Is there more circumstantial evidence against the mccanns than there is CB

[Eleanor]

"Those thousands of Sun readers asked a question (allegedly) and got an answer. Kate and Gerry were not happy to do anything to help clear their names. They had conditions. End of story."

This statement is bordering on Libellous Innuendo.

[faithlilly]

"Those thousands of Sun readers asked a question (allegedly) and got an answer. Kate and Gerry were not happy to do anything to help clear their names. They had conditions. End of story."

This statement is bordering on Libellous Innuendo.

Libellous innuendo ? That’s a new one.

[Mr Gray]

IMO it doesn’t...in fact quite the opposite.

Then you need to read it again...It says they may help. Anyone with a basic level of intelligence will understand that these twsts are not reliable  and prove nothing.
Why do you think they are not used

[Snowgirl]

Then you need to read it again...It says they may help. Anyone with a basic level of intelligence will understand that these twsts are not reliable  and prove nothing.
Why do you think they are not used

So of what actual use are they?

[Mr Gray]

Don’t worry I’ll wait.

UK papers claim that FF said the phonecalls actually prove CBs innocence,... FF says he has not spoken to the UK papers

[Eleanor]

Libellous innuendo ? That’s a new one.

Not on this Forum it isn't.

[Mr Gray]

So of what actual use are they?

as they are not used by UK police or courts...then no use.  Jeremy Kyle seems to like them. In reality they can provide intelligence...i beleive some insurance companies use them..but not proof as Kizzy repeatedly claims

[Eleanor]

So of what actual use are they?

They aren't of any use.  And not acceptable in any Court of Law.

[kizzy]

quoting the sun again...no credibility.


the way I see it they were asked if the would take  a polygraph....gerry answered..

if the PJ asked us to
If they were admissable
if they were reliable
 

Some have taken this as an agreemnet to take  atest.

IMO it absolutely isnt. Its expalining why they wouldnt take the test. Its all about context. IMO the McCans never agreed to a test and therefore never changed their mind. Unless aposter can come up with proof they agreed to take a test everything is specualtion

 IMO the McCans never agreed to a test and therefore never changed their mind.

Well, it's just the obvious thing to do if you are telling the truth IMO.

Look well if CB takes one and passes ...how would you react to that.

I have already said if mccs had done one and passed I would believe them.

[faithlilly]

Then you need to read it again...It says they may help. Anyone with a basic level of intelligence will understand that these twsts are not reliable  and prove nothing.
Why do you think they are not used

Yes, it may help.....and if you asked almost all parents that would be enough.

[faithlilly]

UK papers claim that FF said the phonecalls actually prove CBs innocence,... FF says he has not spoken to the UK papers

You can’t produce the cite, can you ? That’s okay, we’re used to it from you.

[faithlilly]

They aren't of any use.  And not acceptable in any Court of Law.

But they move the investigation on. An self respecting parent would grab that chance.

[G-Unit]

"Those thousands of Sun readers asked a question (allegedly) and got an answer. Kate and Gerry were not happy to do anything to help clear their names. They had conditions. End of story."

This statement is bordering on Libellous Innuendo.

The source said, "Kate and Gerry are happy to do anything that will help clear their names.”
https://themaddiecasefiles.com/we-ll-do-lie-test-the-sun-21-09-07-t3058.html

"Anything" didn't include a lie detector test unless it was requested and run by police, however. Therefore they wouldn't just do "anything", would they? That isn't innuendo nor libel, it's a factual account of what was reported.

[Eleanor]

But they move the investigation on. An self respecting parent would grab that chance.

How can they move the investigation on if they can't be trusted?

[Eleanor]

Who dragged this one up?  And of what use is it?