Author Topic: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?  (Read 131800 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Ady37

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #495 on: November 02, 2020, 10:10:35 PM »
@Vertigo Swirl

“Ady, Please give this one a go as well.  I’ve changed a few of the identifying details for you”

I recognised the statement when I saw it as being from the Bernadette Walker case. Look here and you will see analysis of it. I added some myself in the comments section there. I post under the handle “frommindtomatter” there.

http://statement-analysis.blogspot.com/2020/10/the-disappearance-of-missing-teen.html

If you look through the archives you will be able to study thousands of cases dating back to 2012. Many cases have analysis of suspects who pleaded their innocence but were later found to be guilty. The analysis shows where their deception was indicated prior to them being arrested and convicted. Peter Hyatt runs the site and uses it as an advertisement for his services which are training of law enforcement and other professionals in deception detection training.

To answer your questions from your earlier post - I have studied SA for about three and a half years. I started reading and learning from books and later took Mark McClish`s training course. It is like most things in the sense of the more time and practice you put into it the easier it becomes to spot deception. SA is not just about deception it is a tool which allows its user to be fully aware of what they are being told. Hypothetical example from a fictitious car manufacturer –

“Our new model is probably the most economical on the market”

Note they are not saying “it is” the most economical, but “is probably” the most economical. That tells us they don’t know. If they did no doubt they would be sure to let us know. Always take words “literally”. That’s what their there for.

Adrian.

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #496 on: November 02, 2020, 10:12:47 PM »
Perhaps Kate didn't notice them in the crowd in 5A....Or;

I would like to mention that at approximately 20.00 on the 5th May, I arrived at the McCann apartment with other family communications officers.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JIM_McGARVEY.htm
Yes, the same FLOs who saw nothing suspicious in the McCanns actions or behaviour, yet here we are 13 years later, a bunch of anonymous internet know-it-alls dissecting their statements and reading guilt into their every uttered word.  Such fun!
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline Ady37

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #497 on: November 02, 2020, 10:15:28 PM »
@Davel

Hi, I understand where you are coming from, at least from your perspective. Please understand that these are not my opinions, they are observations. I am stating what is there in black and white. If someone says -

“I think I left the cooker on”

What they are saying is “they are not sure” if they left it on. That is not my opinion, it is an observation made from the words they used. They used the word “think” to signal they are not sure, and we should believe them.
The problem comes when someone says –

“I don’t think I killed him”

We observe they didn’t say “I didn’t kill him” which would be a strong denial, but instead told us “I don’t think I killed him”. We can see that the person is not sure if they killed him or not. Their words revealed to us what they were thinking at the time they made that statement. In analysis of a statement I may say that the speaker when saying “think” is not sure (of whatever it is connected to) as they needed to use the word “think”. Hopefully you can see it is actually the speaker who is giving us their opinion in their own words rather than me giving mine on what they have said. I just listen carefully to what they are saying and make an observation.

I will say that sometimes I read something back which I have posted and wish I had worded it differently. I am not trying to say that I know who did this or that etc… but rather point out what a person is thinking when their statement was made. That is based from their own words. If there is deception there and I see it I will point it out as well.

Adrian.

Offline Eleanor

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #498 on: November 02, 2020, 10:15:38 PM »
Yes, the same FLOs who saw nothing suspicious in the McCanns actions or behaviour, yet here we are 13 years later, a bunch of anonymous internet know-it-alls dissecting their statements and reading guilt into their every uttered word.  Such fun!

Thanks.  My sentiments entirely.

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #499 on: November 02, 2020, 10:46:47 PM »
@Vertigo Swirl

“Ady, Please give this one a go as well.  I’ve changed a few of the identifying details for you”

I recognised the statement when I saw it as being from the Bernadette Walker case. Look here and you will see analysis of it. I added some myself in the comments section there. I post under the handle “frommindtomatter” there.

http://statement-analysis.blogspot.com/2020/10/the-disappearance-of-missing-teen.html

If you look through the archives you will be able to study thousands of cases dating back to 2012. Many cases have analysis of suspects who pleaded their innocence but were later found to be guilty. The analysis shows where their deception was indicated prior to them being arrested and convicted. Peter Hyatt runs the site and uses it as an advertisement for his services which are training of law enforcement and other professionals in deception detection training.

To answer your questions from your earlier post - I have studied SA for about three and a half years. I started reading and learning from books and later took Mark McClish`s training course. It is like most things in the sense of the more time and practice you put into it the easier it becomes to spot deception. SA is not just about deception it is a tool which allows its user to be fully aware of what they are being told. Hypothetical example from a fictitious car manufacturer –

“Our new model is probably the most economical on the market”

Note they are not saying “it is” the most economical, but “is probably” the most economical. That tells us they don’t know. If they did no doubt they would be sure to let us know. Always take words “literally”. That’s what their there for.

Adrian.
I’d be impressed by the analysis of the Walker statement if it had been published prior to the arrest and charging of the mother.  You say “take words literally” but in my opinion the opposite is happening in your analysis.
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline G-Unit

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #500 on: November 02, 2020, 11:28:57 PM »
Yes, the same FLOs who saw nothing suspicious in the McCanns actions or behaviour, yet here we are 13 years later, a bunch of anonymous internet know-it-alls dissecting their statements and reading guilt into their every uttered word.  Such fun!

In case you didn't notice, the quote mentions the arrival at the McCanns by the FLO's on 5th May, as Kate said, which was the topic under discussion.

As to your unconnected comment I have to wonder why Stuart Prior felt it necessary to censor the questions the PJ wanted to be asked of the FLO's.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #501 on: November 02, 2020, 11:59:46 PM »
In case you didn't notice, the quote mentions the arrival at the McCanns by the FLO's on 5th May, as Kate said, which was the topic under discussion.

As to your unconnected comment I have to wonder why Stuart Prior felt it necessary to censor the questions the PJ wanted to be asked of the FLO's.
Who cares?  The FLOs made it clear the McCanns behaviour gave them no cause for suspicion, and these men were trained, professionals, not anonymous self-trained exponents of pseudoscientific statement analysis.
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline Robittybob1

Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Robittybob1

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #503 on: November 03, 2020, 12:49:39 AM »
Adrian or Ady37 your analysis of the McCann meeting has serious flaws as you have not considered the presence of the FCOs and the UK Ambassador to Portugal being present in Praia da Luz.

You say the second announcement was on the 4th, but it is hard to see when exactly when the first announcement occurred at 10:00 PM on the 4th.    Did the second announcement happen less than 2 hours after that?   I suppose that is possible.  What do you think?

Doesn't that affect the substance of what is being said?  What are you expected to say just hours after your more detailed announcement?
« Last Edit: November 03, 2020, 06:41:05 AM by Robittybob1 »
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Robittybob1

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #504 on: November 03, 2020, 07:23:29 AM »
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=11772.msg624945#msg624945

"The McCann’s have made many statements over the years. I will give the transcript of the second one they made to the media on May 4th the day after Madeleine went missing, but first think about this -

Imagine you had nipped over to a friend’s house that lives down the road from you.  On returning home from the friend’s house you find your car has been stolen. A reporter from a local news station comes to cover the theft and says you can make a statement to appeal for help finding it and they will put in on the news that evening. What would you say? This is a big opportunity to get any message you want out to a massive audience. Would you say something like the below?

“I came home from my friend’s house this evening to find someone had taken my car. It was taken between 7:00pm to 7:30pm. Please, if anyone was around Smith Street around that time could you please think back if you saw anything which seemed suspicious? Do you remember any people or vehicles you saw at that time, as they could be the key to finding my car? My car is a four year old silver coloured ford escort with alloy wheels. There is a crack in the front bumper under the passenger side light. This car means the world to me and I am desperate to get it back.”

Now imagine it wasn’t your car that had been taken but your child. You may say even more than the above and with a lot more emotional content included. This is what Gerry said to the media –

"We would like to make another short statement related to Madeleine's disappearance.

First of all we would like to thank everyone here in Portugal, the UK and elsewhere for all your support during this extremingly... extremely difficult time for our family.

We are pleased that the family liaison officers from Leicestershire are now working closely with the Portuguese Police, and in keeping us informed. We have no further information regarding the investigation but appreciate the significant efforts everyone is making on our behalf.

We would again like to [appeal for any information], however small, that [may] lead to the safe return of Madeleine.

Finally we would like to thank the media for respecting our privacy especially that of Madeleine's little brother and sister.”"

So when was this announcement, if the first was also on the 4th at 10:00 PM?

Some analysis:

"Note the statement starts with what they would like to do. That is to “make another [short] statement [related] to Madeleine's disappearance.”

We see they want us to know the statement will be “short”. Why when their daughter is missing would they be thinking about how short their statement will be, why would the length of it be important or on their mind? Gerry doesn’t have to say the word “short” and if it was removed from the sentence it would not affect it, yet he chooses to include it which shows it is sensitive to him. It suggests that he wants to limit what he is going to say. Next notice the statement will be “related” to Madeleine's disappearance (related means “connected” to). Was he expecting people may think he was going to speak of something unrelated. Expected is for him to say “about” showing it is “concerning” her disappearance."

Could it have been short because it was happening around midnight on the 4th?"

"He says “related to Madeleine's disappearance”. This leaves the listener wondering who Madeleine is. There is no full social introduction made or possession taken of her. The expected is “our daughter Madeleine” which tells who she is in relation to them. It also takes possession of her by saying “our” daughter. After this opening statement Gerry says –

"First of all we would like to thank everyone here in Portugal” etc…

This tells us the first thing of importance to him is to thank a list of people. We are expecting that it would be Madeleine who would be placed first. His next priority is to say how pleased he is with various agencies related to the case. So we see Madeleine is not his first or second priority, and we note he has dedicated a lot of words from his “short” statement to other things than talking of his missing daughter. If you look at his statement and count the words he has used in total, and then count how many of them were concerning finding Madeleine, you will be shocked to see how little was used on her. Out of 123 words used, only 20 of those were about finding Madeleine. It is only near the end of his statement he speaks of her –"

Wasn't this because of the personnel who had arrived in Portugal from England and the Ambassador who had come down from Lisbon?

"“We would again like to [appeal for any information], however small, that [may] lead to the safe return of Madeleine.”

That is the appeal for information. Think about the example I gave earlier about the missing car and how much detail it went into. Can we consider the 20 words above to be an appeal? They are not appealing for anything. Where are the details, how can someone help if they have nothing to go on. Where is the emotional content? They do not even take possession of her by saying “our daughter”."

Wasn't all this explained to the press just an hour or so before"

"As human beings we speak from our hearts. Our thoughts and feelings dictate the words which come from our mouths. If those thoughts and feelings are not there, then there is nowhere for the words to come from. When the expected words don’t come from someone relative to what they are experiencing we question why.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #505 on: November 03, 2020, 07:58:13 AM »
6 FLO’s (that’s trained police officers used to dealing with law breakers and traumatised victims)  were asked the question

“Was there anything done or said by Kate or Gerry McCann in your presence or during various contacts that could raise any suspicion that they could have had any knowledge of what could have happened to Madeleine, beyond the circumstances described to the Portuguese investigators”.

All six replied

“No”.

I think their views trump the views of those who did not witness their actions and utterences first hand, who did not have access to them when the cameras were off, who are not experienced in dealing with individuals in such circumstances.

Now if you are a sceptic you must either believe that all six FLO’s are just not very perceptive or you must believe they were part of a conspiracy to protect the McCanns.

So which is it?
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline Mr Gray

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #506 on: November 03, 2020, 08:02:12 AM »
@Davel

Hi, I understand where you are coming from, at least from your perspective. Please understand that these are not my opinions, they are observations. I am stating what is there in black and white. If someone says -

“I think I left the cooker on”

What they are saying is “they are not sure” if they left it on. That is not my opinion, it is an observation made from the words they used. They used the word “think” to signal they are not sure, and we should believe them.
The problem comes when someone says –

“I don’t think I killed him”

We observe they didn’t say “I didn’t kill him” which would be a strong denial, but instead told us “I don’t think I killed him”. We can see that the person is not sure if they killed him or not. Their words revealed to us what they were thinking at the time they made that statement. In analysis of a statement I may say that the speaker when saying “think” is not sure (of whatever it is connected to) as they needed to use the word “think”. Hopefully you can see it is actually the speaker who is giving us their opinion in their own words rather than me giving mine on what they have said. I just listen carefully to what they are saying and make an observation.

I will say that sometimes I read something back which I have posted and wish I had worded it differently. I am not trying to say that I know who did this or that etc… but rather point out what a person is thinking when their statement was made. That is based from their own words. If there is deception there and I see it I will point it out as well.

Adrian.



----------------------------------------------------------------------------

my answer..
What I see in your posts is pure bunkum. ..   And you dont seem to have the insight to see how ridiculously weak your arguments are.

Does Gerry say....I don't think Maddie died due to an accident....does he say...We probably have nothing to do with her disappearnce. No he doesnt...hes quite definite in what he says so stop muddying the waters.

There is no doubt that an experienced detective can pick up things in a statemnt that might suggest things....there is no doubt he could teach others these things. Hyatt uses this to make a factual basis for SA. In reality it doesnt have one.

You have drawn inferences from the McCAnns  statements which you see as facts, they are not...they are your opinions. An opinion based on your erroneous belief that an online course in what is really a junk science gives you some kind of expertise.

You then feel that a forum run by someone making  a living out of peddling this ridiculous nonsense gives it some sort of credibility...It doesnt and shows how little you understand about evidence.

I watched  a video with RD Hall re the Manchester bombings where the sateemnts were examined by an SA expert who concluded that the bombings were false...do you agree with that?  If you answer yes it shows your total lack of credibility ...if you answer no...it shows SA is not relaible.

what is your answer?


« Last Edit: November 03, 2020, 10:28:05 AM by Robittybob1 »

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #507 on: November 03, 2020, 08:17:00 AM »
Thanks Davel, I just watched a few minutes of the SA talking about the Arena Bombing in which she claims bereaved relatives, victims, young children are lying about their experiences because they use “distancing “ language.  I find this need to paint victims as liars and deny them their own awful experiences quite evil actually. 
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline Mr Gray

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #508 on: November 03, 2020, 08:19:46 AM »
The Scientific Content Analysis (SCAN) is a verbal veracity assessment method that is currently used worldwide by investigative authorities. Yet, research investigating the accuracy of SCAN is scarce. The present study tested whether SCAN was able to accurately discriminate between true and fabricated statements. To this end, 117 participants were asked to write down one true and one fabricated statement about a recent negative event that happened in their lives. All statements were analyzed using 11 criteria derived from SCAN. Results indicated that SCAN was not able to correctly classify true and fabricated statements. Lacking empirical support, the application of SCAN in its current form should be discouraged.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4766305/

Offline Mr Gray

Re: What gives us the right to judge the McCanns and find them wanting?
« Reply #509 on: November 03, 2020, 08:40:18 AM »
Thanks Davel, I just watched a few minutes of the SA talking about the Arena Bombing in which she claims bereaved relatives, victims, young children are lying about their experiences because they use “distancing “ language.  I find this need to paint victims as liars and deny them their own awful experiences quite evil actually.
So either SA is unreliable or the Manchester bombing was a hoax and all these victims are lying
« Last Edit: November 03, 2020, 09:39:55 AM by Davel »