The Portuguese Police thought the dogs were 100% accurate.

[Mr Gray]

OMG! That has to be the stupidest post of the year, well done!!

 Well first there is no such word as stupidest...the superlative of stupid is ..most stupid..which perhaps would be a better description of your posts than mine

If you understood the post it makes absolutely perfect sense...perhaps the logic is more than a little beyond you

[Mr Gray]

Grime knows so get over it

no he doesn't..he isn't sure...thats why he has to say the alerts are "suggestive" rather than be definite...you probably don't understand this post either

[Redblossom]

Well first there is no such word as stupidest...the superlative of stupid is ..most stupid..which perhaps would be a better description of your posts than mine

If you understood the post it makes absolutely perfect sense...perhaps the logic is more than a little beyond you

Its not my problem  that you have a problem with cadaver dog alerting to the last place a missing child was seen, all yours

 

[Mr Gray]

read the book!

 

yes they ARE libellous, sorry about that

Only in your opinion which you are posting as fact...against forum rules...what evidence do you have to support that statement

[Mr Gray]

Its not my problem  that you have a problem with cadaver dog alerting to the last place a missing child was seen, all yours

 

The problem is that this dog alerted to a coconut

[Redblossom]

no he doesn't..he isn't sure...thats why he has to say the alerts are "suggestive" rather than be definite...you probably don't understand this post either

Of course I dont understand as I am a member of the neanderthal primitive  uneducated class of beings you  are so highly over, silly

Ps suggestive is quite strong btw!Its a bit different to "maybe maybe not" !

[Redblossom]

Only in your opinion which you are posting as fact...against forum rules...what evidence do you have to support that statement

So you havent read Madeleine? By Kate Mccann? Why not? She does state the dogs only react  to please their master amongst other lies


 

its only couple of quid off kindle, do download it, its an eye opener

[icabodcrane]

Even if there were no dog alerts it is possible that a child may have died there...so in that sense it is irrelavent

Well,  no

Had there been no alert by a cadaver dog in the apartment where the missing child was last seen,  then there would be no indication that she may have died there,  and no basis on which to  present it as a rational possibly 

As it is,  of course,  a cadaver dog  did  alert in the apartment where the missing child was last seen,  and that  does  indicate that the missing child may have died there

It is the cadaver dog's alerts that make it reasonable to address the possibility that the missing child never left Apartment 5A  alive

[Redblossom]

The problem is that this dog alerted to a coconut

Ah, lets have the evidence then since you as a scientist would know all about that


Will look back in an hour or so for your "evidence", needs must, toodles for now

[Mr Gray]

So you havent read Madeleine? By Kate Mccann? Why not? She does state the dogs only react  to please their master amongst other lies


 

its only couple of quid off kindle, do download it, its an eye opener

Judging by your previous "quotes" from the book I can pretty much guarantee that your post is innaccurate

[Mr Gray]

Well,  no

Had there been no alert by a cadaver dog in the apartment where the missing child was last seen,  then there would be no indication that she may have died there,  and no basis on which to  present it as a rational possibly 

As it is,  of course,  a cadaver dog  did  alert in the apartment where the missing child was last seen,  and that  does  indicate that the missing child may have died there

It is the cadaver dog's alerts that make it reasonable to address the possibility that the missing child never left Apartment 5A  alive

Sorry you are totally wrong...without an alert a possible death in the apartment would still be a rational possibility...

[Redblossom]

Judging by your previous "quotes" from the book I can pretty much guarantee that your post is innaccurate

You cant  guarantee anything at all  your flakey track record proves it, I have never quoted anything which is untrue, deal with it, your  ignorance of facts is no excuse, see you soon


 

[icabodcrane]

Sorry you are totally wrong...without an alert a possible death in the apartment would still be a rational possibility...

Let me put it another way


We have   an indication    (  in the form of a cadaver dog alert  )  that the missing child may have died in the apartment 


It is the cadaver dog alert  that 'directly'  lends to the possibility of the missing child's death having occured in apartment  5 A

[Mr Gray]

You cant  guarantee anything at all  your flakey track record proves it, I have never quoted anything which is untrue, deal with it, your  ignorance of facts is no excuse, see you soon


 

Yes you have...you quoted that kate said she did not search because it was too dark and cold..you eventually retracted it when I proved you wrong

[Mr Gray]

Let me put it another way


We have   an indication    (  in the form of a cadaver dog alert  )  that the missing child may have died in the apartment 


It is the cadaver dog alert  that 'directly'  lends to the possibility of the missing child's death having occured in apartment  5 A

You can put it any way you want..the fact is...and it is a FACT...that death in the apt is a rational possibility without an alert...I'm right and you are wrong to say the opposite