Abduction is neither plausible nor logical because…

[Lace]

I've already explained, there's at least a three & a half hour window from the last independent sighting.

If Brueckner is supposed to have removed Maddie totally undetected then there's no reason Gerry couldn't do the same.

If CB removed Madeleine then it would have been after nine o clock when it was dark.

You are either talking abut the McCann's removing Madeleine either before dinner,  when it was still light and Gerry was playing tennis,  or when Gerry did his check,  which didn't give him enough time as he was talking to Jeremy.

[Lace]

Yes, & the GNR saw them kneeling to Mecca.

Did they?  I'm sure they didn't understand their need for prayer in desperation for help as they didn't think things were moving quickly enough for them. 

[Wonderfulspam]

If CB removed Madeleine then it would have been after nine o clock when it was dark.

You are either talking abut the McCann's removing Madeleine either before dinner,  when it was still light and Gerry was playing tennis,  or when Gerry did his check,  which didn't give him enough time as he was talking Jeremy.

How long precisely was Gerry away from the table & how much of that time did he spend talking to Jeremy?

[Wonderfulspam]

Did they?  I'm sure they didn't understand their need for prayer in desperation for help as they didn't think things were moving quickly enough for them.

Well, neither of them phoned the police in the first place so that wouldn't have helped.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I've already explained, there's at least a three & a half hour window from the last independent sighting.

If Brueckner is supposed to have removed Maddie totally undetected then there's no reason Gerry couldn't do the same.

Except it was broad daylight with more people about.

[barrier]

If CB removed Madeleine then it would have been after nine o clock when it was dark.

You are either talking abut the McCann's removing Madeleine either before dinner,  when it was still light and Gerry was playing tennis,  or when Gerry did his check,  which didn't give him enough time as he was talking to Jeremy.

Even Wolters doesn't claim his suspect took Madeleine out of 5a, so why do assume he did.

[Wonderfulspam]

Even Wolters doesn't claim his suspect took Madeleine out of 5a, so why do assume he did.

The evidence suggests Kate opened the window & passed Maddie to Brueckner, that's why Kate's prints were on the window & not Brueckners.

[G-Unit]

Can you please be more precise about the limited window of opportunity.  Was it under a minute?  Under two minutes? Under five minutes? And how did you arrive at your deduction? 
In total how many actual minutes did members of the group spend in a such a position as to hamper the ability of an abductor to enter the apartment either via the patio doors or via the window?

Why don't you prove me and the PJ wrong?
 

[Vertigo Swirl]

Why don't you prove me and the PJ wrong?

Prove them wrong about what?  Why don’t you stick to the thread topic and prove that abduction is neither plausible nor logical.

[Wonderfulspam]

Except it was broad daylight with more people about.

Were there more people about?

Did you conduct a survey?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Were there more people about?

Did you conduct a survey?

yes.

[Anthro]

There is no evidence regarding means, and the motive is questionable. As to opportunity, it was extremely limited by the reported movements of the group. The neglect, by the way, was ignoring guidelines and leaving small children home alone. Others passing the apartment on their way elsewhere were not checking on the McCann children, but would have hampered a potential abductor.

Guidelines are exactly that. Guidelines. Surely, one doesn’t take the expense and effort to vacate in another country just to be restricted by guidelines. “Leaving small children home alone”, according to you, is way too a simplistic explanation. My opinion.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

Prove them wrong about what?  Why don’t you stick to the thread topic and prove that abduction is neither plausible nor logical.

To answer if it is plausible or logical we need to know what time this alleged abduction took place.

[Eleanor]

It seems to me that this is a competition between those who want Madeleine to be dead and those who don't.  I cannot begin to understand the minds of those who do.

[G-Unit]

It seems to me that this is a competition between those who want Madeleine to be dead and those who don't.  I cannot begin to understand the minds of those who do.

Why would anyone want a child to be dead? That's ridiculous. The reality is that whatever happened that night it's sadly highly unlikely that she survived it. What people want has nothing to do with it. Wolters told it like it is - the abduction that some people are so desperate to believe in would not have had a happy ending in his opinion.