Dog Alerts- Evidence or not?

[Mr Gray]

Link please ?

called back to the car twice...and similar incidents in the search of the apartment according to teh PJ...its in the files Ive  supplied it several times

[G-Unit]

called back to the car twice...and similar incidents in the search of the apartment according to teh PJ...its in the files Ive  supplied it several times

The PJ knew as much about how cadaver dogs work as you do. (not much)

[barrier]

called back to the car twice...and similar incidents in the search of the apartment according to teh PJ...its in the files Ive  supplied it several times

Obviously never observed or been around working dogs.

[Mr Gray]

Obviously never observed or been around working dogs.

Then why was the dog not called back to other cars

[Mr Gray]

The PJ knew as much about how cadaver dogs work as you do. (not much)

I think thats a pretty pathetic excuse. Why was the dog not callled back to other cars...why was the McCanns car treated differently. Why did Grime claim he didnt know it was the McCanns car when it was covered in posters

[G-Unit]

Then why was the dog not called back to other cars

Grime watched and understood his dog's body language closely and knew when the dog was in the vicinity of the scent he was trained to find.

[Mr Gray]

Grime watched and understood his dog's body language closely and knew when the dog was in the vicinity of the scent he was trained to find.

Speculation.....there is still no evidence...let alone proof taht the alerts by eddie were correct.

[G-Unit]

Speculation.....there is still no evidence...let alone proof taht the alerts by eddie were correct.

There's no evidence, let alone proof, that Madeleine was abducted.

[Mr Gray]

There's no evidence, let alone proof, that Madeleine was abducted.

Yes there is.. It can be proven on the balance of probability by elimination of the other possibilities . Not proven absolutely but on the balance of probability

[G-Unit]

Yes there is.. It can be proven on the balance of probability by elimination of the other possibilities . Not proven absolutely but on the balance of probability

I have seen nothing which eliminates other possibilities.

[Mr Gray]

I have seen nothing which eliminates other possibilities.

I dont totally eliminate other possibilities...its deciding...on the evidence...what is probable...
I dont see parental involvement as probable...that has to increase the probability of the other possibilities

[G-Unit]

I dont totally eliminate other possibilities...its deciding...on the evidence...what is probable...
I dont see parental involvement as probable...that has to increase the probability of the other possibilities

All scenarios are possible. Probability seems to be related to opinion rather than evidence.

[Mr Gray]

All scenarios are possible. Probability seems to be related to opinion rather than evidence.

i think that is untrue....based on evidence..what do you think is the probability of parental involvemnet

[Lace]

There's no evidence, let alone proof, that Madeleine was abducted.

Strange how OG are looking at abduction then isn't it?    The fact that Madeleine is missing and has not been found is evidence of abduction.

[G-Unit]

i think that is untrue....based on evidence..what do you think is the probability of parental involvemnet

I'm not mathematically inclined, so calculating probabilities isn't my thing.