Is it any wonder that initial investigators arrived at the conclusions they did?

[jassi]

Great.  So it is a lie to say she refused to co-operate with the police inquiry.  At least we got that sorted.  Nearly six hours of answering their questions is alot of chat.

She was there for that length of time. Her degree of participation and cooperation is open to question - unless you have evidence to say otherwise.

[Vertigo Swirl]

She was there for that length of time. Her degree of participation and cooperation is open to question - unless you have evidence to say otherwise.

Erm...yes, in the link provided by G-Unit earlier, from the files, hope that’s a reliable enough source for you

[The General]

That would be unbelievably long for someone in Kates mental state at that time.  In my opinion.  I bet she could hardly think straight.


But then Amaral is known for his, IMO, inhuman treatment of his suspects, isn't he ?  Leonora  Cipriano

A wee 'IMO' and the transparent rhetorical context doesn't stop the comment being defamatory. You'll need your facts straight if you're going down this line.

[Vertigo Swirl]

A wee 'IMO' and the transparent rhetorical context doesn't stop the comment being defamatory. You'll need your facts straight if you're going down this line.

You’re becoming a bore IMO. 

[jassi]

Erm...yes, in the link provided by G-Unit earlier, from the files, hope that’s a reliable enough source for you

OK, thank you. How far back ?  Post number, perhaps ?

[The General]

You’re becoming a bore IMO.

Puzzled by the disparity in moderation.
Sadie's post should have been deleted on sight.
But I am a bore - I'm here. Not exactly mountain biking in Snowdonia, on a surveillance OP in the Med.

[Vertigo Swirl]

OK, thank you. How far back ?  Post number, perhaps ?

Not very far dear, in fact I quoted it in my post to which you replied, so I’m sure you’ll manage to find it if you try hard.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Puzzled by the disparity in moderation.
Sadie's post should have been deleted on sight.
But I am a bore - I'm here. Not exactly mountain biking in Snowdonia, on a surveillance OP in the Med.

You gotta let it go, it’s the only way.  Accept that there is uneven moderation, and accept that we are all victims of it (apart from SIL and the mods themselves of course).  Now, go climb a mountain while you still can.

[G-Unit]

That would be unbelievably long for someone in Kates mental state at that time.  In my opinion.  I bet she could hardly think straight.


But then Amaral is known for his, IMO, inhuman treatment of his suspects, isn't he ?  Leonora  Cipriano

Strangely, I was feeling OK. I think by now I’d switched on to autopilot and an inner strength and
calmness I hadn’t expected to find had begun to take over
Kate McCann madeleine.

[jassi]

Not very far dear, in fact I quoted it in my post to which you replied, so I’m sure you’ll manage to find it if you try hard.

Indeed I have and she doesn't seem to have said an awful lot during the time period - IMO

[Vertigo Swirl]

Indeed I have and she doesn't seem to have said an awful lot during the time period - IMO

Yeah, there were long 20 minute silences where she just stared intently at the questioners, whilst refusing to answer, they just left those bits out of the transcript.

[Mr Gray]

Indeed I have and she doesn't seem to have said an awful lot during the time period - IMO

That's either because she didn't... Or lots was left out... Which seems more likely to me

[Vertigo Swirl]

How many hours was Gerry questioned for and where’s his transcript? 

[Mr Gray]

Wouldn't it have been helpful if like the rogs... The witness statements had been audio recorded. Unfortunately  the PJ were totally unprofessional imo.  They were able to choose exactly what was and wasn't recorded and what was put in the, statements

[Vertigo Swirl]

Here we go, four hours and about the same number of pages.  I expect he did lots of prolonged periods of silence too, whilst refusing to cooperate which the police decided not to mention

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-ARGUIDO.htm#p10p2567