@G-Unit
“SA, imo, is attempting to teach people how to do something which a good detective can do without training. Perhaps it can't be taught by learning a set of rules.”
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/hopolicers/prs135.pdfA quote from the document you linked –
“The results of this study demonstrated that the three groups of SCAN trained officers (Groups 1 to 3)appeared to perform better in comparison with the untrained officers within Groups 4 and 5 (see Table 4). All five groups, however, were able to discriminate between truthful and deceitful statements above the level of chance. Statistically significant differences in performance were only identified between the three SCAN groups and the newly recruited police officers who had no training in the SCAN technique (Group 5); no statistically significant differences were found between the three SCAN groups and the experienced detectives (Group 4).Therefore, while SCAN trained officers were able to discriminate between truthful and deceitful statements with a degree of accuracy, so too were the experienced detectives, untrained in the SCAN technique.”
It says the SCAN trained officers performed as well as the experienced detectives which proves that using SCAN raised the level of their ability to that of an experienced detective, which some would say is impressive. Note though it doesn’t say how much training they had received in SCAN or how long they had been using it. Most training in SCAN is done by attending a course over a few days. That allows for the information to be given to the trainee via lectures and supporting literature. It is then up to the individual to put what he/she has learned into practice. The problem is that it can’t be expected that someone can absorb all that information in such a short time and then go off and hope to analyse statements with high accuracy immediately. When someone attends a college or university or does an apprenticeship to train, their learning is spread over time allowing for more in depth coverage of the subject. Also after their studies they will take a test to see if they have mastered the subject to a high enough standard. Even then they must go into the real world and put what they have learned into practice and learn from their mistakes and gain experience. A SCAN trainee does not have the benefit of training over time in a classroom or the feedback from exams. If they are using the system or some of the techniques within it incorrectly then it is likely they will go on doing so.
The document says the SCAN trained officers had inconsistencies in how they had applied SCAN to the different statements in the study. That is a problem as it shows they are not all applying the system in the same way which shows their understanding of the training is not on the same level as each other. A better test would have been to have used SCAN instructors to take part in the study as then it would have been an opportunity to show the full potential of the technique from the standpoint of using people who have long term confirmed experience using it.
A proper assessment of SCAN can only be achieved if tests are done using experienced subjects. Sending people on a three day course then expecting they can be tested and useful data garnered is ridiculous. I can speak from my experience of studying and using SCAN that it took between 18 months to two years before I had a deep enough understanding of it to be able to use it effectively. That came from reading hundreds of statements from both guilty and innocent subjects, analysing press interviews and current crime and other information in the media.
SCAN is a tool which is primarily used to spot deception, but it can reveal much more than that. Note just because someone is deceptive it does not mean they are guilty. When someone is deceptive in relation to a crime it must be investigated. For example in an interview it allows the interviewer to focus on areas where clarification is needed. Example -
Interviewer: What do you do for a living?
Subject: I trained as a Doctor
Many people would interpret the subjects answer to mean they are a doctor. The fact is they never said they were a doctor only that they trained as one. The interviewer familiar in SCAN doesn’t interpret their answer, they ask more questions until they are satisfied they have a definitive answer. After further questions it will be discovered if the subject is a doctor or something else. If it is discovered they are a doctor, the interviewer also learnt that when asked about their current profession the subjects mind went back to what they did to get there rather than what they are now.
Adrian.