You keep stretching that elastic it's gonna snap back and hit you in the grid, causing superficial swelling and / or lacerations.
Which timeline are you using?
How do you know any of either of them are factual?
Why didn't Gerry check for this 'intruder' at the time, given that his 3 kids were in mortal danger? I'd have gone in to stealth mode at that point - but then I am trained to remain calm under pressure.
If Matt found the door ajar, how did the 'intruder' get out, through the window?
Jesus.
How do I know any of either of them are factual? I don't that is why I inserted IMO, look before you leap General.
Having said that there is no reason at all why this couldn't have happened IMO. The abductor waits for everyone to arrive at their destination, he see's a check being done, one of the friends listened outside, so he thought to himself ok I have time to take Madeleine. He entered 5a but Gerry came to do a check, he wasn't expecting Gerry so either he hid or he left by the front door. Entering again when Gerry had gone, this time keeping the window open in case he was interrupted again.
As for why didn't Gerry look for the intruder, why would he think anyone was there? He thought maybe Madeleine had used the toilet.
Instead of running down what everyone else thinks what happened, why don't you put your own thoughts to what you think happened?