How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?

[amaraltheofficeboy]

Yes, only connected by the Smiths statement, because of the way Gerry held his son.

no similarity at all to the Tanner sighting though

[amaraltheofficeboy]

two men carrying children in a holiday report - wow

[sadie]

Here we go again ... sighs!


The Smiths saw their man in Rua d'Escola.

A scream was heard coming from the staff quarters according to a poster on the 3A's

The staff quarters were only about 50 metres up the Rua d;Escola from the sighting and the man was coming from that direction

Seems quite likely that a member of staff obtained a front door key and was the lifter of Madeleine



.... So, quite a possibility when the pick up car did not arrive, due to Jane witnessing the abduction, that the only place that bundleman could go was to his accomplis, the lifter, at the staff quarters.

[faithlilly]

two people saw two different people carrying a child at night in a holiday resort.

the only connection is what....??????

the time is different

the location is different

The inappropriate way the child was dressed ? Surely two separate father's would not disregard their child's comfort on such a cold night in the very same way ?

[faithlilly]

two men carrying children in a holiday report - wow

Both children wearing nothing to keep them warm ?

[faithlilly]

Here we go again ... sighs!


The Smiths saw their man in Rua d'Escola.

A scream was heard coming from the staff quarters according to a poster on the 3A's

The staff quarters were only about 50 metres up the Rua d;Escola from the sighting and the man was coming from that direction

Seems quite likely that a member of staff obtained a front door key and was the lifter of Madeleine



.... So, quite a possibility when the pick up car did not arrive, due to Jane witnessing the abduction, that the only place that bundleman could go was to his accomplis, the lifter, at the staff quarters.

A scream was heard according to a poster on h 3as  ? Must be rue then !

[amaraltheofficeboy]

faith are you saying you believe it was the same person or not - having difficulty from your answers?

[sadie]

The inappropriate way the child was dressed ? Surely two separate father's would not disregard their child's comfort on such a cold night in the very same way ?

Why are you keeping on that the carriers were fathers?

The man in the two sightings were very similar and SY and the PT authorities appear to accept the very real likelyhood of an abductor

You seem to be stuck in a groove  ............Why?

Do you have an agenda of some sort?  Are you trying to fulfill that agenda by trying to prove that Gerry 'dunit' ?




Or is this propaganda for Amaral ?  A kind of ACE, so that he can use it in Court somehow to bolster his case?

[sadie]

This is all wumming again

Over and over the same stuff you go, boring the pants off people.

I guess in an effort to drive all the pros away.



It is sooo obviously wumming ... and I cant understand why it is being tolerated.

[faithlilly]

faith are you saying you believe it was the same person or not - having difficulty from your answers?

Just batting ideas about. If it was a father carrying their daughter home then it would almost certainly have to be the same person as it would be most unlikely that two separate fathers would show the same disregard for their children's comfort by  clothing them in inappropriate attire for the weather.

If an abductor then the child was too similar for the carrier to be different.
 
Though I myself don't believe Tanner witnessed what she later claimed and have explained why on other threads.

[faithlilly]

This is all wumming again

Over and over the same stuff you go, boring the pants off people.

I guess in an effort to drive all the pros away.



It is sooo obviously wumming ... and I cant understand why it is being tolerated.

For anyone not familiar with the term 'wumming' means espousing contrary viewpoints purely to string people along and get a reaction from them.

Is that what you think is happening here sadie ? Don't you think robust debate is healthy ?

[faithlilly]

Do you speak English as a second language - there are plenty of courses here you realise.

I think it is you who as problems with English comprehension. My post is perfectly clear.

[icabodcrane]

This is all wumming again

Over and over the same stuff you go, boring the pants off people.

I guess in an effort to drive all the pros away.



It is sooo obviously wumming ... and I cant understand why it is being tolerated.

It might be an idea to stop telling the mods how to do their jobs sadie

They managed perfectly well before the recent influx of us newbies ...  and they'll manage  perfectly well after we've gone

The owner of this website runs the board his way  ...  accept it or leave, that's my advice   (  just please stop complaining all the time  )

[amaraltheofficeboy]

I don't believe they were the same person

thread question answered - I can move on

[faithlilly]

I don't believe they were the same person

thread question answered - I can move on

Please do and leave the adults to their discussion