wouldn't understand and would buy into the above by being unable to find guilty 'beyond reasonable doubt'. 

Greedy - JB's case was the first case Kingsley Napley handled funded by legal aid.  Expertise was sourced on the cheap.  In reality they needed to go to the US or some other country eg SA where gun crime is high.   

Incompetent and Negligent - Eg didn't chase down the bible to examine bloodstains and test in an attempt to determine the origin. 
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: scipio_usmc on March 17, 2017, 11:37:37 PM
The rifle was found on SC's body sans silencer.  JB claims the first he knew there was problem at the farm was when he received NB's phone call.  As we know the silencer was found in the gun cupboard days later by relatives.  However instead of looking at ways to repudiate the silencer and blood flake, JB's QC, Geoffrey Rivlin, chose to include it by suggesting SC used the silencer to murder her parents and sons and then removed it before taking her own life.  He also suggested the blood flake represented an intimate mix of NB and June's blood  caused by close range shots and/or the beating NB sustained.

By suggesting the flake was a mixture of June and Nevill's blood was an attempt to repudiate it. While quite weak the alternative was to just give up.

I reject the blood/silencer evidence as I don't believe a flake of blood measuring a 1/4" would survive the hot discharge gases, the cyanoacrylate fuming chamber and time spent at ambient temperature until it was identified on 12th Sep and tested by way of conventional serological analysis of blood.

Your belief is not founded in science though. You can't point to any experts who say the heat would prevent the blood tests from being successful you simply decided it on your own. The defense could only make the argument you present if experts were willing to testify to such but none were. It is an established fact that superglue fuming and the heat in moderators doesn't damage blood to the point it can't be successfully typed.  That is why you can't find any experts who say it never can be type tested after super glue fuming or if found in a moderator.

The defense was operating under the rules of court while you are not and can argue anything you like.

You keep quantifying all of the blood on the outside of the rifle together as if it were all collected in 1 giant sample but is was not. They took small amounts from various stains to test if it was human and that expended such samples. That made each stain smaller. That left less of each stain to remove to try to use for type testing. The flake was a much larger volume of blood than any of the scrapings they got from the outside of the rifle.

You take the fiction that some of the scrapings were larger than the flake inside and that not being able to successfully type such means it would be impossible to have tested the flake successfully.  This simply doesn't work.

You also take the general rule that the length of time to test items will be shortened if stored in high heat/humidity conditions and make the leap this means the heat of the moderator or superglue fuming would always prevent successful. You are free to believe anything you like by making leaps like such but it can't be used in court and is not even persuasive to others here.

You are not really being fair to the defense.

Even with respect to the Bible it would have been quackery for then to look at what page had the blood stains and try to make up some way to suggest it helped prove suicide. Some lawyers are desperate enough to do that 
but I actually think more of them for not engaging in such BS.  The blood on the Bible was presumed to be Sheila's, it was not only by her but sitting in a pool of her blood.  If there were blood from another victim on the Bible they still could not think of a way it would help establish Jeremy's innocence nor can I. Unless you had Sheila's bloody fingerprints on it in Nevill's blood (which would support her having beat him and gotten his blood on her hands in the process) small amounts of blood of other victims would not matter. The police found no prints in blood to try testing.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Samson on March 18, 2017, 05:42:24 AM
By suggesting the flake was a mixture of June and Nevill's blood was an attempt to repudiate it. While quite weak the alternative was to just give up.

Your belief is not founded in science though. You can't point to any experts who say the heat would prevent the blood tests from being successful you simply decided it on your own. The defense could only make the argument you present if experts were willing to testify to such but none were. It is an established fact that superglue fuming and the heat in moderators doesn't damage blood to the point it can't be successfully typed.  That is why you can't find any experts who say it never can be type tested after super glue fuming or if found in a moderator.

The defense was operating under the rules of court while you are not and can argue anything you like.

You keep quantifying all of the blood on the outside of the rifle together as if it were all collected in 1 giant sample but is was not. They took small amounts from various stains to test if it was human and that expended such samples. That made each stain smaller. That left less of each stain to remove to try to use for type testing. The flake was a much larger volume of blood than any of the scrapings they got from the outside of the rifle.

You take the fiction that some of the scrapings were larger than the flake inside and that not being able to successfully type such means it would be impossible to have tested the flake successfully.  This simply doesn't work.

You also take the general rule that the length of time to test items will be shortened if stored in high heat/humidity conditions and make the leap this means the heat of the moderator or superglue fuming would always prevent successful. You are free to believe anything you like by making leaps like such but it can't be used in court and is not even persuasive to others here.

You are not really being fair to the defense.

Even with respect to the Bible it would have been quackery for then to look at what page had the blood stains and try to make up some way to suggest it helped prove suicide. Some lawyers are desperate enough to do that 
but I actually think more of them for not engaging in such BS.  The blood on the Bible was presumed to be Sheila's, it was not only by her but sitting in a pool of her blood.  If there were blood from another victim on the Bible they still could not think of a way it would help establish Jeremy's innocence nor can I. Unless you had Sheila's bloody fingerprints on it in Nevill's blood (which would support her having beat him and gotten his blood on her hands in the process) small amounts of blood of other victims would not matter. The police found no prints in blood to try testing.
Of course blind Freddie knows all the test firing and contact shooting in the world won't get a quarter inch dried flake in the baffles. But that is classic gardening.
Less than reassuring Scipio that law excites you more than science in finding what really happened.

Professor Chris Halkides

Maybe we should coin the term "rat malfeasance unit" RMU and grade the various pieces of evidence accordingly. Or RGU, relative gardening unit...

They called Bruce Hutton the gardener, but the seed had no embryo. Arthur Thomas vs the henchmen. They won for a short while, only 9 years.
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Caroline on March 18, 2017, 12:45:32 PM
Of course blind Freddie knows all the test firing and contact shooting in the world won't get a quarter inch dried flake in the baffles. But that is classic gardening.
Less than reassuring Scipio that law excites you more than science in finding what really happened.

Professor Chris Halkides

Maybe we should coin the term "rat malfeasance unit" RMU and grade the various pieces of evidence accordingly. Or RGU, relative gardening unit...

They called Bruce Hutton the gardener, but the seed had no embryo. Arthur Thomas vs the henchmen. They won for a short while, only 9 years.

Someone will have to translate this, no idea what he's on about!
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 18, 2017, 03:05:44 PM
By suggesting the flake was a mixture of June and Nevill's blood was an attempt to repudiate it. While quite weak the alternative was to just give up.

SNIP


Not so according to KNGB:

http://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php/topic,4121.msg171113.html#msg171113

http://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php/topic,4121.msg171124.html#msg171124

http://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php/topic,4121.msg171132.html#msg171132

http://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php/topic,4121.msg171143.html#msg171143

http://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php/topic,4121.msg171145.html#msg171145

http://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php/topic,4121.msg171157.html#msg171157

http://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php/topic,4121.msg171285.html#msg171285
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 18, 2017, 03:52:59 PM
SNIP

Your belief is not founded in science though. You can't point to any experts who say the heat would prevent the blood tests from being successful you simply decided it on your own. The defense could only make the argument you present if experts were willing to testify to such but none were. It is an established fact that superglue fuming and the heat in moderators doesn't damage blood to the point it can't be successfully typed.  That is why you can't find any experts who say it never can be type tested after super glue fuming or if found in a moderator.

The defense was operating under the rules of court while you are not and can argue anything you like.

SNIP

You would have us believe that the quantity and quality of blood found at soc and subsequently analysed by conventional serological analysis is irrelevant.  It isn't.

http://www.crime-scene-investigator.net/print/blood-print.html

http://www.forensicscienceresources.com/georgecv.htm

I've recently posted text from email communication with arguably the world's leading expert on blood serology:

Sorry I have not responded earlier, but things have been very busy here.  The amount of stain used seems about right to get a result. The stability of the genetic markers that were conducted on the1/4 inch flake of blood are all well within the expected results time frame.  ABO is good for about two years at ambient temperatures and is the longest for the series of five markers you listed.  Haptoglobin and PGM would be the next at about a year, and AK & EAP are about six months.  This is, of course, is for dried stains that have not been environmentally insulted by temperature or humidity.  XXXX would not have the capability of a fingerprint chamber or to test fire a weapon at our facility.

And from a leading UK forensic scientist:

Thank you for your email. I have always found this case very interesting. As I'm sure you have seen on my out of office reply, I am away from work on maternity leave at the moment. I am not back until mid-March so I would not be able to work on any specifics until then.

I have taken on projects of this type in the past but as I work part time now I would need to speak to some colleagues before agreeing to any work. We do have a cyanoacrylate fuming chamber and some kind of firearms licence but I'm not sure what It covers as it may only be for our flare gun.

Maybe we could speak in the new year to discuss your requirements further.

Best wishes"


Myster has been sent copies of the emails.   

The only way to know for sure is to carry out tests. 

You find me some cases/evidence which support the following:

- Blood found at soc and subsequently analysed by way of conventional serological analysis is unaffacted by temperature and humidity.

- Criminal cases that are underpinned by way of blood found in a silencer and subsequently analysed by way of conventional serological analysis.

The fact JB's defence didn't explore the above is irrelevant.  They are lawyers (and not very good ones imo) not forensic scientists. 

Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: Holly Goodhead on March 18, 2017, 04:21:34 PM

SNIP

You keep quantifying all of the blood on the outside of the rifle together as if it were all collected in 1 giant sample but is was not. They took small amounts from various stains to test if it was human and that expended such samples. That made each stain smaller. That left less of each stain to remove to try to use for type testing. The flake was a much larger volume of blood than any of the scrapings they got from the outside of the rifle.

You take the fiction that some of the scrapings were larger than the flake inside and that not being able to successfully type such means it would be impossible to have tested the flake successfully.  This simply doesn't work.

You also take the general rule that the length of time to test items will be shortened if stored in high heat/humidity conditions and make the leap this means the heat of the moderator or superglue fuming would always prevent successful. You are free to believe anything you like by making leaps like such but it can't be used in court and is not even persuasive to others here.

You are not really being fair to the defense.


According to the CoA  doc the flake found inside the silencer measured 1/4" by way of surface and is by definition ultra thin.  By comparison the rifle contained numerous stains, smears and splashes.  According to Glynis Howard's trial testimony bloodstains are greater in volume compared with smears.  One bloodstain measured 1 1/4" x <1/4" which is significantly larger than the flake inside the silencer and yet this was incapable of being typed. 

71. The rifle bore blood smearing on the barrel in the region of the fore-sight and around the mechanism and there were splashes of blood to the left side of the weapon. The appearance of the blood staining was consistent with it having been used to strike somebody who was already bleeding. On analysis the blood was found to be human blood but tests to determine grouping were unsuccessful.   

This imo should have set the alarm bells ringing along with Dr Lincoln's letter to the defence which shows numerous exhibits were tested and none were able to produce the sort of results the blood flake supposedly found inside the silencer did. 
Title: Re: Blood n heat...
Post by: scipio_usmc on March 18, 2017, 09:04:44 PM
According to the CoA  doc the flake found inside the silencer measured 1/4" by way of surface and is by definition ultra thin.  By comparison the rifle contained numerous stains, smears and splashes.  According to Glynis Howard's trial testimony bloodstains are greater in volume compared with smears.  One bloodstain measured 1 1/4" x <1/4" which is significantly larger than the flake inside the silencer and yet this was incapable of being typed. 

71. The rifle bore blood smearing on the barrel in the region of the fore-sight and around the mechanism and there were splashes of blood to the left side of the weapon. The appearance of the blood staining was consistent with it having been used to strike somebody who was already bleeding. On analysis the blood was found to be human blood but tests to determine grouping were unsuccessful.   

This imo should have set the alarm bells ringing along with Dr Lincoln's letter to the defence which shows numerous exhibits were tested and none were able to produce the sort of results the blood flake supposedly found inside the silencer did.

The flake did not represent all blood removed from the barrel.  If all the other blood removed from the barrel were combined it would have exceeded the volume in the flake.  It was not all combined though and wound not be proper to do so. The various flakes they took form inside were all smaller than the flake.

They didn't remove all of the blood on the exterior either let alone remove it all and combine it into a single body to analyze.  They scraped little bits from various stains and those little bits they scraped to test were smaller than the flake.

What matters is the size of the sample scraped off for testing not what the total volume of blood on the weapon was.