Author Topic: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?  (Read 9984 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Lyall

  • Guest
Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #30 on: September 18, 2013, 01:52:59 PM »
Does anyone think the phrase "The manner in which they "worked" for the Smith was brilliant" translates as "The manner in which they arranged for witnesses to see the abductor" in Mr Amaral's mind??

Probably. Two sightings. One before 9.30. One after. >@@(*&)

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #31 on: September 18, 2013, 02:18:52 PM »

9.00  Matt does listening check on way to tapas. OBrien/McCann/Oldfield kids
9.10  Gerry makes first check. McCann kids
9.15  Jane off on check. OBrien kids
9.25   Matt and Russell off on  check O'Brien/McCann/Oldfield
10.00 Kate does her first check and finds Maddie gone. McCann kids
The Oldfield kid is the only kid checked only by her father.
I never understood why Mrs McCann went alone and not proposing to listen to the Oldfield kid at 10.
The only explanation would be that Mrs Webster etc. who said everybody checked on their own kids said the truth. So Mr Oldfield went to check his own child around 21h25 and didn't enter the McCann flat, as it's stated in the first timeline. So he was due again around 10h, which explains why he first went to his flat when Mrs McCann raised the alarm. As Mr McCann had come back around 21h15, Mrs McCann was only due around 21h45. And imo she left around this time.

Offline Carana

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #32 on: September 18, 2013, 02:36:56 PM »
Thank you MM for giving this question its own thread and thank you to everyone who has suggested what it means.  I must admit though that I still don't understand the significance of the word "worked".

This is an important point which Mr Amaral appears to want to emphasise, any more ideas guys?

What was the original of this?

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #33 on: September 18, 2013, 03:32:36 PM »
No hope to find the Portuguese original (print edition).

Shame

Without the wording in its original language, we are only speculating about what Amaral was really getting at.

Can you infer from this translation, Anne - obviously not a very good one - the words that might have been used in Portuguese?

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #34 on: September 18, 2013, 04:35:03 PM »
I wouldn't risk that, but I'm pretty sure it's related to the following extract of the first interview given (Expresso) after the case was shelved (6th SEP 2008), therefore 1 month before the TV Guia interview. Isn't it the first time the McCanns speaks of the Smith sighting ? Mr McCann mentions the "couple with children" to support Ms Tanner's sighting and, when reminded he could have been the carrier they saw, he uses the PJ's final report where the Tapas staff he was at the restaurant, a remark that the AG report corrects : nobody of the staff noticed whether he was or not.
Everybody will note that Mr McCann is libelling Mr Smith. It wasn't smart of him.

Q – Do you still believe that she’s alive?
Kate – There are great possibilities that she is alive, isn’t it? There is nothing in the process to indicate that something bad has happened to her…

Q – But there are no indicia that she has been abducted, either.
Gerry – We firmly believe that she was abducted by a man, minutes after I went to see her in the bedroom. There are two independent witnesses that saw a child of around four years of age being carried that evening. Our friend Jane Tanner and also the Smith family.

Q – The PJ discredits Jane Tanner’s testimony. They say that when she saw said man with the child, you [Gerry] were chatting nearby and it was impossible that you hadn’t seen him as well…
Gerry – I didn’t see her because my back was turned to the location where she passed. I was talking to a friend. And there is also the couple with children that saw a man carrying a child with a pyjama that was similar to Madeleine’s, blond hair, the same age.

Q – Later on, that family stated that the man they saw was Gerry…
Gerry – At that time I was at the restaurant. The fact that we became suspects has probably influenced the Smiths’ testimony.



Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #35 on: September 18, 2013, 04:37:17 PM »
Oh is it cocaine that made you forget the Sign of the Four ;)
How often have I said to you that when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth? We know that he did not come through the door, the window, or the chimney. We also know that he could not have been concealed in the room, as there is no concealment possible.

The seven per cent solution is inclined to have a positive effect, actually.

Nice quote you found...

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #36 on: September 18, 2013, 04:55:59 PM »
The seven per cent solution is inclined to have a positive effect, actually.

Nice quote you found...
Icabodcrane inspired this finding..

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #37 on: September 18, 2013, 05:25:04 PM »
I wouldn't risk that, but I'm pretty sure it's related to the following extract of the first interview given (Expresso) after the case was shelved (6th SEP 2008), therefore 1 month before the TV Guia interview. Isn't it the first time the McCanns speaks of the Smith sighting ? Mr McCann mentions the "couple with children" to support Ms Tanner's sighting and, when reminded he could have been the carrier they saw, he uses the PJ's final report where the Tapas staff he was at the restaurant, a remark that the AG report corrects : nobody of the staff noticed whether he was or not.
Everybody will note that Mr McCann is libelling Mr Smith. It wasn't smart of him.

Q – Do you still believe that she’s alive?
Kate – There are great possibilities that she is alive, isn’t it? There is nothing in the process to indicate that something bad has happened to her…

Q – But there are no indicia that she has been abducted, either.
Gerry – We firmly believe that she was abducted by a man, minutes after I went to see her in the bedroom. There are two independent witnesses that saw a child of around four years of age being carried that evening. Our friend Jane Tanner and also the Smith family.

Q – The PJ discredits Jane Tanner’s testimony. They say that when she saw said man with the child, you [Gerry] were chatting nearby and it was impossible that you hadn’t seen him as well…
Gerry – I didn’t see her because my back was turned to the location where she passed. I was talking to a friend. And there is also the couple with children that saw a man carrying a child with a pyjama that was similar to Madeleine’s, blond hair, the same age.

Q – Later on, that family stated that the man they saw was Gerry…
Gerry – At that time I was at the restaurant. The fact that we became suspects has probably influenced the Smiths’ testimony.


Thanks for this, Anne.


icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #38 on: September 18, 2013, 06:04:45 PM »
9.00  Matt does listening check on way to tapas. OBrien/McCann/Oldfield kids
9.10  Gerry makes first check. McCann kids
9.15  Jane off on check. OBrien kids
9.25   Matt and Russell off on  check O'Brien/McCann/Oldfield
10.00 Kate does her first check and finds Maddie gone. McCann kids
The Oldfield kid is the only kid checked only by her father.
I never understood why Mrs McCann went alone and not proposing to listen to the Oldfield kid at 10.
The only explanation would be that Mrs Webster etc. who said everybody checked on their own kids said the truth. So Mr Oldfield went to check his own child around 21h25 and didn't enter the McCann flat, as it's stated in the first timeline. So he was due again around 10h, which explains why he first went to his flat when Mrs McCann raised the alarm. As Mr McCann had come back around 21h15, Mrs McCann was only due around 21h45. And imo she left around this time.

Seeing it written down in a straightforward way  like that really does demonstrate how  bizarre the 'checking' story is

In the 25 minutes between 9.00pm  and 9.25pm  the McCann children were checked on three times  ...   once audibly, and twice visually  ...   yet it is during that time period   (  when they were in and  around the apartment like dervishes  )  that they claim she was abducted

Back to the op,  though,  I think Amaral was talking about how they managed  to  'work'  the Smith sighting into their abduction story

Redblossom

  • Guest
Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #39 on: September 18, 2013, 06:08:39 PM »
In answer to the OP

Could he just mean that seeing as only Kates fingerprints were found on the window, and havng said she never touched the window all week, that she opened it that night....Matthew had said he didnt noticed any open window or shutter, just closed curtains and no smells or draughts when he did his 9.30 check...sooo....window and shutters were closed at 9.30....Bundleman had not struck.. soooo it was staged by Kate Mccann? And Gerry was seen by the Smths?

Must agree its hard to really know the meaning



« Last Edit: September 18, 2013, 06:11:32 PM by Redblossom »

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #40 on: September 18, 2013, 06:24:50 PM »
I think Amaral was talking about how they managed  to  'work'  the Smith sighting into their abduction story
I've no more doubt. From the beginning the Smith family had been a pain in the neck that became stronger after the lookalike comment. But after the PJ report stated he was sitting at the table when Mrs McCann came back, Mr McCann smartly took advantage of this to give strength to Ms Tanner's sighting. Mr Amaral found brilliant this turning of a point against abduction into a point in its favour.

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #41 on: September 18, 2013, 06:36:11 PM »

In the 25 minutes between 9.00pm  and 9.25pm  the McCann children were checked on three times  ...   once audibly, and twice visually  ...   yet it is during that time period   (  when they were in and  around the apartment like dervishes  )  that they claim she was abducted


It is absolutely incredible that an abduction took place at this time - if you believe it did. And right under the noses of Gerry and Jeremy as well.

Personally I do believe there was an abduction, but I think the fact that there were so many people hovering around at this time casts doubt on their being a team of abductors. The more people around, the greater chance of detection. Hard to believe none of the checkers had the slightest inkling of two or three other men creeping around at the same time. Only benefit to having a team is having look-outs  - who obviously weren't doing their job properly given that Gerry and Jez were so close by. Astonishing luck.


Offline sadie

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #42 on: September 18, 2013, 11:46:08 PM »
It is absolutely incredible that an abduction took place at this time - if you believe it did. And right under the noses of Gerry and Jeremy as well.

Personally I do believe there was an abduction, but I think the fact that there were so many people hovering around at this time casts doubt on their being a team of abductors. The more people around, the greater chance of detection. Hard to believe none of the checkers had the slightest inkling of two or three other men creeping around at the same time. Only benefit to having a team is having look-outs  - who obviously weren't doing their job properly given that Gerry and Jez were so close by. Astonishing luck.

Try reading "sadies theory" Sherlock.  That might explain it to you.

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #43 on: September 19, 2013, 04:48:24 AM »
Try reading "sadies theory" Sherlock.  That might explain it to you.

Oh, I read it a few times, Sadie

Offline John

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #44 on: September 19, 2013, 07:44:33 AM »
I've no more doubt. From the beginning the Smith family had been a pain in the neck that became stronger after the lookalike comment. But after the PJ report stated he was sitting at the table when Mrs McCann came back, Mr McCann smartly took advantage of this to give strength to Ms Tanner's sighting. Mr Amaral found brilliant this turning of a point against abduction into a point in its favour.

An excellent interpretation Anne.  There certainly appears to be more to the Smith sighting than any of us originally thought.
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.