Author Topic: interesting statement by the judge  (Read 9878 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Mr Gray

interesting statement by the judge
« on: September 17, 2013, 08:11:23 AM »
When questioning Emma Loach the judge states...

"The fact that they are innocent" when referring to the McCanns..

well done judge

Offline south of the river

Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #1 on: September 17, 2013, 08:28:46 AM »
absolutely when it comes down to it in the eyes of the law of Portugal they are innocent citizens

This is the crux to me - Amaral being the cop in charge says they committed a heinous crime - but yet 6 years later they have never ever been charged for anything

wither he will be found guilty of libel is another thing as depends on so many interpretations of Portuguese libel  law at present my gut is that Amaral will be not be found guilty - but there will be a sting in the tail somewhere

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #2 on: September 17, 2013, 09:01:43 AM »
absolutely when it comes down to it in the eyes of the law of Portugal they are innocent citizens

This is the crux to me - Amaral being the cop in charge says they committed a heinous crime - but yet 6 years later they have never ever been charged for anything

wither he will be found guilty of libel is another thing as depends on so many interpretations of Portuguese libel  law at present my gut is that Amaral will be not be found guilty - but there will be a sting in the tail somewhere

Time will tell on that.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #3 on: September 17, 2013, 12:21:28 PM »
absolutely when it comes down to it in the eyes of the law of Portugal they are innocent citizens

Certainly.
Mr Amaral never intended to judge the McCanns, his job was to find out what happened to their daughter. Among all the hypotheses listed by the AG report he thought he found the right one.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #4 on: September 17, 2013, 01:18:44 PM »
Certainly.
Mr Amaral never intended to judge the McCanns, his job was to find out what happened to their daughter. Among all the hypotheses listed by the AG report he thought he found the right one.

So from all the hypotheses, Amaral chose the one he thought was right.....That's called judging

Redblossom

  • Guest
Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #5 on: September 17, 2013, 05:11:24 PM »
When questioning Emma Loach the judge states...

"The fact that they are innocent" when referring to the McCanns..

well done judge

Do you have the whole piece in context? For those of us who dont have fancy search abilities on our tablets?

Offline Mr Gray


Redblossom

  • Guest
Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #7 on: September 17, 2013, 06:14:44 PM »
http://missingmadeleine.forumotion.net/t24472-kate-and-gerry-innocent
Have a look there


thank you

The  gist I get from that exchange was the judge asking her how come the book might cause people to think they were not innocent when the Public Prosecutor relieved them of their arguido status ie inferring innocent, or saying no evidence found,  somethng which is NOT just online if you google and read the files, but something all the uk papers reported, somethng most people would come across first


It was IMO NOT any kind of declaration that they are innocent or cleared...the judge was playing devils advocate, as they do, thats my reading, you are free to disagree with it

And I dont believe for a second as was intimated that if you google madeleine mccann Mr Amarals book comes up first!

« Last Edit: September 17, 2013, 06:24:11 PM by Redblossom »

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #8 on: September 17, 2013, 06:31:37 PM »
http://missingmadeleine.forumotion.net/t24472-kate-and-gerry-innocent
Have a look there
I had a look on this forum and found that Carolina's interpretation is correct.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #9 on: September 17, 2013, 06:36:13 PM »
I had a look on this forum and found that Carolina's interpretation is correct.

that's your opinion which as a supporter of amaral is biased. I am not quoting opinion, just plain facts, as reported by yourself. the judge referred to the MccANNS as innocent...fact..end of

Redblossom

  • Guest
Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #10 on: September 17, 2013, 06:41:36 PM »
I had a look on this forum and found that Carolina's interpretation is correct.

Agree, context is everythng



Sorry if this has already been discussed but I have not seen it discussed.  I am just a bit unsure what the judge meant by the word innocent in her questioning.  I didn't think the McCanns had been found innocent regarding Madeleine's disappearance, or does it mean innocent in connection with something else?  

The judge (Maria Emília de Melo e Castro) is now asking Emma Loach questions

MC - How did the book hamper the investigation?
EL - says that if everybody thought Madeleine had died then nobody would look for her. If people thought the parents were involved, they wouldn’t help.

MC - But when the book was published the McCanns were no longer arguidos.
EL - says the public, according to the US, is very important to find missing children.

MC - If some people suspect, from where is their conviction formed?
EL - says it is mainly through the internet. GA's book is the first thing that appears on internet. The
people don't know these allegations aren't true according to the criminal investigation.

MC - People don't know?
EL - hesitates, she says the majority don't.

MC - Are the McCanns ashamed of what is said in the book?
EL - answers yes.

MC - Why?
EL - says the public believes they had covered up and then asked for money to search for Madeleine.

MC - The fact they are innocent didn't suppress this feeling?
EL - says the fact they are innocent necessitates they must find Madeleine. They were more ashamed to be arguidos than because of what the book says.

MC - In which way is it different?
EL - doesn't answer, she is obviously upset. The judge says she may leave. Previous witness Mrs Susan Hubbard gets up immediately and follows Emma Loach out of the court room.

............................................


icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #11 on: September 17, 2013, 06:50:06 PM »
that's your opinion which as a supporter of amaral is biased. I am not quoting opinion, just plain facts, as reported by yourself. the judge referred to the MccANNS as innocent...fact..end of

You quoted out of context

Indeed you present  the phrase  "The fact they  are innocent"  as if it were a stand-alone  statement made by the judge whereas,  in reality,  it was part of a question  :

"The fact they are innocent didn't  suppress this  feeling ?"

The Judge was refering to the feeling of shame Emma Loach said the McCanns felt at the content of Amaral's book

She  (  the Judge )  clearly could not understand why  innocent  people would  feel  'ashamed'  about something they deny occured

It might  even be argued that the judge was of a mind that only 'guilty'  people would have such a feeling
« Last Edit: September 17, 2013, 06:55:07 PM by icabodcrane »

Offline Mr Gray

Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #12 on: September 17, 2013, 06:52:57 PM »
Agree, context is everythng


............................................
what a surprise that two amaral supporters agree..absolutely incredible
I am surprised at your sudden concern for context when you regularly post quotes from the McCanns out of context

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #13 on: September 17, 2013, 06:54:03 PM »
Let's say it another way : you're the best informed person concerning yourself. If someone you like or admire supposes you did something ugly you didn't, you're hurt. But if a complete stranger says the same thing, after a first shock of surprise you can't be affected by it because you know better.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: interesting statement by the judge
« Reply #14 on: September 17, 2013, 06:56:39 PM »
You quoted out of context

Indeed you present  the phrase  "The fact they  are innocent"  as if it were a stand-alone  statement made by the judge whereas,  in reality,  it was part of a question  :

"The fact they are innocent didn't  suppress this  feeling ?"

The Judge was refering to the feeling of shame Emma Loach said the McCanns felt at the content of Amaral's book

She  (  the Judge )  clearly could not understand why  innocent  people would  feel  'ashamed'  about something they deny occured

It might  even be argued that the judge was of a mind that only 'guilty'  people would have such a feeling
Yes, much better said than I did ! Thank you, Icabodcrane.