Why are cadaver dogs ridiculed so much by some people?

[registrar]

I'm balanced on my head on a beam 6 inches wide suspended between the top of the Empire State Building and the next skyscraper, simultaneously juggling half-a-dozen tennis balls with my feet and reading all this, and not believing a word ....

steady Eddy

we wish not to lose a valued poster

[debunker]

No Debunker there was more than one as you well know

Please specify where Eddie alerted and Keela did not in 5a.

[Luz]

To those that question the dogs:

[debunker]

That displays your level of debate.

[Jean-Pierre]

Nobody is ridiculing cadaver or any sniffer or search dogs.  They are invaluable for narrowing down the serach area.  They indicate where forensic material may be located.  Which can then be collected, and which may help in solving a crime.

In this case, no forensic material was found. 

[Admin]

Luz, it goes without saying that even Martin Grime was not in a position to state that Eddie's alerts had any connection with Madeleine McCann because he couldn't do so.  Can you imagine how silly he would look if she then turns up alive and well?

Think about it!

[Luz]

Luz, it goes without saying that even Martin Grime was not in a position to state that Eddie's alerts had any connection with Madeleine McCann because he couldn't do so.  Can you imagine how silly he would look if she then turns up alive and well?

Think about it!

Of course I thought about it. But why should some people keep insisting that the dogs are wrong? The dogs do not have agendas, if they signaled it's because something was there, what it was we don't know for sure, thanks to the best laboratory in the world.

Now, I would be thrilled if Madeleine turned up alive, but I don't have much hope about that.

Thank you Mr. Administrator, Sir   

[ferryman]

 The dogs do not have agendas, ...

Quite right.  They don't.

If only the same were true of humans.

[gilet]

@Luz

There is no debate in your use of smilies.

I have just posted details elsewhere from Amaral's own book of his own criticism of the PJ and their specialists and his comments about how they failed in their work.

It is facts like that that deserve the vomit gif that you used because it is truly stomach churning to think that Amaral and other senior officers in the PJ presided over such a tarnished investigation of the disappearance of a missing child.  Had they been up to the task and had they had procedures to follow then perhaps the investigation may have determined what happened?

[registrar]

The dogs do not have agendas, ...

Quite right.  They don't.

If only the same were true of humans.

or bank accounts that need filling

[Luz]

The dogs do not have agendas, ...

Quite right.  They don't.

If only the same were true of humans.

Let's ask debunker. He seems to know a lot about the subject.

Since you want a debate, what's your agenda debunker?
Are you under contract or are payed for services provided? For how much could a person hire your "debunker" services?

[amaraltheofficeboy]

how silly

[registrar]

Luz - do pipe down

got anything constructive to offer?

[amaraltheofficeboy]

well according to luz she could have done the review without spending a pence (sic)

[registrar]

well according to luz she could have done the review without spending a pence (sic)

Well, Luz is wonderwoman

we all wonder when she posts anything of substance