Author Topic: Why did Amaral and PJ suspect the McCanns and Murat as being somehow involved?  (Read 213320 times)

0 Members and 6 Guests are viewing this topic.

ferryman

  • Guest
Pray tell what the communication problem/disagreement was  ?

Was it 'something' vaguely Eastern European ?

Are you on something?

stephen25000

  • Guest
Are you on something?

Not at all.

So 'ferryman' what or more precisely who was the 'disagreement' over ?   >@@(*&)

Lyall

  • Guest
Well Gerry was playing tennis wasn't he, so how would he know unless kate came to specifically tell him? Kate knew that Gerry was on the spot for the children.  No reason why she shouldn't suddenly decide to go for a jog.

Do you think she should have asked permission?

She left the children on their own you mean?

ferryman

  • Guest
I neither know nor care.

It is obviously irrelevant to Madeleine's abduction and was raised because Kate raised it.

Offline sadie

If Madeleine was already extremely tired at 5.35, this would obviate the need for her parents to give here a sleeping drug.

It does not make sense that they would have been the ones to give her a drug at 5.00 - this would probably have the result of sending her to sleep far earlier than 7.30, and there is nothing to suggest that they wanted their children to go to bed unusually early that night.

It would tally that if Madeleine had been drugged around 5, she would indeed have been very drowsy by 5.35.
So theoretically someone at the complex could have drugged her.

This inside job is getting more complicated though, isn't it Sadie? The accomplice, or one of them, just so happens to have a job which enables him/her to serve the McCann children food.

Another question I have is that if a drug was administered at 5, there would be no guarantee that it would still be in effect several hours later. The abductor happened to have got his chance at 9.15, but he probably wasn't to have known, until then, that the wait for the coast to be clear might have been much longer.
Her parents were not in the habit of giving her a sleeping drug Sherlock.  Why suggest it?

Anne seem s to be an expert on drugs and sedatives.  She might know how long they are effective.

OC is very casual Sherlock.  Anyone attached could wander in and slip a draught in, but yep, it does rather point to nannies, or waiters, or kitchen staff ... but anyone could wander thru.

Offline sadie

Hypothetically, purely hypothetically of course, what if both of the parents had administered a sleeping drug to Madeleine ?

It is known that her parents had 'communication' problems and had slept in separate bedrooms I believe, the night before.
They are very much an item.  No communication probs there.

Gerry was snoring.  I move out when my hubby is snoring.



And Kate was very open about it all.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest

Anne seem s to be an expert on drugs and sedatives.  She might know how long they are effective.

I'm no expert, I do have doctor friends who are.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest

That came to light because Kate volunteered the information.

There was a very undone bed to justify.

Offline sadie

She left the children on their own you mean?
Haven't you read the files Lyall ?  Suggest you do, before making any more, tbh, silly suggestions

They were enjoying themselves at the childrens clubs being looked after by the nannies.

Kate was free to go jogging.

She didn't have to ask your permission ... or Gerrys.

Offline sadie

I'm no expert, I do have doctor friends who are.
Me too, but I prefer not to trouble them.  Am happy for you to provide the info.


stephen25000

  • Guest
They are very much an item.  No communication probs there.

Gerry was snoring.  I move out when my hubby is snoring.



And Kate was very open about it all.

Do you have proof it was over snoring, and not her spouse giving attention to someone else which riled his wife ?

P.S. The book doesn't count.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Would you like to elaborate with pinpointed sources?  Please
Yes of course
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P1/01_VOLUME_Ia_Page_16.jpg

Offline sadie

Do you have proof it was over snoring, and not her spouse giving attention to someone else which riled his wife ?

P.S. The book doesn't count.
Stephen

That is disgusting to even suggest such a thing

I suspect you know that.