Maddie Basta de Mentiras

[kizzy]

We know that according to the PJ the main evidence against the mccanns was the dog alerts.. We therefore know as a fact that they misinterpreted the evidence

We therefore know as a fact that they misinterpreted the evidence

But did they - its not as if they found nothing or anything anywhere else imo

[G-Unit]

We know that according to the PJ the main evidence against the mccanns was the dog alerts.. We therefore know as a fact that they misinterpreted the evidence

There's nothing to stop the police or anyone else from interpreting uncorroberated evidence how they wish. Some people, for example, interpret an alleged open window and shutters as a sign that a stranger abduction occured.

[Mr Gray]

We therefore know as a fact that they misinterpreted the evidence

But did they - its not as if they found nothing or anything anywhere else imo

Yes they did... It's s fact.  Amaral claimed the alerts confirmed a cadaver had been in 5a... They didn't confirm thst at all. 

They suggested a cadaver MAY have been in 5a

[Mr Gray]

There's nothing to stop the police or anyone else from interpreting uncorroberated evidence how they wish. Some people, for example, interpret an alleged open window and shutters as a sign that a stranger abduction occured.

the window is evidence that supports third party involvement... That's a fact

[jassi]

As the identity of the window opener is unknown, how can the event of the window being opened point in any direction, other than someone exercising their opinion ?

[kizzy]

Yes they did... It's s fact.  Amaral claimed the alerts confirmed a cadaver had been in 5a... They didn't confirm thst at all. 

They suggested a cadaver MAY have been in 5a

They suggested a cadaver MAY have been in 5a

Exactly - an seeing no one else it seems died in the apartment.

Cadaver [a dead body] could have been in 5a ....not there was no cadaver.

[kizzy]

It was, sent to the prtuguese govt for their obssevations in Jan.. It has to go back and forth a few times and each exchange takes about three months.  The wheels are in motion

Think its what most people think....seems what wolt  says - is water of a ducks back


Gonçalo Amaral: Today I learned that the German prosecutor has stated, if indeed he has affirmed it, that we performed inefficiently and that they (Germans) can do in a weeks time the work that we, the Portuguese police, have done in six months of investigation. Of what he accuses us, I can only say, for my part not as in charge of the police, but for my part as a citizen, as the coordinator of the Judiciary Police at that time, as a the person that was in charge of the men and women that gave everything to find this child and to know what happened to her, we can only say to that gentleman, to the prosecutor: Get over yourself! (i.e. know your place) and be ware that here in Portugal we are very aware of what is being said. Donkey's voices don't reach the heavens (i.e. similar to the British idiomatic expression "like water off a duck's back"), not even his.

 https://sicnoticias.pt/especiais/caso-maddie---10-anos/2021-10-13-Goncalo-Amaral-lanca-novo-livro-sobre-Maddie-927f1efa

[Eleanor]

Something or someone was passed through that window in my opinion.

[G-Unit]

the window is evidence that supports third party involvement... That's a fact

The window is uncorroberated evidence, just as the cadaver dog alerts are. The significance is opinion in both examples.

[Mr Gray]

The window is uncorroberated evidence, just as the cadaver dog alerts are. The significance is opinion in both examples.

So you accept it's evidence.. As it is.

How much value is, attached to the evidence depends on other factors

[G-Unit]

So you accept it's evidence.. As it is.

How much value is, attached to the evidence depends on other factors

Like who else saw it. We all saw the cadaver dog alerting.

[Mr Gray]

Like who else saw it. We all saw the cadaver dog alerting.

Lol.... And Grime explained it's significance

[Mr Gray]

We therefore know as a fact that they misinterpreted the evidence

But did they - its not as if they found nothing or anything anywhere else imo

Yes 100%...there, was no confirmation of a cadaver in 5a..
It's a fact they misunderstood thr evidence... It's telling you don't realise that

[Mr Gray]

They suggested a cadaver MAY have been in 5a

Exactly - an seeing no one else it seems died in the apartment.

Cadaver [a dead body] could have been in 5a ....not there was no cadaver.

Amaral claimed a cadaver was confirmed... He should realise he, was wrong

[Mr Gray]

Think its what most people think....seems what wolt  says - is water of a ducks back


Gonçalo Amaral: Today I learned that the German prosecutor has stated, if indeed he has affirmed it, that we performed inefficiently and that they (Germans) can do in a weeks time the work that we, the Portuguese police, have done in six months of investigation. Of what he accuses us, I can only say, for my part not as in charge of the police, but for my part as a citizen, as the coordinator of the Judiciary Police at that time, as a the person that was in charge of the men and women that gave everything to find this child and to know what happened to her, we can only say to that gentleman, to the prosecutor: Get over yourself! (i.e. know your place) and be ware that here in Portugal we are very aware of what is being said. Donkey's voices don't reach the heavens (i.e. similar to the British idiomatic expression "like water off a duck's back"), not even his.

 https://sicnoticias.pt/especiais/caso-maddie---10-anos/2021-10-13-Goncalo-Amaral-lanca-novo-livro-sobre-Maddie-927f1efa

Amaral still doesn't understand the evidence