At Last a Podcast from the Experts.

[Mr Gray]

Which as you kindly point out, could be an indication that an alive Madeleine McCann never woke and wandered anywhere on the evening of May 3rd. It couldn't have been anybody else's cadaver could it, if no dead bodies had ever been in the apartment?

thers no confirmation of an alert to cadaver

[The General]

Which as you kindly point out, could be an indication that an alive Madeleine McCann never woke and wandered anywhere on the evening of May 3rd. It couldn't have been anybody else's cadaver could it, if no dead bodies had ever been in the apartment?

To a casual observer it would be pretty compelling. It's just that all I hear is Davel barking '....DOGS! NO CADAVER! DOGS!'.

[Robittybob1]

Mr Smith & wife believed they saw Gerry, & need we recount how the bin scenario would have made discovery of a body quite difficult initially & eventually nigh on impossible?

Was there a bin scenario?  Maybe if the child climbed into a bin and was asleep when the rubbish collectors picked up the bin.  I know this has happened to homeless individuals from time to time.  The compactor truck being that noisy the driver is unaware he has just loaded a living person into the bin on the truck and the compactor kills the victim.  Horrible thought but it happens.

[The General]

thers no confirmation of an alert to cadaver

Yer see?
Course it was.

[Angelo222]

Yeh, but what's the chances? Woke and wandered, died in an accident.......and someone separate died in a holiday apartment?

Nobody died in 5a that we know of but these things happen in real life. A previous owner of 5a died in hospital so cadaver odour could very well have been innocently brought back to the property.  Contamination by cadaver odour is a fact of life, we were even told that the reason the cadaver dog alerted to some of Kate McCann's clothing was because she was a GP and routinely encountered dead bodies. Thus her contaminated clothing since cadaver odour cannot be washed away.

[Robittybob1]

If Maddie woke and wandered... What did Eddie alert to in the apartment

That is a separate question.

[Mr Gray]

To a casual observer it would be pretty compelling. It's just that all I hear is Davel barking '....DOGS! NO CADAVER! DOGS!'.

the casual observer probably believes such rubbish as....solved 200 cases....100% record...neither of which is true..
are you aware of the dogs real track record

[The General]

the casu observer probably believes such rubbish as....solved 200 cases....100% record...neither of which is true..
are you aware of the dogs real track record

You're too easy.....

[Mr Gray]

There is no alive Madeleine McCann as far as I'm aware to confirm that it wasn't her cadaver the dog was alerting to.

perhaps it was lord lucans...no confirmation it wasnt

[Mr Gray]

You're too easy.....

I can back up everything i say with corroborated facts....its easy.

[The General]

I can back up everything i say with corroborated facts....its easy

Yeh I know, you're the best.

[Mr Gray]

Yeh I know, you're the best.

better than all the rest...resistence is futile

[Mr Gray]

That is a separate question.

it seems a question many want to discuss...including angelo

[Angelo222]

I will be issuing warnings if the sniping continues...be warned!!

[Robittybob1]

Kate moaned that Gerry was gone along time watching football.

That much is indisputable since Jane Tanner is a perfectly reliable witness.

Jim Clemente finds Jane a more reliable witness than the Smiths.  (Cite in the podcast somewhere)