Conventional serological analysis"Analysis of the proteins, enzymes, and antigens present in the blood. These substances are more susceptible to degradation than DNA and this type of testing usually requires a "large" sample (quarter size) in good condition for optimal results. This type of testing is rarely statistically individualizing".
"Blood evidence must never be exposed to excessive heat or humidity. If possible, the bloodstained evidence should be refrigerated until it can be transported to the crime lab. The evidence should also be taken to the lab as soon as possible".
The blood in the silencer was analysed using conventional serological analysis producing the following results:
ABO PGM EAP AK Hp
Nevill Bamber O PGM1+ EAP BA AK1 Hp2-1
June Bamber A PGM1+ EAP BA AK2-1 Hp2-1
Daniel Caffell O PGM2+1+ EAP B AK1 Hp2
Nicholas Caffell O PGM2+1+ EAP B AK1 Hp2
Sheila Caffell A PGM1+ EAP BA AK1 Hp2-1
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Blood In Silencer A Nil EAP BA AK1 Hp2-1
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Robert Boutflour A PGM1+ EAP BA AK1 Hp2-1
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ABO = Blood Group System
PGM = Phosphoglucomutase (Enzyme) Breaks down quickly outside the body hence blood in silencer was unable to produce a reading
EAP = Erythrocyte Acid Phosphatase (Enzyme)
AK = Adenylate Kinase (Enzyme)
HP = Haptoglobin (Protein)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Many other exhibits were also analysed using conventional serological analysis:
- Carpet samples from main bedroom
- Wallpaper from wall near kitchen
- Rifle
- Blue socks
- NB's car seat
- JB's dressing gown
- JB's jacket
Blood on the above items was found to be either human in origin or only capable of limited results. The only exhibit capable of full serological analysis as per the table above was the silencer. A possible explanation for this is that EP deliberately contaminated the silencer with SC's blood from her sample handed to EP by the pathologist and stored in EP's soc fridge at Chelmsford police station. This would ensure good quality blood in prime condition as it was stored at the correct temperature and in sufficient quantity.
If heat has the potential to destroy blood evidence how did the blood 'found' in the silencer produce full serological results as per the table above?
I have previously posted up a youtube clip showing a silencer heating up to 390F after 30 rounds being fired through it but the bullets used were clearly more powerful than the bullets used at WHF based on the size of the magazine.
The barrel of the rifle would also heat up but not as much as the silencer due to the hot gasses getting trapped in the silencer's expansion chamber and baffles. The CoA doc states after firing 25 rounds through the silencer it heated up to 24.5C/76.1F. The reason for this test was to establish how quickly the blood dried and whether it was possible for June's blood to dry and overlay NB's blood or vice-versa (irrelevant to this thread but just explaining the reason for the temp test). The ITV documentary aired around March/April 2012 shows the rifle/silencer heated up after firing but no actual temperature was given. It was shown to be insufficient to cause the burn marks to NB's back. In CAL's book Dr V states that NB would have been mindful of not grabbing the rifle as it would be hot after firing and yet 24.5C would not be capable of causing any sort of skin burn? Dr V also states in his interview with CAL that he is now of the opinion that the burn marks on NB's back were caused by the rifle. Malcolm Fletcher states that he fired the rifle "loads of times" and grabbed the barrel and silencer but it would only warm up and wasn't hot enough to burn skin.
John Hayward the biologist who carried out the blood analysis left FSS shortly after the murders at WHF and was in private practice at the time of trial. His son David Hayward now runs the practice:
http://www.haywardforensics.co.uk/client-resources/professional-profiles/I need to establish whether the blood 'found' in the silencer was capable of withstanding the heat from the silencer after firing AND ambient temperature over many days until it was analysed by FSS and still capable of producing the above results.
&%+((£
...Hello David...
