The Evidence Madeleine Was Taken In A Criminal Act By A Stranger.

[barrier]

Maybe he corrected Kate's mistake.

Defence to prosecution, what open window ?

[G-Unit]

I think I will leave it to the three Police investigations,  investigating abduction.

I think that's a good idea. Some people tried to make sense of the damages trial and the ECHR appeal and got it completely wrong.

[Wonderfulspam]

Defence to prosecution, what open window ?

"Mrs McCann/Healy, could you demonstrate to the court once again how the curtains just blew open"

[Vertigo Swirl]

I think that's a good idea. Some people tried to make sense of the damages trial and the ECHR appeal and got it completely wrong.

If you really thought it was a good idea you'd keep quiet and wait and see what eventuates, instead of speculating, and basing your research on an incomplete set of information. 

[Vertigo Swirl]

Defence to prosecution, what open window ?

Are you suggesting that an open window would have somehow incriminated the McCanns?  Please explain. 

[jassi]

Maybe just maybe thats why it remains unsolved.

Yup, if you concentrate solely on an abduction theory, you are unlikely to pay any attention to anything else.

[Wonderfulspam]

If you really thought it was a good idea you'd keep quiet and wait and see what eventuates, instead of speculating, and basing your research on an incomplete set of information.

You'd be waiting a long time.

[barrier]

Are you suggesting that an open window would have somehow incriminated the McCanns?  Please explain.

Nope, I'm trying to fathom the open window which a half decent defence would question, but I doubt any prosecution would rely on it .This thread is about stranger abduction and evidence there of.

[G-Unit]

If you really thought it was a good idea you'd keep quiet and wait and see what eventuates, instead of speculating, and basing your research on an incomplete set of information.

Incomplete maybe, but I try to post about what is known rather than relying on the belief that OG have everything under control.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Incomplete maybe, but I try to post about what is known rather than relying on the belief that OG have everything under control.

Can't you see how you are contradicting yourself?  You think it's a good idea to "leave it to the three Police investigations,  investigating abduction" but at the same time you're don't want to rely on them having everything under control.  So what exactly do you see as your role in all of this? 

[kizzy]

Can you imagine finding your daughter missing?   Have you ever tried to put yourself in the place of Kate a mother who couldn't find her daughter?

You talk as though she should have acted as if she was a Police woman 'better not touch the window because of finger prints'  'better shut the window'  'don't go into the apartment its all evidence'.    Kate wouldn't have been thinking any of this her main course of action was to search for her child.

It's great to look at it with no compassion  isn't it,   knowing what happened next.

Now just a minute here, how is your reply any evidence to show Maddie was abducted

Your post again is just telling me how I should feel....just because you do .

You believe Maddie was abducted ...I don't ...hence lack of compassion.

My point was why she closed the window...when she got back and not before she left twins still inside [destroying evidence, it seems if there was any]

Why when she took over 10 mins to search the apartment and knew Maddie had been taken and let 20-plus people into the room what was the point/motive for that? [destroying any evidence it seems, if there was any]

[kizzy]

Are you suggesting that an open window would have somehow incriminated the McCanns?  Please explain.

It seems to me it wouldn't incriminate the mccs...them saying the window was open.

The incrimination or point is whether it was open or not. IMO

[Lace]

Now just a minute here, how is your reply any evidence to show Maddie was abducted

Your post again is just telling me how I should feel....just because you do .

You believe Maddie was abducted ...I don't ...hence lack of compassion.

My point was why she closed the window...when she got back and not before she left twins still inside [destroying evidence, it seems if there was any]

Why when she took over 10 mins to search the apartment and knew Maddie had been taken and let 20-plus people into the room what was the point/motive for that? [destroying any evidence it seems, if there was any]

No not how you feel but how Kate would have felt.   You are proving again that you have no idea how someone would react when finding their child missing.   You seem intent on making out the McCann's were destroying evidence when first of all Kate is supposed to have opened the window to stage an abduction but leaving her fingerprints on it,  then closing it!!  How is that staging an abduction?   People entered 5a including the Police with dogs the Police left ash everywhere.   I don't think it was the McCann's who destroyed evidence.

[Lace]

Defence to prosecution, what open window ?

Why would Kate say the window was open if it hadn't been?

[Wonderfulspam]

No not how you feel but how Kate would have felt.   You are proving again that you have no idea how someone would react when finding their child missing.   You seem intent on making out the McCann's were destroying evidence when first of all Kate is supposed to have opened the window to stage an abduction but leaving her fingerprints on it,  then closing it!!  How is that staging an abduction?   People entered 5a including the Police with dogs the Police left ash everywhere.   I don't think it was the McCann's who destroyed evidence.

Does Kate? You're presuming once again that MWTIACABAS, when there's scant evidence to support that, except the McCanns untested testimony.