Does Madeleine have the right to be found?

[Lace]

It's been physically demonstrated  that couldn't have been possible but maybe you don't look at the things I do because obviously fairytale ideas while they sound reasonable in the minds of those who believe them would be destroyed in seconds .

Take a look at this video Snowgirl  https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=truth+of+the+lie+youtube&view=detail&mid=B47345D833CA38B6CB17B47345D833CA38B6CB17&FORM=VIRE

It is not physically impossible for someone to make an escape through the window.   The video shows someone trying to get through holding a child,  of course someone could have been on the other side of the window to retrieve the child but this isn't mentioned.   If no child in his or her arms,  someone could easily have got through the window.  IMO

[Angelo222]

Play nicely please girls.  And some posts on topic would be refreshing.

[jassi]

Take a look at this video Snowgirl  https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=truth+of+the+lie+youtube&view=detail&mid=B47345D833CA38B6CB17B47345D833CA38B6CB17&FORM=VIRE

It is not physically impossible for someone to make an escape through the window.   The video shows someone trying to get through holding a child,  of course someone could have been on the other side of the window to retrieve the child but this isn't mentioned.   If no child in his or her arms,  someone could easily have got through the window.  IMO

Possibility is not the same as reality.

[Lace]

IMO the fairy tale is that Madeleine is living a life of unbridled happiness somewhere in never never land.

It would be your opinion only as you can't definitely say that is not what is happening  IMO

If someone had posted that Madeleine had been taken because a woman didn't want her four year old girl having anything to do with her biological father and that Madeleine's DNA would prove that she wasn't the fathers child.  You would no doubt have said that was a fairy tale.   But that did happen didn't it,  that two year old girl was snatched purely for the woman to give her DNA instead of her own child. Truth is stranger than fiction as they say.   

[Lace]

Possibility is not the same as reality.

Mrs Fenn's burglar got out via the window.

[jassi]

Mrs Fenn's burglar got out via the window.

Which merely shows that it is possible, not that it did happen in the McCann case

[G-Unit]

So do you agree with snowgirl that my opinion is a 'fairy tale'?

Did I express any such opinion? I merely pointed out that no-one knows if there was 'an intruder' or not.

[Snowgirl]

Take a look at this video Snowgirl  https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=truth+of+the+lie+youtube&view=detail&mid=B47345D833CA38B6CB17B47345D833CA38B6CB17&FORM=VIRE

It is not physically impossible for someone to make an escape through the window.   The video shows someone trying to get through holding a child,  of course someone could have been on the other side of the window to retrieve the child but this isn't mentioned.   If no child in his or her arms,  someone could easily have got through the window.  IMO

That is the demonstration I was speaking about  ,yes, and so it does show it would have been impossible with a child in the intrudor’s arms . I never said it was impossible for anyone to get through the window did I ?

[Snowgirl]

Mrs Fenn's burglar got out via the window.

You have taken it upon yourself to think I was talking about one person being able to get out of an apartment window but you are quite wrong .

[Alice Purjorick]

IMO the fairy tale is that Madeleine is living a life of unbridled happiness somewhere in never never land.

Indeed. Assuming she did not die within 48 hours of the "abduction" which appears to be the norm according many police forces.
Recommended reading and viewing:
Novel "The Searchers" by Alan LeMay  turned into a movie of the same name.
Movie "Two Rode Together".
Both paint more realistic pictures under the circumstances, of obsession and wanting to play god.

[ShiningInLuz]

Indeed. Assuming she did not die within 48 hours of the "abduction" which appears to be the norm according many police forces.
Recommended reading and viewing:
Novel "The Searchers" by Alan LeMay  turned into a movie of the same name.
Movie "Two Rode Together".
Both paint more realistic pictures under the circumstances, of obsession and wanting to play god.

If it was an RC why would she die within 48 hours of abduction?

[Eleanor]

Back to Madeleine being picked up from her bed and being handed to someone else, which would account for the child Jane Tanner saw being carried having her feet facing in the opposite direction.
This could have occurred if Madeleine was handed through the window.

[jassi]

Back to Madeleine being picked up from her bed and being handed to someone else, which would account for the child Jane Tanner saw being carried having her feet facing in the opposite direction.
This could have occurred if Madeleine was handed through the window.

Opposite direction to what?

[Sunny]

Could someone start a new thread for replacement child or Eleanor's theory please.

It is all interesting but is seriously off topic and IMO wouldn't hurt more discussion.

Just my opinion of course.

[Lace]

You have taken it upon yourself to think I was talking about one person being able to get out of an apartment window but you are quite wrong .

This is my post that you replyed to -   It could have been opened to send the message 'I didn't have a key'   or to pass Madeleine to another person outside,  or a precaution in case someone came into the bedroom when the intruder was there,  he could make his/her getaway through the window.


I can see know how our posts got misunderstood.

I apoligise Snowgirl,   what I  SHOULD have said was he/she could make a getaway through the window,  leaving Madeleine in the bedroom.   As that is was I meant.