How Did JB Commit The Killings

[Myster]

I think it more likely that NB stumbled into kitchen furniture.

In terms of the casings you're right research shows up to 25% deviation.

As did Jeremy Bamber trying to knock him out with blows from the rifle, one or more of which caused a piece to shear off from the stock.

[Holly Goodhead]

How can it possibly NOT have? Every act carried out by every person, whether you like it or not, carries it's own psychology. It's about why we are who we are. It informs everything we do, irrespective of whether you agree.

We are talking about the physical evidence APRIL. If you want to start up a new thread go for it.

[barrier]

As did Jeremy Bamber trying to knock him out with blows from the rifle, one or more of which caused a piece to shear off from the stock.

We're being led to believe Sheila was capable of this? edit that, some want to believe it was Sheila who was capable of this.

[Holly Goodhead]

As did Jeremy Bamber trying to knock him out with blows from the rifle, one or more of which caused a piece to shear off from the stock.

How does a piece of wood shearing off from the rifle butt point to JB and rule out SC?

[Vertigo Swirl]

I think it more likely that NB stumbled into kitchen furniture.

In terms of the casings you're right research shows up to 25% deviation.

Your reconstruction is therefore rendered less useful if the physical evidence can’t even be relied on.

[Holly Goodhead]

We're being led to believe Sheila was capable of this? edit that, some want to believe it was Sheila who was capable of this.

How does a piece of wood shearing off from the rifle butt point to JB and rule out SC?

[Holly Goodhead]

Your reconstruction is therefore rendered less useful if the physical evidence can’t even be relied on.

As I keep saying a reconstruction is based on the totality of the physical evidence. 

[Vertigo Swirl]

As I keep saying a reconstruction is based on the totality of the physical evidence.

Well get on with it then, Jeremy isn’t getting any younger...

[Myster]

How does a piece of wood shearing off from the rifle butt point to JB and rule out SC?

No bruises on her delicate hands, nor damage to her long fingernails.  And before you put any links to Farmgirl as a distraction (I know your wily ways), Sheila wasn't built like a bulldozer either.

[Myster]

Well get on with it then, Jeremy isn’t getting any younger...

That's true...

[Holly Goodhead]

No bruises on her delicate hands, nor damage to her long fingernails.  And before you put any links to Farmgirl as a distraction (I know your wily ways), Sheila wasn't built like a bulldozer either.

But you're making an assumption as to how the piece broke off and how the perp held the rifle thought to be the blunt instrument used to inflict NB's non-gsw's.

The butt might have collided with the lampshade with both breaking in the process. 

Afaik the shard piece wasn't forensically examined?

[Nicholas]

But you're making an assumption as to how the piece broke off and how the perp held the rifle thought to be the blunt instrument used to inflict NB's non-gsw's.

The butt might have collided with the lampshade with both breaking in the process. 

Afaik the shard piece wasn't forensically examined?

Are you claiming a lampshade broke the butt of the rifle ?

[Holly Goodhead]

Are you claiming a lampshade broke the butt of the rifle ?

I said:

The butt might have collided with the lampshade with both breaking in the process.

Can you see how it can be ruled out?

[Vertigo Swirl]

I said:

The butt might have collided with the lampshade with both breaking in the process.

Can you see how it can be ruled out?

Was it a concrete, rigid lampshade?

[Holly Goodhead]

Was it a concrete, rigid lampshade?

I've no idea.  I only know broken pieces were found on the floor.

(As an aside I was looking to add something to a thread you started 'How Sheila.....' which seems to have disappeared?)